(In)equity in CLIL programs?Classroom interaction and the development of higher order thinking skills across bilingual strands
NataliaEvnitskaya & AnaLlinares
Universitat Internacional de Catalunya | Universidad Autónoma de Madrid
Abstract
This study explores issues of potential (in)equity in Content and Language Integrated Learning (CLIL) programs in bilingual secondary schools in the Madrid region (Spain). Based on their general L2 proficiency, students in grades 7 to 10 are streamed into either High Exposure (HE) or Low Exposure (LE) strands, with different degrees of exposure to CLIL. Although this system ensures that all students in a bilingual secondary school receive CLIL to a certain degree, recent voices have signaled the potential risk of fostering inequality among students by streaming within the program (Fernández-Agüero & Hidalgo-McCabe, 2020; Hidalgo-McCabe, 2020). In this study, we explore classroom interactional practices by one science teacher teaching the same content in both groups (grade 7 HE and LE strands), and the effect of such interactional practices on enhancing (or not) students’ higher order thinking skills and the expression of academic content in the L2 or L1. For the analysis, we developed a multi-layered analytical model which incorporates the construct of cognitive discourse functions (CDFs) (Dalton-Puffer, 2013) and the semantic dimension of Legitimation Code Theory (LCT) (Maton, 2013, 2020). We find significant differences across the two groups in the use of CDFs and ‘semantic codes’ for knowledge construction and meaning making. More specifically, the results show a more frequent use of the CDF evaluate and a higher rate of semantic density (abstractions) in classroom discourse in the HE strand.
After almost three decades of the implementation of Content and Language Integrated Learning (CLIL) programs in Europe and all over the world, the celebratory tone of the early years has been followed by the emergence of critical voices. The arrival and growth of CLIL programs in some European countries, for example Spain, was an initial step forward in guaranteeing equal access to bilingual education and opportunities for ‘immersion-like’ foreign language development, which were previously only available to students whose families could afford sending their children to expensive private (elite) schools. However, there are concerns about the potential role of CLIL in enhancing equity or inequity in education (see, e.g., Nikula, Skinnari, & Mård-Miettinen, 2022; Siepmann, Rumlich, Matz, & Römhild, 2021). Against this backdrop, it may be worth distinguishing between CLIL as a methodological approach and CLIL as a type of educational program or context for learning (Dalton-Puffer, Hüttner, & Llinares, 2022; Llinares, 2015).
References
Breeze, R., & Dafouz, E.
(2017) Constructing complex cognitive discourse functions in higher education: An exploratory study of exam answers in Spanish- and English medium instruction settings. System, 70, 81–91.
Cervantes-Soon, C. G., Dorner, L., Palmer, D., Heiman, D., Schwerdtfeger, R., & Choi, J.
(2017) Combating inequalities in two-way language immersion programs: Toward critical consciousness in bilingual education spaces. Review of Research in Education, 41(1), 403–427.
Codó, E., & Patiño-Santos, A.
(2018) CLIL, unequal working conditions and neoliberal subjectivities in a state secondary school. Language Policy, 17(4), 479-499.
Council of Europe
(2001) Common European Framework of Reference for Languages: Learning, teaching, assessment. Cambridge University Press.
Dalton-Puffer, C.
(2013) A construct of cognitive discourse functions for conceptualising content-language integration in CLIL and multilingual education. European Journal of Applied Linguistics, 1(2), 216–253.
Dalton-Puffer, C., Hüttner, J., & Llinares, A.
(2022) CLIL in the 21st Century: Retrospective and prospective challenges and opportunities. Journal of Immersion and Content-Based Language Education, 10(2), 182–206.
Evnitskaya, N., & Dalton-Puffer, C.
(2023) Cognitive discourse functions in CLIL classrooms: Eliciting and analysing students’ oral categorizations in science and history. International Journal of Bilingual Education and Bilingualism, 26(3), 311–330.
Fernández-Agüero, M., & Hidalgo-McCabe, E.
(2020) CLIL students’ affectivity in the transition between education levels: The effect of streaming at the beginning of secondary education. Journal of Language, Identity & Education, 21(6), 363–377.
Flores, N.
(2013) Silencing the subaltern: Nation-state/colonial governmentality and bilingual education in the United States. Critical Inquiry in Language Studies, 10(4), 263–287.
Flores, N., & García, O.
(2017) A critical review of bilingual education in the United States: From basements and pride to boutiques and profit. Annual Review of Applied Linguistics, 37, 14–29.
