Cover not available
Article published In:
Studies in Language
Vol. 40:4 (2016) ► pp.765–814

The hypothesis of insubordination and three types of wh-exclamatives

| National Research University Higher School of Economics

This paper provides evidence for Evans’ (2007) insubordination hypothesis w.r.t. wh-exclamatives. It investigates word order in matrix wh-exclamatives and their subordinate correlates and tests matrix-subordinate asymmetry (the felicitousness of wh-words in matrix and subordinate contexts). It establishes distinctions among three groups of wh-exclamatives. Group 1 comprises qualitative and quantitative wh-exclamatives, which together seem to be a basic cross-linguistic wh-exclamative pattern. The qualitative variety demonstrates several strategies of using wh-words, some of which are exclamative-only and/or are sensitive to ellipsis of a gradable adjective/adverb. Group 2 implies the semantic hierarchy w.r.t. the felicitousness of wh-words in matrix exclamatives: ‘what’/‘who’/‘where’>‘when’>‘why’. Group 3 includes ‘which’, ‘what kind’, ‘how’ (manner) exclamatives. Unlike Groups 1 and 3, Group 2 is subject to cross-linguistic variation w.r.t. matrix-subordinate asymmetry. The paper suggests partial overlap between the established classification of wh-exclamatives and the classification developed by Nouwen and Chernilovskaya (2015) and has implications for an exclamative sentence type.

