Humboldt, Bhartrihari, and the dialogic
Drawing on the work of von Humboldt (1963, 1997, 1999) and the 5th century BCE Indian Grammarian Bhartrihari (1971), this essay sketches how dialogue is neither a special-use of language nor a specific mode of pragmatics, but forms instead the primordial character of all language. When the study of language is restricted to Saussure’s bifurcated paradigm, the ontologically basic character of dialogue is concealed. In what follows, I will first briefly sketch a history of ancient Indian linguistics and its influence on European linguistics, then briefly review Saussure’s bifurcated conceptions of langue and parole, and then illustrate several ways that Bhartrihari and Humboldt saw language as, at heart, dialogic.
Article outline
- 1.Introduction
- 2.Indian philosophy of language
- 3.Humboldt’s context
- 4.Saussure and language use
- 5.Dialogical language
- 6.Dialogical thought
- 7.Conclusion: Dialogical world-making
-
References
References
Bakhtin, Mikhail M.
1981 The Dialogic Imagination. Translatedby
Caryl Emerson and
Michael Holquist. Austin: University of Texas.

Bakhtin, Mikhail M.
1984 Problems of Dostoyevsky’s Poetics. ed. by
Michael Holquist, translated by
Caryl Emerson and
Michael Holquist.Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.


Bakhtin, Mikhail M.
1986 Speech Genres & Other Late Essays. Translatedby
Vern McGee. Austin: University of Texas.

Beck, Guy L.
1993 Sonic Theology: Hinduism and Sacred Sound. Studies in Comparative Religion. Columbia, South Carolina: University of South Carolina Press.

Bhartrhari
1971 Vākyapadīya: Critical Text of Cantos I and II. Translated by
K. Raghavan. Delhi: Motilal Banarsidass.

Bloomfield, Leonard
1933 Language. New York: Henry Holt.

Bopp, Franz
1885 A Comparative Grammar of the Sanskrit, Zend, Greek, Latin, Lithuanian, Gothic German and Sclavonic Languages. University of California Libraries.

Bronkhorst, Johannes
1992 “
Pānini’s View of Meaning and Its Western Counterpart.” In
Current Advances in Semantic Theory, ed. by
Maxim I. Stamenov, 455–464. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.

Bronkhorst, Johannes
2001 “
The Peacock’s Egg: Bhartrhari on Language and Reality.”
Philosophy East and West. 51(4): 474–491.


Bronkhorst, Johannes
2005 “
Bhattoji Diksita on Sphota.”
Journal of Indian Philosophy. 33: 3–41.


Buber, Martin
1958 I and Thou. New York: Scribner.

Colebrooke, H. T.
1801/1873 “
On the Sanskrit and Prakrit Languages.” In
Miscellaneous Essays, ed. by
H. T. Colebrooke, with Life of the Author, by His Son,
Sir T. E. Colebrooke, vol. 1, new edition. London: Trubner.

Deshpande, Madhav
2011 “
Language and Testimony in Classical Indian Philosophy.” In
Stanford Encylopedia of Philosophy, ed. by
Edward N. Zalta. Available online at
[URL].

Goddard, Cliff
2003 “
Whorf Meets Wierzbicka: Variation and Universals in Language and Thinking.”
Language Sciences. 25: 393–432.


Golubovs’ka, Iryna
2009 “
Language World Models: Universal and Specific Features.”
Philologica Jassyensia, Anul V, Nr. 1 (9): 131–140.

von Humboldt, Wilhelm
1963 Humanist without Portfolio: An Anthology of the Writings of Wilhelm von Humboldt. Translated by
Marianne Cowan. Detroit, MI: Wayne State University Press.

Humboldt, Wilhelm von
1997 Essays on language, ed. by
Theo Harde and
D. Farrelly. Frankfurt am Main: Peter Lang.

Humboldt, Wilhelm von
1999 On Language: On the Diversity of Human Language Construction and Its Influence on the Mental Development of the Human Species, ed. by
Michael Losonsky, Translated by
Peter Heath. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Johnstone, Christopher Lyle
2012 Listening to the Logos: Speech and the Coming of Wisdom in Ancient Greece. The University of South Carolina Press.