(2015) Integration in CLIL: A proposal to inform research and successful pedagogy. Language, Culture and Curriculum, 28(1), 58–73.
Llinares, A., & Dafouz, E.
(2010) Content and language integrated programmes in the Madrid region: Overview and research findings. In D. Lasagabaster & Y. Ruiz de Zarobe (Eds.), CLIL in Spain: Implementation, results and teacher training. Cambridge Scholars.
Llinares, A., & Evnitskaya, N.
(2021) Classroom interaction in CLIL programs: Offering opportunities or fostering inequalities?TESOL Quarterly, 55(2), 366–397.
Llinares, A., & Nikula, T.
(2016) Teacher and student evaluative language in CLIL across contexts: Integrating SFL and pragmatic approaches. In T. Nikula, E. Dafouz, P. Moore & U. Smit (Eds.), Conceptualising integration in CLIL and multilingual education. Multilingual Matters.
Lo, Y.Y., Lin, A.M., & Liu, Y.
(2023) Exploring content and language co-construction in CLIL with semantic waves. International Journal of Bilingual Education and Bilingualism, 26(3), 289–310.
Lorenzo, F., Granados, A., & Rico, N.
(2021) Equity in bilingual education: Socioeconomic status and Content and Language Integrated Learning in monolingual Southern Europe. Applied Linguistics, 42(3), 393–413.
Martín Rojo, L.
(2015) The social construction of inequality in and through interaction in multilingual classrooms. In N. Markee (Ed.), The handbook of classroom discourse and interaction (pp. 490–505). John Wiley & Sons.
Maton, K.
(2013) Making semantic waves: A key to cumulative knowledge-building. Linguistics and Education, 24, 8–22.
Maton, K.
(2020) Semantic waves: Context, complexity and academic discourse. In J. R. Martin, K. Maton, & Doran, Y. J. (Eds.), Accessing academic discourse: Systemic functional linguistics and Legitimation Code Theory (pp. 59–85). Routledge.
Moller, S., & Stearns, E.
(2012) Tracking success: High school curricula and labor market outcomes by race and gender. Urban Education, 47(6), 1025–1054.
Morton, T.
(2012) Teachers’ knowledge about language and classroom interaction in content and language integrated learning (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). Universidad Autónoma de Madrid.
Morton, T.
(2020) Cognitive discourse functions: A bridge between content, literacy and language for teaching and assessment in CLIL. CLIL Journal of Innovation and Research in Plurilingual and Pluricultural Education, 3(1), 7–17.
Morton, T., & Llinares, A.
forthcoming). Building teachers’ knowledge of cognitive discourse functions to integrate content and language: A semantic analysis. In S. Ballinger, R. Fielding, & D. Tedick Eds. International perspectives on teacher education for immersion and content-based contextsMultilingual Matters
Nashaat-Sobhy, N., & Llinares, A.
(2023) CLIL students’ definitions of historical terms. International Journal of Bilingual Education and Bilingualism, 26(3), 331–344.
Nikula, T., Skinnari, K., & Mård-Miettinen, K.
(2022) Diversity in CLIL as experienced by Finnish CLIL teachers and students: Matters of equality and equity. International Journal of Bilingual Education and Bilingualism.
Oakes, J.
(2005) Keeping track: How schools structure inequality (2nd ed.). Yale University Press.
O’Donnell, M.
(2008) Demonstration of the UAM CorpusTool for text and image annotation. In Proceedings of the ACL-08: HLT Demo Session (Companion Volume) (pp. 13–16). Association for Computational Linguistics.
Pérez Cañado, M. L.
(2021) Inclusion and diversity in bilingual education: A European comparative study. International Journal of Bilingual Education and Bilingualism.
Siepmann, P., Rumlich, D., Matz, F., & Römhild, R.
(2021) Attention to diversity in German CLIL classrooms: Multi-perspective research on students’ and teachers’ perceptions. International Journal of Bilingual Education and Bilingualism.
Somers, T., & Llinares, A.
(2021) Students’ motivation for content and language integrated learning and the role of programme intensity. International Journal of Bilingual Education and Bilingualism, 24(6), 839–854.
Tsuchiya, K., & Pérez Murillo, M. D.
(2019) Content and Language Integrated Learning in Spanish and Japanese Contexts. Palgrave Macmillan.
Whittaker, R., & McCabe, A.
(2023) Expressing evaluation across disciplines in primary and secondary CLIL writing: A longitudinal study. International Journal of Bilingual Education and Bilingualism, 26(3), 345–362.