Keywords: semantics of exclamatives, syntax of exclamatives, hypothesis of insubordination, embedded wh-exclamatives, typology of exclamatives
Published online: 2 February 2017
DOI logo
https://doi.org/10.1075/sl.40.4.02zev
References
Abels, Klaus
2004 Why surprise-predicates do not embed polar interrogatives. Linguistische Arbeitsberichte 791. 203–221.Google Scholar
2005 Remarks on Grimshaw’s clausal typology. In Emar Maier, Corien Bary & Janneke Huitink (eds.), Proceedings of Sinn und Bedeutung 91. 1–15.Google Scholar
2010 Factivity in exclamatives is a presupposition. Studia Linguistica 64(1). 141–157. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Akhvlediani, Georgij S
(ed.) 1963 Grammatika osetinskogo jazyka. (The grammar of the Ossetic language). Ordzhonikidze: NII pri sovete ministrov Severo-Osetinckoj ASSR.Google Scholar
Andueza, Patricia
2011 Rhetorical exclamatives in Spanish. Columbus, OH: Ohio StateUniversity dissertation.Google Scholar
Aronson, Howard
1990 Georgian: A reading grammar. Columbus, OH: Slavica publishers.Google Scholar
Badan, Linda & Lisa Cheng
2015 Exclamatives in Mandarin Chinese. Journal of East-Asian Linguistics 24(4). 383–413. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Bagaev, Nikolaj K
1982 Sovremennyj osetinskij jazyk (Contemporary Ossetic Language). Ordzhonikidze: Ir.Google Scholar
Beyssade, Claire
2009 Exclamation and presupposition. In Paul Égré & Giorgio Magri (eds.), MIT Working Papers in Linguistics 601. 19–34.Google Scholar
Castroviejo, Elena
2006 Wh-exclamatives in Catalan. Barcelona: Universitat de Barcelona dissertation.Google Scholar
Castroviejo, Elena & Magdalena Schwager
2008 Amazing DPs. Proceedings of SALT [Semantics and Linguistic Theory] XVIII1. Ithaca, New-York: CLC publications. 176–193.
Chang, Suk-Jin
1996 Korean. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Chernilovskaya, Anna & Rick Nouwen
2012 On wh-exclamatives and noteworthiness. In Maria Aloni, Vadim Kimmelman, Floris Roelofsen, Galit Sassoon, Katrin Schulz, & Matthijs Westera (eds.), Logic, Language and Meaning: 18th Amsterdam Colloquium. Lecture notes in Computer Science, vol. 72181, 271–280. Springer. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
d’Avis, Franz-Josef
2002 On the interpretation of wh-clauses in exclamative environments. Theoretical Linguistics 28(1). 5–32. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
de Rijk, Rudolf
2008 Standard Basque: A progressive grammar. Cambridge & London: MIT Press.Google Scholar
Delfitto, Denis & Fiorin Gaetano
2014 Exclamatives: Issues of syntax, logical form and interpretation. Lingua 1521. 1–20. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Dryer, Matthew
2005 Position of interrogative phrases in content questions. In Martin Haspelmath, Matthew Dryer, David Gil & Bernard Comrie (eds.), The world atlas of language structures, 378–381. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Elliott, Dale
1974 Toward a grammar of exclamations. Foundations of language 11(2): 231–246.Google Scholar
Erelt, Mati
2003 Estonian language. Tallinn: Estonian academy publishers.Google Scholar
Erelt, Mati, Tiiu Erelt & Kristiina Ross
2007  Eesti keele käsiraamat. Tallinn. [URL] (Accessed 27 February 2016).
Evans, Nicholas
2007 Insubordination and its uses. In Irina Nikolaeva (ed.), Finiteness: Theoretical and empirical foundations, 366–431. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Faure, Richard
2012 The interaction between presupposition and focus: Classical Greek wh- exclamatives. Journal of Greek linguistics 12(2). 276–304. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Gagkaev, Konstantin E
1956 Sintaksis osetinskogo jazyka (Syntax of the Ossetic language). Ordzhonikidze: Severo-osetinskoe knizhnoe izdatel’stvo.Google Scholar
Glinert, Lewis
2005 Modern Hebrew: An essential grammar. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Göksel, Aslı & Ceila Kerslake
2005 Turkish: A comprehensive grammar. London: Routledge. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Grimshaw, Jane
1979 Complement selection and the lexicon. Linguistic inquiry 1(2). 279–326.Google Scholar
Haegeman, Liliane
1997 Introduction to elements of grammar. A handbook of generative syntax. Dordrecht: Kluwer.Google Scholar
Harris, Alice
1984 Georgian. In William Chisholm, Louis Milic & John Greppin (eds.), Interrogativity: A colloquium on the grammar, typology and pragmatics of questions in seven diverse languages, 63–112. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Hewitt, George
