829 03 01 01 JB code JB John Benjamins Publishing Company 01 JB code SLCS 8 Hb 15 9789027230072 06 10.1075/slcs.8 13 82226284 00 BB 01 245 mm 02 164 mm 08 785 gr 10 01 JB code SLCS 02 0165-7763 02 8.00 01 02 Studies in Language Companion Series Studies in Language Companion Series 01 01 Argumentation Approaches to theory formation. Containing the contributions to the Groningen Conference on the Theory of Argumentation, October 1978 Argumentation: Approaches to theory formation. Containing the contributions to the Groningen Conference on the Theory of Argumentation, October 1978 1 B01 01 JB code 1120 E.M. Barth Barth, E.M. E.M. Barth 07 https://benjamins.com/catalog/persons/1120 2 B01 01 JB code 1121 J.L. Martens Martens, J.L. J.L. Martens 07 https://benjamins.com/catalog/persons/1121 01 eng 11 362 03 03 xviii 03 00 333 03 01 19 160 03 1978 BC5 04 Logic--Congresses. 04 Reasoning--Congresses. 10 LAN009000 12 CF 24 JB code LIN.DISC Discourse studies 24 JB code LIN.PRAG Pragmatics 24 JB code LIN.SEMAN Semantics 01 06 03 00 The contributions in the first part ‘Re-modelling logic’ of this volume take account of formal logic in the theory of ‘rational’ argumentation. Part two contains papers that distinguish the various dialogue games for logics in terms of ‘rights’ and ‘obligations’ of the players. The authors following in the third section study the interaction between participants in a dialogue. Here the tools of the logician are used for the wider purpose of studying the nature of dialogue. The fourth section concern modes of argumentation that are actually found in philosopical texts from earlier centuries. To be followed by contributions in Part five that may be read as attempts to retrieve what was left of the spirit of criticism and debate in philosphy after the onslaught of Cartesianism and idealism. 01 00 03 01 01 D503 https://benjamins.com/covers/475/slcs.8.png 01 01 D502 https://benjamins.com/covers/475_jpg/9789027230072.jpg 01 01 D504 https://benjamins.com/covers/475_tif/9789027230072.tif 01 01 D503 https://benjamins.com/covers/1200_front/slcs.8.hb.png 01 01 D503 https://benjamins.com/covers/125/slcs.8.png 02 00 03 01 01 D503 https://benjamins.com/covers/1200_back/slcs.8.hb.png 03 00 03 01 01 D503 https://benjamins.com/covers/3d_web/slcs.8.hb.png 01 01 JB code slcs.8.01con 06 10.1075/slcs.8.01con v Miscellaneous 1 01 04 Contributors Contributors 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.02pre 06 10.1075/slcs.8.02pre vii Miscellaneous 2 01 04 Preface Preface 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.03par 06 10.1075/slcs.8.03par Section header 3 01 04 Part One: Re-Modelling Logic Part One: Re-Modelling Logic 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.04bar 06 10.1075/slcs.8.04bar 3 Miscellaneous 4 01 04 Introduction Introduction 1 A01 01 JB code 752066514 E.M. Barth Barth, E.M. E.M. Barth 07 https://benjamins.com/catalog/persons/752066514 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.05nae 06 10.1075/slcs.8.05nae 9 Chapter 5 01 04 A Necessary Component of Logic A Necessary Component of Logic 01 04 Empirical Argumentation Analysis Empirical Argumentation Analysis 1 A01 01 JB code 782066515 Arne Naess Naess, Arne Arne Naess 07 https://benjamins.com/catalog/persons/782066515 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.06log 06 10.1075/slcs.8.06log Subsection 6 01 04 1. Logic has empirical components and needs empirical research 1. Logic has empirical components and needs empirical research 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.07arg 06 10.1075/slcs.8.07arg Subsection 7 01 04 2. `Argumentation analysis' 2. ‘Argumentation analysis’ 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.08opt 06 10.1075/slcs.8.08opt Subsection 8 01 04 3. Options in a clarification and assessment game 3. Options in a clarification and assessment game 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.09ana 06 10.1075/slcs.8.09ana Subsection 9 01 04 4. Analysis of agreement and pseudo-agreement 4. Analysis of agreement and pseudo-agreement 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.10deg 06 10.1075/slcs.8.10deg Subsection 10 01 04 5. Degree of definiteness of intention (discrimination acuity) as a factor in argumentation 5. Degree of definiteness of intention (discrimination acuity) as a factor in argumentation 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.11the 06 10.1075/slcs.8.11the Subsection 11 01 04 6. The hermeneutical spiral as a factor in argumentation 6. The hermeneutical spiral as a factor in argumentation 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.12lor 06 10.1075/slcs.8.12lor 23 Chapter 12 01 04 Die Dialogische Begrundung Von Logikkalkulen Die Dialogische Begründung Von Logikkalkülen 1 A01 01 JB code 191066516 P. Lorenzen Lorenzen, P. P. Lorenzen 07 https://benjamins.com/catalog/persons/191066516 01 ger 01 01 JB code slcs.8.13dre 06 10.1075/slcs.8.13dre Subsection 13 01 04 1. Drei Typen von Logikkalkulen 1. Drei Typen von Logikkalkülen 01 ger 01 01 JB code slcs.8.14das 06 10.1075/slcs.8.14das Subsection 14 01 04 2. Das Begrundungsproblem 2. Das Begründungsproblem 01 ger 01 01 JB code slcs.8.15emp 06 10.1075/slcs.8.15emp Subsection 15 01 04 3. Empraktische Einfuhrung der Verwendungsregeln 3. Empraktische Einführung der Verwendungsregeln 01 ger 01 01 JB code slcs.8.16mat 06 10.1075/slcs.8.16mat Subsection 16 01 04 4. Materiale Dialoge 4. Materiale Dialoge 01 04 Semantik Semantik 01 ger 01 01 JB code slcs.8.17erw 06 10.1075/slcs.8.17erw Subsection 17 01 04 5. Erweiterungen der strengen Dialoge 5. Erweiterungen der strengen Dialoge 01 04 Liberalisierungen Liberalisierungen 01 ger 01 01 JB code slcs.8.18die 06 10.1075/slcs.8.18die Subsection 18 01 04 6. Die effektive Dialogregel 6. Die effektive Dialogregel 01 ger 01 01 JB code slcs.8.19das 06 10.1075/slcs.8.19das Subsection 19 01 04 7. Das Problem der Konsistenz 7. Das Problem der Konsistenz 01 04 Schnittregel Schnittregel 01 ger 01 01 JB code slcs.8.20die 06 10.1075/slcs.8.20die Subsection 20 01 04 8. Die klassische Dialogregel 8. Die klassische Dialogregel 01 ger 01 01 JB code slcs.8.21die 06 10.1075/slcs.8.21die Subsection 21 01 04 9. Die Beziehung materialer Dialoge zu Logikkalkulen 9. Die Beziehung materialer Dialoge zu Logikkalkülen 01 ger 01 01 JB code slcs.8.22zur 06 10.1075/slcs.8.22zur Subsection 22 01 04 10. Zur Frage der sog 10. Zur Frage der sog 01 04 Vollstandigkeit Vollständigkeit 01 ger 01 01 JB code slcs.8.23vol 06 10.1075/slcs.8.23vol Subsection 23 01 04 11. Vollstandigkeit ohne Semantik 11. Vollständigkeit ohne Semantik 01 ger 01 01 JB code slcs.8.24hin 06 10.1075/slcs.8.24hin 55 Chapter 24 01 04 Sherlock Holmes Confronts Modern Logic Sherlock Holmes Confronts Modern Logic 01 04 Toward a Theory of Information-Seeking Through Questioning Toward a Theory of Information-Seeking Through Questioning 1 A01 01 JB code 602066517 Jaakko Hintikka Hintikka, Jaakko Jaakko Hintikka 07 https://benjamins.com/catalog/persons/602066517 2 A01 01 JB code 681066518 Merrill B. Hintikka Hintikka, Merrill B. Merrill B. Hintikka 07 https://benjamins.com/catalog/persons/681066518 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.25she 06 10.1075/slcs.8.25she Subsection 25 01 04 1. Sherlock Holmes vs. philosophers on deduction 1. Sherlock Holmes vs. philosophers on deduction 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.26mak 06 10.1075/slcs.8.26mak Subsection 26 01 04 2. Making tacit information explicit through questioning 2. Making tacit information explicit through questioning 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.27the 06 10.1075/slcs.8.27the Subsection 27 01 04 3. The structure of question-inference complexes 3. The structure of question-inference complexes 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.28ont 06 10.1075/slcs.8.28ont Subsection 28 01 04 4. On the principle of total evidence. Bayesianism 4. On the principle of total evidence. Bayesianism 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.29the 06 10.1075/slcs.8.29the Subsection 29 01 04 5. The role of observations 5. The role of observations 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.30que 06 10.1075/slcs.8.30que Subsection 30 01 04 6. Question-answer sequences as games against Nature 6. Question-answer sequences as games against Nature 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.31pay 06 10.1075/slcs.8.31pay Subsection 31 01 04 7. Payoffs and strategies 7. Payoffs and strategies 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.32ded 06 10.1075/slcs.8.32ded Subsection 32 01 04 8. Deductions sometimes replaceable by questions and answers 8. Deductions sometimes replaceable by questions and answers 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.33hin 06 10.1075/slcs.8.33hin 77 Chapter 33 01 04 Semantical Games and Transcendental Arguments Semantical Games and Transcendental Arguments 1 A01 01 JB code 11066519 Jaakko Hintikka Hintikka, Jaakko Jaakko Hintikka 07 https://benjamins.com/catalog/persons/11066519 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.34kan 06 10.1075/slcs.8.34kan Subsection 34 01 04 1. Kant on the logic of existence 1. Kant on the logic of existence 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.35see 06 10.1075/slcs.8.35see Subsection 35 01 04 2. Seeking and finding, and game-theoretical