Processing conjunctive entailment of disjunction
In a sentence where the disjunction huo ‘or’ appears under the negation mei ‘no’ (e.g.: Ta mei chi qingjiao huo qiezi. ‘He did not eat green peppers or eggplants.’), the sentence is globally ambiguous between the conjunctive interpretation and the disjunctive interpretation. The primary goal of this study is to investigate if there is a default meaning for simple negative statements containing huo ‘or’. Data collected from the self-paced region-by-region reading experiment indicated that the participants consistently preferred the conjunctive interpretation. Additionally, in the conjunction-biased condition where the sentences turned out to favor the disjunctive interpretations at the end, there was reading time penalty at the last region of the sentences and participants spent significantly longer time judging the appropriateness of those sentences. Contrary to Jing’s (2008) assertion that both disjunction and conjunction readings are equally prominent in an out-of-the-blue context, the results from the quantitative data revealed that the conjunction reading is the default meaning for simple negative statements containing huo ‘or’. The findings of the current experiment provide essential implications to the study of child language acquisition. Specifically, we argue that understanding the adults’ linguistic patterns is a prerequisite to the study of children’s language acquisition patterns.
Article outline
- 1.The backdrop
- 1.1The downward entailing ‘or’
- 1.2Previous investigation on ‘or’
- 1.3The role of quantitative methods in linguistics
- 1.4The present study
- 2.Methods
- 2.1Participants
- 2.2Design and materials
- 2.3Procedure
- 2.4Data treatment
- 3.Results
- 3.1Accuracy rate
- 3.2Reading time
- 3.3Conjunction or disjunction?
- 4.Discussion
- 5.Concluding remarks
- Acknowledgements
- Notes
-
References
References
Aoshima, Sachiko, Colin Phillips, & Amy Weinberg
2004 Processing filler-gap dependencies in a head-final language.
Journal of Memory and Language 51.1:23–54.
Chierchia, Gennaro, Stephen Crain, Maria Teresa Guasti, Andrea Gualmini, & Luisa Meroni
2001 The acquisition of disjunction: Evidence for a grammatical view of scalar implicatures.
Proceedings of the 25th Boston University Conference on Language Development (BUCLD 25), Vol. 11, ed. by
Anna H.-J. Do,
Laura Domínguez &
Aimee Johansen, 157–168. Somerville: Cascadilla Press.
Chierchia, Gennaro, Maria Teresa Guasti, Andrea Gualmini, Luisa Meroni, Stephen Crain, & Francesca Foppolo
2004 Semantic and pragmatic competence in children’s and adults’ comprehension of ‘or’.
Experimental Pragmatics, ed. by
Ira A. Noveck &
Dan Sperber, 283–300. Basingstoke, Hampshire & New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Crain, Stephen
2008 The interpretation of disjunction in universal grammar.
Language and Speech 51.1-2:151–169.
Crain, Stephen, & Cecile McKee
1985 The acquisition of structural restrictions on anaphora.
Proceedings of NELS 15, ed. by
Stephen Berman,
Jae-Woong Choe &
Joyce McDonough, 94–110. Amherst, MA: GLSA.
Crain, Stephen, & Rosalind Thornton
1998 Investigations in Universal Grammar: A Guide to Experiments on the Acquisition of Syntax and Semantics. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Crain, Stephen, & Rosalind Thornton
2006 Acquisition of syntax and semantics.
Handbook of Psycholinguistics (2nd edition), ed. by
Matthew J. Traxler &
Morton Ann Gernsbacher, 1073–1110. Amsterdam: Elsevier.
Crain, Stephen, Takuya Goro, & Rosalind Thornton
2006 Language acquisition is language change.
Journal of Psycholinguistic Research 35.1:31–49.
Crain, Stephen, Amanda Gardner, Andrea Gualmini, & Beth Rabbin
2002 Children’s command of negation.
Proceedings of the Third Tokyo Conference on Psycholinguistics, ed. by
Yukio Otsu, 71–95. Tokyo: Hituzi Publishing Company.
Culicover, Peter W., & Ray Jackendoff
2010 Quantitative methods alone are not enough: Response to Gibson and Fedorenko.
Trends in Cognitive Sciences 14.6:234–235.
