It’s not a BAZAAR: Invoking student accountability through teacher reproach routines in ESL classrooms
This multimodal study investigates teacher-initiated reproach in a Grade 6 bilingual English as a Second Language (ESL) classroom in Bangladesh. Within this pedagogical context, recurring issues such as classroom noise and indistinct student talk frequently lead to student inattentiveness, challenges to teacher authority, and disruptions to disciplinary order. The study examines how teachers manage students’ reproachable actions during ongoing instruction. Adopting conversation analysis (CA) informed multimodal interaction analysis, the study investigates the sequential organization of in-situ reproach routines, with particular attention to how reproaches are progressively enacted and how multimodal resources are mobilized in interaction. The analysis demonstrates that teachers deploy coordinated verbal and embodied resources — including gaze, gesture, prosody, and spatial orientation — to address disruptive behavior, invoke student accountability, and restore classroom order. The findings contribute to a deeper understanding of the interactional organization of classroom discipline by showing how reproach routines function as dynamically accomplished practices embedded within ongoing instructional activity. The study further highlights how teachers balance disciplinary authority with pedagogical continuity through the strategic deployment of multimodal resources in real-time classroom interaction.