semantics 2. Seeking and finding, and game-theoretical semantics 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.36atr 06 10.1075/slcs.8.36atr Subsection 36 01 04 3. A transcendental refutation of certain related views 3. A transcendental refutation of certain related views 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.37ate 06 10.1075/slcs.8.37ate Subsection 37 01 04 4. A test-case 4. A test-case 01 04 branching quantifiers branching quantifiers 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.38mat 06 10.1075/slcs.8.38mat Subsection 38 01 04 5. Material vs. logical truth, formal argumentation, and semantics 5. Material vs. logical truth, formal argumentation, and semantics 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.39fro 06 10.1075/slcs.8.39fro Subsection 39 01 04 6. From semantical games to dialogical ones 6. From semantical games to dialogical ones 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.40apo 06 10.1075/slcs.8.40apo 93 Chapter 40 01 04 Towards a General Theory of Argumentation Towards a General Theory of Argumentation 1 A01 01 JB code 205066520 Leo Apostel Apostel, Leo Leo Apostel 07 https://benjamins.com/catalog/persons/205066520 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.41log 06 10.1075/slcs.8.41log Subsection 41 01 04 1. Logic and rhetorics, heuristics, proof theory 1. Logic and rhetorics, heuristics, proof theory 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.42the 06 10.1075/slcs.8.42the Subsection 42 01 04 2. Theory of discussion 2. Theory of discussion 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.43wha 06 10.1075/slcs.8.43wha Subsection 43 01 04 3. What are discussions? 3. What are discussions? 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.44red 06 10.1075/slcs.8.44red Subsection 44 01 04 4. Reduction to the theory of (inter-)action 4. Reduction to the theory of (inter-)action 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.45pro 06 10.1075/slcs.8.45pro Subsection 45 01 04 5. "Proponent", "Opponent", "defence" and "attack" 5. “Proponent”, “Opponent”, “defence” and “attack” 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.46sys 06 10.1075/slcs.8.46sys Subsection 46 01 04 6. Systematic connections between the theory of games and some theories discussed at this conference 6. Systematic connections between the theory of games and some theories discussed at this conference 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.47ham 06 10.1075/slcs.8.47ham Subsection 47 01 04 7. Hamblin's theory 7. Hamblin's theory 01 04 What is an argument? What is an argument? 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.48dec 06 10.1075/slcs.8.48dec Subsection 48 01 04 8. Decomposition of argumentative texts 8. Decomposition of argumentative texts 01 04 Sub-games Sub-games 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.49equ 06 10.1075/slcs.8.49equ Subsection 49 01 04 9. Equivocation and use of metaphors 9. Equivocation and use of metaphors 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.50kra 06 10.1075/slcs.8.50kra 123 Chapter 50 01 04 Theory of Argumentation and the Dialectical Garb of Formal Logic Theory of Argumentation and the Dialectical Garb of Formal Logic 1 A01 01 JB code 655066521 Erik C.W. Krabbe Krabbe, Erik C.W. Erik C.W. Krabbe 07 https://benjamins.com/catalog/persons/655066521 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.51inh 06 10.1075/slcs.8.51inh 133 Chapter 51 01 04 Ein Konstruktiver Weg Zur Semantik Der "Moglichen Welten" Ein Konstruktiver Weg Zur Semantik Der “Möglichen Welten” 1 A01 01 JB code 816066522 Rüdiger Inhetveen Inhetveen, Rüdiger Rüdiger Inhetveen 07 https://benjamins.com/catalog/persons/816066522 01 ger 01 01 JB code slcs.8.52dia 06 10.1075/slcs.8.52dia Subsection 52 01 04 1. Dialogebenen 1. Dialogebenen 01 04 Spielregel Spielregel 01 ger 01 01 JB code slcs.8.53bei 06 10.1075/slcs.8.53bei Subsection 53 01 04 2. Beispiele 2. Beispiele 01 ger 01 01 JB code slcs.8.54bez 06 10.1075/slcs.8.54bez Subsection 54 01 04 3. Beziehung zu den modallogischen Standardsystemen 3. Beziehung zu den modallogischen Standardsystemen 01 ger 01 01 JB code slcs.8.55par 06 10.1075/slcs.8.55par Section header 55 01 04 Part Two: Choosing the Rules Part Two: Choosing the Rules 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.56bar 06 10.1075/slcs.8.56bar 143 Chapter 56 01 04 Introduction Introduction 1 A01 01 JB code 41066523 E.M. Barth Barth, E.M. E.M. Barth 07 https://benjamins.com/catalog/persons/41066523 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.57lor 06 10.1075/slcs.8.57lor 145 Chapter 57 01 04 On the Criteria for the Choice of Rules of Dialogic Logic On the Criteria for the Choice of Rules of Dialogic Logic 1 A01 01 JB code 112066524 Kuno Lorenz Lorenz, Kuno Kuno Lorenz 07 https://benjamins.com/catalog/persons/112066524 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.58aga 06 10.1075/slcs.8.58aga Subsection 58 01 04 1. A game-theoretic pragmatic conception of truth 1. A game-theoretic pragmatic conception of truth 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.59spe 06 10.1075/slcs.8.59spe Subsection 59 01 04 2. Specifying the game ("global" game rules) 2. Specifying the game (“global” game rules) 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.60arg 06 10.1075/slcs.8.60arg Subsection 60 01 04 3. Argument rules ("local" game rules) 3. Argument rules (“local” game rules) 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.61sub 06 10.1075/slcs.8.61sub Subsection 61 01 04 4. Subjunction 4. Subjunction 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.62for 06 10.1075/slcs.8.62for Subsection 62 01 04 5. Formal winning-strategy and formal truth 5. Formal winning-strategy and formal truth 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.63ath 06 10.1075/slcs.8.63ath Subsection 63 01 04 6. A theorem of formal dialogic logic 6. A theorem of formal dialogic logic 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.64bar 06 10.1075/slcs.8.64bar 159 Chapter 64 01 04 A Normative-Pragmatical Foundation of the Rules of some Systems of Formal3 Dialectics A Normative-Pragmatical Foundation of the Rules of some Systems of Formal3 Dialectics 1 A01 01 JB code 355066525 E.M. Barth Barth, E.M. E.M. Barth 07 https://benjamins.com/catalog/persons/355066525 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.65new 06 10.1075/slcs.8.65new Subsection 65 01 04 1. New foundations 1. New foundations 01 04 Statemental dialogue attitudes Statemental dialogue attitudes 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.66two 06 10.1075/slcs.8.66two Subsection 66 01 04 2. Two purposes -- presentation of the dialectical systems, and the problem of fallacy 2. Two purposes — presentation of the dialectical systems, and the problem of fallacy 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.67bas 06 10.1075/slcs.8.67bas Subsection 67 01 04 3. Basic norms and ends; implementations 3. Basic norms and ends; implementations 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.68dia 06 10.1075/slcs.8.68dia Subsection 68 01 04 4. Dialectics should be systematic and thorough going 4. Dialectics should be systematic and thorough going 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.69dia 06 10.1075/slcs.8.69dia Subsection 69 01 04 5. Dialectics should be orderly and dynamic 5. Dialectics should be orderly and dynamic 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.70epi 06 10.1075/slcs.8.70epi Subsection 70 01 04 6. Epilogue 6. Epilogue 01 04 The three elementary phases of a critical discussion The three elementary phases of a critical discussion 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.71par 06 10.1075/slcs.8.71par Section header 71 01 04 Part Three: Describing Argumentative Dialogues Part Three: Describing Argumentative Dialogues 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.72bar 06 10.1075/slcs.8.72bar 171 Chapter 72 01 04 Introduction Introduction 1 A01 01 JB code 666066526 E.M. Barth Barth, E.M. E.M. Barth 07 https://benjamins.com/catalog/persons/666066526 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.73gun 06 10.1075/slcs.8.73gun 175 Chapter 73 01 04 A Set of Concepts for the Study of Dialogical Argumentation A Set of Concepts for the Study of Dialogical Argumentation 1 A01 01 JB code 831066527 Arnold Gunther Gunther, Arnold Arnold Gunther 07 https://benjamins.com/catalog/persons/831066527 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.74int 06 10.1075/slcs.8.74int Subsection 74 01 04 1. Introduction 1. Introduction 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.75arg 06 10.1075/slcs.8.75arg Subsection 75 01 04 2. Argumentation -- informally described 2. Argumentation — informally described 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.76dia 06 10.1075/slcs.8.76dia Subsection 76 01 04 3. Dialogue bases 3. Dialogue bases 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.77coo 06 10.1075/slcs.8.77coo Subsection 77 01 04 4. Co-operative argumentative dialogues and argumentation 4. Co-operative argumentative dialogues and argumentation 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.78hei 06 10.1075/slcs.8.78hei 191 Chapter 78 01 04 Montague-Grammars for Argumentative Dialogues Montague-Grammars for Argumentative Dialogues 1 A01 01 JB code 11066528 Carl H. Heidrich Heidrich, Carl