The History of General and Comparative Linguistics in 19th Century Russia
F. M.Berezin
USSR Academy of Sciences, Moscow
Summary
The article attempts to demonstrate how problems in general and historical-comparative linguistics were worked out and developed during the 19th century in Russia. Largely following the tradition established by 18th-century Russian scholars, especially M. V. Lomonosov (1711–65), who is regarded as the founder of Russian linguistics, 19th-century linguists displayed a lively interest in investigating the social nature of language. Other key interests of these scholars were the study of the systematic character of language, the development of the phonemic principle (including the distinctive feature concept), the typological study of related and unrelated languages, etc. It is shown that their work generally mirrored the intellectual trends of their period, with biologistic views giving way to sociological and psychological ones, as is evident in the work of N. I. Greč, A. X. Vostokov, A. A. Potebnja, J. Baudouin de Courtenay, F. F. Fortuna-tov, and many others. The intellectual climate of 19th-century Europe allowed for a free exchange of scientific information; thus, in its earlier stages, the Russian scientific scene was sometimes influenced by ideas from the West, whereas it can be said that Russian scholars working in linguistics paid back toward the end of the 19th and in the earlier 20th centuries by furthering research leading to a structural concept of language, the study of morphophonology, typology and language universals as is evident in the theories advanced by members of the Prague and Copenhagen schools.
I have included, in addition to items referred to in the text, bibliographical data in an effort to show the vast scope of work on the history of linguistics carried out in the Soviet Union in the hope that Western scholars may find them useful.
Baudouin de Courtenay, I(van) A(leksandrovič) (= Jan Ignacy Niecisɫaw
. 1845–1929) 1963 Izbrannye trudy po obščemu jazykoznaniju (Collected Works on General Linguistics). Ed. by S. G. Barxudarovet al. 2 vols. Moscow: Akad. Nauk.
Belinskij, V(issarion) G(rigor’evič
. 1811–48) 1837 Osnovanija russkoi grammatiku dlja pervonacal’nogo obučenija (Foundations of Russian Grammar for Elementary Study). St. Petersburg.
Berezin, F(jodor) M(ixajlovič)
1968Očerki po istorii jazykoznanija v Rossii (konec XIX – načalo XX v.). (Sketches in the History of Linguistics in Russia (end 19th – beginning 20th century)). Moscow: Nauka.
Berezin, F(jodor) M(ixajlovič)
1973Xrestomatija po istorii russkogo jazykoznanija (Chrestomathy in the history of Russian linguistics). Moscow: Vysšaya škola. (2nd ed. 1976.) [Cf. T. M. S. Priestly’s review article in HL 4:1.69–88 (1977).]
Berezin, F(jodor) M(ixajlovič)
1974 “Russkoje teoreticeskoe jazykoznanie v Akademii Nauk (Russian Theoretical Linguistics in the Akademy of Sciences). VJa 23:3.14–26.
Berezin, F(jodor) M(ixajlovič)
1975htorija lingvističeskix učenij (History of Linguistic Studies). Moscow: Vysšaya škola.
Berezin, F(jodor) M(ixajlovič)
1976Russkoe jazykoznanie konca XIX-načala XX v. (Russian Linguistics of the End of the 19th and Beginning of the 20th centuries). Moscow: Nauka. [Cf. J. Boyadjiev’s review in HL 4:3.388–91 (1977).]
Berezin, F(jodor) M(ixajlovič)
1979Itorija russkogo jazykoznanija (The History of Russian Linguistics). Moscow: Vysšaya škola.
Berezin, F(jodor) M(ixajlovič), and B(oris) N(ikolaevič) Golovin
1857–1941) 1890 Einige Reformvorschläge auf dem Gebiete der vergleichenden Grammatik der indo-europäischen Sprachen. Kazan: Universitätsverlag.
Bogorodickij, V(asilij) A(lekseevič
1857–1941) 1915 Leckit po obščemu jazykovedeniju (Lectures on general linguistics). Kazan: Tipo-Litografia Imp. univ.
Brückner, A(lexander
1856–1939) 1917 “Slawisch Litauisch.” Geschichte der Indogermanischen Sprachwissenschaft ed. by Wilhelm Streitberg, vol. III, 1–107. Berlin & Leipzig: W. de Gruyter.
Bulaxov, M(ixail) G(apeevič)
1976Vostočnoslavjanskie jazykovedy: Biobibliografičeskij slovar’ (East Slavic linguists: A biobibliographical dictionary). Minsk: Izd-vo BGU im. V. I. Lenina. [Tome I: A-Z (XVI – the end of the XlXth century) – cf. HL 3:3.385–86 (1976); Tome II: A-K – cf. HL 5:1/2.207–08 (1978), Tome III: L-Z (the end of the 19th to the 70s of the 20th century – cf.HL 5:3.355 (1978).]
Buslaev, F(edor) I(vanovič
1818–97) 1858 Istoričeskaja grammatika russkogo jazyka (Historical Grammar of Russian). Moscow: Izd. Moskovskogo Univ.
Buslaev, F(edor) I(vanovič
1818–97) 1844 O prepodavanii rodnogo jazyka (On teaching the native language). Moscow: Izd. Moskovskogo Univ.
