Responses to English compliments on language ability: A cross‑generational study of Saudi Arabian university female students and lecturers
Randa Saleh MaineAlharbi,PatStrauss and LynnGrant
1Ministry of Education, Saudi Arabia | 2Auckland University of Technology |
Retired
Abstract
Employing a cross-generational perspective, this study attempts to deepen our understanding of the politeness
strategies Saudi females use when responding to compliments in English from an English speaker. The study investigated how Saudi
females from two generations respond to compliments in an educational setting in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (KSA). Participants
included sixty-two female undergraduate students and sixty-four female lecturers from one university in the KSA. Following a mixed
methods approach, the study included two primary sources of data: a quantitative Discourse Completion Task questionnaire for
eliciting compliment responses (CRs) from the two generations; and qualitative semi-structured interviews with six participants
from each group. Findings indicate that participants from both groups tended to accept compliments although there was a tendency
to question the sincerity of the compliments.
Compliments constitute a vital aspect of humans’ everyday communication, and are therefore an important social phenomenon in
every society and culture. In simple terms, a compliment refers to a speech act which either implicitly or explicitly
attributes credit to the person addressed for some good, such as a possession, characteristic or skill that is positively viewed by
the speaker (Holmes 1988, 445–465). The primary function of compliments remains both
establishing and maintaining solidarity between interlocutors (J. Chen and Boonkongsaen
2012; Herbert 1990, 201; Manes and Wolfson
1981, 116–132). The giving and receiving of compliments is, however, affected by sociocultural factors such as age, gender,
status, etc. (Herbert 1990, 224). In addition, all languages are characterised by a unique
set of patterned and routine expressions used by speakers to perform different types of speech act, such as compliments (Ziaei 2013, 23). As is visible from the various types of compliment responses (CRs) explored
by a number of theorists and researchers, both compliments and the responses they receive, determine the success of communication
between two or more interlocutors; compliments and their responses therefore play a vital role in communication. A number of studies
have explored the use of compliments and compliment responses in terms of their linguistic format, compliment topic, and the factors
that play a role in producing and receiving compliments. Specifically, over the last three decades, a large and growing body of
research (Al Falasi 2007, 28–42; Al-Khateeb
2009, 23–45; Al-Rousan and Awal 2016, 16; Donaldson 1938, 563; He 2012, 29–51; Othman
2011, 86–103; Salameh 2001, 88–112; Yousefvand 2010, 91–112) has focused on compliments and compliment responses and their pragmatic significance in
intra-cultural settings.
References
Al-Khateeb, Sana’Mohammed
Ibrahim
2009 “The Speech Act of
Thanking as a Compliment Response as Used by the Arab Speakers of English: A Comparative Intercultural
Study.” Unpublished Masters Thesis, An Najah National
University.
Al-Rousan, Mohammad
Yahya, and Nosimah
Mat Awal
2016 “Compliment
Responses among Male and Female Jordanian University Students.” GEMA Online Journal of Language
Studies 16 (1).
Al-Shahri, Mohammad
Zahri
2002 “Culturally Sensitive Caring
for Saudi Patients.” Journal of Transcultural
Nursing 13 (2): 133–138.
Al-Seghayer, Khalid
2014 “The
Four Most Common Constraints Affecting English Teaching in Saudi Arabia.” International Journal
of English
Linguistics 4 (5): 17–26.
Al
Dameg, KA
2011 “The
Suitable Age for Learning Foreign Languages in Public Education.” Damascus University
Journal 27 (1–2): 753–811.
Al
Falasi, Hessa
2007 “Just
Say Thank You: A Study of Compliment Responses.” The Linguistics
Journal 2 (1): 28–42.
Alqarni, Saad
2017 “A
Sociolinguistic Investigation of Compliments and Compliment Responses among Young
Saudis.” Unpublished Masters Thesis, Western Sydney
University.
Alrashidi, Oqab, and Huy Phan
2015 “Education
Context and English Teaching and Learning in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia: An Overview.” English
Language
Teaching 8 (5): 33–44.
Alsalem, Nuha
Khalid
2015 “Compliment Responses: A
Comparison of Saudi English Learners and Native Speakers of American English in an Academic
Environment.” Unpublished Masters Thesis, Southern Illinois
University at Carbondale.
Badry, Fatima, and John Willoughby
2016Higher
Education Revolutions in the Gulf: Globalization and Institutional Viability. Taylor &
Francis.
Barnawi, Osman
Z.
2016 “The Effect of Negotiating
Pedagogies in Saudi College EFL Writing Classrooms.” Language and
Literacy 18 (1): 1–22.
Barnawi, Osman
Z., and Sajjadullah Al-Hawsawi
2017 “English
Education Policy in Saudi Arabia: English Language Education Policy in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia: Current Trends, Issues and
Challenges.” In English Language Education Policy in the Middle East
and North Africa, ed. by Robert Kirkpatrick, 199–222. Springer.
Bowen, Wayne
H.
2014The History of Saudi
Arabia. Westport,
CT: Greenwood.
