219-7677 10 7500817 John Benjamins Publishing Company Marketing Department / Karin Plijnaar, Pieter Lamers onix@benjamins.nl 201608250316 ONIX title feed eng 01 EUR
582009728 03 01 01 JB John Benjamins Publishing Company 01 JB code P&b III:8 Eb 15 9789027280572 06 10.1075/pb.iii.8 13 2003541667 DG 002 02 01 P&b 02 0166-6258 Pragmatics & Beyond III:8 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">Topical Relevance in Argumentation</TitleText> 01 pb.iii.8 01 https://benjamins.com 02 https://benjamins.com/catalog/pb.iii.8 1 A01 Douglas N. Walton Walton, Douglas N. Douglas N. Walton 01 eng 89 viii 81 LAN009000 v.2006 CF 2 24 JB Subject Scheme LIN.PRAG Pragmatics 24 JB Subject Scheme LIN.SEMAN Semantics 24 JB Subject Scheme LIN.THEOR Theoretical linguistics 06 01 It is a longstanding if not altogether coherent tradition of logic and rhetorical studies that an argument can be incorrect or fallacious in virtue of some proposition in it being “irrelevant”. This monograph clarifies that tradition. Non-classical propositional calculi, including relevance logics and relatedness logics, are juxtaposed against conversational criticisms of irrelevance in natural argumentation, e.g. in parliamentary debates. The object is to see if there is a reasonable way of evaluating criticisms like “That’s beside the point!” or “That’s irrelevant!”. 04 09 01 https://benjamins.com/covers/475/pb.iii.8.png 04 03 01 https://benjamins.com/covers/475_jpg/9789027225245.jpg 04 03 01 https://benjamins.com/covers/475_tif/9789027225245.tif 06 09 01 https://benjamins.com/covers/1200_front/pb.iii.8.pb.png 07 09 01 https://benjamins.com/covers/125/pb.iii.8.png 25 09 01 https://benjamins.com/covers/1200_back/pb.iii.8.pb.png 27 09 01 https://benjamins.com/covers/3d_web/pb.iii.8.pb.png 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.01con 1 1 Chapter 1 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">1. Conversational Allegations of Irrelevance</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.02obj 1 1 Subsection 2 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">1.0 Objective of Study</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.03dua 1 1 Subsection 3 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">1.1 Dual Nature of Pragmatic Analysis</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.04dis 3 1 Subsection 4 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">1.2 Disputation Theory</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.05sta 4 1 Subsection 5 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">1.3 Standard Preconceptions of Irrelevance</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.06fal 6 1 Subsection 6 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">1.4 Fallacies of Emotional Distraction</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.07adm 7 1 Subsection 7 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">1.5 <i>Ad Misericordiam</i> Arguments</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.08aco 8 1 Subsection 8 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">1.6 A Contrastive Case Study</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.09the 10 1 Subsection 9 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">1.7 The <i>Ad Hominem</i> Fallacy</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.10rel 11 1 Subsection 10 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">1.8 Relevant Answers to Questions</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.11ase 16 1 Subsection 11 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">1.9 A Second Case Study of Question-Relevance</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.12fun 18 1 Subsection 12 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">1.10 Function of Questioning in Parliamentary Debate</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.13pro 20 1 Chapter 13 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">2. Propositional Inferences in Disputation</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.14rel 20 1 Subsection 14 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">2.0 Relevance in Games of Dialogue</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.15ref 21 1 Subsection 15 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">2.1 Refutation and Propositional Structure</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.16cla 23 1 Subsection 16 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">2.2 Classical Propositional Logic</TitleText> <Subtitle textformat="02">Basic Elements</Subtitle> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.17val 25 1 Subsection 17 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">2.3 Valid Arguments in Classical Logic</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.18ast 26 1 Subsection 18 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">2.4 Astounding Inferences in Classical Logic</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.19rel 28 1 Subsection 19 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">2.5 Relatedness Propositional Logic</TitleText> <Subtitle textformat="02">Basic Elements</Subtitle> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.20val 29 1 Subsection 20 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">2.6 Valid Arguments in Relatedness Logic</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.21the 31 1 Subsection 21 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">2.7 The Astounding Inferences Revisited</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.22the 32 1 Subsection 22 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">2.8 The Propositional Core of Disputation</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.23par 35 1 Chapter 23 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">3. Paradoxes, Sophisms and Relatedness</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.24the 35 1 Subsection 24 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">3.0 The Meaning of Relatedness</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.25act 35 1 Subsection 25 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">3.1 Act-Sequences and Relatedness</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.26sub 38 1 Subsection 26 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">3.2 Subject-Matter Contents of Propositions</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.27par 41 1 Subsection 27 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">3.3 Paradoxes and Astounding Inferences</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.28mis 44 1 Subsection 28 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">3.4 Missing Factors</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.29nee 46 1 Subsection 29 