Savage eloquence in America and the linguistic construction of a British identity in the 18th century
Summary
This paper examines particular aspects of 18th-century British linguistic thought by focusing upon discussions of American Indians which depicted them as poetic and eloquent. The paper places this depiction within the context of the larger British concerns of the time to show how it was used by some to portray the ‘primitive’ Indians and their languages as inferior, by others as superior, to the ‘modern’ Europeans and their languages. It is argued that this contextualizing of the idea of the ‘savage poet’ helps us to understand the terms of the debates over which European language could rightfully lay claim to the crown of linguistic supremacy.
Quick links
References
A.Primary sources
Adair, James
Anon
Bailey, Nathan
Barton, Benjamin Smith
Bartram, John
Beatty, Charles
Beattie, James
Blackwell, Thomas
Blair, Hugh
Boswell, James
Buchanan, James
Burke, Edmund
Carver, Jonathan
Cleland, John
Colden, Cadwallader
Donaldson, John
Drake, William
Edwards, Jonathan
Ferguson, Adam
Harris, James
Henley, John
Hume, David
Johnson, Samuel
Johnson, Sir William
Jones, Rowland
Long, J.
Lonsdale, Roger
Macpherson, James
Malcolme, David
1738 An Essay on the Antiquities of Great Britain and Ireland: Wherein they are placed in a clearer light than hitherto. Designed as an introducction to a larger work, especially an attempt to shew an affinity betwixt the languages of the ancient Britains and the Americans […]. Edinburgh: Printed by T. & W. Ruddinmans.![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Martin, Benjamin
Monboddo, James Burnet, Lord
Morton, Sarah Wentworth
Parsons, James
Priestley, Joseph
Saint-Simon, Maximilien Henri, Marquis de
Shaftesbury, Anthony Ashley Cooper, Earl of
Sheridan, Thomas
Smith, William, D.D.
Stackhouse, Thomas
Thwaites, Reuben Gold
Tytler, Alexander Fraser, Lord Woodhouselee
Wilson, Thomas
Wise, Francis
B.Secondary sources
Attridge, Derek
Auroux, Sylvain & Francisco Quiexalos
Bate, Walter Jackson
Bergheaud, Patrice
Bisseil, Benjamin
Bonfante, Guiliano
Cohen, Murray
De Mauro, Tullio & Lia Formigari
Derrida, Jacques
Douthwaite, Julia
Droixhe, Daniel
Droixhe, Daniel & Pol.-P. Gossiaux
Formigari, Lia
Frank, Thomas
Howell, Wilbur Samuel
Huddlestone, Lee Eldridge
Hymes, Dell
Knowlson, James
Land, Stephen K.
Leonard, Sterling Andrus
McCosh, James
Paxman, David B.
Pilling, James Constantine
Richards, Eric
Ricken, Ulrich
Salmon, Vivian
Schreyer, Rüdiger
Shortland, Michael
Simonsuuri, Kirsti
Smith, Janet Adam
Stam, James Henry
Thomson, Ian
Ulman, H. Lewis
Vaughan, Alden T.
Wardhaugh, Ronald
Weinbrot, Howard D.