Article published In:
Journal of Language and PoliticsVol. 20:2 (2021) ► pp.226–253
Animals vs. armies
Resistance to extreme metaphors in anti-immigration discourse
Within the emerging paradigm of experimental Critical Discourse Analysis, this paper investigates the framing effects of dehumanising vs militarising metaphors in anti-immigration discourses. These metaphors are characterised as ‘extreme metaphors’ in so far as they are manifestly metaphorical and obviously inflammatory. Attested examples of these metaphors in political and media discourses are identified and critically analysed before their potential framing effects are investigated experimentally.
Contrary to predictions, alternative metaphors did not increase support for actions and evaluations consistent with the unique framings that they present. In fact, extreme metaphors decreased support for anti-immigration sentiments and hostile immigration policies compared to literal framings. It seems that extreme metaphors alert readers to the metaphorical framing being presented so that, among certain groups of people, the framing is more readily scrutinised and rejected, prompting readers adopt more sympathetic attitudes toward immigration. The implications of these findings for Critical Discourse Analysis are discussed.
Keywords: metaphor, extreme metaphor, metaphor resistance, immigration discourse, experimental methods
Article outline
- 1.Introduction/background
- 2.Critical metaphor analysis and the metaphor framing effect
- 3.Experiment
- 3.1Methods
- 3.1.1Participants and design
- 3.1.2Materials and procedure
- 3.1.3Measures
- 3.2Results
- 3.3Discussion
- Issues and limitations
- 3.1Methods
- 4.Summary and conclusion
- Acknowledgements
- Notes
-
References
References (67)
Behrend, Tara S., David J. Sharek, Adam W. Meade, and Eric N. Weibe. 2011. “The Viability of Crowdsourcing for Survey Research.” Behaviour Research Methods 431: 800–13. 
Boeynaems, Amber, Christian Burgers, Elly A. Konijn, and Gerard J. Steen. 2017. “The Effects of Metaphorical Framing on Political Persuasion: A Systematic Literature Review”. Metaphor and Symbol 32 (2): 118–134.
Buhrmester, Michael, Tracy Kwang, and Samuel D. Gosling. 2011. “Amazon’s Mechanical Turk: A New Source of Inexpensive, yet High-Quality, Data? Perspectives on Psychological Science 6 (1): 3–5.
Catalano, Theresa and Andreas Musolff. 2019. “‘Taking the Shackles off’: Metaphor and Metonymy of Migrant Children and Border Officials in the U.S”. Metaphorik.de 291.
Chandler, Jesse, Pam Mueller, and Gabriele Paolacci. 2014. Nonnaïveté among Amazon Mechanical Turk Workers: Consequences and Solutions for Behavioral Researchers. Behavior Research Methods 46(1): 112–30.
Charteris-Black, Jonathan. 2004. Corpus Approaches to Critical Metaphor Analysis. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
. 2006. “Britain as a Container: Immigration Metaphors in the 2005 Election Campaign. Discourse & Society 17(5): 563–581.
Chilton, Paul. 2005. “Manipulation, Memes and Metaphors: The Case of Mein Kampf.” In Manipulation and Ideologies in the Twentieth Century: Discourse, Language, Mind, edited by Louis de Saussure and Peter Schulz, 15–44. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Crump, Matthew J. C., John V. McDonnel, and Todd M. Gureckis. 2013. “Evaluating Amazon’s Mechanical Turk as a Tool for Experimental Behavioural Research.” PLoS ONE 8 e57410.
DeVellis, Robert F. 2012. Scale Development: Theory and Applications. 3rd edn. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
de Lavalette, Kiki Y. R., Conia Andone, and Gerard J. Steen. 2019a. “Figurative Analogies and How They are Resisted in British Public Bill Committee Debates.” Metaphor and the Social World 9(1): 107–130.
. 2019b. “ ‘I Did Not Say that the Government Should Be Plundering Anybody’s Savings’: Resistance to Metaphors Expressing Starting Points in Parliamentary Debates.” Journal of Language and Politics 18(5): 718–738.
El Refaie, Elizabeth. 2001. “Metaphors We Discriminate by: Naturalized Themes in Austrian Newspaper Articles about Asylum Seekers.” Journal of Sociolinguistics 5 (3): 352–71.
. 2003. “Understanding Visual Metaphor: The Example of Newspaper Cartoons.” Visual Communication 2 (1): 75–96.