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">3.5 Needed Premisses in Inferences</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.30irr 48 1 Subsection 30 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">3.6 Irrelevant Premisses</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.31plu 51 1 Subsection 31 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">3.7 Pluralism of Concepts of Relevance</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.32inf 53 1 Subsection 32 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">3.8 Information Inclusion</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.33cri 56 1 Chapter 33 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">4. Criticisms of Irrelevance in Games of Dialogue</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.34six 56 1 Subsection 34 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">4.0 Six Types of Criticisms of Irrelevance</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.35var 56 1 Subsection 35 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">4.1 Varieties of Games</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.36str 58 1 Subsection 36 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">4.2 Strong and Weak Refutation</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.37sym 59 1 Subsection 37 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">4.3 Symmetrical and Asymmetrical Games</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.38mis 60 1 Subsection 38 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">4.4 Misconception of Refutation</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.39per 63 1 Subsection 39 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">4.5 Pertinence</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.40que 65 1 Subsection 40 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">4.6 Question-Answer Relevance</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.41typ 66 1 Subsection 41 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">4.7 Types of Questions and Answers</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.42rul 67 1 Subsection 42 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">4.8 Rules for Responding</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.43typ 70 1 Subsection 43 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">4.9 Types of Relevance Compared</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.44con 73 1 Subsection 44 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">4.10 Conditionals in Disputation</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.45not 75 1 Miscellaneous 45 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">Notes</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.46ref 76 1 Miscellaneous 46 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">References</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.47ind 80 1 Miscellaneous 47 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">Index</TitleText> 02 JBENJAMINS John Benjamins Publishing Company 01 John Benjamins Publishing Company Amsterdam/Philadelphia NL 04 19820101 1982 John Benjamins 02 WORLD 13 15 9789027225245 01 JB 3 John Benjamins e-Platform 03 jbe-platform.com 09 WORLD 21 01 00 65.00 EUR R 01 00 55.00 GBP Z 01 gen 00 98.00 USD S 549 03 01 01 JB John Benjamins Publishing Company 01 JB code P&b III:8 Pb 15 9789027225245 13 2003541667 BC 01 P&b 02 0166-6258 Pragmatics & Beyond III:8 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">Topical Relevance in Argumentation</TitleText> 01 pb.iii.8 01 https://benjamins.com 02 https://benjamins.com/catalog/pb.iii.8 1 A01 Douglas N. Walton Walton, Douglas N. Douglas N. Walton 01 eng 89 viii 81 LAN009000 v.2006 CF 2 24 JB Subject Scheme LIN.PRAG Pragmatics 24 JB Subject Scheme LIN.SEMAN Semantics 24 JB Subject Scheme LIN.THEOR Theoretical linguistics 06 01 It is a longstanding if not altogether coherent tradition of logic and rhetorical studies that an argument can be incorrect or fallacious in virtue of some proposition in it being “irrelevant”. This monograph clarifies that tradition. Non-classical propositional calculi, including relevance logics and relatedness logics, are juxtaposed against conversational criticisms of irrelevance in natural argumentation, e.g. in parliamentary debates. The object is to see if there is a reasonable way of evaluating criticisms like “That’s beside the point!” or “That’s irrelevant!”. 04 09 01 https://benjamins.com/covers/475/pb.iii.8.png 04 03 01 https://benjamins.com/covers/475_jpg/9789027225245.jpg 04 03 01 https://benjamins.com/covers/475_tif/9789027225245.tif 06 09 01 https://benjamins.com/covers/1200_front/pb.iii.8.pb.png 07 09 01 https://benjamins.com/covers/125/pb.iii.8.png 25 09 01 https://benjamins.com/covers/1200_back/pb.iii.8.pb.png 27 09 01 https://benjamins.com/covers/3d_web/pb.iii.8.pb.png 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.01con 1 1 Chapter 1 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">1. Conversational Allegations of Irrelevance</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.02obj 1 1 Subsection 2 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">1.0 Objective of Study</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.03dua 1 1 Subsection 3 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">1.1 Dual Nature of Pragmatic Analysis</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.04dis 3 1 Subsection 4 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">1.2 Disputation Theory</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.05sta 4 1 Subsection 5 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">1.3 Standard Preconceptions of Irrelevance</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.06fal 6 1 Subsection 6 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">1.4 Fallacies of Emotional Distraction</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.07adm 7 1 Subsection 7 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">1.5 <i>Ad Misericordiam</i> Arguments</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.08aco 8 1 Subsection 8 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">1.6 A Contrastive Case Study</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.09the 10 1 Subsection 9 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">1.7 The <i>Ad Hominem</i> Fallacy</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.10rel 11 1 Subsection 10 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">1.8 Relevant Answers to Questions</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.11ase 16 1 Subsection 11 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">1.9 A Second Case Study of