Ch. 4 | Exercise 5

Chapter 4
The Internal Structure of Words and Processes of Word Formation in English

Exercise 4.5
Writing Morphemic Rules

1.

Examine the following past tense forms in English:

hated

pulled

roared

walked

raided

opened

hugged

pushed

faded

groomed

robbed

missed

fitted

mowed

bruised

hoped

mated

cried

loved

fetched

loaded

paid

judged

laughed

a.

Determine the allomorphs of this inflectional suffix.

b.

Determine the conditioning environments for each of the allomorphs.

c.

Decide on the underlying (or “elsewhere”) form of this morpheme from which the other allomorphs are derived. For what reasons did you choose this particular form as the base?

d.

Write a morphemic rule.

e.

Consider the following past tense forms. How are they conditioned? How are they realized?

sang bought cut went
rang fought put were
f.

How do you account for the following variants: learned/learnt, dreamed/dreamt, burned/burnt?

2.

Consider the following words:

illegal

ineligible

inactive

imbalance

irrelevant

intolerant

indeterminate

immature

impossible

insecure

illogical

irregular

immoral

infamous

imbalance

injudicious

impatient

injury

ingrate

incongruous

a.

Determine the allomorphs of this derivational prefix.

b.

Determine the conditioning factors for each of the allomorphs.

c.

Decide on the underlying (or “elsewhere”) form of this morpheme from which the other allomorphs are derived. Justify the base form.

d.

Write a morphemic rule.

e.

State the meaning of the morpheme.

f.

Why are the forms ignoble and ignominious, which presumably contain the same prefix, a problem? Try to account for this problem. (Hint: Look up the etymologies of these words.)

3.

Consider the following words:

collect

cohabit

collide

correct

coalesce

corrode

connect

collate

confess

commute

commend

cohere

combat

contend

coexist

compute

consent

coincide

compare

condemn

a.

Determine the allomorphs of this derivational prefix.

b.

Write a morphemic rule, specifying the underlying form, allomorphs, and conditioning environments.

c.

State the meaning of the morpheme, if possible.

4.

Consider the following pairs of words:

sign

signature

design

designation

resign

resignation

a.

What is the root allomorphy exhibited by all of the forms?

b.

Write a morphemic rule for the first set of words.

1.
a.

The allomorphs of the past tense all have the orthographic form -ed, but phonologically they are [əd], [d], and [t].

b.

The [əd] allomorph follows roots ending in [t] or [d]; the [t] allomorph follows roots ending in voiceless obstruents, and the [d] allomorph follows roots ending in voiced stops and fricatives, liquids, nasals, and vowels.

c.

The underlying or “elsewhere” form is likely to be [d] since it is found after the greatest variety of sounds. In addition, it is easy to derive the other allomorphs from it by natural phonological processed: schwa insertion to break up a cluster of two alveolar stops will yield [əd], and voice assimilation will yield [t].

d.
{past} → [əd] / after alveolar stops
[t] / after voiceless consonants
[d] / elsewhere

Note that the rule is read downward. Thus, since [t] and [d] occur in the first line, they are not included among the voiceless consonants in the second line or other sounds in the third line.

e.

These forms are all grammatically rather than phonologically conditioned. Some are realized by a vowel change (sing/sang), some by a vowel change plus an inflectional ending (bring/brought), some by a zero morph (cut/cut), and some by a different form entirely (go/went).

f.

These forms are in free variation.

2.
a.

The allomorphs appear to be il-, ir-, im-, and in-. Note, however, that il- and ir- are both pronounced [ɪ], im- is pronounced [ɪm], in- is pronounced [ɪn] (in intolerant, insecure, infamous, etc.) but [ɪŋ] in ingrate and incongruous.

b.

The [ɪ] allomorph is conditioned by a following liquid (as initial sound of the root), the [ɪm] allomorph by a following bilabial, the [ɪŋ] by a following velar stop, and [ɪn] by a following vowel, or labiodental, alveolar, or alveopalatal consonants.

c.

[ɪn] appears to be the underlying form since it is found in the greatest variety of environments and is the form from which the other forms can be derived most easily: [ɪm] and [ɪŋ] by assimilation in place of articulation to the place of the following sound (with no change in manner of articulation), and [ɪ] by loss of the nasal.

d.
{IN} → [ɪ] / before liquids
[ɪm] / before labials
[ɪŋ] / before velars
[ɪn] / elsewhere
e.

The meaning is ‘not’.

f.

The word ignoble comes from Latin gnōbilis ‘noble’ (which later lost its initial consonant to give nōbilis, hence noble). When in- was combined with gnobilis, the first n dropped out, giving English ignoble. The g is thus part of the root, not part of the prefix. The word ignominious comes from Latin nōmen ‘name’; it acquired a g by mistaken analogy with gnōsco, a process called “contamination”.

3.
a.

Again, the orthography is a bit misleading. The allomorphs seem to be col-, cor-, con-, co-, and com-. However, the phonological forms are actually [kə], [kən], [koʊ], and [kəm] since the [l] in col-, the [r] in cor-, the [n] in con- before the alveolar nasal, and the [m] in com- before the bilabial nasal is actually part of the root.

b.
{CON} → [kə]/ before liquids and nasals
[kən]/ before dentals (alveolars and labiodentals)
[kəm]/ before bilabial stops
[koʊ]/ before vowels and [h]

It is rather difficult to know which is the “elsewhere” form in this case. Historically, the com- [kom] form is original. If it is considered the underlying form, the [kən] form is derived by assimilation in place of articulation to the following stop with vowel reduction, the [kə] form by reduction of the vowel and loss of the [m] before liquids and nasals, and the [koʊ] form by loss of the [m] and vowel shift.

c.

The meaning is either associative ‘with, together’ as in compare, cohabit, coexist, collect, etc., or intensive ‘completely’, as in correct, contend, corrode, etc.

4.
a.

In all of the words, the final syllable in the unsuffixed form is [aɪn] and the same syllable in the suffixed form is [ɪgn].

b.
{SIGN} → [sɪgn] / -derivational suffix
[saɪn] / elsewhere