Entman, Robert M. 1993. “Framing: Toward a Clarification of a Fractured Paradigm.” Journal of Communication 43(4): 51–58.
2004. Projections of Power: Framing News, Public Opinion, and US Foreign Policy. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Ethical Journalism Network. 2015. Moving Stories. International Review of How Media Cover Migration. London: Ethical Journalism Network.
Fairclough, Norman. 1989. Language and Power. London: Longman.
. 1995. Critical Discourse Analysis: The Critical Study of Language. London: Longman.
Fauconnier, Gilles and Mark Turner. 2002. The Way We Think: Conceptual Blending and the Mind’s Hidden Complexities. New York: Basic Books.
Fillmore, Charles. 1982. “Frame Semantics.” In Linguistics in the Morning Calm, edited by Linguistics Society of Korea, 111–37. Seoul: Hanshin Publishing Co.
. 1985. “Frames and the Semantics of Understanding.” Quaderni di Semantica VI (2): 222–254.
Fuoli, Matteo and Christopher Hart. 2018. “Trust-Building Strategies in Corporate Discourse: An Experimental Study. Discourse & Society 29(5): 514–552.
Flusberg, Stephen J., Mark Lauria, and Paul H. Thibodeau. 2018. “Metaphor Framing in Multiple Communication Modalities. In Proceedings of the 40th Annual Conference of the Cognitive Science Society, 374–79. Madison, WI.
Giese, Stephanie and Christian Baden. 2014. “Putting the Image back into the Frame: Modelling the Linkage between Visual Communication and Frame-Processing Theory.” Communication Theory 25(1): 46–69.
Graber, Doris A. 1990. “Seeing is Remembering: How Visuals Contribute to Learning from Television News. Journal of Communication 40 (3): 134–155.
Hart, Christopher. 2010. Critical Discourse Analysis and Cognitive Science: New Perspectives on Immigration Discourse. Basingstoke: Palgrave.
. 2017. “Metaphor and Intertextuality in Media Framings of the (1984–85) British Miners’ Strike: A Multimodal Analysis.” Discourse & Communication 11(1): 3–30.
. 2018a. “‘Riots Engulfed the City’: An Experimental Study Investigating the Legitimating Effects of Fire Metaphors in Discourses of Disorder.” Discourse & Society 29(3): 279–298.
. 2018b. “Event-Frames Affect Blame Assignment and Perception of Aggression: An Experimental Case Study in CDA.” Applied Linguistics 39(3): 400–421.
Hart, Christopher and Matteo Fuoli. 2020. “Objectification Strategies Outperform Subjectification Strategies in Military Interventionist Discourse.” Journal of Pragmatics 1621: 17–28.
Hartman, Todd K. 2012. “Toll Booths on the Information Superhighway? Policy Metaphors in the Case of Net Neutrality.” Political Communication 29(3): 278–298.
Hauser, David J., Pheobe C. Ellsworth, and Richard Gonzalez. 2018. “Are Manipulation Checks Necessary?” Frontiers in Psychology 91: 998.
Jeffries, Stuart. 2014. “‘Swamped’ and ‘Riddled’: The Toxic Words that Wreck Public Discourse.” Guardian, Octoboer 27, 2014. [URL]
Kampf, Zohar and Yossi David. 2019. “Too Good to Be True: The Effect of Conciliatory Message Design on Compromising Attitudes in Intractable Conflicts.” Discourse & Society 30(3): 264–286.
Klein, Richard A., Kate A. Ratliff, Michelangelo Vianello, Reginald B. Adams Jr., Štěpán Bahnik, Michael J. Bernstein, Konrad Bocian et al. 2014. “Investigating Variation in Replicability.” Social Psychology 451: 142–152.
Koller, Veronika. 2004. Metaphor and Gender in Business Media Discourse: A Critical Cognitive Study. Basingstoke: Palgrave.
Krzyżanowski, Michal. 2018. “Discursive Shifts in Ethno-Nationalist Politics: On Politicization and Mediatization of the ‘Refugee Crisis’ in Poland.” Journal of Immigrant & Refugee Studies 16(1–2): 76–96.
. 2020. “Discursive Shifts and the Normalisation of Racism: Imaginaries of Immigration, Moral Panics and the Discourse of Contemporary Right-Wing Populism.” Social Semiotics 30 (4): 503–527.