Collinder, B(jörn)
1962Les origines du structuralisme. (= Acta Universatis Uppsaliensis; Nova series, 1.) Stockholm & Uppsala: Almqvist & Wikseil.
Cerepanov, M(ixail) V(asil’evič)
1967Kazanskaja linguističeskaja škola (The linguistic school of Kazan). (= Uč. zapiski leningradskogo pedagogočeskogo instituta im. A. I. Gercena, No. 354.) Leningrad: Izd-vo Leningrad, gos. ped.instituta.
1882–1953), ed. 1948 Dokumenty k istorii slavjanovedenija v Rossii (1850–1912) (Documents for the history of Slavistics in Russia (1850–1912)) Moscow: Akad. Nauk.
Godel, Robert
1957Les Sources manuscrites du Cours de linguistique générale de F. de Saussure. Geneva. Droz.
Greč, N(ikolai) I(vanovič
1787–1867) 1827 Praktčeskaja russkaja grammatika (Practical Russian Grammar). St. Petersburg.
Häusler, Frank
1968Das Problem Phonetik und Phonologie bei Baudouin de Courtenay und in seiner Nachfolge. Halle: Niemeyer.
Hjelmslev, Louis
(1899–1965). 1928Principes de grammaire générale. Copenhagen: F. A. Høst.
Jakob, Ljudvig Genrix (= Ludwig Heinrich
1759–1827) 1812 Načertanie vseoščeij grammatiki dlja gimnazij Rossijskoi imperii sočinennoe (Sketch of a general grammar, composed for grammar schools of the Russian Empire). St. Petersburg: Imp. Akad. Nauk.
Kacnel’son, S(olomon) D(avidovič)
1954 “Teorija sonantov F.F. Fortunatova i ee značenie v svete sovremennyx dannyx (F. F. Fortunatov’s Theory of Sonants and its importance in the light of modern data).” VJa No. 6.47–61.
Katkov, M(ixail) N(ikiforovič
1818–87) 1845 Ob elementax i formax slavjanorusskogo jazyka (On the elements and forms of the Slav-Russian language). Moscow: Izd. Moskovskogo Univ.
Klausenburger, Jurgen
1978 “Mikoɫaj Kruszewski’s Theory of Morphophology”. HL 5:1/2.109–20.
Korš, F(edor) E(vgen’evič
1843–1915) 1877 Sposoby otnositel’nogo podčinenija: Glava iz sravnitel’nogo sintaxisa (Means of relative subordination: A chapter from comparative syntax). Moscow: Izd. Moskovskogo Univ.
1749–1820) 1801 A Grammar of the Pure and Mixed Dialects, spoken in all the eastern countries. Methodologically arranged at Calcutta, according to the Brahmenian system, of the Shamscrit language. London: J. S.Kirven.
Loja, J(an) V(iljumovič
1896–1969) 1968 Istorija lingvističeskix učenij (History of Linguistic Studies). Moscow: Vysšaja škola.
Lomonosov, M(ixail) V(asil’evič
1711–65) 1755 Rossijskaja Grammatika (Russian Grammar.) (Repr. in Polnoe sobranie socinenij (Complete Collection of Works). Moscow & Leningrad: Nauka 1952.)
Meillet, Antoine
(1866–1936). 1930 [Obituary of Baudouin de Courtenay]. Revue des études slaves 10:1/2.
Meščaninov, I(van) I(vanovič
1883–1967) 1949 Kistorii otečestvennogo jazykoznanija (Towards a history of native linguistics). Moscow: Učebno-pedagogičeskoe izd-vo.
Meščerskij, N(ikita) A(leksandrovič)
ed.1971Russkoe jazykoznanie v Peter-burgskom-Leningradskom universitete (Russian Linguistics at the St. Petersburg-Leningrad University). Leningrad: Izd-vo LGU.
Obnorskij, S(ergei) P(etrovič
1888–1962), ed. 1947 A. A. Šaxmatov (1864–1920). Moscow & Leningrad: Akad. Nauk.
Ornatovskij, I(van)
(? – ?). 1811Noveijšee načertanie pravil rossijskoj grammatiki, na načalax vseoščej osnovannyx (The newest account of the rules of the Russian grammar, composed on those of a general grammar). Xarkov: Izd. Univ.
Pavskij, G(erasim) P(etrovič
1787–1863) 1841–42 Filologičeskie nabljudenija nad sostavom russkogo jazyka (Philological observations on the structure of the Russian language). St. Petersburg: Tip. Imp. Akad. Nauk.
Pokrovskij, M(ixail) M(ixajlovič
1869–1942) 1895 O važnosti sravnitel’nogo jazykoznanija dlja classičeskoj filologii (On the importance of comparative linguistics for classic philology). Moscow.
Pokrovskij, M(ixail) M(ixajlovič
1869–1942) 1896 O metodax semasiologii (On the methods in semasiology). Moscow.
Potebnja, A(leksandr) A(fanasjevič
1835–91) 1862 Mysli jazyk (Thought and Language). St. Petersburg: Tip. Ogrizko.
