The Donatus minor between Via antiqua and Via moderna: Grammar education and the Wegestreit
C. H.Kneepkens
University of Groningen
Abstract
In the 15th and early 16th centuries, educational life at the universities of Western and Central Europe was dominated by serious doctrinal conflicts between several schools of thought (the Antiqui/Reales vs the Moderni/Nominales), the Wegestreit. This clash not only had serious consequences for instruction in philosophy and theology, but was also felt in the grammar courses of the BA programme. Remarkably, we find the old elementary grammar primer, the Donatus minor, as a prescribed textbook in several Arts faculties. This essay examines the impact of the so-called Wegestreit on university grammar instruction with special reference to late 15th- and early 16th-cent. commentaries on the Donatus minor. After a concise sketch of the philosophical and logical roots of the Wegestreit, I present the development of the conflicting approaches to language and grammar in the 14th century that underlay the divergent opinions of the 15th-century masters.The third section deals with the position of the Donatus minor as a textbook for the undergraduate grammar courses of the Arts faculties. The remainder of this essay falls into two sections. First, a discussion of the different ways the Antiqui and Moderni analyse and explain some theoretical and the related practical aspects of syntactic relations in the last decades of the 15th cent. This part is followed by two case studies of the analyses, explanations and applications of these syntactic phenomena in the commentaries on the Donatus minor of the Realist/Thomist, Magnus Hundt (1449–1519) of Leipzig, and the Modernist Florentius Diel (fl.1490–1509) of Mainz.
The title or colophon of some 15th- and early-16th-century commentaries on the Donatus minor informs its readership that the commentary they intend to use has been composed in conformity with the principles and methods (secundum viam) of the Antiqui, the Modist(a)e, Thomas Aquinas, or the Moderni. These signposts reflect the academic clash commonly referred to as the Wegestreit. In this period, a conflict between competing schools of thought disrupted intellectual life at the majority of the universities of Western and Central Europe. At stake was the exclusive right to frame the teaching programmes of a university, faculty, or college according to the tenets of a particular line of thought. The mutual controversies were legion and covered a wide range of doctrinal and methodological aspects, but the origin of the conflict must be looked for in fundamentally different views on the ontological status of the universals. Expressed in general words, the Antiqui, who were sometimes subdivided into Thomists, Scotists, and Albertists, defended a realist position, which held that a universal as a common nature or an idea in God’s mind (ante rem), as an immanent form in the individual existing in reality (in re), and abstracted as a universal concept in the human mind (post rem) was one and the same. This means that, in their view, a universal has some degree of reality independent of the human mind but also that the universal existed as a principle of knowledge in the human mind. The Moderni, on the other hand, adhered to a nominalist or conceptualist view and considered the universal only to be a concept, an exclusive product of the human intellect without any existence outside the human mind (Braakhuis 1989: 16).
References
Sigla used throughout the article
DMS = Destructiones Modorum Significandi1994 Ed. by Ludger Kaczmarek. Amsterdam & Philadelphia: B. R. Grüner.
GL = Grammatici LatiniEd. byHeinrich Keil. 8 vols. Leipzig: B. G. Teubner, 1857–1870. (Facs. Repr., Hildesheim & NewYork: Georg Olms) 1981.
2005Summulae de propositionibus. Ed. by Ria van der Lecq. Turnhout: Brepols.
Johannes of Glogów
1506Donati minoris Grammatici non uulgaris de octo partibus orationis egregia utilisque declaratio. Leipzig: Wolfgang Stöckel (Monacensis).
Ps-Johannes Versor
1489Octo partium orationis explanatio. Heidelberg: [Friedrich Misch] (GW M50207).
Magnus Hundt
1489Expositio Donati secundum viam Doctoris Sancti perutilis baccalariandis. [Leipzig]: Conradus Kacheloven. (GW 13657; ex. Darmstadt, UB, inc.-ii-20).
Petrus de Alliaco
1489/95Conceptus. Ed. by Claudius Clerardus. Paris: Durand Gerlier. (GW M31921; ex. Ste-Geneviève, Paris).
Priscianus
Institutionum Grammaticarum Libri XVIII Ed. by Martin Hertz GL II III
Radulphus Brito
1980Quaestiones super Priscianum minorem. Ed. by Heinz W. S. Enders & Jan Pinborg. 2 vols. Stuttgart-Bad Cannstatt: Frommann-Holzboog.
