What counts as language in South African schooling? Monoglossic ideologies and children’s participation

Carolyn McKinney,1 Hannah Carrim, Alex Marshall & Laura Layton
1University of Cape Town, South Africa

This paper focuses on the lack of impact on language education of recent paradigm shifts in the study of language and society such as the recognition of the ideology of language[s] as stable, discrete or bounded entities and the reality of heteroglossic languaging and semiotic practices in everyday life. Using South Africa as a case, the paper explores the implications of heteroglossic conceptualising of language as social practice for language education through three ethnographically informed case studies of classroom discourse. I will argue that monoglossic orientations which ironically underpin both monolingual and “multilingual” approaches have wide-ranging constraining effects on how children are positioned in schooling, and on children’s participation in classrooms, resulting in a form of ‘epistemic injustice’ (Fricker, 2007).

Quick links
A browser-friendly version of this article is not yet available. View PDF
Alim, H.S
2010 Critical language awareness. In Sociolinguistics and Language Education, N.H. Hornberger & S.L. McKay (eds), 205–231. Bristol: Multilingual Matters. Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Arthur, J. & Martin, P
2006 Accomplishing lessons in postcolonial classrooms: Comparative perspectives from Botswana and Brunei Darussalam. Comparative Education 42(2): 177–202. Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Bailey, B
2007 Heteroglossia and boundaries. In Bilingualism: A Social Approach, M. Heller (ed.). Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan. Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Bakhtin, M.M
1981 Discourse in the novel. In The Dialogic Imagination Four Essays, M. Holquist (ed.). Austin TX: University of Texas Press.Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Benor, S
2010 Ethnolinguistic repertoire: Shifting the focus in language and ethnicity. Journal of Sociolinguistics 14(2): 159–183. Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Blackledge, A. & Creese, A
2010 Multilingualism: A Critical Perspective. London: Continuum.Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
2014 Heteroglossia as practice and pedagogy. In Heteroglossia as Practice and Pedagogy, A. Blackledge & A. Creese (eds), 1–20. Dordrecht: Springer. Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Blommaert, J
1996 Language planning as a discourse on language and society: The linguistic ideology of a scholarly tradition. Language Problems and Language Planning 20(3): 199–222. Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
2005a Discourse. Cambridge: CUP. Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
2005b Language policy and national identity. In An Introduction to Language Policy: Theory and Method, T. Ricento (ed.), 238–254. London: Wiley-Blackwell.Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
2006 Language ideology. In Encyclopedia of Language and Linguistics, Vol. 6, 2nd edn, K. Brown (Editor in Chief), 510–522. Oxford: Elsevier. Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Blommaert, J., Muyllaert, N., Huysmans, M. & Dyers, C
2005 Peripheral normativity: Literacy and the production of locality in a South African township school. Linguistics and Education 16(4): 378–403. Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Blommaert, J. & Dong J
2010 Ethnographic Fieldwork. Bristol: Multilingual Matters. Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Blommaert, J. & Backus, A
2011 Repertoires revisited: ‘Knowing language’. In Superdiversity [Working Papers in Urban Language and Literacies (WPULL) Paper 67]. London: Kings College London.Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Bourdieu, P
1977 The economics of linguistic exchanges. Social Science Information 16(6): 645–668. Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Bowerman, S
2004 White South African English: Phonology. In A Handbook of Varieties of English, 1: Phonology, E. Schneider, K. Burridge, B. Kortmann, R. Mesthrie & C. Upton (eds), 931–942. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Busch, B
2010 School language profiles: Valorizing linguistic resources in heteroglossic situations in South Africa. Language and Education 24(4): 283–294. Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
2012 The linguistic repertoire revisited. Applied Linguistics 33(5): 503–523. Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Canagarajah, A.S
2006 The place of world Englishes in composition: Pluralisation continued. College, Composition and Communication 57(4): 586–618.Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
2007 Lingua franca English, multilingual communities, and language acquisition. The Modern Language Journal 91(focus issue): 923–939. Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
2009 The plurilingual tradition and the English language in South Asia. AILA Review 22: 5–22. Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
2015 Negotiating mobile codes and literacies at the contact zone: Another perspective on South African township schools. In Language, Literacy and Diversity: Moving Words, C. Stroud and M. Prinsloo (eds), 34–54. New York and London: Routledge.Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Carrim, H
2013 ‘The Language is Weak’: Language Ideologies and Learner Positioning in a Desegregated English Medium Suburban Primary School. MA dissertation, University of Cape Town.
