Article published In:
Historiographia LinguisticaVol. 6:1 (1979) ► pp.57–76
Contemporary Reactions to Rudolf Meringer’s Speech Error Research
Rudolf Meringer (1859–1931) published two large collections of speech errors, in 1895 and 1908. Although the idea that errors in spontaneous speech might be of linguistic interest did not originate with Meringer, he was the first to produce a large collection of error data and a detailed theoretical analysis of error phenomena. Contemporary reaction to Meringer’s two speech error books is analysed in this essay. Firstly, direct comment at the time, which ranged from enthusiastic praise to dismissal of the project as trivial and uninteresting, is analysed; dismissive reactions, it is seen, came from those who were in any case Meringer’s opponents on broader issues of theoretical orientation. The following section deals with the correctness of Meringer’s analysis of error phenomena, which met its chief challenge at the time from Sigmund Freud’s contention that speech errors were interesting for reasons not of linguistics but of individual psychopathology. Thirdly, Meringer’s devotion to the observational method is described; this led him into a controversy with contemporaries who preferred the research methods of experimental psychology.
References
Aschaffenburg, Georg
(1866–1944). 1896 “Experimentelle Studien über Associationen”. Psychologische Arbeiten 11.209–300.
Baars, Bernard J., Michael T. Motley & Donald G. MacKay
1975 “Output Editing for Lexical Status in Artificially Elicited Slips of the Tongue”. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior 141.382–91. 
Cutler, Anne & David A. Fay
1978 “Introduction”. New edition of Meringer & Mayer (1895), IX–XL.
Fay, David A., & Anne Cutler
1977 “Malapropisms and the Structure of the Mental Lexicon”. Linguistic Inquiry 81.505–520.
Freud, Sigmund
(1856–1939). 1901 “Zur Psychopathologie des Alltagslebens (Vergessen, Versprechen, Vergreifen), nebst Bemerkungen über eine Wurzel des Aberglaubens”. Monatschrift für Psychiatrie und Neurologie 101.1–13, 95–143.
(1856–1939). 1916 Vorlesungen zur Einführung in die Psychoanalyse. Vol. 11. Leipzig & Wien: Heller.
Fromkin, Victoria A.
ed. 1973 Speech Errors as Linguistic Evidence. The Hague: Mouton.
ed. in press Slips of the tongue, ear, pen and hands New York Academic Press
von Grienberger, Theodor
(1855–1932). 1901 Review of Meringer & Mayer (1895). Anzeiger für Deutsches Altertum und Deutsche Literatur 27:89–91.
Güntert, Hermann
(1886–1948). 1932 “Rudolf Meringer zum Gedächtnis”. Wörter und Sachen 141.III–IV.
(1886–1948). 1937 “Vorbemerkung”. Wörter und Sachen 171.V–VI.
Helbig, Gerhard
1970 Geschichte der neueren Sprachwissenschaft. Leipzig: VEB Bibliographisches Institut.
Heller, Theodor
(1869–1935). 1896 Review of Meringer & Mayer (1895). Zeitschrift für Psychologie und Physiologie der Sinnesorgane 101.305–306.
Jastrow, Joseph
(1863–1944). 1906 “The Lapses of Speech”. Popular Science Monthly, February, 119–26.
Jespersen, Otto
(1860–1943). 1941 Efficiency in Linguistic Change. Copenhagen: E. Munksgaard.
Lashley, Karl Spence
(1890–1958). 1951 “The Problem of Serial Order in Behavior”. Cerebral Mechanisms in Behavior ed. by Lloyd A. Jeffress, 112–36. New York: John Wiley & Sons.
Menzerath, Paul
(1883–1954). 1909 “Psychologische Untersuchungen über die sprachliche Kontamination”. Zeitschrift für angewandte Psychologie 21.280–90.
Meringer, Rudolf
(1859–1931). 1896 “Entgegnung”. Berliner Philologische Wochenschrift 161.351–52.
(1859–1931). 1900 “Wie man sich versprechen kann”. Neue Freie Presse 23 August, 6–7.
(1859–1931). 1901 Review of Maurice Grammont (1866–1946), Là dissimilation consonantique dans les langues indo-européennes et dans les langues romanes (Dijon 1895) Anzeiger für indogermanische Sprach- und Altertumskunde 121.8–14.
(1859–1931). 1908 Aus dem Leben der Sprache. Berlin: B. Behr.
(1859–1931). 1909 “Wörter und Sachen”. Germanisch-Romanische Monatsschrift 11.593–98.
(1859–1931). 1911 “Zur Aufgabe und zum Namen unserer Zeitschrift”. Wörter und Sachen 31.22–56 (1912).