Lakoff, George and Mark Johnson. 1980. Metaphors We Live by. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Landau, Mark J., Daniel Sullivan, and Jeff Greenberg. 2009. “Evidence that Self-Relevant Motives and Metaphoric Framing Interact to Influence Political and Social Attitudes.” Psychological Science 20 (11): 1421–1426.
Luke, Allan. 2002. “Beyond Science and Ideology Critique: Developments in Critical Discourse Analysis.” Annual review of Applied Linguistics 22(1): 96–110.
Mason, Winter and Siddharth Suri. 2012. “Conducting Behavioural Research on Amazon’s Mechanical Turk.” Behavioural Research Methods 441: 1–23.
Musolff, Andreas. 2004. Metaphor and Political Discourse: Analogical Reasoning in Debates about Europe. Basingstoke: Palgrave.
. 2016. Political Metaphor Analysis: Discourse and Scenarios. London: Bloomsbury.
Ofcom. 2014. News Consumption in the UK: 2014 Report. [URL]
Paolacci, Gabriele, Jesse Chandler, and Panagiotis G. Ipeirotis. 2010. “Running Experiments on Amazon Mechanical Turk.” Judgement and Decision Making 51: 411–419.
Peer, Eyal, Laura Brandimarte, Sonam Samat, and Alessandro Acquisti. 2017. “Beyond the Turk: Alternative Platforms for Crowdsourcing Behavioral Research.” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 701: 153–163.
Reijnierse, W. Gudrun, Christian Burgers, Tina Krennmayr, and Gerard J. Steen. 2015. “How Viruses and Beasts Affect our Opinions (or Not): The Role of Extendedness in Metaphorical Framing.” Metaphor and the Social World 5(2): 245–263.
Robins, Shani and Richard E. Mayer. 2000. “The Metaphor Framing Effect: Metaphorical Reasoning about Text-Based Dilemmas.” Discourse Processes 30 (1): 57–86.
Santa Ana, Otto. 1999. “‘Like an Animal I was Treated’: Anti-Immigrant Metaphor in US Public Discourse.” Discourse & Society 10(2): 191–224.
. 2002. Brown Tide Rising: Metaphors of Latinos in Contemporary American Public Discourse. Austin: University of Texas Press.
Semino, Elena. 2008. Metaphor in Discourse. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Shariatmadari, David. 2015. “Swarms, Floods and Marauders: The Toxic Metaphors of the Migration Debate.” Guardian, August 10, 2015. [URL]
Steen, Gerard J. 2008. “The Paradox of Metaphor: Why We Need a Three-Dimensional Model of Metaphor.” Metaphor and Symbol 231: 213–241.
2010. “When is Metaphor Deliberate?” In Selected Papers from the Stockholm 2008 Metaphor Festival, edited by Nils-Lennart Johannesson, Christina Alm-Arvius, and David C. Minugh, 43–63. Stockholm: University of Stockholm.
Steen, Gerard J., W. Gudrun Reijnierse, and Christian Burgers. 2014. “When Do Natural Language Metaphors Influence Reasoning? A Follow-up Study to Thibodeau and Boroditsky (2013).” PLoS ONE 9(12): e113536.
Subtirelu, Nicholas C. and Shakthidhar R. Gopavaram. 2016. “Crowdsourcing Critical Discourse Analysis: Using Amazon’s Mechanical Turk to Explore Readers’ Uptake of Comments about Language on RateMyProfessors.com.” CADAAD 8 (1): 38–57.
Thibodeau, Paul H. 2016. “Extended Metaphors are the Home Runs of Persuasion: Don’t Fumble the Phrase.” Metaphor and Symbol 31 (2): 53–72.
Thibodeau, Paul H. and Lera Boroditsky. 2011. “Metaphors We Think with: The Role of Metaphor in Reasoning.” PLoS ONE 6(2): e16782.
. 2013. “Natural Language Metaphors Covertly Influence Reasoning.” PLoS ONE 8(1): e52961.
Thibodeau, Paul H. and Lera Borodistky. 2015. “Measuring Effects of Metaphor in a Dynamic Opinion Landscape.” PLoS ONE 10(7): e0133939.
Utych, Stephen M. 2018. “How Dehumanization Influences Attitudes toward Immigrants.” Political Research Quarterly 7(2): 440–452.
Van Dijk, Teun A. 1998. Ideology: A Multidisciplinary Perspective. London: Sage.