Chick, J.K
1996 Safe-talk: Collusion in apartheid education. In Society and the Language Classroom, H. Coleman (ed.), 21–39. Cambridge: CUP.Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Chimbutane, F
2011 Rethinking Bilingual Education in Postcolonial Contexts. Bristol: Multilingual Matters. Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Creese, A. & Blackledge, A
2010 Translanguaging in the bilingual classroom: A pedagogy for learning and teaching? The Modern Language Journal 94(1): 103–115. Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Cummins, J
2008 Teaching for transfer: Challenging the two solitudes assumption in bilingual education. In Encyclopedia of Language and Education, 2nd edn, J. Cummins & N.H. Hornberger (eds), 65–75. Berlin: Springer. Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
De Klerk, G
2002 Mother tongue education in South Africa: The weight of history. International Journal of Sociology of Language 154: 29–46. Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Department of Education
1997 Language in education policy. July. Pretoria: Department of Education.Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Department of Basic Education
2013 The incremental introduction of African languages in schools draft policy. September. Pretoria: Department of Education.Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Dixon, K. and Dornbrack, J
2014 Towards a more explicit writing pedagogy: The complexity of teaching argumentative writing. Reading and Writing 5(1): 1–8.Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Foucault, M
1980 Power/Knowledge: Selected Interviews and Other Writings 1971–1977. New York NY: Pantheon Books.Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Fricker, M
2007 Epistemic Injustice. Power and the Ethics of Knowing. Oxford: OUP. Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
2012 Silence and institutional prejudice. In Out from the Shadows: Analytical Feminist Contributions to Traditional Philosophy, S. Crasnow & A. Superson (eds). Oxford: OUP. Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
García, O
2009 Bilingual Education in the 21st Century: A Global Perspective. Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell.Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
García, O. & Sylvan, C
2011 Pedagogies and practices in multilingual classrooms: Singularities in pluralities. The Modern Language Journal 95(3): 385–400. Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Gibbons, P
2001 Learning a new register in a second language. In English Language Teaching in its Social Context: A Reader, C. Candlin & N. Mercer (eds). London: Routledge.Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
2003 Mediating language learning: Teacher interactions with ESL students in a content-based classroom. TESOL Quarterly 37(2): 247–273. Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Gumperz, J
1972 Introduction. In Gumperz, J., and Hymes, D (eds) Directions in Sociolinguistics: The Ethnography of Communication. 1–25. London: Blackwell.Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Gutiérrez, K., Baqquedano-López, P., Alvarez, H.H. & Chiu, M.M
1999a Building a culture of collaboration through hybrid language practices. Theory into Practice 28(2): 87–93. Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Gutiérrez, K., Baquedano-López, P. & Tejeda, C
1999b Rethinking diversity: Hybridity and hybrid language practices in the third Space. Mind, Culture and Activity 6: 286–303. Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Heller, M
2007 Bilingualism as ideology and practice. Bilingualism A Social Approach. Houndmills: Palgrave. Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Hendricks, M
2008 ‘Capitalising on the dullness of data’: A linguistic analysis of a Grade 7 learner’s writing. South African Linguistics and Applied Language Studies 26 (1): 27–42. Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Hornberger, N. & Chick, K
2001 Co-constructing school safetime: Safetalk practices in Peruvian and South African classrooms. In Voices of Authority: Education and Linguistic Difference, M. Heller & M. Martin-Jones (eds), 31–56. Westport CT: Greenwood.Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Horner, B., Lu, M-Z., Royster, J.J. & Trimbur, J
2011 Language different in writing: Towards a translingual approach. College English 73(3): 303–320.Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Irvine, J
2014 Language as cultural ‘heritage’: Visions of ethnicity in nineteenth-century African linguistics. Paper presented in School of African and Gender Studies, Anthropology and Linguistics . University of Cape Town, 22 August.
Ivanov, V
2000 Heterglossia. Journal of Linguistic Anthropology 9(1-2): 100–102. Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Janks, H., Dixon, K., Ferreira, A., Granville, S. & Newfield, D
2014 Doing Critical Literacy. New York NY: Routledge.Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Jørgenson, J.N
2008 Polylingual languaging around and among children and adolescents. International Journal of Multilingualism 5(3): 161–176. Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Layton, L
2014 Language ideologies and the positioning of learners in a multilingual grade 1 classroom: A case study. MA dissertation, University of Cape Town.
Lillis, T
2008 Ethnography as method, methodology and ‘deep theorising’: Closing the gap between text and context in academic writing research. Written Communication 25(3): 353–388. Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Makalela, L
2013 Black South African English on the radio. World Englishes 32(1): 93–107. Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
2014 Translanguaging as a teachable strategy for reading development: Enhancing epistemic access and fluid identity construction in primary schools. Paper presented at the symposium on ‘Heteroglossia and Language as a Resource in South African Schooling’ , University of Cape Town, 1 September.
