Does the Gricean distinction between natural and non-natural meaning exhaustively account for all instances of communication?
Anne Reboul |
Institut de Sciences Cognitives, CNRS Lyon
The Gricean distinction between natural meaning and non-natural meaning has generally been taken to apply to communication in general. However, there is some doubts that the distinction exhaustively accounts for all instances of communication. Notably, some animal communication seems to be voluntary, though not implying double-barrelled intentions, i.e., falling neither under natural nor under non-natural meaning. Another worry is how the audience can distinguish between that kind of 1st order voluntary communication and non-natural meaning. The paper shows that the Gricean distinction is not exhaustive and that the second intention characteristic of non-natural meaning is presupposed on the basis of the cost of interpretation in linguistic communication given its semantic underdetermination.
Dezecache, Guillaume, Hugo Mercier & Thomas C. Scott-Phillips
2013. An evolutionary approach to emotional communication. Journal of Pragmatics 59 ► pp. 221 ff.
Gabora, Liane & Scott Barry Kaufman
2010. Evolutionary Approaches to Creativity. In The Cambridge Handbook of Creativity, ► pp. 279 ff.
Gabora, Liane & Anne Russon
2011. The Evolution of Intelligence. In The Cambridge Handbook of Intelligence, ► pp. 328 ff.
2019. Organic Meaning: An Approach to Communication with Minimal Appeal to Minds. In Further Advances in Pragmatics and Philosophy: Part 2 Theories and Applications [Perspectives in Pragmatics, Philosophy & Psychology, 20], ► pp. 211 ff.
Scott-Phillips, Thom & Christophe Heintz
2023. Great ape interaction: Ladyginian but not Gricean. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 120:42
2010. What‐is‐Said From Different Points of View. Language and Linguistics Compass 4:8 ► pp. 705 ff.
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 3 december 2023. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers.
Any errors therein should be reported to them.