Ps-Remigius
1982Remigius A Latin grammar in facsimile edition with a postscript ed. by Jan Pinborg. København: Munksgaard. [Originally published Schleswig, 1486].
Statuta Facultatis Artium Generalis Studii Coloniensis
1398, in: Bianco 1855: 59–73.
The Mediaeval Statutes of the Faculty of Arts of the University of Freiburg im Breisgau
1964 Ed. by H. Ott & J. M. Fletcher. Notre Dame, Indiana: The Medieval Institute, University of Notre Dame.
Thomas Aquinas
1989Expositio Libri Peryermenias ed. by René-Antoine Gauthier. Roma & Paris: Commissio Leonina-J. Vrin.
Thomas of Erfurt
1972Grammatica speculativa. Ed. by Geoffrey L. Bursill-Hall. London: Longman.
Tre latinske Grammatikker. Donatus. Fundamentum. Regulae
1979 Ed. by Jan Pinborg & Erik Dal. Copenhague: Det Kongelige Danske Videnskabernes Selskab.
Urkunden zur Geschichte der Universität Tübingen aus den Jahren 1476–1550
Ed. byRudolph von Roth. Tübingen: J. C. B. Mohr1877 (Repr., Aalen: Scientia Verlag 1973.)
Urkundenbuch der Universitaet Heidelberg
1886 Ed. by Eduard Winkelmann. Heidelberg: Carl Winter.[ p. 386 ]
B. Secondary literature
Bianco, Franz Joseph von
1855Die Alte Universität Köln. 2. Auflage. Band II: Nachtrag: Ausführliche Nachrichten über die Niederlassung und das Wirken der Gesellschaft Jesu in Köln. Anlagen: Akten und Quellen. Köln: Chr. Gehly. (Repr., Aalen: Scientia Verlag 1974.)
Biard, Joël
1989Logique et théorie du signe au XIVe siècle. Paris: J. Vrin.
Braakhuis, H. A. G.
1989 “School Philosophy and Philosophical Schools: The semantic-ontological views in Cologne commentaries on Peter of Spain, and the “Wegestreit”. Die Kölner Universität im Mittelalter. Geistige Wurzeln und soziale Wirklichkeit. Ed. by Albert Zimmermann, 1–18. Berlin & New York: Walter De Gruyter.
Bursill-Hall, Geoffrey L.
1971Speculative Grammars of the Middle Ages: The Doctrine of Partes orationis of the Modistae. The Hague & Paris: Mouton.
Bursill-Hall, Geoffrey L.
1981A Census of Medieval Latin Grammatical Manuscripts. Stuttgart-Bad Cannstatt: Frommann-Holzboog.
Covington, Michael A.
1984Syntactic Theory in the High Middle Ages. Modistic models of sentence structure. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Covington, Michael A.
1986 “Grammatical Theory in the Middle Ages”. Studies in the History of Western Linguistics. Ed. by Thea Bynon & Frank R. Palmer, 23–55. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Ebbesen, Sten & Irène Rosier-Catach
1997 “Le trivium à la Faculté des arts”. L’enseignement des disciplines à la Faculté des arts (Paris et Oxford, XIIIe-XVe siècle). Ed. by O. Weijers & Louis Holtz, 97–128. Turnhout: Brepols.
Fredborg, K. Margareta
2014 “Medieval Commentators on the Notion ‘persona agentis’ in Priscian’s Syntactic Theory”. Historiographia Linguistica 41. 219–245.
Gabriel, Astrik L.
1955Student Life in Ave Maria College, Mediaeval Paris. History and Chartulary of the College. Notre Dame, Ind.: University of Notre Dame Press.
Hasenbrink, Burkhard
2000 “Latinität als Bildungsfundament”. Schulliteratur im Späten Mittelalter. Ed. Klaus Grubmüller, 49–76. München: Wilhelm Fink.
Hoenen, J. F. Maarten
1995 “Late Medieval Schools of Thought in the Mirror of University Textbook: The Promptuarium argumentorum (Cologne 1492)”. Philosophy and Learning: Universities in the Middle Ages. Ed. by J. F. Maarten Hoenen, J. H. Josef Schneider, Georg Wieland, 329–369. Leiden–New York– Köln: E. J. Brill.
Hübener, W.
1981 “ ‘Oratio mentalis’ und ‘oratio vocalis’ in der Philosophie des 14. Jahrhunderts”. Sprache und Erkenntnis im Mittelalter. Ed. by W. Kluxenet al., 488–497. Berlin & New York: Walter de Gruyter
Kaczmarek, Ludger
1992 “The Age of the Sign: New Light on the Role of the Fourteenth Century in the History of Semiotics”. Dialogue: Canadian Philosophical Review 31. 509–515.