2015 Moving out of linguistic boxes: The effects of translanguaging strategies for multilingual classrooms. Language and Education 29(3): 200–217. Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Makoe, P. & McKinney, C
2009: Hybrid discursive practices in a South African multilingual primary classroom: A case study. English Teaching Practice and Critique 8(2): 80–95.Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
2014 Linguistic ideologies in multilingual South African suburban schools. Journal of Multilingual and Multicultural Development 35(7): 658–673. Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Makoni, S
1999 African languages as Colonial scripts. In Negotiating the Past, C. Coetzee & S. Nuttall (eds). Cape Town: OUP.Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
2003 From misinvention to disinvention of language: Multilingualism and the South African Constitution. In Black Linguistics, Language, Society, and Politics in Africa and the Americas, S. Makoni, G. Smitherman, A.F. Ball & A.K. Spears (eds), 132–153. Clevedon: Multilingual Matters.Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Makoni, S., Brutt-Griffler, J. & Mashiri, P
2007 The use of ‘indigenous’ and urban vernaculars in Zimbabwe. Language in Society 36: 25–49. Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Makoni, S. & Meinhof, U
2004 Western perspectives in applied linguistics in Africa. AILA Review 17: 77–104. Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Makoni, S. & Mashiri, P
2007 ‘Critical historiography’. Does language planning in African need a construct of language as part of its theoretical apparatus? In Disinventing and Reconstituting Languages, S. Makoni & A. Pennycook, 62–89. Clevedon: Multilingual Matters.Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Makoni, S. & Pennycook, A
2007 Disinventing and reconstituting languages. In Disinventing and Reconstituting Languages, S. Makoni & A. Pennycook (eds), 1–41. Clevedon: Multilingual Matters.Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
May, S
2010 Review of S. Makoni and A. Pennycook (eds). Disinventing and Reconstituting Languages, Bristol: Multilingual Matters, 2007. Applied Linguistics 23: 159–163. Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Marshall, A
2015 How English as First Additional Language is taught and used in a quintile one primary school, in Grade 4, where learners officially change from isiXhosa to English as the language of instruction: a Case Study. MA dissertation. University of Cape Town.
McKinney, C
2013 Orientations to English in post-apartheid schooling. English Today 29(1): 22–27. Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
2014 Anglonormativity and what counts as English in South African suburban schools. Paper presented at Symposium on ‘The (in)visibility of children’s linguistic and cultural resources in education in African contexts’ . AILA World Congress Brisbane, 10-15 August.
McNamara, T
2012 Poststructuralism and its challenges for applied linguistics. Applied Linguistics 33(5): 473–482. Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Mesthrie, R
2010 Socio-phonetics and social change: Deracialisation of the GOOSE vowel in South African English. Journal of Sociolinguistics 14(1): 3–33. Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
NEEDU
2012 National Report 2012: The state of literacy teaching and learning in the foundation phase.
Otsuji, E. & Pennycook, A
2010 Metrolingualism: Fixity, fluidity and language in flux. International Journal of Multilingualism 7(3): 240–254. Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Pennycook, A. & Otsuji, E
2014 Metrolingual multi-tasking and spatial repertoires: ‘Pizza mo two minutes coming’. Journal of Sociolinguistics 18(2): 161–184. Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Prinsloo, M. and Stroud, C
2014 Introduction. In Educating for Language and Literacy Diversity: Mobile Selves, M. Prinsloo and C. Stroud( eds). Palgrave MacMillan. Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Probyn, M
2005 Language and the struggle to learn: The intersection of classroom realities, language policy, and neo-colonial and globalisation discourses in South African schools. In Decolonisation, Globalisation Language-in-Education Policy and Practice, A. Lin & P. Martin (eds). Clevedon: Multilingual Matters. Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
2009 ‘Smuggling the vernacular into the classroom’: Conflicts and tensions in classroom codeswitching. International Journal of Bilingual Education and Bilingualism 12(2):123–136. Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Rampton, B., Tusting, K., Maybin, J., Barwell, R, Creese, A. & Lytra, V
2004 UK Linguistic ethnography: A discussion paper. Linguistic ethnography Forum. http://​www​.lingethnog​.org​/docs​/rampton​-et​-al​-2004​-uk​-linguistic​-ethnography​-a​-discussion​-paper/Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Rampton, B
2011 From ‘multi-ethnic adolescent heteroglossia’ to ‘contemporary urban vernaculars’. Language and Communication 31: 276–294. Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Silverstein, M
2003 Indexical order and the dialectics of sociolinguistic life. Language and Communication 23: 193–229. Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Van Rooy, B
2004 Black South African English. In A Handbook of Varieties of English, 1: Phonology, E. Schneider, K. Burridge, B. Kortmann, R. Mesthrie & C. Upton (eds), 943–963. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Vinjevold, P
1999 Language issues in South African classrooms. In Getting Learning Right: Report of the President’s education initiative research project, N. Taylor (ed.). Johannesburg: Joint Education Trust.Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Walter, S
2008 The language of instruction issue: Framing an empirical perspective. In The Handbook of Educational Linguistics, B. Spolsky & F.M. Hult (eds), 129–146. Malden MA: Blackwell. Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Wei, L
2011 Moment analysis and translanguaging space. Journal of Pragmatics 43: 1222–1235. 10.1016/j.pragma.2010.07.035.Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
Zegeye, A
(ed.) 2001 General introduction. In Social Identities in the New South Africa: After Apartheid, Vol. 1. Cape Town & Maroelana: Kwela Books & SA History Online.Google Scholar logo with link to Google Scholar
 
Authentication
Mobile Menu Logo with link to supplementary files background Layer 1 jbe-platform.quadraat-sans-bold jbe-platform.quadraat-sans-bold-dark jbe-platform.quadraat-sans-bold-light jbe-platform.quadraat-sans-bold prag Twitter_Logo_Blue