H. Carl H. Heidrich 07 https://benjamins.com/catalog/persons/11066528 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.79int 06 10.1075/slcs.8.79int Subsection 79 01 04 1. Introduction 1. Introduction 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.80bac 06 10.1075/slcs.8.80bac Subsection 80 01 04 2. Background and motivation 2. Background and motivation 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.81ane 06 10.1075/slcs.8.81ane Subsection 81 01 04 3. An example of a dialogue 3. An example of a dialogue 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.82amo 06 10.1075/slcs.8.82amo Subsection 82 01 04 4. A Montague-grammar 4. A Montague-grammar 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.83par 06 10.1075/slcs.8.83par Section header 83 01 04 Part Four: Analysing Philosophy Part Four: Analysing Philosophy 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.84bar 06 10.1075/slcs.8.84bar 229 Chapter 84 01 04 Introduction Introduction 1 A01 01 JB code 205066529 E.M. Barth Barth, E.M. E.M. Barth 07 https://benjamins.com/catalog/persons/205066529 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.85kra 06 10.1075/slcs.8.85kra 233 Chapter 85 01 04 Formal Dialectics as Immanent Criticism of Philosophical Systems Formal Dialectics as Immanent Criticism of Philosophical Systems 1 A01 01 JB code 273066530 Erik C.W. Krabbe Krabbe, Erik C.W. Erik C.W. Krabbe 07 https://benjamins.com/catalog/persons/273066530 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.86int 06 10.1075/slcs.8.86int Subsection 86 01 04 1. Introduction 1. Introduction 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.87the 06 10.1075/slcs.8.87the Subsection 87 01 04 2. The provocative thesis 2. The provocative thesis 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.88cri 06 10.1075/slcs.8.88cri Subsection 88 01 04 3. Critical interpretation of the logical constants 3. Critical interpretation of the logical constants 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.89inf 06 10.1075/slcs.8.89inf Subsection 89 01 04 4. Information-seeking interpretation of the logical constants 4. Information-seeking interpretation of the logical constants 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.90nae 06 10.1075/slcs.8.90nae 245 Chapter 90 01 04 An Application of Empirical Argumentation Analysis to Spinoza's "Ethics" An Application of Empirical Argumentation Analysis to Spinoza's “Ethics” 1 A01 01 JB code 539066531 Arne Naess Naess, Arne Arne Naess 07 https://benjamins.com/catalog/persons/539066531 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.91the 06 10.1075/slcs.8.91the Subsection 91 01 04 1. The propositions of the "Ethics" conceived of as arguments in a debate 1. The propositions of the “Ethics” conceived of as arguments in a debate 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.92spi 06 10.1075/slcs.8.92spi Subsection 92 01 04 2. Spinoza's theses of equivalence 2. Spinoza's theses of equivalence 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.93equ 06 10.1075/slcs.8.93equ Subsection 93 01 04 3. Equivalences as arguments 3. Equivalences as arguments 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.94bar 06 10.1075/slcs.8.94bar 257 Chapter 94 01 04 Finite Debates About "The Infinite" Finite Debates About “The Infinite” 1 A01 01 JB code 729066532 E.M. Barth Barth, E.M. E.M. Barth 07 https://benjamins.com/catalog/persons/729066532 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.95two 06 10.1075/slcs.8.95two Subsection 95 01 04 1. Two philosophical paradigms 1. Two philosophical paradigms 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.96ton 06 10.1075/slcs.8.96ton Subsection 96 01 04 2. "Tongue-twisting for the sake of consistency" -- a recent description of the Weierstrass method 2. “Tongue-twisting for the sake of consistency” — a recent description of the Weierstrass method 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.97two 06 10.1075/slcs.8.97two Subsection 97 01 04 3. Two-role logic and the notion of `limit' 3. Two-role logic and the notion of ‘limit’ 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.98ins 06 10.1075/slcs.8.98ins Subsection 98 01 04 4. Instantaneous velocities 4. Instantaneous velocities 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.99par 06 10.1075/slcs.8.99par Subsection 99 01 04 5. Paradigmatically misleading expressions 5. Paradigmatically misleading expressions 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.100con 06 10.1075/slcs.8.100con Subsection 100 01 04 6. Conclusion 6. Conclusion 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.101par 06 10.1075/slcs.8.101par Section header 101 01 04 Part Five: Analysing Interaction Part Five: Analysing Interaction 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.102bar 06 10.1075/slcs.8.102bar 271 Chapter 102 01 04 Introduction Introduction 1 A01 01 JB code 26066533 E.M. Barth Barth, E.M. E.M. Barth 07 https://benjamins.com/catalog/persons/26066533 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.103leo 06 10.1075/slcs.8.103leo 273 Chapter 103 01 04 A Decision-Theoretical Interpretation of Dialogues A Decision-Theoretical Interpretation of Dialogues 1 A01 01 JB code 89066534 Ulrike Leopold-Wildburger Leopold-Wildburger, Ulrike Ulrike Leopold-Wildburger 07 https://benjamins.com/catalog/persons/89066534 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.104dun 06 10.1075/slcs.8.104dun 281 Chapter 104 01 04 On the Philosophy of Argument and the Logic of Common Morality On the Philosophy of Argument and the Logic of Common Morality 1 A01 01 JB code 131066535 F. van Dun Dun, F. van F. van Dun 07 https://benjamins.com/catalog/persons/131066535 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.105dia 06 10.1075/slcs.8.105dia Subsection 105 01 04 1. Dialectical argument and first principles 1. Dialectical argument and first principles 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.106the 06 10.1075/slcs.8.106the Subsection 106 01 04 2. The fundamental principle of morality 2. The fundamental principle of morality 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.107adi 06 10.1075/slcs.8.107adi Subsection 107 01 04 3. A dialogical approach to the logic of common morality 3. A dialogical approach to the logic of common morality 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.108the 06 10.1075/slcs.8.108the Section header 108 01 04 Theory of Argumentation Theory of Argumentation 01 04 A Chronological Bibliography of some Important Works A Chronological Bibliography of some Important Works 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.109ach 06 10.1075/slcs.8.109ach 295 Miscellaneous 109 01 04 A. Chronological Bibliography A. Chronological Bibliography 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.110bin 06 10.1075/slcs.8.110bin 329 Miscellaneous 110 01 04 B. Index of Names to Chronological Bibliography B. Index of Names to Chronological Bibliography 01 eng 01 JB code JBENJAMINS John Benjamins Publishing Company 01 01 JB code JB John Benjamins Publishing Company 01 https://benjamins.com 02 https://benjamins.com/catalog/slcs.8 Amsterdam NL 00 John Benjamins Publishing Company Marketing Department / Karin Plijnaar, Pieter Lamers onix@benjamins.nl 04 01 00 19820101 C 1982 John Benjamins Publishing Company D 1982 John Benjamins Publishing Company 02 WORLD WORLD US CA MX 09 01 JB 1 John Benjamins Publishing Company +31 20 6304747 +31 20 6739773 bookorder@benjamins.nl 01 https://benjamins.com 21 5 01 00 Unqualified price 02 JB 1 02 120.00 EUR 02 00 Unqualified price 02 101.00 01 Z 0 GBP GB US CA MX 01 01 JB 2 John Benjamins Publishing Company +1 800 562-5666 +1 703 661-1501 benjamins@presswarehouse.com 01 https://benjamins.com 21 5 01 00 Unqualified price 02 JB 1 02 180.00 USD 345014175 03 01 01 JB code JB John Benjamins Publishing Company 01 JB code SLCS 8 GE 15 9789027283160 06 10.1075/slcs.8 00 EA E133 10 01 JB code SLCS 02 JB code 0165-7763 02 8.00 01 02 Studies in Language Companion Series Studies in Language Companion Series 01 01 Argumentation Argumentation 1 B01 01 JB code 1120 E.M. Barth Barth, E.M. E.M. Barth 2 B01 01 JB code 1121 J.L. Martens Martens, J.L. J.L. Martens 01 eng 11 362 03 03 xviii 03 00 333 03 24 JB code LIN.DISC Discourse studies 24 JB code LIN.PRAG Pragmatics 24 JB code LIN.SEMAN Semantics 10 LAN009000 12 CF 01 06 03 00 The contributions in the first part ‘Re-modelling logic’ of this volume take account of formal logic in the theory of ‘rational’ argumentation. Part two contains papers that distinguish the various dialogue games for logics in terms of ‘rights’ and ‘obligations’ of the players. The authors following in the third section study the interaction between participants in a dialogue. Here the tools of the logician are used for the wider purpose of studying the nature of dialogue. The fourth section concern modes of argumentation that are actually found in philosopical texts from earlier centuries. To be followed by contributions in Part five that may be read as attempts to retrieve what was left of the spirit of criticism and debate in philosphy after the onslaught of Cartesianism and idealism. 