Kaczmarek, Ludger
1995a “Sprach- und Zeichentheorie in der deutschen Spätscholastik: Gabriel Biel, ‘Ultimus scholasticorum’, Florentius Diel, ‘Primus modernorum’ und die Grammatiker des 15. Jahrhunderts”. Sprachtheorien in Spätantike und Mittelalter. Ed. by Sten Ebbesen, 207–236. Tübingen: Gunter Narr.
Kaczmarek, Ludger
1995b “ ‘Magister Sotphi’. Gerhard von Zutphens Glosa notabilis (1487–88) und die Geschichte der Grammatik im. 15. Jahrhundert”. History and Rationality. Ed. by Klaus D. Dutz & Kjell Å. Forsgren, 75–92. Münster: Nodus.
Kaczmarek, Ludger
2000 “Erhard Knab von Zwiefalten (†1480): Improbatio modorum significandi.” Edition nach den Handschriften. Individuation, Sýmpnoia, Harmonia, Emanation. Festgabe H. Schepers. Ed. by Klaus D. Dutz, 109–155. Münster: Nodus.
[ p. 387 ]
Kaluza, Zenon
1988Les querelles doctrinales à Paris. Nominalists et réalists aux confins du XIVe et du XVe siècles. Bergamo: Pierluigi Lubrina.
Kleineidam, Erich
1985Universitas Studii Erffordensis. Überblick über die Geschichte der Universität Erfurt. Teil I: Spätmittellater 1392–1460. Leipzig: St. Benno-Verlag.
Klima, Gyula
2001John Buridan. Summulae de Dialectica. An annotated translation, with a philosophical introduction. New Haven & London: Yale University Press.
Kneepkens, Corneille Henri
1990 “Erfurt, Ampl. Q.70A: A Quaestiones Commentary on the second part of Alexander de Villa Dei’s Doctrinale by Marsilius of Inghen? An explorative note on a specimen of conceptualist grammar”. Vivarium 28. 26–54.
Kneepkens, Corneille Henri
1992 “On the Notion of constructio in Conceptualist Grammar: Quaestio XXXV of the Doctrinale. Commentary Preserved in Erfurt, Amplon. Q 70A and attributed to a Master Marcilius”. Marsilius of Inghen: Acts of the International Marsilius of Inghen Symposium organized by the Nijmegen Centre for Medieval Studies (CMS) Nijmegen (18–20 December 1986) ed. by H. A. G. Braakhuis & M. J. F .M. Hoenen, 143–172. Nijmegen: Ingenium.
Kneepkens, Corneille Henri
1995 “The Priscianic Tradition”. Sprachtheorien in Spätantike und Mittelalter. Ed. by Sten Ebbesen, 239–264. Tübingen: Gunter Narr.
Kneepkens, Corneille Henri
2003 “The Tradition of Universal and Speculative Grammar in the Late Middle Ages”. El Brocense y las Humanidades en el siglo XVI. Ed. by Carmen Codoñer, Santiago López Moreda & Jesus Ureña Bracero, 31–60. Salamanca: Ediciones Universidad.
Kneepkens, Corneille Henri
2004a “Some Notes on the Revival of Modistic Linguistics in the Fifteenth Century: Ps.-Johannes Versor and William Zenders of Weert”. John Buridan and Beyond: Topics in the language sciences, 1300–1700. Ed. by Russell L. Friedman & Sten Ebbesen, 69–119. Copenhagen: The Royal Danish Academy of Sciences and Letters.
Kneepkens, Corneille Henri
2004b “The Via antiqua and the Via moderna in Grammar: The Late Medieval discussions on the subject of the sentence”. Medieval Theories on Assertive and Non-Assertive Language. Ed. by Alfonso Maieru & Luisa Valente, 219–244. Firenze: Leo S. Olschki.
Kneepkens, Corneille Henri
2006 “Dyophysitism in grammaticis. William Zenders: Alexander de Villa Dei and Lorenzo Valla in One Mind”, Erziehung, Bildung, Bildungsinstitutionen / Education, Training and their Institutions. Ed. by Rudolf Suntrup, Jan R. Veenstra & Anne M. Bollmann, 131–160. Frankfurt am Main: Peter Lang.