Widdowson, Henry G. 2004. Text, Context, Pretext: Critical Issues in Discourse Analysis. Oxford: Blackwell.
Woods, Andy T., Carlos Velasco, Carmel A. Levitan, Xiaoang Wan, and Charles Spence. 2015. “Conducting Perception Research over the Internet: A Tutorial Review.” Peer J 3 e1058.
YouGov. 2018. Where the Public Stands on Immigration. [URL]
Cited by (22)
Cited by 22 other publications
Andreasen, Søren Mosgaard
Assimakopoulos, Stavros & Anna Piata
2024. Chapter 5. Liquid racism, metaphor and the visual modality. In Exploring the Ambivalence of Liquid Racism [Pragmatics & Beyond New Series, 341], ► pp. 118 ff. 
Dyrmo, Tomasz
Díaz-Peralta, Marina
2024. Epistemic stance and public discourse on irregular migration in one of Europe’s outermost regions. Journal of Language and Politics
Ertanir, Beyhan, Alan Meca, Cory Cobb, Ingrid Zeledon, Jennifer B. Unger, Elma Lorenzo‐Blanco, Pablo Montero‐Zamora, Byron L. Zamboanga, Lourdes Baezconde‐Garbanati, Daniel W. Soto, Dilan Aksoy, Wassilis Kassis, Maria Duque, Aigerim Alpysbekova & Seth J. Schwartz
2024. Disentangling the directionality among cultural stressors and psychosocial outcomes in recently immigrated Hispanic families: A random intercept cross‐lagged panel model approach. Journal of Research on Adolescence
Gonçalves, Isabella
2024. Promoting Hate Speech by Dehumanizing Metaphors of Immigration. Journalism Practice 18:2 ► pp. 265 ff.
Jin, Ying & Dennis Tay
2024. Use of Offensive Animal Metaphor as an Interactional Activity in Online Forum Discussions. Metaphor and Symbol 39:4 ► pp. 281 ff.
O’Connell Davidson, Julia
2024. Thinking with space invaders: ‘Freed slaves’, ‘asylum seekers’ and social wastelands. European Journal of Cultural Studies
Coschignano, Serena, Gosse Minnema & Chiara Zanchi
2023. Explaining the distribution of implicit means of misrepresentation: A case study on Italian immigration discourse. Journal of Pragmatics 213 ► pp. 107 ff.
Hart, Christopher
2023. Frames, framing and framing effects in cognitive CDA. Discourse Studies 25:2 ► pp. 247 ff.
Hart, Christopher
2024. Multimodal meaning making in news communication about immigration: using the NewsScape corpus to explore co-verbal images in TV news. Frontiers in Communication 9
Heritage, Frazer
2023. Introduction. In Incels and Ideologies [Palgrave Studies in Language, Gender and Sexuality, ], ► pp. 1 ff.
List, Alexandra
2023. Social justice reasoning when students learn about social issues using multiple texts. Discourse Processes 60:4-5 ► pp. 244 ff.
Steen, Gerard J.
2023. Thinking by metaphor, fast and slow: Deliberate Metaphor Theory offers a new model for metaphor and its comprehension. Frontiers in Psychology 14
Zhang, Yan & Wenxing Yang
2023. The landslide’s conceptualizing economic decline and its framing effect: Mandarin evidence. Frontiers in Psychology 14
Benczes, Réka & Bence Ságvári
Jatileni, Cloneria Nyambali & Shemunyenge Taleiko Hamukwaya
2022. The Use of Animal Metaphors to Reveal Beliefs of Grade Three Namibian Learners Who Experienced Mathematics Learning Difficulties During the COVID-19 Pandemic. In Mathematics Education in Africa, ► pp. 243 ff.
Porto, M. Dolores
2022. Water Metaphors and Evaluation of Syrian Migration: The Flow of Refugees in the Spanish Press. Metaphor and Symbol 37:3 ► pp. 252 ff.
GIBBS, RAYMOND W. & JOSIE SIMAN
2021. How We Resist Metaphors. Language and Cognition 13:4 ► pp. 670 ff.
Meluzzi, Chiara, Erica Pinelli, Elena Valvason & Chiara Zanchi
2021. Responsibility attribution in gender-based domestic violence: A study bridging corpus-assisted discourse analysis and readers' perception. Journal of Pragmatics 185 ► pp. 73 ff.
[no author supplied]
[no author supplied]
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 22 november 2024. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers. Any errors therein should be reported to them.