01 00 03 01 01 D503 https://benjamins.com/covers/475/slcs.8.png 01 01 D502 https://benjamins.com/covers/475_jpg/9789027230072.jpg 01 01 D504 https://benjamins.com/covers/475_tif/9789027230072.tif 01 01 D503 https://benjamins.com/covers/1200_front/slcs.8.hb.png 01 01 D503 https://benjamins.com/covers/125/slcs.8.png 02 00 03 01 01 D503 https://benjamins.com/covers/1200_back/slcs.8.hb.png 03 00 03 01 01 D503 https://benjamins.com/covers/3d_web/slcs.8.hb.png 01 01 JB code slcs.8.01con 06 10.1075/slcs.8.01con v Miscellaneous 1 01 04 Contributors Contributors 01 01 JB code slcs.8.02pre 06 10.1075/slcs.8.02pre vii Miscellaneous 2 01 04 Preface Preface 01 01 JB code slcs.8.03par 06 10.1075/slcs.8.03par Section header 3 01 04 Part One: Re-Modelling Logic Part One: Re-Modelling Logic 01 01 JB code slcs.8.04bar 06 10.1075/slcs.8.04bar 3 Miscellaneous 4 01 04 Introduction Introduction 1 A01 01 JB code 752066514 E.M. Barth Barth, E.M. E.M. Barth 01 01 JB code slcs.8.05nae 06 10.1075/slcs.8.05nae 9 Chapter 5 01 04 A Necessary Component of Logic A Necessary Component of Logic 01 04 Empirical Argumentation Analysis Empirical Argumentation Analysis 1 A01 01 JB code 782066515 Arne Naess Naess, Arne Arne Naess 01 01 JB code slcs.8.06log 06 10.1075/slcs.8.06log Subsection 6 01 04 1. Logic has empirical components and needs empirical research 1. Logic has empirical components and needs empirical research 01 01 JB code slcs.8.07arg 06 10.1075/slcs.8.07arg Subsection 7 01 04 2. `Argumentation analysis' 2. ‘Argumentation analysis’ 01 01 JB code slcs.8.08opt 06 10.1075/slcs.8.08opt Subsection 8 01 04 3. Options in a clarification and assessment game 3. Options in a clarification and assessment game 01 01 JB code slcs.8.09ana 06 10.1075/slcs.8.09ana Subsection 9 01 04 4. Analysis of agreement and pseudo-agreement 4. Analysis of agreement and pseudo-agreement 01 01 JB code slcs.8.10deg 06 10.1075/slcs.8.10deg Subsection 10 01 04 5. Degree of definiteness of intention (discrimination acuity) as a factor in argumentation 5. Degree of definiteness of intention (discrimination acuity) as a factor in argumentation 01 01 JB code slcs.8.11the 06 10.1075/slcs.8.11the Subsection 11 01 04 6. The hermeneutical spiral as a factor in argumentation 6. The hermeneutical spiral as a factor in argumentation 01 01 JB code slcs.8.12lor 06 10.1075/slcs.8.12lor 23 Chapter 12 01 04 Die Dialogische Begrundung Von Logikkalkulen Die Dialogische Begründung Von Logikkalkülen 1 A01 01 JB code 191066516 P. Lorenzen Lorenzen, P. P. Lorenzen 01 01 JB code slcs.8.13dre 06 10.1075/slcs.8.13dre Subsection 13 01 04 1. Drei Typen von Logikkalkulen 1. Drei Typen von Logikkalkülen 01 01 JB code slcs.8.14das 06 10.1075/slcs.8.14das Subsection 14 01 04 2. Das Begrundungsproblem 2. Das Begründungsproblem 01 01 JB code slcs.8.15emp 06 10.1075/slcs.8.15emp Subsection 15 01 04 3. Empraktische Einfuhrung der Verwendungsregeln 3. Empraktische Einführung der Verwendungsregeln 01 01 JB code slcs.8.16mat 06 10.1075/slcs.8.16mat Subsection 16 01 04 4. Materiale Dialoge 4. Materiale Dialoge 01 04 Semantik Semantik 01 01 JB code slcs.8.17erw 06 10.1075/slcs.8.17erw Subsection 17 01 04 5. Erweiterungen der strengen Dialoge 5. Erweiterungen der strengen Dialoge 01 04 Liberalisierungen Liberalisierungen 01 01 JB code slcs.8.18die 06 10.1075/slcs.8.18die Subsection 18 01 04 6. Die effektive Dialogregel 6. Die effektive Dialogregel 01 01 JB code slcs.8.19das 06 10.1075/slcs.8.19das Subsection 19 01 04 7. Das Problem der Konsistenz 7. Das Problem der Konsistenz 01 04 Schnittregel Schnittregel 01 01 JB code slcs.8.20die 06 10.1075/slcs.8.20die Subsection 20 01 04 8. Die klassische Dialogregel 8. Die klassische Dialogregel 01 01 JB code slcs.8.21die 06 10.1075/slcs.8.21die Subsection 21 01 04 9. Die Beziehung materialer Dialoge zu Logikkalkulen 9. Die Beziehung materialer Dialoge zu Logikkalkülen 01 01 JB code slcs.8.22zur 06 10.1075/slcs.8.22zur Subsection 22 01 04 10. Zur Frage der sog 10. Zur Frage der sog 01 04 Vollstandigkeit Vollständigkeit 01 01 JB code slcs.8.23vol 06 10.1075/slcs.8.23vol Subsection 23 01 04 11. Vollstandigkeit ohne Semantik 11. Vollständigkeit ohne Semantik 01 01 JB code slcs.8.24hin 06 10.1075/slcs.8.24hin 55 Chapter 24 01 04 Sherlock Holmes Confronts Modern Logic Sherlock Holmes Confronts Modern Logic 01 04 Toward a Theory of Information-Seeking Through Questioning Toward a Theory of Information-Seeking Through Questioning 1 A01 01 JB code 602066517 Jaakko Hintikka Hintikka, Jaakko Jaakko Hintikka 2 A01 01 JB code 681066518 Merrill B. Hintikka Hintikka, Merrill B. Merrill B. Hintikka 01 01 JB code slcs.8.25she 06 10.1075/slcs.8.25she Subsection 25 01 04 1. Sherlock Holmes vs. philosophers on deduction 1. Sherlock Holmes vs. philosophers on deduction 01 01 JB code slcs.8.26mak 06 10.1075/slcs.8.26mak Subsection 26 01 04 2. Making tacit information explicit through questioning 2. Making tacit information explicit through questioning 01 01 JB code slcs.8.27the 06 10.1075/slcs.8.27the Subsection 27 01 04 3. The structure of question-inference complexes 3. The structure of question-inference complexes 01 01 JB code slcs.8.28ont 06 10.1075/slcs.8.28ont Subsection 28 01 04 4. On the principle of total evidence. Bayesianism 4. On the principle of total evidence. Bayesianism 01 01 JB code slcs.8.29the 06 10.1075/slcs.8.29the Subsection 29 01 04 5. The role of observations 5. The role of observations 01 01 JB code slcs.8.30que 06 10.1075/slcs.8.30que Subsection 30 01 04 6. Question-answer sequences as games against Nature 6. Question-answer sequences as games against Nature 01 01 JB code slcs.8.31pay 06 10.1075/slcs.8.31pay Subsection 31 01 04 7. Payoffs and strategies 7. Payoffs and strategies 01 01 JB code slcs.8.32ded 06 10.1075/slcs.8.32ded Subsection 32 01 04 8. Deductions sometimes replaceable by questions and answers 8. Deductions sometimes replaceable by questions and answers 01 01 JB code slcs.8.33hin 06 10.1075/slcs.8.33hin 77 Chapter 33 01 04 Semantical Games and Transcendental Arguments Semantical Games and Transcendental Arguments 1 A01 01 JB code 11066519 Jaakko Hintikka Hintikka, Jaakko Jaakko Hintikka 01 01 JB code slcs.8.34kan 06 10.1075/slcs.8.34kan Subsection 34 01 04 1. Kant on the logic of existence 1. Kant on the logic of existence 01 01 JB code slcs.8.35see 06 10.1075/slcs.8.35see Subsection 35 01 04 2. Seeking and finding, and game-theoretical semantics 2. Seeking and finding, and game-theoretical semantics 01 01 JB code slcs.8.36atr 06 10.1075/slcs.8.36atr Subsection 36 01 04 3. A transcendental refutation of certain related views 3. A transcendental refutation of certain related views 01 01 JB code slcs.8.37ate 06 10.1075/slcs.8.37ate Subsection 37 01 04 4. A test-case 4. A test-case 01 04 branching quantifiers branching quantifiers 01 01 JB code slcs.8.38mat 06 10.1075/slcs.8.38mat Subsection 38 01 04 5. Material vs. logical truth, formal argumentation, and semantics 5. Material vs. logical truth, formal argumentation, and semantics 01 01 JB code slcs.8.39fro 06 10.1075/slcs.8.39fro Subsection 39 01 04 6. From semantical games to dialogical ones 6. From semantical games to dialogical ones 01 01 JB code slcs.8.40apo 06 10.1075/slcs.8.40apo 93 Chapter 40 01 04 Towards a General Theory of Argumentation Towards a General Theory of Argumentation 1 A01 01 JB code 205066520 Leo Apostel Apostel, Leo Leo Apostel 01 01 JB code slcs.8.41log 06 10.1075/slcs.8.41log Subsection 41 01 04 1. Logic and rhetorics, heuristics, proof theory 1. Logic and rhetorics, heuristics, proof theory 01 01 JB code slcs.8.42the 06 10.1075/slcs.8.42the Subsection 42 01 04 2. Theory of discussion 2. Theory of discussion 01 01 JB code slcs.8.43wha 06 10.1075/slcs.8.43wha Subsection 43 01 04 3. What are discussions? 3. What are discussions? 01 01 JB code slcs.8.44red 06 10.1075/slcs.8.44red Subsection 44 01 04 4. Reduction to the theory of (inter-)action 4. Reduction to the theory of (inter-)action 01 01 JB code slcs.8.45pro 06 10.1075/slcs.8.45pro Subsection 45 01 04 5. "Proponent", "Opponent", "defence" and "attack" 5. “Proponent”, “Opponent”, “defence” and “attack” 01 01 JB code slcs.8.46sys 06 10.1075/slcs.8.46sys Subsection 46 01 04 6. Systematic connections between the theory of games and some theories discussed at this conference 6. Systematic connections between the theory of games and some theories discussed at this conference 01 01 JB code slcs.8.47ham 06 10.1075/slcs.8.47ham Subsection 47 01 04 7. Hamblin's theory 7. Hamblin's theory 01 04 What is an argument? What is an argument? 