Kneepkens, Corneille Henri
2013 “A Note on articulatio and University Grammar”. Logic and Language in the Middle Ages: A Volume in Honour of Sten Ebbesen. Ed. by Jakob Leth Fink, Heine Hansen & Ana María Mora-Márquez, 221–237. Leiden & Boston: Brill.
Krauze-Błachowicz, Krystyna
2003 “Johannes Glogoviensis’ Concept of Construction”. Studies in Logic, Grammar and Rhetoric 6:19.31–37.
Leader, D. R.
1983 “Grammar in Late-Medieval Oxford and Cambridge”. History of Education 12.9–14.
Lenz, Martin
2003Mentale Sätze: Wilhelm von Ockhams Thesen zur Sprachlichkeit des Denkens. Wiesbaden & Stuttgart: Franz Steiner.
Lexicon grammaticorum: Who’s Who in the history of world linguistics
1996 Ed. by Harro Stammerjohann. Tübingen: Max Niemeyer.
Lhotsky, Alphons
1965Die Wiener Artistenfakultät 1365–1497. Wien: Hermann Böhlaus Nachf.
Marenbon, John
1999The Philosophy of Peter Abelard. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Meuthen, Erich
1988Kölner Universitätsgeschichte, Bd. I: Die alte Universität. Köln & Wien: Hermann Böhlaus Nachf.
[ p. 388 ]
Normore, Calvin
2009 “The End of Mental Language”. Le langage mental du Moyen Âge à l’Âge Classique. Ed. by Joel Biard, 293–306. Louvain-la-Neuve ˗ Louvain ˗ Paris ˗Walpole, Mass.: Peeters.
Panaccio, Claude
1999Le discours intérieur: De Platon à Guillaume d’Ockham. Paris: Éditions du Seuil.
Percival, W. Keith
1975 “The Grammatical Tradition and the Rise of the Vernaculars”, Current Trends in Linguistics. Ed. by Thomas A. Sebeok. Vol. XIII: Historiography of Linguistics, 231–275. The Hague: Mouton. (Repr. in Percival, Studies in Renaissance Grammar. New York & London: Routledge 2004).
Pinborg, Jan
1967Die Entwicklung der Sprachtheorie im Mittelalter. Münster & Kopenhagen: Aschendorff.
Pinborg, Jan
1975 “Die Logik der Modisten”. Studia Mediewistyczne 16: 39–97.
Pinborg, Jan
1982 “Speculative Grammar”. The Cambridge History of Later Medieval Philosophy: From the rediscovery of Aristotle to the disintegration of Scholasticism 1100–1600. Ed. by Norman Kretzmann, Anthony Kenny & Jan Pinborg, 254–269. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Puff, Helmut
1995 “Von dem schlüssel aller Künsten / nemblich der Grammatica”: Deutsch im lateinischen Grammatikunterricht 1480–1560. Tübingen & Basel: Francke.
Rosier(-Catach), Irène
1983La grammaire spéculative des modistes. Lille: Presses Universitaires.
Rosier-Catach, Irène
2014 “Grammar”. The Cambridge History of Medieval Philosophy. Ed. by Robert Pasnau, 196–216. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
Spade, Paul V.
1980Peter of Ailly: Concepts and insolubles. An annotated translation. Dordrecht – Boston – London: D. Reidel.
Steiner, Jürgen
1989Die Artistenfakultät der Universität Mainz 1477–1562. Stuttgart: Franz Steiner.
Tavoni, Mirko
2000 “The Traditional Study of Latin at the University in the Age of Humanism”, History of the Language Sciences (= Handbücher zur Sprach- und Kommunikationswissenschaft, XVIII.1). Ed. by Sylvain Auroux, E. F. Konrad Koerner, Hans-Josef Niederehe & Kees Versteegh, 650–656. Berlin & New York: Walter de Gruyter.
Thurot, Charles
1850De l’organisation de l’enseignement dans l’université de Paris au Moyen-Age. Paris & Besançon: Dezobry & Magdeleine / Veuve Charles Deis.
Worstbrock, Franz J.
2008a “Diel (Dül, Tyll), Florentius”. Deutscher Humanismus 1480–1520: Verfasserlexicon. Ed. by Franz J. Worstbrock, 557–564. Berlin & New York: Walter de Gruyter.
Worstbrock, Franz J.
2008b “Hundt (Hund, Hunt; Canis, Magnus, d. Ä. (Magnus Magdeburgensis, Pathenopolitanus)”. Ibid., 1176–1185.[ p. 389 ][ p. 390 ]