Gibson, Edward, & Evelina Fedorenko
2010 Weak quantitative standards in linguistics research.
Trends in Cognitive Sciences 14.6:233–234.
Gibson, Edward, & Evelina Fedorenko
2013 The need for quantitative methods in syntax and semantics research.
Language and Cognitive Processes 28.1-2:88–124.
Gibson, Edward, & H.-H. Iris Wu
2013 Processing Chinese relative clauses in context.
Language and Cognitive Processes 28.1-2:125–155.
Gibson, Edward, Steven T. Piantadosi, & Evelina Fedorenko
2013 Quantitative methods in syntax/semantics research: A response to Sprouse and Almeida (2013).
Language and Cognitive Processes 28.3:229–240.
Goldberg, Adele E.
2003 Constructions: a new theoretical approach to language.
Trends in Cognitive Sciences 7.5:219–224.
Goldberg, Adele E.
2006 Constructions at Work: The Nature of Generalization in Language. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Goro, Takuya, & Sachie Akiba
2004 The acquisition of disjunction and positive polarity in Japanese.
WCCFL 23: Proceedings of the 23rd West Coast Conference on Formal Linguistics, ed. by
Vineeta Chand,
Ann Kelleher,
Angelo J. Rodríguez &
Benjamin Schmeiser, 251–264. Somerville: Cascadilla Press.
Gualmini, Andrea, & Stephen Crain
2002 Why no child or adult must learn de Morgan’s laws.
Proceedings of the 26th Annual Boston University Conference on Language Development (BUCLD 26), Vol. 11, ed. by
Barbora Skarabela,
Sarah Fish &
Anna H.-J Do, 243–254. Somerville: Cascadilla Press.
Gualmini, Andrea, & Stephen Crain
2004 Operator conditioning.
Proceedings of the 28th Annual Boston University Conference on Language Development (BUCLD 28), Vol. 11, ed. by
Alejna Brugos,
Linnea Micciulla &
Christine E. Smith, 232–243. Somerville: Cascadilla Press.
Gualmini, Andrea, Stephen Crain, Luisa Meroni, Gennaro Chierchia, & Maria Teresa Guasti
2001 At the semantics/pragmatics interface in child Language.
Proceedings of SALT XI, ed. by
Rachel Hastings,
Brendan Jackson &
Zsofia Zvolenszky, 231–247. Ithaca: Cornell University.
Guasti, Maria Teresa, Gennaro Chierchia, Stephen Crain, Francesca Foppolo, Andrea Gualmini, & Luisa Meroni
2005 Why children and adults sometimes (but not always) compute implicatures.
Language and Cognitive Processes 20.5:667–696.
Hsiao, Franny, & Edward Gibson
2003 Processing relative clauses in Chinese.
Cognition 90.1:3–27.
Hsu, Chun-chieh Natalie
2006 Issues in Head-Final Relative Clauses in Chinese–Derivation, Processing and Acquisition. Newark: University of Delaware dissertation.
Huang, Chu-Ren, Adam Kilgarriff, Yiching Wu, Chih-Ming Chiu, Simon Smith, Pavel Rychly, Ming-Hong Bai, & Keh-Jiann Chen
2005 Chinese sketch engine and the extraction of grammatical collocations.
Proceedings of the Fourth SIGHAN Workshop on Chinese Language Processing, October 14–15, 2005, ed. by
Chu-Ren Huang &
Gina-Anne Levow, 48–55. Jeju: IJCNLP-05.
Jing, Chunyuan
2008 Pragmatic Computation in Language Acquisition: Evidence from Disjunction and Conjunction in Negative Context. College Park: University of Maryland dissertation.
Jing, Chun-Yuan, Stephen Crain, & Ching-Fen Hsu
2005 The interpretation of focus in Chinese: child vs. adult language.
Proceedings of the 6th Tokyo Conference on Psycholinguistics, ed. by
Yukio Otsu, 165–190. Tokyo: Hituzi Publishing Company.
Just, Marcel A., Patricia A. Carpenter, & Jacqueline D. Woolley
1982 Paradigms and processes in reading comprehension.
Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 111.2:228–238.