01 01 JB code slcs.8.48dec 06 10.1075/slcs.8.48dec Subsection 48 01 04 8. Decomposition of argumentative texts 8. Decomposition of argumentative texts 01 04 Sub-games Sub-games 01 01 JB code slcs.8.49equ 06 10.1075/slcs.8.49equ Subsection 49 01 04 9. Equivocation and use of metaphors 9. Equivocation and use of metaphors 01 01 JB code slcs.8.50kra 06 10.1075/slcs.8.50kra 123 Chapter 50 01 04 Theory of Argumentation and the Dialectical Garb of Formal Logic Theory of Argumentation and the Dialectical Garb of Formal Logic 1 A01 01 JB code 655066521 Erik C.W. Krabbe Krabbe, Erik C.W. Erik C.W. Krabbe 01 01 JB code slcs.8.51inh 06 10.1075/slcs.8.51inh 133 Chapter 51 01 04 Ein Konstruktiver Weg Zur Semantik Der "Moglichen Welten" Ein Konstruktiver Weg Zur Semantik Der “Möglichen Welten” 1 A01 01 JB code 816066522 Rüdiger Inhetveen Inhetveen, Rüdiger Rüdiger Inhetveen 01 01 JB code slcs.8.52dia 06 10.1075/slcs.8.52dia Subsection 52 01 04 1. Dialogebenen 1. Dialogebenen 01 04 Spielregel Spielregel 01 01 JB code slcs.8.53bei 06 10.1075/slcs.8.53bei Subsection 53 01 04 2. Beispiele 2. Beispiele 01 01 JB code slcs.8.54bez 06 10.1075/slcs.8.54bez Subsection 54 01 04 3. Beziehung zu den modallogischen Standardsystemen 3. Beziehung zu den modallogischen Standardsystemen 01 01 JB code slcs.8.55par 06 10.1075/slcs.8.55par Section header 55 01 04 Part Two: Choosing the Rules Part Two: Choosing the Rules 01 01 JB code slcs.8.56bar 06 10.1075/slcs.8.56bar 143 Chapter 56 01 04 Introduction Introduction 1 A01 01 JB code 41066523 E.M. Barth Barth, E.M. E.M. Barth 01 01 JB code slcs.8.57lor 06 10.1075/slcs.8.57lor 145 Chapter 57 01 04 On the Criteria for the Choice of Rules of Dialogic Logic On the Criteria for the Choice of Rules of Dialogic Logic 1 A01 01 JB code 112066524 Kuno Lorenz Lorenz, Kuno Kuno Lorenz 01 01 JB code slcs.8.58aga 06 10.1075/slcs.8.58aga Subsection 58 01 04 1. A game-theoretic pragmatic conception of truth 1. A game-theoretic pragmatic conception of truth 01 01 JB code slcs.8.59spe 06 10.1075/slcs.8.59spe Subsection 59 01 04 2. Specifying the game ("global" game rules) 2. Specifying the game (“global” game rules) 01 01 JB code slcs.8.60arg 06 10.1075/slcs.8.60arg Subsection 60 01 04 3. Argument rules ("local" game rules) 3. Argument rules (“local” game rules) 01 01 JB code slcs.8.61sub 06 10.1075/slcs.8.61sub Subsection 61 01 04 4. Subjunction 4. Subjunction 01 01 JB code slcs.8.62for 06 10.1075/slcs.8.62for Subsection 62 01 04 5. Formal winning-strategy and formal truth 5. Formal winning-strategy and formal truth 01 01 JB code slcs.8.63ath 06 10.1075/slcs.8.63ath Subsection 63 01 04 6. A theorem of formal dialogic logic 6. A theorem of formal dialogic logic 01 01 JB code slcs.8.64bar 06 10.1075/slcs.8.64bar 159 Chapter 64 01 04 A Normative-Pragmatical Foundation of the Rules of some Systems of Formal3 Dialectics A Normative-Pragmatical Foundation of the Rules of some Systems of Formal3 Dialectics 1 A01 01 JB code 355066525 E.M. Barth Barth, E.M. E.M. Barth 01 01 JB code slcs.8.65new 06 10.1075/slcs.8.65new Subsection 65 01 04 1. New foundations 1. New foundations 01 04 Statemental dialogue attitudes Statemental dialogue attitudes 01 01 JB code slcs.8.66two 06 10.1075/slcs.8.66two Subsection 66 01 04 2. Two purposes -- presentation of the dialectical systems, and the problem of fallacy 2. Two purposes — presentation of the dialectical systems, and the problem of fallacy 01 01 JB code slcs.8.67bas 06 10.1075/slcs.8.67bas Subsection 67 01 04 3. Basic norms and ends; implementations 3. Basic norms and ends; implementations 01 01 JB code slcs.8.68dia 06 10.1075/slcs.8.68dia Subsection 68 01 04 4. Dialectics should be systematic and thorough going 4. Dialectics should be systematic and thorough going 01 01 JB code slcs.8.69dia 06 10.1075/slcs.8.69dia Subsection 69 01 04 5. Dialectics should be orderly and dynamic 5. Dialectics should be orderly and dynamic 01 01 JB code slcs.8.70epi 06 10.1075/slcs.8.70epi Subsection 70 01 04 6. Epilogue 6. Epilogue 01 04 The three elementary phases of a critical discussion The three elementary phases of a critical discussion 01 01 JB code slcs.8.71par 06 10.1075/slcs.8.71par Section header 71 01 04 Part Three: Describing Argumentative Dialogues Part Three: Describing Argumentative Dialogues 01 01 JB code slcs.8.72bar 06 10.1075/slcs.8.72bar 171 Chapter 72 01 04 Introduction Introduction 1 A01 01 JB code 666066526 E.M. Barth Barth, E.M. E.M. Barth 01 01 JB code slcs.8.73gun 06 10.1075/slcs.8.73gun 175 Chapter 73 01 04 A Set of Concepts for the Study of Dialogical Argumentation A Set of Concepts for the Study of Dialogical Argumentation 1 A01 01 JB code 831066527 Arnold Gunther Gunther, Arnold Arnold Gunther 01 01 JB code slcs.8.74int 06 10.1075/slcs.8.74int Subsection 74 01 04 1. Introduction 1. Introduction 01 01 JB code slcs.8.75arg 06 10.1075/slcs.8.75arg Subsection 75 01 04 2. Argumentation -- informally described 2. Argumentation — informally described 01 01 JB code slcs.8.76dia 06 10.1075/slcs.8.76dia Subsection 76 01 04 3. Dialogue bases 3. Dialogue bases 01 01 JB code slcs.8.77coo 06 10.1075/slcs.8.77coo Subsection 77 01 04 4. Co-operative argumentative dialogues and argumentation 4. Co-operative argumentative dialogues and argumentation 01 01 JB code slcs.8.78hei 06 10.1075/slcs.8.78hei 191 Chapter 78 01 04 Montague-Grammars for Argumentative Dialogues Montague-Grammars for Argumentative Dialogues 1 A01 01 JB code 11066528 Carl H. Heidrich Heidrich, Carl H. Carl H. Heidrich 01 01 JB code slcs.8.79int 06 10.1075/slcs.8.79int Subsection 79 01 04 1. Introduction 1. Introduction 01 01 JB code slcs.8.80bac 06 10.1075/slcs.8.80bac Subsection 80 01 04 2. Background and motivation 2. Background and motivation 01 01 JB code slcs.8.81ane 06 10.1075/slcs.8.81ane Subsection 81 01 04 3. An example of a dialogue 3. An example of a dialogue 01 01 JB code slcs.8.82amo 06 10.1075/slcs.8.82amo Subsection 82 01 04 4. A Montague-grammar 4. A Montague-grammar 01 01 JB code slcs.8.83par 06 10.1075/slcs.8.83par Section header 83 01 04 Part Four: Analysing Philosophy Part Four: Analysing Philosophy 01 01 JB code slcs.8.84bar 06 10.1075/slcs.8.84bar 229 Chapter 84 01 04 Introduction Introduction 1 A01 01 JB code 205066529 E.M. Barth Barth, E.M. E.M. Barth 01 01 JB code slcs.8.85kra 06 10.1075/slcs.8.85kra 233 Chapter 85 01 04 Formal Dialectics as Immanent Criticism of Philosophical Systems Formal Dialectics as Immanent Criticism of Philosophical Systems 1 A01 01 JB code 273066530 Erik C.W. Krabbe Krabbe, Erik C.W. Erik C.W. Krabbe 01 01 JB code slcs.8.86int 06 10.1075/slcs.8.86int Subsection 86 01 04 1. Introduction 1. Introduction 01 01 JB code slcs.8.87the 06 10.1075/slcs.8.87the Subsection 87 01 04 2. The provocative thesis 2. The provocative thesis 01 01 JB code slcs.8.88cri 06 10.1075/slcs.8.88cri Subsection 88 01 04 3. Critical interpretation of the logical constants 3. Critical interpretation of the logical constants 01 01 JB code slcs.8.89inf 06 10.1075/slcs.8.89inf Subsection 89 01 04 4. Information-seeking interpretation of the logical constants 4. Information-seeking interpretation of the logical constants 01 01 JB code slcs.8.90nae 06 10.1075/slcs.8.90nae 245 Chapter 90 01 04 An Application of Empirical Argumentation Analysis to Spinoza's "Ethics" An Application of Empirical Argumentation Analysis to Spinoza's “Ethics” 1 A01 01 JB code 539066531 Arne Naess Naess, Arne Arne Naess 01 01 JB code slcs.8.91the 06 10.1075/slcs.8.91the Subsection 91 01 04 1. The propositions of the "Ethics" conceived of as arguments in a debate 1. The propositions of the “Ethics” conceived of as arguments in a debate 01 01 JB code slcs.8.92spi 06 10.1075/slcs.8.92spi Subsection 92 01 04 2. Spinoza's theses of equivalence 2. Spinoza's theses of equivalence 01 01 JB code slcs.8.93equ 06 10.1075/slcs.8.93equ Subsection 93 01 04 3. Equivalences as arguments 3. Equivalences as arguments 01 01 JB code slcs.8.94bar 06 10.1075/slcs.8.94bar 257 Chapter 94 01 04 Finite Debates About "The Infinite" Finite Debates About “The Infinite” 1 A01 01 JB code 729066532 E.M. Barth Barth, E.M. E.M. Barth 01 01 JB code slcs.8.95two 06 10.1075/slcs.8.95two Subsection 95 01 04 1. Two philosophical paradigms 1. Two philosophical paradigms 01 01 JB code slcs.8.96ton 06 10.1075/slcs.8.96ton Subsection 96 01 04 2. "Tongue-twisting for the sake of consistency" -- a recent description of the Weierstrass method 2. “Tongue-twisting for the sake of consistency” — a recent description of the Weierstrass method 01 01 JB code slcs.8.97two 06 10.1075/slcs.8.97two Subsection 97 01 04 3. Two-role logic and the notion of `limit' 3. Two-role logic and the notion of ‘limit’ 01 01 JB code slcs.8.98ins 06 10.1075/slcs.8.98ins Subsection 98 01 04 4. Instantaneous velocities 4. Instantaneous velocities 01 01 JB code slcs.8.99par 06 10.1075/slcs.8.99par Subsection 99 01 04 5. Paradigmatically misleading expressions 5. Paradigmatically misleading expressions 01 01 JB code slcs.8.100con 06 10.1075/slcs.8.100con Subsection 100 01 04 6. Conclusion 6. Conclusion 01 01 JB code slcs.8.101par 06 10.1075/slcs.8.101par Section header 101 01 04 Part Five: Analysing Interaction Part Five: Analysing Interaction 01 01 JB code slcs.8.102bar 06 10.1075/slcs.8.102bar 271 Chapter 102 01 04 Introduction Introduction 1 A01 01 JB code 26066533 E.M. Barth Barth, E.M. E.M. Barth 01 01 JB code slcs.8.103leo 06 10.1075/slcs.8.103leo 273 Chapter 103 01 04 A Decision-Theoretical Interpretation of Dialogues A Decision-Theoretical Interpretation of Dialogues 1 A01 01 JB code 89066534 Ulrike Leopold-Wildburger Leopold-Wildburger, Ulrike Ulrike Leopold-Wildburger 01 01 JB code slcs.8.104dun 06 10.1075/slcs.8.104dun 281 Chapter 104 01 04 On the Philosophy of Argument and the Logic of Common Morality On the Philosophy of Argument and the Logic of Common Morality 1 A01 01 JB code 131066535 F. van Dun Dun, F. van F. van Dun 01 01 JB code slcs.8.105dia 06 10.1075/slcs.8.105dia Subsection 105 01 04 1. Dialectical argument and first principles 1. Dialectical argument and first principles 01 01 JB code slcs.8.106the 06 10.1075/slcs.8.106the Subsection 106 01 04 2. The fundamental principle of morality 2. The fundamental principle of morality 01 01 JB code slcs.8.107adi 06 10.1075/slcs.8.107adi Subsection 107 01 04 3. A dialogical