Braun, Virginia, and Victoria Clarke
2006 “Using
Thematic Analysis in Psychology.” Qualitative Research in
Psychology 3 (2): 77–101.
Brinkmann, Svend, and Steinar Kvale
2015 “Conducting
an Interview.” In Interviews: Learning the Craft of Qualitative
Research
Interviewing. London: Sage.
Brown, Penelope, and Stephen
C. Levinson
1978 “Universals
in Language Usage: Politeness Phenomena.” In Questions and
Politeness: Strategies in Social Interaction, ed. by Esther
N. Goody, 56–311. Cambridge,
UK: Cambridge University Press.
Charmaz, Kathy
2011 “Grounded
Theory Methods in Social Justice Research.” In The Sage Handbook of
Qualitative Research, ed. by Norman
K. Denzin, and Yvonna
S. Lincoln, 359–380. Thousand
Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
Chen, Jun, and Nathaya Boonkongsaen
2012 “Compliment
Response Strategies by Thai and Chinese EFL Teachers: A Contrastive Study.” Theory &
Practice in Language
Studies 2 (9): 1860–1867.
Chen, Rong, and Dafu Yang
2010 “Responding
to Compliments in Chinese: Has It Changed?” Journal of
Pragmatics 42 (7): 1951–1963.
Couper, Mick
P.
2000 “Web Surveys: A Review of Issues
and Approaches.” The Public Opinion
Quarterly 64 (4): 464–494.
2015 “A Critical Examination
of the Significance of Arabic in Realizing an Arab Identity: The Perspectives of Arab Youth at an English Medium University in
the United Arab Emirates.” Unpublished PhD thesis, University
of Exeter.
Donaldson, B. A.
1938The
Wild Rue: A Study of Muhammadan Magic and Folklore in Iran. Luzac &
Company.
Dörnyei, Z.
2007Research
Methods in Applied Linguistics: Quantitative, Qualitative, and Mixed Methodologies. Oxford,
UK: Oxford University Press.
Enssaif, Z.
2005 “Compliment
Behavior: Strategies and Realizations in English and Arabic: A Case Study of Female Students of the English Department, King
Saud University.” Unpublished Masters Thesis, King Saud
University.
Farghal, Mohammed, and Ahmed
1997 “Pragmareligious
Failure in Translating Arabic Politeness Formulas into English: Evidence from Mahfouz’s Awlad
Haritna.” Multilingua – Journal of Cross-Cultural and Interlanguage
Communication 16 (1): 77–100.
Gibbs, Raymond
W.
2000 “Irony in Talk among
Friends.” Metaphor and
Symbol 15 (1–2): 5–27.
Goffman, Erving
1955 “On
Face-work: An Analysis of Ritual Elements in Social
Interaction.” Psychiatry 18 (3): 213–231.
Golato, Andrea
2005Compliments
and Compliment Responses: Grammatical Structure and Sequential Organization. Urbana-Champaign,
Ill: John Benjamins Publishing.
He, Yun
2012 “Different
Generations, Different Face? A Discursive Approach to Naturally Occurring Compliment Responses in
Chinese.” Journal of Politeness
Research 8 (1): 29–51.
Herbert, Robert
K.
1990 “Sex-Based Differences in
Compliment Behavior.” Language in
Society 19 (2): 201–224.
Holmes, Janet
1986 “Compliments
and Compliment Responses in New Zealand English.” Anthropological
Linguistics 28 (4): 485–508.
Homes, Janet
1988 “Paying
Compliments: A Sex-Preferential Politeness Strategy.” Journal of
Pragmatics 12 (4): 445–465.
Holmes, Janet
1993 “New
Zealand Women Are Good to Talk to: An Analysis of Politeness Strategies in
Interaction.” Journal of
Pragmatics 20 (2): 91–116.
Ide, Risako
1998 “ ‘Sorry
for Your Kindness’: Japanese Interactional Ritual in Public Discourse.” Journal of
Pragmatics 29 (5): 509–529.
Jorgensen, Julia
1996 “The
Functions of Sarcastic Irony in Speech.” Journal of
Pragmatics 26 (5): 613–634.
Karimnia, Amin, and Akbar Afghari
2010 “On
the Applicability of Cultural Scripts in Teaching L2 Compliments.” English Language
Teaching 3 (3): 71–80.
Kaspar, Gabriele, and Kenneth Rose
2001 “Pragmatics
in Language Teaching”. In Pragmatics in Language
Teaching, ed. by Kenneth Rose, and Gabriele Kaspar, 1–10. Cambridge,
UK: Cambridge University Press.
Kia, Elnaz, and Mohammad Salehi
2013 “The
Effect of Explicit and Implicit Instruction of English Thanking and Complimenting Formulas on Developing Pragmatic Competence
of Iranian EFL Upper-Intermediate Level Learners.” Journal of Basic and Applied Scientific
Research 3 (8): 202–215.
Kirkpatrick, Robert, and Osman
Z. Barnawi
2017 “Introduction:
English Language Education Policy in MENA.” In English Language
Education Policy in the Middle East and North Africa, ed. by Robert Kirkpatrick, 1–8. Springer.
