Developing L2 listening comprehension through extensive and intensive listening
Abstract
In the fall semester of 2020, 269 Japanese university students were compared in a quasi-experimental study to determine whether extensive and intensive listening interventions yielded significant gains in L2 listening comprehension. At the beginning of the study, 269 students took a 100-item L2 listening exam, and were randomly placed into an extensive (n = 135) or intensive listening group (n = 134). After each group completed five assignments based on extensive or intensive listening principles, students took another 100-item L2 listening exam. Paired-sample t-tests of raw scores and Rasch person ability estimates indicated that the extensive listening group significantly improved in raw scores, t(134) = −7.44, p = .00, but not in Rasch person ability estimates t(134) = −1.86, p = .07, while the intensive listening group significantly improved in both raw scores, t(133) = −9.48, p = .00, and Rasch person ability estimates, t(133) = −3.58, p = .00.
Keywords:
Publication history
Table of contents
Amongst the language skills of reading, writing, speaking, and listening, listening may be the most important (Flowerdew & Miller, 2010; Vandergrift, 2012; Vandergrift & Goh, 2012), with some suggesting that listening accounts for 40–50% of communication time, significantly more than the other three language skills (Gilman & Moody, 1984; Nunan, 1998). However, despite the importance of listening, there has been a tendency for educators to assess listening rather than teach listening (Brown, 2011; Schmidt, 2016; Vandergrift & Goh, 2012).
References
Asquith, S.
(2014) Integrating
a functional approach with Japanese junior high school teaching
practices. In P. Clements, A. Krause, & H. Brown (Eds.), JALT2014:
Conversations across
borders (pp. 48–57). JALT.
Barr, A., & Lyon, P.
(2017) How
to support students in selecting graded
readers. Studies in Self-Access Learning
Journal,
8
(3), 247–254. 
Bibby, S.
(2020) Listening
in the language classroom: The case for extensive
listening. Theoretical and Applied
Linguistics at Kobe
Shoin,
23
(1), 1–11.
Blyth, A.
(2011) How
teachers teach listening in Japan: Part
1. KOTESL Proceedings
2010,
15
(1), 71–82.
Bond, T. G., & Fox, C. M.
(2007) Applying
the Rasch model: Fundamental measurement in the human
sciences (2nd
ed.). Lawrence Erlbaum
Associates.
Brown, S.
(2011) Listening
myths: Applying second language research to classroom
teaching. University of Michigan
Press.
Buck, G.
(1988) Testing
listening comprehension in Japanese university entrance
examinations. JALT
Journal,
10
(1), 15–42.
Chang, A.
(2010) Second-language
listening anxiety before and after a 1-yr intervention in extensive
listening compared with standard foreign language
instruction. Perceptual and Motor
Skill,
110
(2), 355–365.
(2012) Gains
to L2 learners from extensive listening: Listening development, vocabulary
acquisition and perceptions of the
intervention. Hong Kong Journal of Applied
Linguistics,
14
(1), 35–47.
Chang, A., & Millett, S.
(2016) Developing
L2 listening fluency through extended listening-focused activities in an
extensive-listening programme. RELC
Journal,
47
(3), 349–362.
Chang, A., Millett, S., & Renandya, W.
(2018) Developing listening fluency through supported extensive listening practice. RELC Journal.
50
(3), 422–438.
Cid, J., Wei, Y., Kim, S., & Hauck, C.
(2017) Statistical
analyses for the updated TOEIC listening and reading
test. ETS Research Memorandum ETS
RM-17-05. ETS.
Cohen, J.
(2015) The
effectiveness of using dictation to develop listening
comprehension. Kinki University Center for
Liberal Arts and Foreign Language Education
Journal,
6
(2), 43–56.
Cook, T. D., & Campbell, D. T.
(1979) Quasi-Experimentation: Design and Analysis Issues for Field Settings. Houghton Mifflin.
Cross, J.
(2009) Effects
of listening strategy instruction on news videotext
comprehension. Language Teaching
Research,
13
(2), 151–176.
(2012) Listening
strategy instruction (or extensive listening?): A response to Renandya
(2012). Teaching English and Communication in
Higher
Education. NUS. Retrieved
on 4 April
2023 from https://blog.nus.edu.sg/celcblog/2012/06/10/listening-strategy-instruction-or-extensive-listening-a-response-to-renandya-2012/
Cross, J., & Vandergrift, L.
(2018) Metacognitive
listening
strategies. In J. I. Liontas, T.
International Association, & M. DelliCarpini (Eds.), The
TESOL encyclopedia of English language teaching.
Daily, A.
(2010) Difficulties
implementing CLT in South Korea: Mismatch between the language policy and
what is taking place in the
classroom. University of
Birmingham.
Day, R., & Bamford, J.