2005 Georgian: A learner’s grammar. London: Routledge. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Holmberg, Andres
2011 Verb second. In Tibor Kiss & Artemis Alexiadou (eds.), Syntax: An international handbook of contemporary syntactic research. Berlin: Walter de Gruyter.Google Scholar
Hualde, José I. & Ortiz de Urbana
2003 A grammar of Basque. Berlin & New York: Mouton de Gruyter. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Huddleston, Rodney
1993 Remarks on the construction You won’t believe who ED has married.Lingua 911. 175–184.Google Scholar
Kalinina, Elena
2011 Exclamative clauses in the languages of the North Caucasus and the problem of finiteness. In Gilles Authier & Timur Maisak (eds.), Tense, aspect, modality and finiteness in East-Caucasian languages, 161–201. Bochum: Brockmeyer.Google Scholar
Kautzsch, Emil
(ed.) 1910 Gesenius Hebrew grammar. Oxford: Clarendon Press.Google Scholar
Kiparsky, Paul & Carol Kiparsky
1970 Fact. In Manfred Bierwisch & Karl Heidolph (eds.), Progress in linguistics, 143–173. The Hague: Mouton.Google Scholar
Koenig, Ekkehard & Peter Siemund
2007 Speech act distinctions in grammar. In Timothy Shopen (ed.), Language typology and syntactic description, vol. 11, 276–324. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
2013 Satztyp und Typologie. In Jörg Meibauer, Markus Steinbach & Hans Altmann (eds.) Satztypen des Deutschen, 846–873. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Kovtunova, Irina I
1976 Russkij sintaksis: porjadok slov i aktual’noe chlenenie predlozhenija (Russian syntax: word order and information structure of a sentence). Moscow: Prosveshchenie.Google Scholar
Krylova, Olga A. & Serafima A. Khavronina
1976 Porjadok slov v russkom jazyke (Word order in Russian). Moscow: Russkij jazyk.Google Scholar
Kwon, Kyong
2011  What for diachronically. In Alexander Podobryaev et al. (eds.), Proceedings of Formal Approaches to Slavic Languages Conference 20. Ann Arbor, MI: Michigan University Press.Google Scholar
Lahiri, Utpal
2000 Lexical selection and quantificatonal variability in embedded interrogatives. Linguistics and Philosophy 231. 325–389. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Leu, Thomas
2007 A note on what for split. In Lisa Levinson & Oana Savescu-Ciucivara (eds.), NYU Working Papers in Linguistics, vol. 11. New York: New York University.Google Scholar
Lewis, M. Paul, Gary F. Simons & Charles D. Fennig
(eds.) 2015 Ethnologue: Languages of the World, (18th ed.). Dallas, TX: SIL International.Google Scholar
Lipták, Aniko
2001 On the syntax of wh-items in Hungarian. Utrecht: LOT dissertation.Google Scholar
2006 Word order in Hungarian exclamatives. Acta Linguistica Hungarica 53(4). 343–391. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Ljutikova, Ekaterina & Sergey Tatevosov
2009 The clause internal left edge: Exploring the preverbal position in Ossetian. Paper presented at the Third International Conference on Iranian Linguistics , Paris III, Sorbonne Nouvelle, 11–13 September.
Marandin, Jean-Marie
2008 The exclamative clause type in French. In Stefan Müller (ed.), Proceedings of the HPSG08 Conference, 436–456. CSLI Publications.Google Scholar
Mathiassen, Terje
1996 A short grammar of Lithuanian. Bloomington, IN: Slavica publishers, Inc.Google Scholar
Michaelis, Laura
2001 Exclamative constructions. In Martin Haspelmath, Ekkehard Koenig, Wulf Oesterreicher & Wolfgang Raible (eds.), Language typology and language universals. An international handbook, vol. 21, 1038–1050. Berlin & New York: Walter de Gruyter.Google Scholar
Nouwen, Rick & Anna Chernilovskaya
2015 Two types of exclamatives. Linguistic Variation 15(2). 201–224. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Obenauer, Hans-George
1994 Aspects de la syntaxe A-barre: Effets d’intervention et mouvements des quantifieurs. University of Paris 8 dissertation.Google Scholar
Olbertz, Hella
2009 Mirativity and exclamatives in functional discourse grammar: Evidence from Spanish. In Evelien Keizer & Gerry Wanders (eds.), Web-papers in functional discourse grammar, 66–82.Google Scholar
Ono, Hajime
2002 Exclamatory sentences in Japanese: A preliminary study. In Yukio Otsu (ed.), Proceedings of the Third Tokyo Conference on Psycholinguistics, 305–326. Tokyo: Hituzi Syobo Publ.Google Scholar