Lipari, Lisbeth
2014a Listening, Thinking, Being: Toward an Ethics of Attunement. State College, PA: Penn State University Press.

Lipari, Lisbeth
2014b “
Interlistening and the Idea of Dialogue.”
Theory and Psychology. 24(4): 504–523.


Lipari, Lisbeth
2017 “
The Speech We Do Not Speak: Dialogic Mind, Praxis, and Ethics.”
Language and Dialogue. 7(1): 45–62

Luria, Alexander R.
1981 Language and Cognition. Edited by
James V. Wertsch. New York: Wiley.

Longhurst, C. A.
2011 “
Unamuno, Schleirmacher, Humboldt: A Question of Language.”
Hispanic Review, Autumn: 573–591.


Master, Alfred
1946 “
The Influence of Sir William Jones upon Sanskrit Studies.”
Bulletin of the School of Oriental and African Studies. 11(4): 798–806.


Matilal, Bimal Krishna
1981 “
Error and Truth: Classical Indian Theories.”
Philosophy East and West. 18: 321–333.


Matilal, Bimal Krishna
1988 “
Śābdabodha and the Problem of Knowledge-Representation in Sanskrit.”
Journal of Indian Philosophy. 16: 107–122.


Matilal, Bimal Krishna
1990 The Word and the World: India’s Contribution to the Study of Language. Delhi: Oxford University Press.

McElvenny, James
2016 “
The Fate of Form in Tradition.”
Language and Communication 47: 30–42.


Mohanty, Jitendra N.
1993 Essays on Indian Philosophy Traditional and Modern, ed. by
Purush-ottama Bilimoria. Delhi: Oxford University Press.

Mueller-Vollmer, Kurt and Messling, Markus
2017 “
Wilhelm von Humboldt.” In
The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, ed. by
Edward N. Zalta.

Müller, F. Max
1869 Lectures on the Science of Language. From the 2nd London ed. rev. New York: Charles Scribner.

Murti, Tiruppattur Ramesehayyar Venkatachala
1974.“
Some Comments on the Philosophy of Language in the Indian Context ”
Journal of Indian Philosophy. 2: 321–331.


Murti, Tiruppattur Ramesehayyar Venkatachala
1983 Studies in Indian Thought: Collected Papers of Prof. T. R V.Murti, ed. by
Harold G. Coward.Delhi: Motilal Banarsidass.

Pajevic, Marko
2014 “
Translation and Poetic Thinking.”
German Life and Letters 67: 6–21.


Pānini
1897 Ashtadhyayi. Translated by
Srisa Chandra Vasu. Benares.

Pillai, K. Raghavan
1971 “
Translator’s note on Karika 145.” In
Vākyapadīya: Critical Text of Cantos I and II. Delhi: Motilal Banarsidass.

Pollock, Sheldon
2009 “
Future Philology? The Fate of a Soft Science in a Hard World.”
Critical Inquiry. 35: 931–961.


Saussure, Ferdinand
1959 Course in General Linguistics, ed. by
Charles Bally and
Albert Sechehaye, Translated by
Wade Baskin. New York: McGraw-Hill.

Schlegel, Friedrich
1849 On the Language and Wisdom of the Indians. Translated by
E. Millington. London: Henry G. Bohn.

Shastri, Gaurinath
1974 A Concise History of Classical Sanskrit Literature. Delhi: Motilal

Smith, J. Mark
2009 “
The Rippling of Verschiedenheit: Wilhelm von Humboldt on Philology, Usage and Intra-linguistic Diversity.”
European Romantic Review 20(2): 237–245.


Vygotsky, Lev
1986 Thought and Language. Translated by
Alex Kozulin. Cambridge, MA: Massachusetts Institute of Technology.

Wilhelm, Friedrich
1961 “
The German Response to Indian Culture.”
Journal of the American Oriental Society 81(4): 395–405.


Cited by
Cited by 1 other publications
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 18 november 2023. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers.
Any errors therein should be reported to them.