approach to the logic of common morality 3. A dialogical approach to the logic of common morality 01 01 JB code slcs.8.108the 06 10.1075/slcs.8.108the Section header 108 01 04 Theory of Argumentation Theory of Argumentation 01 04 A Chronological Bibliography of some Important Works A Chronological Bibliography of some Important Works 01 01 JB code slcs.8.109ach 06 10.1075/slcs.8.109ach 295 Miscellaneous 109 01 04 A. Chronological Bibliography A. Chronological Bibliography 01 01 JB code slcs.8.110bin 06 10.1075/slcs.8.110bin 329 Miscellaneous 110 01 04 B. Index of Names to Chronological Bibliography B. Index of Names to Chronological Bibliography 01 JB code JBENJAMINS John Benjamins Publishing Company 01 01 JB code JB John Benjamins Publishing Company 01 https://benjamins.com Amsterdam NL 00 John Benjamins Publishing Company Marketing Department / Karin Plijnaar, Pieter Lamers onix@benjamins.nl 04 01 00 19820101 C 1982 John Benjamins Publishing Company D 1982 John Benjamins Publishing Company 02 WORLD 13 15 9789027230072 WORLD 03 01 JB 17 Google 03 https://play.google.com/store/books 21 01 00 Unqualified price 00 120.00 EUR 01 00 Unqualified price 00 101.00 GBP 01 00 Unqualified price 00 180.00 USD 428009445 03 01 01 JB code JB John Benjamins Publishing Company 01 JB code SLCS 8 Eb 15 9789027283160 06 10.1075/slcs.8 00 EA E107 10 01 JB code SLCS 02 0165-7763 02 8.00 01 02 Studies in Language Companion Series Studies in Language Companion Series 11 01 JB code jbe-all 01 02 Full EBA collection (ca. 4,200 titles) 11 01 JB code jbe-2015-all 01 02 Complete backlist (3,208 titles, 1967–2015) 05 02 Complete backlist (1967–2015) 11 01 JB code jbe-2015-linguistics 01 02 Subject collection: Linguistics (2,773 titles, 1967–2015) 05 02 Linguistics (1967–2015) 11 01 JB code jbe-2015-slcs 01 02 Studies in Language Companion Series (vols. 1–171, 1978–2015) 05 02 SLCS (vols. 1–171, 1978–2015) 11 01 JB code jbe-2015-pragmatics 01 02 Subject collection: Pragmatics (804 titles, 1978–2015) 05 02 Pragmatics (1978–2015) 01 01 Argumentation Approaches to theory formation. Containing the contributions to the Groningen Conference on the Theory of Argumentation, October 1978 Argumentation: Approaches to theory formation. Containing the contributions to the Groningen Conference on the Theory of Argumentation, October 1978 1 B01 01 JB code 1120 E.M. Barth Barth, E.M. E.M. Barth 07 https://benjamins.com/catalog/persons/1120 2 B01 01 JB code 1121 J.L. Martens Martens, J.L. J.L. Martens 07 https://benjamins.com/catalog/persons/1121 01 eng 11 362 03 03 xviii 03 00 333 03 01 19 160 03 1978 BC5 04 Logic--Congresses. 04 Reasoning--Congresses. 10 LAN009000 12 CF 24 JB code LIN.DISC Discourse studies 24 JB code LIN.PRAG Pragmatics 24 JB code LIN.SEMAN Semantics 01 06 03 00 The contributions in the first part ‘Re-modelling logic’ of this volume take account of formal logic in the theory of ‘rational’ argumentation. Part two contains papers that distinguish the various dialogue games for logics in terms of ‘rights’ and ‘obligations’ of the players. The authors following in the third section study the interaction between participants in a dialogue. Here the tools of the logician are used for the wider purpose of studying the nature of dialogue. The fourth section concern modes of argumentation that are actually found in philosopical texts from earlier centuries. To be followed by contributions in Part five that may be read as attempts to retrieve what was left of the spirit of criticism and debate in philosphy after the onslaught of Cartesianism and idealism. 01 00 03 01 01 D503 https://benjamins.com/covers/475/slcs.8.png 01 01 D502 https://benjamins.com/covers/475_jpg/9789027230072.jpg 01 01 D504 https://benjamins.com/covers/475_tif/9789027230072.tif 01 01 D503 https://benjamins.com/covers/1200_front/slcs.8.hb.png 01 01 D503 https://benjamins.com/covers/125/slcs.8.png 02 00 03 01 01 D503 https://benjamins.com/covers/1200_back/slcs.8.hb.png 03 00 03 01 01 D503 https://benjamins.com/covers/3d_web/slcs.8.hb.png 01 01 JB code slcs.8.01con 06 10.1075/slcs.8.01con v Miscellaneous 1 01 04 Contributors Contributors 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.02pre 06 10.1075/slcs.8.02pre vii Miscellaneous 2 01 04 Preface Preface 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.03par 06 10.1075/slcs.8.03par Section header 3 01 04 Part One: Re-Modelling Logic Part One: Re-Modelling Logic 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.04bar 06 10.1075/slcs.8.04bar 3 Miscellaneous 4 01 04 Introduction Introduction 1 A01 01 JB code 752066514 E.M. Barth Barth, E.M. E.M. Barth 07 https://benjamins.com/catalog/persons/752066514 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.05nae 06 10.1075/slcs.8.05nae 9 Chapter 5 01 04 A Necessary Component of Logic A Necessary Component of Logic 01 04 Empirical Argumentation Analysis Empirical Argumentation Analysis 1 A01 01 JB code 782066515 Arne Naess Naess, Arne Arne Naess 07 https://benjamins.com/catalog/persons/782066515 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.06log 06 10.1075/slcs.8.06log Subsection 6 01 04 1. Logic has empirical components and needs empirical research 1. Logic has empirical components and needs empirical research 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.07arg 06 10.1075/slcs.8.07arg Subsection 7 01 04 2. `Argumentation analysis' 2. ‘Argumentation analysis’ 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.08opt 06 10.1075/slcs.8.08opt Subsection 8 01 04 3. Options in a clarification and assessment game 3. Options in a clarification and assessment game 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.09ana 06 10.1075/slcs.8.09ana Subsection 9 01 04 4. Analysis of agreement and pseudo-agreement 4. Analysis of agreement and pseudo-agreement 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.10deg 06 10.1075/slcs.8.10deg Subsection 10 01 04 5. Degree of definiteness of intention (discrimination acuity) as a factor in argumentation 5. Degree of definiteness of intention (discrimination acuity) as a factor in argumentation 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.11the 06 10.1075/slcs.8.11the Subsection 11 01 04 6. The hermeneutical spiral as a factor in argumentation 6. The hermeneutical spiral as a factor in argumentation 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.12lor 06 10.1075/slcs.8.12lor 23 Chapter 12 01 04 Die Dialogische Begrundung Von Logikkalkulen Die Dialogische Begründung Von Logikkalkülen 1 A01 01 JB code 191066516 P. Lorenzen Lorenzen, P. P. Lorenzen 07 https://benjamins.com/catalog/persons/191066516 01 ger 01 01 JB code slcs.8.13dre 06 10.1075/slcs.8.13dre Subsection 13 01 04 1. Drei Typen von Logikkalkulen 1. Drei Typen von Logikkalkülen 01 ger 01 01 JB code slcs.8.14das 06 10.1075/slcs.8.14das Subsection 14 01 04 2. Das Begrundungsproblem 2. Das Begründungsproblem 01 ger 01 01 JB code slcs.8.15emp 06 10.1075/slcs.8.15emp Subsection 15 01 04 3. Empraktische Einfuhrung der Verwendungsregeln 3. Empraktische Einführung der Verwendungsregeln 01 ger 01 01 JB code slcs.8.16mat 06 10.1075/slcs.8.16mat Subsection 16 01 04 4. Materiale Dialoge 4. Materiale Dialoge 01 04 Semantik Semantik 01 ger 01 01 JB code slcs.8.17erw 06 10.1075/slcs.8.17erw Subsection 17 01 04 5. Erweiterungen der strengen Dialoge 5. Erweiterungen der strengen Dialoge 01 04 Liberalisierungen Liberalisierungen 01 ger 01 01 JB code slcs.8.18die 06 10.1075/slcs.8.18die Subsection 18 01 04 6. Die effektive Dialogregel 6. Die effektive Dialogregel 01 ger 01 01 JB code slcs.8.19das 06 10.1075/slcs.8.19das Subsection 19 01 04 7. Das Problem der Konsistenz 7. Das Problem der Konsistenz 01 04 Schnittregel Schnittregel 01 ger 01 01 JB code slcs.8.20die 06 10.1075/slcs.8.20die Subsection 20 01 04 8. Die klassische Dialogregel 8. Die klassische Dialogregel 01 ger 01 01 JB code slcs.8.21die 06 10.1075/slcs.8.21die Subsection 21 01 04 9. Die Beziehung materialer Dialoge zu Logikkalkulen 9. Die Beziehung materialer Dialoge zu Logikkalkülen 01 ger 01 01 JB code slcs.8.22zur 06 10.1075/slcs.8.22zur Subsection 22 01 04 10. Zur Frage der sog 10. Zur Frage der sog 01 04 Vollstandigkeit Vollständigkeit 01 ger 01 01 JB code slcs.8.23vol 06 10.1075/slcs.8.23vol Subsection 23 01 04 11. Vollstandigkeit ohne Semantik 11. Vollständigkeit ohne Semantik 01 ger 01 01 JB code slcs.8.24hin 06 10.1075/slcs.8.24hin 55 Chapter 24 01 04 Sherlock Holmes Confronts Modern Logic Sherlock Holmes Confronts Modern Logic 01 04 Toward a Theory of Information-Seeking Through Questioning Toward a Theory of Information-Seeking Through Questioning 1 A01 01 JB code 602066517 Jaakko Hintikka Hintikka, Jaakko Jaakko Hintikka 07 https://benjamins.com/catalog/persons/602066517 2 A01 01 JB code 681066518 Merrill B. Hintikka Hintikka, Merrill B. Merrill B. Hintikka 07 https://benjamins.com/catalog/persons/681066518 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.25she 06 10.1075/slcs.8.25she Subsection 25 01 04 1. Sherlock Holmes vs. philosophers on deduction 1. Sherlock Holmes vs. philosophers on deduction 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.26mak 06 10.1075/slcs.8.26mak Subsection 26 01 04 2. Making tacit information explicit through questioning 2. Making tacit information explicit through questioning 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.27the 