Knapp, Mark
L., Robert Hopper, and Robert
A. Bell
1984 “Compliments:
A Descriptive Taxonomy.” Journal of
Communication 34 (4); 12–31.
Kraus, Markus
2017 “Comparing
Generation X and Generation Y on Their Preferred Emotional Leadership Style.” Journal of
Applied Leadership and
Management 5: 62–75.
Mahboob, Ahmar, and Tariq Elyas
2014 “English
in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia.” World
Englishes 33 (1): 128–142.
Maíz-Arévalo, Carmen
2012 ““Was
That a Compliment?” Implicit Compliments in English and Spanish.” Journal of
Pragmatics 44 (8): 980–996.
Manes, Joan, and Nessa Wolfson
1981 “The
Compliment Formula.” In Conversational
Routine, ed. by Florian Coulmas, 116–132. The
Hague: Mouton Publishers.
Mao, LuMing
Robert
1994 “Beyond Politeness Theory:
‘Face’ Revisited and Renewed.” Journal of
Pragmatics 21 (5): 451–486.
Matsumoto, Yoshiko
1988 “Reexamination
of the Universality of Face: Politeness Phenomena in Japanese.” Journal of
Pragmatics 12 (4): 403–426.
Migdadi, Fathi, Muhammad
A. Badarneh, and Kawakib Momani
2010 “Divine
Will and Its Extensions: Communicative Functions of Maašaallah in Colloquial Jordanian
Arabic.” Communication
Monographs 77 (4): 480–499.
Moghaddam, Mostafa
Morady
2017 “Politeness at the
Extremes: Iranian Women’s Insincere Responses to Compliments.” Language and
Dialogue 7 (3): 413–431.
Moghaddam, Mostafa
Morady
2019 “Appraising and
Reappraising of Compliments and the Provision of Responses: Automatic and Non-Automatic
Reactions.” Pragmatics 29 (3): 410–435.
Mostafa, Mariam
2009 “A
Study of Compliment Responses Among Male and Female Egyptian Undergraduate
Students.” Unpublished Masters Thesis, The American
Univeristy in Cairo.
Mursy, Ahmad
Aly, and John Wilson
2006 “Towards
a Definition of Egyptian Complimenting”. Multilingua Journal of Cross-Cultural and
Interlanguage
Communication 20 (2): 133–154.
Othman, Normala
2011 “Pragmatic
and Cultural Considerations of Compliment Responses Among Malaysian-Malay Speakers.” Asiatic:
IIUM Journal of English Language and
Literature 5 (1): 86–103.
Paltridge, Brian
2021Discourse
Analysis: An Introduction. Bloomsbury Publishing.
Pomerantz, Anita
1978 “Compliment
Responses: Notes on the Co-operation of Multiple
Constraints.” In Studies in the Organization of Conversational
Interaction, ed. by Jim Schenkein, 79–112. Elsevier.
Rees-Miller, Janie
2011 “Compliments
Revisited: Contemporary Compliments and Gender.” Journal of
Pragmatics 43 (11): 2673–2688.
Riessman, Catherine
Kohler
2008Narrative Methods for the Human
Sciences. Sage.
Salameh, Abdallah
2001 “Compliment
Responses in American English, Saudi Arabic and the English of Saudi EFL
learners.” Unpublished DEd thesis, University of
Leicester.
Sharifian, Farzad
2005 “The
Persian Cultural Schema of Shekasteh-Nafsi: A Study of Compliment Responses in Persian and Anglo-Australian
Speakers.” Pragmatics &
Cognition 13 (2): 337–361.
Tawalbeh, Ayman, and Emran Al-Oqaily
2012 “In-Directness
and Politeness in American English and Saudi Arabic Requests: A Cross-Cultural
Comparison.” Asian Social
Science 8 (10): 85–97.
Tripp, Harvey, and Peter North
2003Culture
Shock!: Saudi Arabia. Graphic Arts Center Publishing
Company.
Woodland, Jennifer, and Daniel Voyer
2011 “Context
and Intonation in the Perception of Sarcasm.” Metaphor and
Symbol 26 (3): 227–239.
Yousefvand, Zohreh
2010 “Study
of Compliment Speech Act Realization Patterns Across Gender in Persian.” Journal of Second
Language Acquisition and
Teaching 17: 91–112.
Yu, Kyong-Ae
2011 “Culture-Specific
Concepts of Politeness: Indirectness and Politeness in English, Hebrew and Korean
Requests.” Intercultural
Pragmatics 8 (3): 385–409.
Yuan, Yi
2001 “An
Inquiry into Empirical Pragmatics Data-Gathering Methods: Written DCTs, Oral DCTs, Field Notes, and Natural
Conversations.” Journal of
Pragmatics 33 (2): 271–292.
Ziaei, Narjes
2013 “Translation
on the Basis of Frequency: Compliment and Compliment Response.” Translation
Journal 16 (3): 4.