(1859–1931), & Carl Mayer (1862–1936). 1895 Versprechen und Verlesen: Eine psychologisch-linguistische Studie. Stuttgart: G. J. Göschen. (New edition, with an introduction by Anne Cutler and David A. Fay, Amsterdam: J. Benjamins 1978.)
Meyer, Gustav
(1850–1900). 1896 Review of Meringer & Mayer (1895). Berliner Philologische Wochenschrift 161.52–53.
Meyer, Richard Moritz
(1860–1914). 1897 Review of Meringer & Mayer (1895). Anzeiger für indogermanische Sprach- und Altertumskunde 71.209–14.
(1860–1914). 1909 Review of Meringer (1908). Deutsche Literaturzeitung 301.151–152.
Murray, David J(ames)
1978 “Introduction”. New edition of Thumb & Marbe (1901), XI–LXIII.
Oertel, Hanns
(1868–1952). 1902 Lectures on the Study of Language, New York: C. Scribner’s Sons.
Paul, Hermann
(1846–1921). 1880 Prinzipien der Sprachgeschichte. Halle a.d.S.: M. Niemeyer. (5th rev. ed. 1920.)
Piquet, Félix
(1855-after 1929). 1909 Review of Meringer (1908). Revue germanique 51.471–472.
Polle, Konrad Friedrich
(1830–1902). 1895 Review of Meringer & Mayer (1895). Wochenschrift für klassische Philologie (4 December), col. 1349.
Postman, Leo, & Geoffrey Keppel
1970 Norms of Word Association. New York: Academic Press.
Reichelt, Hans
(1877–1939). 1931 “Rudolf Meringer zum Gedächtnis”. Grazer Tagespost 17 February, 1.
Saling, Gertrud
(no dates available) 1908 “Assoziative Massenversuche”. Zeitschrift für Psychologie und Physiologie der Sinnesorgane 491.238–533.
Scheinert, Moritz Friedrich
(1880–19??). 1909 Review of Meringer (1908). Literarisches Zentralblatt 601.1335.
Scripture, Edward Wheeler
(1864–1945). 1902 The Elements of Experimental Phonetics. New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons.
Stern, Clara (Joseephy) & William Stern
(1871–1938). 1907 Die Kindersprache. Leipzig: J. A. Barth.
Stolz, Friedrich
(1850–1915). 1903 “Sprachpsychologische Spänne” Zeitschrift für die österreichischen Gymnasien 541.491–98.
Streitberg, Wilhelm
(1864–1925). 1896 Review of Meringer & Mayer,(1895). Literarisches Zentralblatt 471.23.
Thumb, Albert
(1865–1915). 1910a Review of Meringer (1908). Zeitschrift für deutsche Philologie 421.499–501.
(1865–1915). 1910b “Beobachtung und Experiment in der Sprachpsychologie”. Festschrift Wilhelm Viëtor, 19–26. Marburg: N. G. Elwert.
(1865–1915). 1911 “Experimentelle Psychologie und Sprachwissenschaft”. Germanisch-Romanische Monatsschrift 31.65–74.
(1865–1915) & Karl Marbe (1869–1953). 1901 Experimentelle Untersuchungen über die psychologischen Grundlagen der sprachlichen Analogiebildungen. Leipzig: Engelmann. (Reissue, with a replication of Thumb & Marbe’s experiments by Erwin A. Esper and with an introduction by David J. Murray, Amsterdam: J. Benjamins 1978.)
Wells, Frederic Lyman
(1832–1920). 1906 Linguistic Lapses. New York: The Science Press.
Wundt, Wilhelm
(1832–1920). 1900 Völkerpsychologie. Bd. I: Die Sprache. Leipzig: Engelmann.
(1832–1920). 1901 Review of Thumb & Marbe (1901). Anzeiger für indogermanische Sprach- und Altertumskunde 121.17–20.
Zwicky, Arnold M.
1978 “Classical Malapropisms”. Paper presented to the Linguistic Society of America, 28–30 July, Urbana, Illinois.
Cited by
Cited by 3 other publications
Cutler, A.
2006. Meringer, Rudolf (1859–1931). In Encyclopedia of Language & Linguistics, ► pp. 12 ff. 
Sartori, Manuel
2022. Lapsus et apposition de rectification de l’arabe. Historiographia Linguistica 49:1 ► pp. 1 ff.
Nuria Yáñez-Bouza, Emma Moore, Linda van Bergen & Willem B. Hollmann
2019. Categories, Constructions, and Change in English Syntax,
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 24 september 2023. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers. Any errors therein should be reported to them.