2006 An investigation of exclamatives in English and Japanese: Syntax and sentence processing. College Park, MD: University of Maryland dissertation.Google Scholar
Primus, Beatrice
2001 Word order typology. In Martin Haspelmath, Ekkehard Koenig, Wulf Oesterreicher & Wolfgang Raible (eds.), Language typology and language universals. An international handbook, vol. 21, 855–872. Berlin & New York: Walter de Gruyter.Google Scholar
Quirk, Randolph, Stanly Greenbaum, Geoffrey Leech & Jan Svartvik
1985 A comprehensive grammar of the English language. London: Longman.Google Scholar
Radford, Andrew
2006  Minimalist syntax revisited . [URL] (Accessed 22 February 2015)
Ramstedt, Gustaf
1939 [1968] A Korean grammar (2nd ed.). Oosterhout, The Netherlands: Anthropological Publications.Google Scholar
Repp, Sophie
2013 D-linking vs. degrees: Inflected and uninflected welch in exclamatives and rhetorical questions. Interfaces of Morphology, 59–90. Berlin: Akademie.Google Scholar
Rett, Jessica
2008a Degree modification in natural language. New Brunswick, NJ: University of Rutgers dissertation.Google Scholar
2008b A degree account of exclamatives. In Tova Friedman & Satoshi Ito (eds.), Proceedings of the 18th Semantic and Linguistic Theory Conference, 601–618. Fort Washington, PA: CLC Publications.Google Scholar
2011 Exclamatives, degrees and speech acts. Linguistics and Philosophy 34(5). 411–442. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Rett, Jessica & Sarah Murray
2013 A semantic account of mirative evidentials. Proceedings of SALT 231. 453–472.
Rudin, Catherine
1986 Aspects of Bulgarian syntax: Complementisers and wh-constructions. Columbus, OH: Slavica Publishers Inc.Google Scholar
Sæbø, Kjell
2006 Explaining clausal exclamatives. 3ieme Journée de Sémantique et Modélisation. ENS, Paris.Google Scholar
2010 On the semantics of “embedded exclamatives”. Studia Linguistica 64(1). 116– 140. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Sharvit, Yael
1999 Connectivity in specificational sentences. Natural language and linguistic theory 7(3). 299–339.Google Scholar
Shlonsky, Ur
1988 Complementiser-cliticization in Hebrew and the empty category principle. Natural Language and Linguistic Theory 6 (2). 191–205. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Shvedova, Natalia Y
(ed.) 1980 Russkaja grammatika (Russian grammar). Moscow: Nauka.Google Scholar
Siemund, Peter
2001 Interrogative constructions. In Martin Haspelmath, Ekkehard Koenig, Wulf Oesterreicher & Wolfgang Raible (eds.), Language typology and language universals. An international handbook, vol. 21, 1010–1028. Berlin, New York: Walter de Gruyter.Google Scholar
2015 Exclamative clauses in English and their relevance for theories of clause types. Studies in Language 39(3). 698–728. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Sung, Li-May
(2015) Why exclamatives in Budai Rukai. In Elisabeth Zaitoun, Stacy Teng & Joy Wu (eds.), New Advances in Formosan Linguistics, 291–312.Google Scholar
Villalba, Xavier
2003 An exceptional exclamative sentence type in Romance. Lingua 1131. 713– 745. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
2008 Exclamatives: A thematic guide with many questions and few answers. Catalan Journal of Linguistics: Exclamatives at the Interface 71. 9–40. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Yamato, Naouyki
2010 The left periphery of Japanese exclamatives. Studia Linguistica 64(1). 55–80. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Zevakhina, Natalia
2013 Syntactic strategies of exclamatives. The Journal of Estonian and Finno-Ugric Linguistics 4(2). 157–178.Google Scholar
Zanuttini, Raffaella & Paul Portner
2003 Exclamative clauses: At the syntax-semantics interface. Language 79(1). 39–81. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Cited by

Cited by 3 other publications

Heine, Bernd, Gunther Kaltenböck & Tania Kuteva
2020. On the status of wh-exclamatives in English. Functions of Language 27:2 ► pp. 207 ff. DOI logo
Troughton, Faye
2024. Quelle traduction ! A study of the translation of French quel and English what exclamatives in political discourse. Meta 68:2 ► pp. 245 ff. DOI logo
Vishenkova, Anna & Natalia Zevakhina
2019. Wh-exclamatives with and without predicates in Russian. Russian Linguistics 43:2 ► pp. 107 ff. DOI logo

This list is based on CrossRef data as of 14 april 2024. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers. Any errors therein should be reported to them.