Radical reform, inevitable debts: Lorenzo Valla, Alexander de Villa-Dei, and recent grammarians
ClementinaMarsico
Ludwig Boltzmann Institute for Neo-Latin Studies
Summary
In a letter to his friend Joan Serra, Lorenzo Valla (1407–1457) shows his contempt for medieval grammars, describing Alexander de Villa-Dei, Evrard de Béthune, Giovanni Balbi, and others as faex hominum. Many traces of Valla’s polemics against medieval authors are woven into his linguistic works, in primis in his Elegantie lingue latine.
The Elegantie represent a monumental attempt to restore Latin to its original splendour after the so-called barbarities of the Middle Ages. Starting from its structure, this work adopts a completely different form compared with the systematic grammatical syntheses of the previous period. It functions as a series of thematic chapters united in the goal of denouncing earlier grammatical, lexical, syntactic, and interpretive usage and decisions. The chapters are built entirely on an expertly assembled collection of quotations. For Valla, only through consulting the best authors can a scholar reach the latine loqui. In practical terms, however, is Valla truly able to reach this goal and break from the medieval tradition?
Beginning with this question, this paper focuses on Valla’s linguistic works, showing both their innovative and traditional facets. The most significant changes Valla proposes in his linguistic analysis – often presented by the author as a strong attack on medieval grammarians – are illustrated. Also, the paper clarifies the humanist’s inevitable debt to the tradition he scorns, particularly evident when considering his use of grammatical terminology.
In a passage from the Antidotum in Facium, responding to his adversary Bartolomeo Facio, an ardent defender of Priscian’s authority, Valla clarifies his position with respect to the grammarians who preceded him:
References
A.Primary literature
Doctrinale
=See Villa-Dei1893.
Nonius (Nonius Marcellus)
1903De compendiosa doctrina libros XX. Ed. by Wallace A. Lindsay. Leipzig: B. G. Teubner.
Valla
, Ars=See Valla 1990.
Valla, Laurentius
1962 “Elegantiae”. Opera omnia, vol. I. Ed. by Eugenio Garin. Turin: Bottega d’Erasmo.
Valla, Laurentius
1970Collatio Novi Testamenti. Ed. by Alessandro Perosa. Florence: Sansoni.
Valla, Laurentius
1981Antidotum in Facium. Ed. by Mariangela Regoliosi. Padua: Antenore.
Valla, Laurentius
1984Epistole. Ed. by Ottavio Besomi, Mariangela Regoliosi. Padua: Antenore.
Valla, Laurentius
1990L’arte della grammatica. Ed. by Paola Casciano. Rome-Milan: Fondazione Lorenzo Valla-Mondadori.
Valla, Laurentius
1999De linguae latinae elegantia. Ed. by Santiago López Moreda. Caceres: Universidad de Extremadura.
Valla, Laurentius
2007Raudensiane note. Ed. by Gian Matteo Corrias. Florence: Polistampa.
Valla, Laurentius
2009Emendationes quorundam locorum ex Alexandro ad Alfonsum primum Aragonum regem. Ed. by Clementina Marsico. Florence: Polistampa.
Valla, Lorenzo
2013Correspondence. Ed. by Brendan Cook. Cambridge, Mass.; London: The I Tatti Renaissance Library-Harvard University Press.
Villa-Dei, Alexander
1893Das Doctrinale des Alexander de Villa-Dei. Ed. by Dietrich Reichling. Berlin: Hofman & Company.
B.Secondary literature
Amsler, Mark
1993 “History of Linguistics, ‘Standard Latin’, and Pedagogy”. Historiographia Linguistica 20.49–66.
Black, Robert
2001Humanism and Education in Medieval and Reinassance Italy: Tradition and Innovation in Latin Schools from the twelfth to the fifteenth century. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
[ p. 408 ]
Camporeale, Salvatore I.
1972Lorenzo Valla. Umanesimo e teologia. Florence: Istituto nazionale di studi sul Rinascimento.
Cerruti, Maria Grazia
1992 “Gravis”. Studi Noniani 14.7–49.
De Nonno, Mario
1990 “Le citazioni dei grammatici”. Lo spazio letterario di Roma antica, vol. III: La ricezione del testo. Ed. by Guglielmo Cavalloet al., 597–646. Rome: Salerno.
Dictionary of Medieval Latin from British Sources
2013 Ed. by R. K. Ashdowneet al.. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Gavinelli, Simona
1988 “Le Elegantie di Lorenzo Valla: fonti grammaticali e stratificazione compositiva”. Italia medioevale e umanistica 31.205–247.