Potebnja, A(leksandr) A(fanasjevič
1835–91) 1872 Iz zapisokpo Russkoi grammatike (Memoirs on Russian grammar). Xarkov: Tip. Universiteta.
Radiščev, A(leksandr) N(ikolaevič
1749–1802) 1792 O čeloveke, o jego smert-nosti i bessmertii (On man, on his death and immortality). Repr. in Collected Works on Philosophy, Moscow: Gos. učebno-pedagog. izd-vo 1949.)
Rižskij, I(van) S(tepanovič
1761–1811) 1806 Vvedenie v krug slovesnosti (Introduction to the field of philology). Xarkov: Imp. Akad. Nauk.
1973 “Baudouin de Courtenay and the Theory of Distinctive Features”. BFon 14.91–99.
Smirnov, S(avvatij) V(asil’evič)
1971F. I. Buslaev i russkoe jazykoznanie pervoj poloviny XIX v. (F. I. Buslaev and Russian linguistics of the first half of the 19th century). (= Uč. zapiski Tartusskogo universiteta, vypusk 279.) Tartu: Izd. univ.
Sommerfelt, A(lf)
(1892–1965). 1961 “The French School of Linguistics”. Trends in European and American Linguistics ed. by Christine Mohrmannet al., 283–93. Utrecht & Antwerp: Spectrum.
Sreznevskij, I(smail) I(vanovič
1812–80) 1850 Mysli ob istorü russkogo jazyka (Thoughts on the history of the Russian language). St. Petersburg.
Stieber, Z.
1955 “Teorija fonem Boduena de Kurtene v sovremennom jazy-koznanii (Baudouin de Courtenay’s theory of phonemes in modern linguistics).” VJa 4:89–93.
Šaxmatov, A(leksei) A(lexandrovič
1864–1920) 1925 Syntaksis russkogo jazyka (Syntax of Russian). Moscow: Akad. Nauk.
Šercl, V(ikentij) I(vanovič
1843–1906) 1884 O slovax s protivopoložnym značeniem (On words with opposite meaning). Voronež.
Schuchardt, H(ugo
1842–1927) 1925 “Der Individualismus in der Sprachforschung”. Akad. d. Wissenschaften in Wien; Philosophisch-historische Klasse, Sitzungberichte 204. Bd.2. Abhandl. 1.1–24.
Ščerba, L(ev) V(ladimirovič
1880–1944) 1963 “F. F. Fortunatov v istorii nauki o jazyke”. VJa 12:5.89–93. [Transl, by T. M. S. Priestly, “F. F. Fortunatovin the History of the Science of Language”, HL 3:1.129–39 (1976).]
Ščerba, L(ev) V(ladimirovič
1880–1944) 1930 “I A. Boduèn de Kurtenè i ego značenie v nauke o jazyke (J. I. Baudouin de Courtenay and his importance in the science of language)”. (Published in L. V. Scerba, Izbrannye trudy po russkomu jazyku, Moscow: Prosveščenie 1957.)
Timkovskij, I(l’ja) F(edorovič
1772–1853) 1811 Opytnij sposob k filosofi-českomu poznaniju russkogo jazyka (An experimental way to the philosophical study of Russian). St. Petersburg.
Vinogradov, V(iktor) V(ladimirovič
1895–1969) 1975 Izbrannye trudy: Issledovanija po russkoi grammatike (Collected works: Studies in Russian grammar). Moscow: Nauka.
Vinogradov, V(iktor) V(ladimirovič
1895–1969) 1958 Iz istorii izučenija russkogo sintaksisa (ot Lomonosova do Potebni i Fortunatova) (From the History of the Study of Russian Syntax. From Lomonosov to Potebnja and Fortunatov). Moscow: Izd. Moskovskogo Univ.
Vinogradov, V(iktor) V(ladimirovič
1895–1969) ed. 1963 Pis’ma I. V. Jagiča k russkim učenym (1865–1886) (V. Jagič’s letters to Russian scientists (1865–1886)). Moscow & Leningrad: Akad. Nauk.
Vostokov, A(leksandr) X(ristoforovič
1781–1864) 1820 Rassuždenie o slav-janskom jazyke, služaščee vvedeniem k grammatike sego jazyka, sostavljaemoj po drevnejšim onogo pis’mennym pamjatnikam (Discourse on the Slavic language, serving as an introduction to the grammar of this language composed according to the oldest written monuments of the same). St. Petersburg: Trudy obščestva ljub’it’el’ei rossijskoi slovesnosti.
Zeleneckij, K(onstantin) P(etrovič
1812–58) 1841 Sistema u soderžanie philo-sofskogo jazykočenija primenitel’no k russkomu jazyku (System and contents of philosophical linguistics with special reference to Russian). St. Petersburg: Tip. Rossijskoi Akademii.
Zinder, L(ev) R(afailovtč)
1960 “Kistorii fonetiki v Rossii (Towards a history of phonetics in Russia). Voprosy fonetiki 2. (= Uč. zapiski Leningradskogo universiteta, No. 237, serija fil. nauk, vypusk 40), 5–25. Leningrad: Izd. Leningradskogo Univ.