‘All Languages Are Equally Complex’: The rise and fall of a consensus
Summary
Throughout most of the history of the discipline, linguists have had little hesitation in comparing languages in terms of their relative complexity, whether or not they extrapolated judgements of superiority or inferiority from such comparisons. By the mid 20th century, however, a consensus had arisen that all languages were of equal complexity. This paper documents and explains the rise of this consensus, as well as the reasons that have led to it being challenged in recent years, from various directions, including language diversity, as analysed by Daniel Everett; arguments about Creoles and Creoloids, as put forward by Peter Trudgill, and others; and views from generative linguistics and evolutionary anthropology.
Quick links
References
Akmajian, Adrian, Richard A. Demers, Ann K. Farmer, Robert Harnish et al.
Andresen, Julie Tetel
Baker, Mark C.
Baltin, Mark & Anthony Kroch
Bickerton, Derek
Bisang, Walter
Boas, Franz
1911 “Introduction”. Handbook of American Indian Languages, Part I, by Franz Boas, with illustrative sketches by Roland B. Dixon, P. E. Goddard, William Jones & Truman Michelson, John E. Swanton & William Thalbitzer (=
Smithsonian Institution, Bureau of American Ethnology, Bulletin 40), 1–83. Washington, D.C.: Government Printing Office.![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Bunzl, Matti
1996 “Franz Boas and the Humboldtian Tradition: From Volksgeist and Nationalcharakter to an Anthropological Concept of Culture”. Volksgeist as Method and Ethic: Essays on Boasian Ethnography and the German Anthropological Tradition, ed. by George W. Stocking, Jr., 17–78. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Burnouf, Eugène
Chomsky, Noam
Cinque, Guglielmo
Colapinto, John
Covington, Michael & Mark Rosenfelder
2010 “Are All Languages Equally Complex, or are some more primitive than others?”. http://stason.org/TULARC/languages/linguistics/13-Areall-languages-equally-complex-or-are-some-more-prim.html Accessed 16. Sept. 2011.
Darwin, Charles
Deutscher, Guy
Dixon, R. M. W.
Everett, Daniel L.
Freidin, Robert
Fromkin, Victoria A. & Robert Rodman
Gabelentz, Georg von der
Greenberg, Joseph H.
Hale, Ken
Hauser, Marc D., Noam Chomsky & W. Tecumseh Fitch
Hermann, Eduard
Hornstein, Norbert & Amy Weinberg
Huang, C.-T. James
Humboldt, Wilhelm von
1826 “Lettre à Monsieur Abel-Rémusat”, 7 mars 1826. Sections 1–7, 20–23 and 27–28 published as “Sur le génie grammatical de la langue chinoise, comparé à celui des autres langues” in Journal Asiatique 9 (1826), 115–123. [First complete publication: Lettre à Monsieur Abel Rémusat. sur la nature des formes grammaticales en général et sur le génie de la langue chinoise en particulier par monsieur Guillaume de Humboldt. Observations sur quelques passages de la lettre précédente, par M. A[bel] R[émusat], Paris: Doudey-Dupré 1827.]![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Hutton, Christopher M.
Jakobson, Roman
Jespersen, Otto
Joseph, John E.
Lauzon, Matthew
Malmberg, Bertil
Matisoff, James A.
McWhorter, John H.
Miestamo, Matti, Kaius Sinnemäki & Fred Karlsson
Miller, George A. & Noam Chomsky
Moro, Andrea
Nevins, Andrew A., David Pesetsky & Cilene Rodrigues
Newmeyer, Frederick J.
Nordlinger, Rachel
O’Grady, William, Michael Dobrovolsky & Mark Aronoff
Olender, Maurice
Passy, Paul
Riddle, Elizabeth M.
Riemsdijk, Henk van
Roberts, Ian
Sampson, Geoffrey, David Gil & Peter Trudgill
Saussure, Ferdinand de
Saussure, Léopold de
Schlegel, Friedrich von
1847 The Philosophy of Life, and Philosophy of Language, in a course of lectures. Transl. by Rev. A. J. W. Morrison. London: Henry G. Bohn; New York: Harper & Brothers 1855 [Orig. publ. as Philosophie des Lebens, in funfzehn Vorlesungen gehalten zu Wien im Jahre 1827; and Philosophische Vorlesungen, insbesondere über Philosophie der Sprache und des Wortes (Wien: Carl Schaumburg 1830).]![Google Scholar](https://benjamins.com/logos/google-scholar.svg)
Schuchardt, Hugo
Siewierska, Anna
Trager, George L.
Walls, Laura Dassow
Wells, Rulon