06 10.1075/slcs.8.27the Subsection 27 01 04 3. The structure of question-inference complexes 3. The structure of question-inference complexes 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.28ont 06 10.1075/slcs.8.28ont Subsection 28 01 04 4. On the principle of total evidence. Bayesianism 4. On the principle of total evidence. Bayesianism 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.29the 06 10.1075/slcs.8.29the Subsection 29 01 04 5. The role of observations 5. The role of observations 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.30que 06 10.1075/slcs.8.30que Subsection 30 01 04 6. Question-answer sequences as games against Nature 6. Question-answer sequences as games against Nature 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.31pay 06 10.1075/slcs.8.31pay Subsection 31 01 04 7. Payoffs and strategies 7. Payoffs and strategies 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.32ded 06 10.1075/slcs.8.32ded Subsection 32 01 04 8. Deductions sometimes replaceable by questions and answers 8. Deductions sometimes replaceable by questions and answers 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.33hin 06 10.1075/slcs.8.33hin 77 Chapter 33 01 04 Semantical Games and Transcendental Arguments Semantical Games and Transcendental Arguments 1 A01 01 JB code 11066519 Jaakko Hintikka Hintikka, Jaakko Jaakko Hintikka 07 https://benjamins.com/catalog/persons/11066519 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.34kan 06 10.1075/slcs.8.34kan Subsection 34 01 04 1. Kant on the logic of existence 1. Kant on the logic of existence 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.35see 06 10.1075/slcs.8.35see Subsection 35 01 04 2. Seeking and finding, and game-theoretical semantics 2. Seeking and finding, and game-theoretical semantics 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.36atr 06 10.1075/slcs.8.36atr Subsection 36 01 04 3. A transcendental refutation of certain related views 3. A transcendental refutation of certain related views 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.37ate 06 10.1075/slcs.8.37ate Subsection 37 01 04 4. A test-case 4. A test-case 01 04 branching quantifiers branching quantifiers 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.38mat 06 10.1075/slcs.8.38mat Subsection 38 01 04 5. Material vs. logical truth, formal argumentation, and semantics 5. Material vs. logical truth, formal argumentation, and semantics 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.39fro 06 10.1075/slcs.8.39fro Subsection 39 01 04 6. From semantical games to dialogical ones 6. From semantical games to dialogical ones 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.40apo 06 10.1075/slcs.8.40apo 93 Chapter 40 01 04 Towards a General Theory of Argumentation Towards a General Theory of Argumentation 1 A01 01 JB code 205066520 Leo Apostel Apostel, Leo Leo Apostel 07 https://benjamins.com/catalog/persons/205066520 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.41log 06 10.1075/slcs.8.41log Subsection 41 01 04 1. Logic and rhetorics, heuristics, proof theory 1. Logic and rhetorics, heuristics, proof theory 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.42the 06 10.1075/slcs.8.42the Subsection 42 01 04 2. Theory of discussion 2. Theory of discussion 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.43wha 06 10.1075/slcs.8.43wha Subsection 43 01 04 3. What are discussions? 3. What are discussions? 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.44red 06 10.1075/slcs.8.44red Subsection 44 01 04 4. Reduction to the theory of (inter-)action 4. Reduction to the theory of (inter-)action 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.45pro 06 10.1075/slcs.8.45pro Subsection 45 01 04 5. "Proponent", "Opponent", "defence" and "attack" 5. “Proponent”, “Opponent”, “defence” and “attack” 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.46sys 06 10.1075/slcs.8.46sys Subsection 46 01 04 6. Systematic connections between the theory of games and some theories discussed at this conference 6. Systematic connections between the theory of games and some theories discussed at this conference 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.47ham 06 10.1075/slcs.8.47ham Subsection 47 01 04 7. Hamblin's theory 7. Hamblin's theory 01 04 What is an argument? What is an argument? 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.48dec 06 10.1075/slcs.8.48dec Subsection 48 01 04 8. Decomposition of argumentative texts 8. Decomposition of argumentative texts 01 04 Sub-games Sub-games 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.49equ 06 10.1075/slcs.8.49equ Subsection 49 01 04 9. Equivocation and use of metaphors 9. Equivocation and use of metaphors 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.50kra 06 10.1075/slcs.8.50kra 123 Chapter 50 01 04 Theory of Argumentation and the Dialectical Garb of Formal Logic Theory of Argumentation and the Dialectical Garb of Formal Logic 1 A01 01 JB code 655066521 Erik C.W. Krabbe Krabbe, Erik C.W. Erik C.W. Krabbe 07 https://benjamins.com/catalog/persons/655066521 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.51inh 06 10.1075/slcs.8.51inh 133 Chapter 51 01 04 Ein Konstruktiver Weg Zur Semantik Der "Moglichen Welten" Ein Konstruktiver Weg Zur Semantik Der “Möglichen Welten” 1 A01 01 JB code 816066522 Rüdiger Inhetveen Inhetveen, Rüdiger Rüdiger Inhetveen 07 https://benjamins.com/catalog/persons/816066522 01 ger 01 01 JB code slcs.8.52dia 06 10.1075/slcs.8.52dia Subsection 52 01 04 1. Dialogebenen 1. Dialogebenen 01 04 Spielregel Spielregel 01 ger 01 01 JB code slcs.8.53bei 06 10.1075/slcs.8.53bei Subsection 53 01 04 2. Beispiele 2. Beispiele 01 ger 01 01 JB code slcs.8.54bez 06 10.1075/slcs.8.54bez Subsection 54 01 04 3. Beziehung zu den modallogischen Standardsystemen 3. Beziehung zu den modallogischen Standardsystemen 01 ger 01 01 JB code slcs.8.55par 06 10.1075/slcs.8.55par Section header 55 01 04 Part Two: Choosing the Rules Part Two: Choosing the Rules 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.56bar 06 10.1075/slcs.8.56bar 143 Chapter 56 01 04 Introduction Introduction 1 A01 01 JB code 41066523 E.M. Barth Barth, E.M. E.M. Barth 07 https://benjamins.com/catalog/persons/41066523 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.57lor 06 10.1075/slcs.8.57lor 145 Chapter 57 01 04 On the Criteria for the Choice of Rules of Dialogic Logic On the Criteria for the Choice of Rules of Dialogic Logic 1 A01 01 JB code 112066524 Kuno Lorenz Lorenz, Kuno Kuno Lorenz 07 https://benjamins.com/catalog/persons/112066524 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.58aga 06 10.1075/slcs.8.58aga Subsection 58 01 04 1. A game-theoretic pragmatic conception of truth 1. A game-theoretic pragmatic conception of truth 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.59spe 06 10.1075/slcs.8.59spe Subsection 59 01 04 2. Specifying the game ("global" game rules) 2. Specifying the game (“global” game rules) 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.60arg 06 10.1075/slcs.8.60arg Subsection 60 01 04 3. Argument rules ("local" game rules) 3. Argument rules (“local” game rules) 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.61sub 06 10.1075/slcs.8.61sub Subsection 61 01 04 4. Subjunction 4. Subjunction 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.62for 06 10.1075/slcs.8.62for Subsection 62 01 04 5. Formal winning-strategy and formal truth 5. Formal winning-strategy and formal truth 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.63ath 06 10.1075/slcs.8.63ath Subsection 63 01 04 6. A theorem of formal dialogic logic 6. A theorem of formal dialogic logic 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.64bar 06 10.1075/slcs.8.64bar 159 Chapter 64 01 04 A Normative-Pragmatical Foundation of the Rules of some Systems of Formal3 Dialectics A Normative-Pragmatical Foundation of the Rules of some Systems of Formal3 Dialectics 1 A01 01 JB code 355066525 E.M. Barth Barth, E.M. E.M. Barth 07 https://benjamins.com/catalog/persons/355066525 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.65new 06 10.1075/slcs.8.65new Subsection 65 01 04 1. New foundations 1. New foundations 01 04 Statemental dialogue attitudes Statemental dialogue attitudes 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.66two 06 10.1075/slcs.8.66two Subsection 66 01 04 2. Two purposes -- presentation of the dialectical systems, and the problem of fallacy 2. Two purposes — presentation of the dialectical systems, and the problem of fallacy 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.67bas 06 10.1075/slcs.8.67bas Subsection 67 01 04 3. Basic norms and ends; implementations 3. Basic norms and ends; implementations 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.68dia 06 10.1075/slcs.8.68dia Subsection 68 01 04 4. Dialectics should be systematic and thorough going 4. Dialectics should be systematic and thorough going 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.69dia 06 10.1075/slcs.8.69dia Subsection 69 01 04 5. Dialectics should be orderly and dynamic 5. Dialectics should be orderly and dynamic 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.70epi 06 10.1075/slcs.8.70epi Subsection 70 01 04 6. Epilogue 6. Epilogue 01 04 The three elementary phases of a critical discussion The three elementary phases