Question-Relevance</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.12fun 18 1 Subsection 12 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">1.10 Function of Questioning in Parliamentary Debate</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.13pro 20 1 Chapter 13 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">2. Propositional Inferences in Disputation</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.14rel 20 1 Subsection 14 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">2.0 Relevance in Games of Dialogue</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.15ref 21 1 Subsection 15 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">2.1 Refutation and Propositional Structure</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.16cla 23 1 Subsection 16 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">2.2 Classical Propositional Logic</TitleText> <Subtitle textformat="02">Basic Elements</Subtitle> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.17val 25 1 Subsection 17 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">2.3 Valid Arguments in Classical Logic</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.18ast 26 1 Subsection 18 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">2.4 Astounding Inferences in Classical Logic</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.19rel 28 1 Subsection 19 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">2.5 Relatedness Propositional Logic</TitleText> <Subtitle textformat="02">Basic Elements</Subtitle> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.20val 29 1 Subsection 20 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">2.6 Valid Arguments in Relatedness Logic</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.21the 31 1 Subsection 21 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">2.7 The Astounding Inferences Revisited</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.22the 32 1 Subsection 22 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">2.8 The Propositional Core of Disputation</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.23par 35 1 Chapter 23 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">3. Paradoxes, Sophisms and Relatedness</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.24the 35 1 Subsection 24 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">3.0 The Meaning of Relatedness</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.25act 35 1 Subsection 25 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">3.1 Act-Sequences and Relatedness</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.26sub 38 1 Subsection 26 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">3.2 Subject-Matter Contents of Propositions</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.27par 41 1 Subsection 27 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">3.3 Paradoxes and Astounding Inferences</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.28mis 44 1 Subsection 28 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">3.4 Missing Factors</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.29nee 46 1 Subsection 29 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">3.5 Needed Premisses in Inferences</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.30irr 48 1 Subsection 30 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">3.6 Irrelevant Premisses</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.31plu 51 1 Subsection 31 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">3.7 Pluralism of Concepts of Relevance</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.32inf 53 1 Subsection 32 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">3.8 Information Inclusion</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.33cri 56 1 Chapter 33 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">4. Criticisms of Irrelevance in Games of Dialogue</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.34six 56 1 Subsection 34 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">4.0 Six Types of Criticisms of Irrelevance</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.35var 56 1 Subsection 35 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">4.1 Varieties of Games</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.36str 58 1 Subsection 36 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">4.2 Strong and Weak Refutation</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.37sym 59 1 Subsection 37 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">4.3 Symmetrical and Asymmetrical Games</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.38mis 60 1 Subsection 38 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">4.4 Misconception of Refutation</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.39per 63 1 Subsection 39 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">4.5 Pertinence</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.40que 65 1 Subsection 40 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">4.6 Question-Answer Relevance</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.41typ 66 1 Subsection 41 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">4.7 Types of Questions and Answers</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.42rul 67 1 Subsection 42 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">4.8 Rules for Responding</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.43typ 70 1 Subsection 43 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">4.9 Types of Relevance Compared</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.44con 73 1 Subsection 44 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">4.10 Conditionals in Disputation</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.45not 75 1 Miscellaneous 45 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">Notes</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.46ref 76 1 Miscellaneous 46 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">References</TitleText> 10 01 JB code pb.iii.8.47ind 80 1 Miscellaneous 47 <TitleType>01</TitleType> <TitleText textformat="02">Index</TitleText> 02 JBENJAMINS John Benjamins Publishing Company 01 John Benjamins Publishing Company Amsterdam/Philadelphia NL 04 19820101 1982 John Benjamins 02 WORLD 01 240 mm 02 160 mm 08 175 gr 01 JB 1 John Benjamins Publishing Company +31 20 6304747 +31 20 6739773 bookorder@benjamins.nl 01 https://benjamins.com 01 WORLD US CA MX 21 5 01 02 JB 1 00 65.00 EUR R 02 02 JB 1 00 68.90 EUR R 01 JB 10 bebc +44 1202 712 934 +44 1202 712 913 sales@bebc.co.uk 03 GB 21 02 02 JB 1 00 55.00 GBP Z 01 JB 2 John Benjamins North America +1 800 562-5666 +1 703 661-1501 benjamins@presswarehouse.com 01 https://benjamins.com 01 US CA MX 21 01 gen 02 JB 1 00 98.00 USD