Publications
Publication details [#61499]
Özçelik, Öner. 2016. Against Isomorphism and the Maxim of Charity in child language acquisition: Implications for the validity of the TVJT methodology. Linguistics 54 (2) : 305–338.
Publication type
Article in journal
Publication language
English
Keywords
Place, Publisher
De Gruyter
Journal WWW
Annotation
This paper explores children’s interpretation of scopally equivocal sentences comprising negation and quantification. Using Relevance Theory, and novel tests with 5-year-olds, it reveals that children formerly appeared to foster surface scope interpretations as they founded their decisions on the contextually most apt information. It is argued that children are not unlike adults in scopal options licensed by their grammar, but insofar as they rate “salience” higher as general “relevance” indication than the Charity Maxim, albeit for adults, the Charity Maxim is at least evenly apposite.