La grammatica proverbiandi y La nova ratio nebrissensis

Miguel Ángel Esparza Torres y Vicente Calvo Fernández
Summary

Antonio de Nebrija (1444?–1522) published his Gramática Castellana in 1492, at a time when humanist appreciation of Castilian as a cultural language had not yet advanced to a discussion of its possibilities to become an established norm. However, an analysis of Nebrija’s linguistic and grammatical theories does shed some light on this question. For instance, it becomes clear that the new method which he proposes for the teaching of Latin (nova ratio Nebrissensis) presupposed a recognition of the presence of universal grammatical concepts in the pupil’s mother tongue. Such a conception is possible because Nebrija accepts an essential starting point of the medieval speculative tradition: language composition may be reduced to two basic concepts: materia (lexical element submitted to ‘corruption’) and forma (other elements – ‘accidents’ – which are stable). This composition is common to all languages. Therefore, Nebrija holds that by making use of the constrastive method it is possible to study two languages such as Latin and Castilian (which also happen to be closely related). Therefore, we must not consider the Gramática Castellana as separate from the rest of Nebrija’s scholarly production. He himself had coined the notion of ‘unity in diversity’ concerning his grammatical work. In order to teach the Castilian language and, starting from Castilian, Latin, Nebrija writes grammatical and lexicographical works which have an underlying unity. His general approach was exclusive to Nebrija; however, although nobody before him had worked out such an ambitious project, there is no doubt that he was continuing on the way in which grammatical tradition had been heading for some time. An example of this tradition is the so-called Grarnmatica proverbiandi. In this paper, the main features of this kind of medieyal grammar are analyzed. It is argued that they constitute the immediate precursor of the Nebrija’s undertaking, since we find in them didactic postulates which he developed further. These postulates led Nebrija to a contrastive grammar of Latin and Castilian and the creation of a grammatical terminology for the vernacular.

Quick links
Full-text access is restricted to subscribers. Log in to obtain additional credentials. For subscription information see Subscription & Price. Direct PDF access to this article can be purchased through our e-platform.

Referencias bibliográficas

Aldrete, Bernardo José
1606Del origen y principio de la lengua castellana o romance que oi se usa en España. Roma: Carlo Vulliet. (Nova ed. de Lidio Nieto, Madrid: CSIC 1975.)Google Scholar
Anon
1555Util, i breve institution, para aprender los principios, y fundamentos de la lengua Hespañola. Lovaina: Bartholomaei Gravii. (Nova ed. de Antonio Roldán, Madrid: CSIC 1977.)Google Scholar
1559Gramática de la lengua Vulgar de España. Lovaine: Bartholomaei Gravii. (Nova ed. de Antonio Roldán & Rafael de Baibín, Madrid: CSIC 1966.)Google Scholar
Bursill-Hall, Geoffrey L.
1974 “Toward a History of Linguistics in the Middle Ages (1100–1450)”. Studies in the History of Linguistics: Traditions and paradigms ed. Dell H. Hymes, 72–92. Bloomington: Indiana Univ. Press.Google Scholar
Bustos, Eugenio de
1983 “Nebrija, primer lingüista español”. Actas de la Tercera Academia Literaria Renacentista, 205–222. Salamanca: Publica-ciones de la Universidad.Google Scholar
Cerezo, Andrés G. de
1485Grammatica Brevis. Burgos: Fadrique de Ba-silea.Google Scholar
Colón, Germà & Amadeu J. Soberanas
1985Panorama de la lexicografia catalana. De les glosses medievals a Pompeu Fabra. Barcelona: Bibliote-ca Universitaria.Google Scholar
González Rolán, Tomás & Pilar Saquero Suárez-Somonte
1992 “La ense-ñanza gramatical en Valencia a comienzos del siglo XV: Importancia de la Grammatica proverbiandi en la renovación pedagógica del latín”. Ex-cerpta Philologica: Antonio Holgado Redondo (= Sacra Revista de Filo-logía Griega y Latina, 1), 299–331. Universidad de Cádiz.Google Scholar
Keniston, Hayward
1975 “The « Liberis educandis » of Antonio de Lebri-ja”. Homenaje a R. Menéndez Pidal, vol. III: Miscelánea de estudios lin-güísticos, literarios e históricos, 127–141. Madrid: Hernando.Google Scholar
Mates, Bartolomé
1468Libellus pro efficendis orationibus. Barcelona: Johannes Gherling.Google Scholar
Nebrija, Antonio de
1481Introductiones Latinae. Salamanca: s.i.Google Scholar
1482/1483Introductiones Latinae. Salamanca: s.i.Google Scholar
1488Introductiones Latinae. Salamanca: s.i.Google Scholar
1492Diccionario latino-español. Salamanca: s.i.Google Scholar
1495Vocabulario de romance en latín (VEL). Salamanca: s.i.Google Scholar
1495Introductiones Latinae (Recognitio). Salamanca: s.i.Google Scholar
1992[1492]Gramática Castellana. Antonio de Nebrija. Introductión y notas de Miguel-Ángel Esparza & Ramón Sarmiento. Madrid: SGEL.Google Scholar
Nepos, Ferdinandus C.
1492Materies grammatices. Toulouse: Henricus Mayer.Google Scholar
Niederehe, Hans-Josef
1987Alfonso X el Sabio y la lingüística de su tiempo. Madrid: SGEL.Google Scholar
Pastrana, Juan de. C.
1495Compendium grammatice. Toulousse: Henricus Mayer.Google Scholar
Reichling, Dietrich
ed. 1893Das Doctrinale des Alexandre de Villa-Dei. Kritisch-exegetische Ausgabe mit Einleitung, Verzeichniss der Handschriften und Drucke nebst Registern. (= Monumenta Germaniae Pedagögica, 12.) Berlín: A. Hofmann.Google Scholar
Rico, Francisco
1978Nebrija freute a los bárbaros. Salamanca: Ediciones de la Universidad.Google Scholar
1981 “Un prólogo al Renacimiento español. La dedicatoria de Nebrija a las Introductiones Latinae, 1488”. Homenaje a Marcel Bataillon, 6194. Sevilla-Bordeaux: Universidad de Sevilla & Universidad de Bur-deos.Google Scholar
Ridruejo, Emilio
1977 “Notas romances en gramáticas latino-españolas”. Revis ta de Filología Española 59.51–80.Google Scholar
Sisón, Daniel
1490Perutile grammaticale compendium. Zaragoza: Juan Hums.Google Scholar
Thurot, Charles
1868Extraits de divers manuscrits latins pour servir à l’histoire des doctrines grammaticales au moyen âge. Paris: Imprimerie Impériale. (Reed., Frankfurt/Main: Minerva 1964.)Google Scholar
Torre y del Cerro, Antonio de la & José Rubio y Balaguer
1971Documentes para la historia de la Universidad de Barcelona. Barcelona: Fa-cultad de Filosofía y Letras.Google Scholar
Valdés, Juan
1984[1535]Diálogo de la lengua. Editión de Juan M. Lope Blanch. Madrid: Clásicos Castalia.Google Scholar
Villalón, Cristóbal de
1558Gramática Castellana: Arte breve y compen-diosa para saber hablar y escrevir en la lengua Castellana congrua y de-centemente. Anvers: Guillermo Simón. (Nova ed. de Constantino García, Madrid: CSIC 1971.)Google Scholar