(2002) Top
ten principles in teaching extensive
reading. Reading in a Foreign
Language,
14
, 136–141. 10125/66761
Ducker, N. D., & Saunders, J. M.
(2014) Extensive
listening: Using authentic
materials. In N. Sonda, & A. Krause (Eds.), JALT2013
Conference
Proceedings (pp. 383–394). JALT.
Field, A. P.
(2009) Discovering
statistics using SPSS (and sex and drugs and rock ‘n’
roll). Sage.
Field, J.
(2003) Promoting
perception: Lexical segmentation in L2
listening. ELT
Journal,
57
(4), 325–334.
(2004) An
insight into listeners’ problems: Too much bottom-up or too much
top-down? System,
32
(3), 363–377.
Flowerdew, J., & Miller, L.
(2010) Listening
in a second
language. In A. D. Wolvin (Ed.), Listening
and human communication in the 21st
Century (pp. 158–177). Blackwell.
Gilman, R. A., & Moody, L. M.
(1984) What
practitioners say about listening: Research implications for the
classroom. Foreign Language
Annals,
17
(4), 331–334.
Goh, C.
(2010) Listening
as process: Learning activities for self-appraisal and self
regulation. In N. Harwood (Ed.), Materials
in ELT: Theory and
practice (pp. 179–206). Cambridge
University Press.
Graham, S.
(2006) Listening
comprehension: The learner’s
perspective. System,
34
, 165–182.
Hoa, L. B.
(2020) Listening
portfolio: A combination of extensive and intensive
listening. The Center for ELF
Journal,
6
(1), 95–106.
Holden, W.
(2008) Extensive
listening: A new approach to an old
problem. Journal of the faculty of
Humanities, Toyama
University,
49
(1), 299–312.
Jeon, E-Y., & Day, R.
(2016) The
effectiveness of ER on reading proficiency: A
meta-analysis. Reading in a Foreign
Language,
28
(2), 246–265.
Karimi, M., & Nazari, M.
(2017) The
congruity/incongruity of EFL teachers’ beliefs about listening instruction
and their listening instructional
practices. Australian Journal of Teacher
Education,
42
(2), 62–80.
Karlin, O., & Karlin, S.
(2019) L2
listening homework: Intensive vs.
extensive. Korea TESOL
Journal,
14
(2), 97–115.
(2021) Comparing
the effectiveness of L2 extensive and intensive listening
Approaches. English as a Foreign Language
International
Journal,
25
(4), 26–54.
Kiany, G. R., & Shiramiry, E.
(2002) The
effect of frequent dictation on the listening comprehension ability of
elementary EFL learners. TESL Canada
Journal,
20
(1), 57–63.
Kuo, Y.
(2010) Using
partial dictation of an English teaching radio program to enhance EFL
learners’ listening comprehension. Asian EFL
Journal: Professional Teaching
Articles,
47
, 1–26.
Lake, J., & Holster, T.
(2014) Developing
autonomous self-regulated readers in an extensive reading
program. Studies in Self-Access Learning
Journal,
5
(4), 394–403.
Lee, S. C.
(2010) Developing
intensive listening skills: A case study of the long-term dictation tasks
using rapid speech. The English
Teacher,
39
(1), 94–120.
Levin, J. R., & O’Donnell, A. M.
(1999) What
to do about educational research’s credibility
gaps? Issues in
Education,
5
(2), 177–229.
Linacre, J. M.
(1999) Investigating
rating scale category utility. Journal of
Outcome
Measurement,
3
(2), 103–122. Retrieved
on 4 April
2023 from http://www.researchgate.net/publication/13094554_Investigating_rating_scale_category_utility
Long, D. R.
(1990) What
you don’t know can’t help you. Studies in
Second Language
Acquisition,
12
(1), 65–80.
Marzban, A., & Abdollahi, M.
(2013) The
effect of partial dictation on the listening comprehension ability of
Iranian intermediate EFL
learners. International Research Journal of
Applied and Basic
Sciences,
5
(2), 238–244.
Mayora, C. A.
(2017) Extensive
listening in a Colombian university: Process, product, and
perceptions. HOW,
24
(1), 101–121.
Nation, I. S. P., & Newton, J.
(2009) Teaching
ESL/EFL listening and
speaking. Routledge.
Nunan, D.
(1992) Research
methods in language learning. Cambridge
University Press.
(1998) Approaches
to teaching listening in the language
classroom. Proceedings of the 1997 Korea
TESOL Conference. Taejon,
Korea. KOTESOL.
Pelletier, L. G., Séguin-Lévesque, C., & Legault, L.
(2002) Pressure
from above and pressure from below as determinants of teachers’ motivation
and teaching behaviors. Journal of
Educational
Psychology,
94
(1), 186–196.
Pica, T.