of a critical discussion 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.71par 06 10.1075/slcs.8.71par Section header 71 01 04 Part Three: Describing Argumentative Dialogues Part Three: Describing Argumentative Dialogues 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.72bar 06 10.1075/slcs.8.72bar 171 Chapter 72 01 04 Introduction Introduction 1 A01 01 JB code 666066526 E.M. Barth Barth, E.M. E.M. Barth 07 https://benjamins.com/catalog/persons/666066526 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.73gun 06 10.1075/slcs.8.73gun 175 Chapter 73 01 04 A Set of Concepts for the Study of Dialogical Argumentation A Set of Concepts for the Study of Dialogical Argumentation 1 A01 01 JB code 831066527 Arnold Gunther Gunther, Arnold Arnold Gunther 07 https://benjamins.com/catalog/persons/831066527 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.74int 06 10.1075/slcs.8.74int Subsection 74 01 04 1. Introduction 1. Introduction 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.75arg 06 10.1075/slcs.8.75arg Subsection 75 01 04 2. Argumentation -- informally described 2. Argumentation — informally described 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.76dia 06 10.1075/slcs.8.76dia Subsection 76 01 04 3. Dialogue bases 3. Dialogue bases 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.77coo 06 10.1075/slcs.8.77coo Subsection 77 01 04 4. Co-operative argumentative dialogues and argumentation 4. Co-operative argumentative dialogues and argumentation 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.78hei 06 10.1075/slcs.8.78hei 191 Chapter 78 01 04 Montague-Grammars for Argumentative Dialogues Montague-Grammars for Argumentative Dialogues 1 A01 01 JB code 11066528 Carl H. Heidrich Heidrich, Carl H. Carl H. Heidrich 07 https://benjamins.com/catalog/persons/11066528 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.79int 06 10.1075/slcs.8.79int Subsection 79 01 04 1. Introduction 1. Introduction 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.80bac 06 10.1075/slcs.8.80bac Subsection 80 01 04 2. Background and motivation 2. Background and motivation 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.81ane 06 10.1075/slcs.8.81ane Subsection 81 01 04 3. An example of a dialogue 3. An example of a dialogue 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.82amo 06 10.1075/slcs.8.82amo Subsection 82 01 04 4. A Montague-grammar 4. A Montague-grammar 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.83par 06 10.1075/slcs.8.83par Section header 83 01 04 Part Four: Analysing Philosophy Part Four: Analysing Philosophy 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.84bar 06 10.1075/slcs.8.84bar 229 Chapter 84 01 04 Introduction Introduction 1 A01 01 JB code 205066529 E.M. Barth Barth, E.M. E.M. Barth 07 https://benjamins.com/catalog/persons/205066529 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.85kra 06 10.1075/slcs.8.85kra 233 Chapter 85 01 04 Formal Dialectics as Immanent Criticism of Philosophical Systems Formal Dialectics as Immanent Criticism of Philosophical Systems 1 A01 01 JB code 273066530 Erik C.W. Krabbe Krabbe, Erik C.W. Erik C.W. Krabbe 07 https://benjamins.com/catalog/persons/273066530 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.86int 06 10.1075/slcs.8.86int Subsection 86 01 04 1. Introduction 1. Introduction 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.87the 06 10.1075/slcs.8.87the Subsection 87 01 04 2. The provocative thesis 2. The provocative thesis 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.88cri 06 10.1075/slcs.8.88cri Subsection 88 01 04 3. Critical interpretation of the logical constants 3. Critical interpretation of the logical constants 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.89inf 06 10.1075/slcs.8.89inf Subsection 89 01 04 4. Information-seeking interpretation of the logical constants 4. Information-seeking interpretation of the logical constants 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.90nae 06 10.1075/slcs.8.90nae 245 Chapter 90 01 04 An Application of Empirical Argumentation Analysis to Spinoza's "Ethics" An Application of Empirical Argumentation Analysis to Spinoza's “Ethics” 1 A01 01 JB code 539066531 Arne Naess Naess, Arne Arne Naess 07 https://benjamins.com/catalog/persons/539066531 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.91the 06 10.1075/slcs.8.91the Subsection 91 01 04 1. The propositions of the "Ethics" conceived of as arguments in a debate 1. The propositions of the “Ethics” conceived of as arguments in a debate 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.92spi 06 10.1075/slcs.8.92spi Subsection 92 01 04 2. Spinoza's theses of equivalence 2. Spinoza's theses of equivalence 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.93equ 06 10.1075/slcs.8.93equ Subsection 93 01 04 3. Equivalences as arguments 3. Equivalences as arguments 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.94bar 06 10.1075/slcs.8.94bar 257 Chapter 94 01 04 Finite Debates About "The Infinite" Finite Debates About “The Infinite” 1 A01 01 JB code 729066532 E.M. Barth Barth, E.M. E.M. Barth 07 https://benjamins.com/catalog/persons/729066532 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.95two 06 10.1075/slcs.8.95two Subsection 95 01 04 1. Two philosophical paradigms 1. Two philosophical paradigms 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.96ton 06 10.1075/slcs.8.96ton Subsection 96 01 04 2. "Tongue-twisting for the sake of consistency" -- a recent description of the Weierstrass method 2. “Tongue-twisting for the sake of consistency” — a recent description of the Weierstrass method 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.97two 06 10.1075/slcs.8.97two Subsection 97 01 04 3. Two-role logic and the notion of `limit' 3. Two-role logic and the notion of ‘limit’ 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.98ins 06 10.1075/slcs.8.98ins Subsection 98 01 04 4. Instantaneous velocities 4. Instantaneous velocities 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.99par 06 10.1075/slcs.8.99par Subsection 99 01 04 5. Paradigmatically misleading expressions 5. Paradigmatically misleading expressions 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.100con 06 10.1075/slcs.8.100con Subsection 100 01 04 6. Conclusion 6. Conclusion 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.101par 06 10.1075/slcs.8.101par Section header 101 01 04 Part Five: Analysing Interaction Part Five: Analysing Interaction 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.102bar 06 10.1075/slcs.8.102bar 271 Chapter 102 01 04 Introduction Introduction 1 A01 01 JB code 26066533 E.M. Barth Barth, E.M. E.M. Barth 07 https://benjamins.com/catalog/persons/26066533 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.103leo 06 10.1075/slcs.8.103leo 273 Chapter 103 01 04 A Decision-Theoretical Interpretation of Dialogues A Decision-Theoretical Interpretation of Dialogues 1 A01 01 JB code 89066534 Ulrike Leopold-Wildburger Leopold-Wildburger, Ulrike Ulrike Leopold-Wildburger 07 https://benjamins.com/catalog/persons/89066534 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.104dun 06 10.1075/slcs.8.104dun 281 Chapter 104 01 04 On the Philosophy of Argument and the Logic of Common Morality On the Philosophy of Argument and the Logic of Common Morality 1 A01 01 JB code 131066535 F. van Dun Dun, F. van F. van Dun 07 https://benjamins.com/catalog/persons/131066535 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.105dia 06 10.1075/slcs.8.105dia Subsection 105 01 04 1. Dialectical argument and first principles 1. Dialectical argument and first principles 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.106the 06 10.1075/slcs.8.106the Subsection 106 01 04 2. The fundamental principle of morality 2. The fundamental principle of morality 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.107adi 06 10.1075/slcs.8.107adi Subsection 107 01 04 3. A dialogical approach to the logic of common morality 3. A dialogical approach to the logic of common morality 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.108the 06 10.1075/slcs.8.108the Section header 108 01 04 Theory of Argumentation Theory of Argumentation 01 04 A Chronological Bibliography of some Important Works A Chronological Bibliography of some Important Works 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.109ach 06 10.1075/slcs.8.109ach 295 Miscellaneous 109 01 04 A. Chronological Bibliography A. Chronological Bibliography 01 eng 01 01 JB code slcs.8.110bin 06 10.1075/slcs.8.110bin 329 Miscellaneous 110 01 04 B. Index of Names to Chronological Bibliography B. Index of Names to Chronological Bibliography 01 eng 01 JB code JBENJAMINS John Benjamins Publishing Company 01 01 JB code JB John Benjamins Publishing Company 01 https://benjamins.com 02 https://benjamins.com/catalog/slcs.8 Amsterdam NL 00 John Benjamins Publishing Company Marketing Department / Karin Plijnaar, Pieter Lamers onix@benjamins.nl 04 01 00 19820101 C 1982 John Benjamins Publishing Company D 1982 John Benjamins Publishing Company 02 WORLD 13 15 9789027230072 WORLD 09 01 JB 3 John Benjamins e-Platform 03 https://jbe-platform.com 29 https://jbe-platform.com/content/books/9789027283160 21 01 00 Unqualified price 02 120.00 EUR 01 00 Unqualified price 02 101.00 GBP GB 01 00 Unqualified price 02 180.00 USD