Harto Trujillo, María Luisa
2009 “Las fuentas gramaticales de las Elegantie”. Lorenzo Valla. La riforma della lingua e della logica. Atti del convegno del Comitato Nazionale VI centenario della nascita di Lorenzo Valla, Prato, 4–7 giugno 2008. Ed. by M. Regoliosi, 31–49. Florence: Polistampa.
Law, Vivienne
1987 “Late Latin Grammar in the Early Middle Ages: A Typological History”. The History of Linguistics in the Classical Period. Ed. by Daniel J. Taylor, 191–206. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Law, Vivienne
2003The History of Linguistics in Europe. From Plato to 1600. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Lo Monaco, Francesco
2009 “Vulgus imperitum grammatice professorum. Lorenzo Valla, le Elegantie e i grammatici recentes”. Lorenzo Valla. La riforma della lingua e della logica. Atti del convegno del Comitato Nazionale VI centenario della nascita di Lorenzo Valla, Prato, 4–7 giugno 2008. Ed. by Mariangela Regoliosi, 51–66. Florence: Polistampa.
Marsh, David
1979 “Grammar, method and polemic in Lorenzo Valla’s ‘Elegantiae’”. Rinascimento 19.91–116.
Marsico, Clementina
2009 “Sulle Emendationes del Valla al Doctrinale: indagine linguistica e proposte metodologiche”. Lorenzo Valla. La riforma della lingua e della logica. Atti del convegno del Comitato Nazionale VI centenario della nascita di Lorenzo Valla, Prato, 4–7 giugno 2008. Ed. by Mariangela Regoliosi, 323–346. Florence: Polistampa.
Marsico, Clementina
2013Per l’edizione delle Elegantie. Studio sul V libro. Florence: Firenze University Press.
Marsico, Clementina
2014 “Tra autobiografia e letteratura. Il proemio al V libro delle Elegantie lingue latine”. Nel cantiere degli umanisti. Per Mariangela Regoliosi, vol. II. Ed. by Lucia Bertolini, Donatella Coppini, & Clementina Marsico, 875–895. Florence, Polistampa.
Marsico, Clementina
2018. “‘Talking about everything is a nearly infinite task’. Encyclopaedism and Specialisation in Lorenzo Valla’s Elegantie lingue latine”. Renaissance Encyclopaedism: Studies in Curiosity and Ambition Ed. by Scott W. Blanchard, Andrea Severi 59 106 TorontoUniversity of Toronto Press
Percival, Keith W.
1986 “Renaissance linguistics: the old and the new”. Studies in the History of Western Linguistics in Honour of R. H. Robins. Ed. by Theodora Bynon and Frank R. Palmer, 56–68. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
2000 “Le Elegantie del Valla come ‘grammatica’ antinormativa”. Studi di grammatica italiana 19.315–336.
Regoliosi, Mariangela
2007 “Nihil crescit sola imitatione. Il rapporto di Lorenzo Valla con la tradizione”. Munus quaesitum meritis. Homenaje a Carmen Codoñer. Ed. by Gregorio Hinojo Andrés & José Carlos Fernández Corte, 765–773. Salamanca: Universidad de Salamanca.
[ p. 409 ]
Regoliosi, Mariangela
2008 “Per l’edizione delle Elegantie: proposte metodologiche”. Pubblicare il Valla. Ed. by Mariangela Regoliosi, 297–304. Florence: Polistampa.
Regoliosi, Mariangela
2010 “Cupidus docendi iuniores. Il programma culturale di Lorenzo Valla”. Gli Antichi e i Moderni. Studi in onore di Roberto Cardini, vol. III. Ed. by Lucia Bertolini & Donatella Coppini, 1129–1167. Florence: Polistampa.
Rizzo, Silvia
1997 “Il Valla e il progetto di un nuovo Doctrinale”. Filologia umanistica. Per Gianvito Resta, vol. III. Ed. by Vincenzo Fera, Giacomo Ferraù, 1583–1612. Padua: Antenore.
Rizzo, Silvia
2002Ricerche sul latino umanistico. Rome: Edizioni di Storia e Letteratura.
Tavoni, Mirko
1986 “Lorenzo Valla e il volgare”. Lorenzo Valla e l’Umanesimo italiano. Atti del Convegno Internazionale di Studi Umanistici (Parma, 18–19 ottobre 1984). Ed. by Ottavio Besomi & Mariangela Regoliosi, 199–216. Padua: Antenore.
Tavoni, Mirko
1990 “La linguistica rinascimentale”. Storia della linguistica, vol. II. Ed. by Giulio C. Lepschy, 169–312. Bologna: Il Mulino.