(2000) Tradition
and transition in English language teaching
methodology. System,
28
(1), 1–18.
Plonsky, L., & Oswald, F. L.
(2014) How
big is “big”? Interpreting effect sizes in L2
research. Language
Learning,
64
(4), 879–912.
Povey, E.
(2016) Extensive
listening: Pedagogy, resources, and
tools. International Journal of Educational
Investigations,
3
(7), 35–49.
Powers, D. E., Kim, H., & Weng, V. Z.
(2008) The
redesigned TOEIC (listening and reading) test: Relations to test-taker
perceptions of proficiency in English. ETS
Research Report
Series, 1–16.
Rasch, G.
(1960) Probalistic
models for some intelligence and attainment
tests. Danmarks Paedagogiske
Institut.
Ratkowsky, D. A., Evans, M. A., & Allredge, J. R.
(1992) Cross-over
experiments: Design, analysis, and
application. Marcel
Dekker.
Renandya, W.
(2012) Five
reasons why listening strategy instruction might not work with lower
proficiency
learners. ELTWorldOnline.com. Retrieved
on 4 April
2023 from http://blog.nus.edu.sg/eltwo/2012/02/22/five-reasons-why-listening-strategyinstruction-might-not-work-with-lower-proficiency-learners/
Richards, J. C.
(2005) Second
thoughts on teaching listening. RELC
Journal,
36
(1), 85–92.
Rost, M.
(2016) Teaching
and Researching Listening (3rd
ed.). Routledge.
Saito, Y.
(2019) Impacts
of introducing four-skill English tests into university entrance
examinations. The Language
Teacher,
43
(2), 9–14.
Sawyer, R. S., Graham, S., & Harris, K. R.
(1992) Direct
instruction, strategy instruction, and strategy instruction with explicit
self-regulation: effects on learning disabled students’ composition skills
and self-efficacy. Journal of Educational
Psychology,
84
(3), 340–352.
Schmidt, A.
(2016) Listening
journals for extensive and intensive listening
practice. English Teaching
Forum,
54
(2), 2–11.
Shimauchi, S.
(2018) English-medium
instruction in the internationalization of higher education in Japan:
Rationale and issues. Educational Studies in
Japan: International
Yearbook,
12
(1), 77–90.
Siegal, J.
(2011) Thoughts
on L2 listening pedagogy. ELT
Journal,
65
(3), 318–321.
(2014) Exploring
L2 listening instruction: Examinations of
practice. ELT
Journal,
68
(1), 22–30.
Siegal, J., & Siegal, A.
(2015) Getting
to the bottom of L2 listening instruction: Making a case for bottom-up
activities. Studies in Second Language
Learning and
Teaching,
5
(4), 637–662.
Taguchi, N.
(2005) The
communicative approach in Japanese secondary schools: Teachers’ perceptions
and practice. The Language
Teacher,
29
(3), 3–12.
Tanewong, S.
(2019) Metacognitive
pedagogical sequence for less-proficient Thai EFL listeners: A comparative
investigation. RELC
Journal,
50
(1), 86–103.
The Extensive Reading
Foundation
(2011) The
Extensive Reading Foundation’s guide to extensive
reading. Retrieved
on 4 April
2023 from erfoundation.org/guide/ERF_Guide.pdf
Thorn, S.
(2009) Mining
listening texts. Modern English
Teacher,
18
(2), 5–13.
Tsui, A., & Fullilove, J.
(1998) Bottom-up
or top-down processing as a discriminator of L2 listening
performance. Applied
Linguistics,
19
(4), 432–451.
Van Meter, P., Yokoi, L., & Pressley, M.
(1994) A Theory of Notetaking Derived from Student’s Perceptions of Notetaking. Manuscript under publication review, University at Albany, State University of New York, Department of Educational Psychology and Statistics, Albany, NY.
Vandergrift, L.
(2012) Teaching
listening. In C. A. Chapelle (Ed.), The
encyclopedia of applied
linguistics (pp. 1–8). Blackwell.
Vandergrift, L., & Goh, C.
(2012) Teaching
and learning second language
listening. Routledge.
Weaver, C., Jones, A., & Bulach, J.
(2008) Comparing
placement decisions based on raw test scores and Rasch ability
scores. The Language
Teacher,
32
(6), 3–8.
Winsteps.com
n.d.). Reliability
and separation of measures. Retrieved
on 4 April
2023 from http://www.winsteps.com/winman/reliability.htm
Yeldham, M.
(2016) Second
language listening instruction: Comparing a strategies-based approach with
an interactive strategies/bottom-up skills
approach. TESOL
Quarterly,
50
(2), 394–420.
Yonezaki, H.
(2014) Effectiveness of dictation in improving English listening ability of Japanese high school students. Research Reports of Nagaoka College of Technology,
50
, 21–30.