Kilgarriff, Adam, Pavel Rychly, Pavel Smrz, & David Tugwell
2004 The sketch engine.
Proceedings of EURALEX 2004, July 6–10, 2004, ed. by
Geoffrey Williams &
Sandra Vessier, 105–116. Lorient: Université de Bretagne Sud.
Lin, Chien-Jer Charles
2006 Grammar and Parsing: A Typological Investigation of Relative-Clause Processing. Tucson: University of Arizona dissertation.
Liu, Chin-Ting Jimbo
2014 Conjunctive entailment of disjunction in individuals with Asperger syndrome: A semantic or pragmatic deficit? Paper presented at the 16th Annual International Conference of the Japanese Society for Language Sciences (JSLS 2014), June 28–29, 2014. Saitama: Bunkyo University.
Liu, Chin-Ting Jimbo, & Hsiu-Fen Hélène Lee
2014 Modality and children’s scope understanding.
Journal of Psycholinguistic Research 43.5:487–506
.
Myers, James
2009a Syntactic judgment experiments.
Language and Linguistics Compass 3.1:406–423.
Myers, James
2009b The design and analysis of small-scale syntactic judgment experiments.
Lingua 119.3:425–444.
Myers, James
2012 Testing adjunct and conjunct island constraints in Chinese.
Language and Linguistics 13.3:437–470.
Partee, Barbara H., Alice ter Meulen, &d Robert E. Wall
1990 Mathematical Methods in Linguistics. Dordrecht & Boston: Kluwer.
Phillips, Colin
2009 Should we impeach armchair linguists? Japanese/Korean Linguistics, Vol. 171, ed. by
Shoishi Iwasaki,
Hajime Holi,
Patrica M. Clancy &
Sung-Ock Sohn, 49–64. Stanford: CSLI Publications.
Rohde, Doug
2001–2003 Linger. Available at
[URL] (accessed November 11 2013).
Scontras, Gregory, & Edward Gibson
2011 A quantitative investigation of the imperative-and-declarative construction in English.
Language 87.4:817–829.
Sprouse, Jon
2007 Continuous acceptability, categorical grammaticality, and experimental syntax.
Biolinguistics 11:123–134.
Sprouse, Jon, & Diogo Almeida
2013 The empirical status of data in syntax: A reply to Gibson and Fedorenko.
Language and Cognitive Processes 28.3:222–228.
Su, Yi Esther
2013 Scalar implicatures and downward entailment in child Mandarin.
Journal of East Asian Linguistic 22.2:167–187.
Su, Yi (Esther), & Stephen Crain
2013 Children’s knowledge of disjunction and universal quantification in Mandarin Chinese.
Language and Linguistics 14.3: 599–631.
Su, Yi (Esther), Peng Zhou, & Stephen Crain
2012 Downward entailment in child Mandarin.
Journal of Child Language 39.5:957–990.
Syrett, Kristen, & Jeffrey Lidz
2009 QR in child grammar: Evidence from antecedent-contained deletion.
Language Acquisition 16.2:67–81.
Szabolcsi, Anna
2002 Hungarian disjunctions and positive polarity.
Approaches to Hungarian, Vol. 81, ed. by
Istvan Kenesei &
Peter Siptar, 217–241. Budapest: Akademiai Kiado.
Tomasello, Michael
2000 First steps toward a usage-based theory of language acquisition.
Cognitive Linguistics 11.1-2:61–82.
Tomasello, Michael
2003 Constructing a Language: A Usage-based Theory of Language Acquisition. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Trueswell, John C., Irina Sekerina, Nicole M. Hill, & Marian L. Logrip
1999 The kindergarten-path effect: studying on-line sentence processing in young children.
Cognition 73.2:89–134.
Cited by
Cited by 2 other publications
Liu, Chin-Ting & Li-Mei Chen
2019.
Comprehending conjunctive entailment of disjunction among individuals with Asperger syndrome.
Clinical Linguistics & Phonetics ► pp. 1 ff.
Surányi, Balázs & Gulás, Máté
2022.
A diszjunkció mint Pozitív Polaritású Elem.
Jelentés és Nyelvhasználat 9:1
► pp. 185 ff.
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 3 april 2024. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers.
Any errors therein should be reported to them.