Images of Cortés in sixteenth-century translations of Francisco López de Gómara’s Historia de la conquista de México (1552)

Victoria Ríos Castaño

Abstract

This study provides an overview of five sixteenth-century translations of Francisco López de Gómara’s Historia de la conquista de México (1552), namely, Agostino di Cravaliz’s and Lucio Mauro’s into Italian, Thomas Nicholls’s into English, and Martin Fumée’s and Guillaume Le Breton’s into French. The article is organized into two main sections. The first one casts some light upon the socio-historical context in which the translations were written by analysing several paratexts (e.g., acknowledgements and introductions). The second section focuses on the manner in which passages regarding Cortés’s origins and death were rendered, discussing translators’ techniques, skopos, and target audiences.

Keywords:
Publication history
Table of contents

Soon after its publication, the Spanish priest Francisco López de Gómara’s (1511-ca. 1559) Historia general de las Indias (General history of the Indies) (1552) was shrouded in polemics. As encapsulated by its subtitle – “con todo el descubrimiento y cosas notables que han acaecido desde que se ganaron hasta el año de 1551” (covering the discovery and notable events occurring since [the Indies] were won until the year of 1551) – López de Gómara aspired to furnish a comprehensive story of New World “discoveries” and conquests by the Spaniards. Its second part, Historia de la conquista de México (History of the conquest of Mexico), was specifically concerned with Hernán Cortés’s military campaigns against the Aztec Empire. A year after its publication, and despite the novelty of its contents, the highest colonial administration within the Spanish Empire (the Council of the Indies) banned it. López de Gómara apparently met with discontent from a circle of officials, historians, and conquistadores alike. Firstly, he failed to dedicate the history of the conquest of Mexico to Emperor Charles V or to the future emperor, his son Philip II. Instead, the honour was bestowed upon Cortés’s son, the Marquis of Valle Don Martín Cortés. Secondly, López de Gómara was accused of making factual mistakes and of elevating Hernán Cortés to the stature of an exemplary Christian hero of military acumen, exhibiting bravery in battle, the gift of speech, and a moral compass. These accolades were perceived as having been inscribed in a biased narrative (Gurría Lacroix 2007, xviii–xxiii; Roa-de-la-Carrera 2005, 3).

Full-text access is restricted to subscribers. Log in to obtain additional credentials. For subscription information see Subscription & Price. Direct PDF access to this article can be purchased through our e-platform.

References

Albertín Astilleros, Chiara
2013 “Las traducciones al italiano de las crónicas de Indias en la segunda mitad del siglo XVI.” Orillas 2: 1–18.Google Scholar
Alcibíades, Mirla
2007 “Cronología.” In Historia de la conquista de México, Francisco López de Gómara, edited by Jorge Gurría Lacroix and Mirla Alcibíades, 461–462. Caracas: Ayacucho.Google Scholar
Aracil Varón, Beatriz
2016“Yo, don Hernando Cortés”: Reflexiones en torno a la escritura cortesiana. Madrid: Iberoamericana; Frankfurt: Vervuert. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Baldwin, R. C. D.
2004 “Nicholls, Thomas (1532–1601)”. In Oxford Dictionary of National Biography. Oxford: Oxford University Press. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Carman, Glen
2006Rhetorical Conquests: Cortés, Gómara, and Renaissance Imperialism. West Lafayette, IN: Purdue University Press.Google Scholar
Castillo, Francisco Javier
1992 “The English Renaissance and the Canary Islands: Thomas Nichols and Edmund Scory.” In Actas del II Congreso de la Sociedad Española de Estudios Renacentistas Ingleses (SEDERI), 2, edited by Santiago González Fernández-Corugedo, 57–70. Oviedo: Universidad de Oviedo, Servicio de Publicaciones.Google Scholar
Cravaliz, Agostino di
1556La historia generale delle Indie Occidentali, con tutti li discoprimenti, & cose notabili, che in esse sono successe, da che si acquistorno fino a hora. Scritta per Francesco Lopez de Gomara in lingua spagnuola, & tradotta nel volgare italiano per Augustino de Craualiz. Roma: Valerio, & Luigi Dorici.Google Scholar
1576Historia di Don Ferdinando Cortes, Marchese della Valle, Capitano Valorosissimo. Con le sue maravigliose prodezze, nel tempo che discoprì, & acquistò la nuoua Spagna. Venetia: Camillo Franceschini.Google Scholar
De Schepper, Susanna L. B.
2012 “ Foreign Books for English Readers: Published Translations of Navigation Manuals and Their Audience in the English Renaissance, 1500–1640. PhD diss., University of Warwick, Centre for the Study of the Renaissance.Google Scholar
Fumée, Martin
1587Historia generalle des Indes Occidentales, et Terres neuues, qui iusques à present ont esté descouuertes, augmentee en ceste cinquiesme edition de la description de la nouuvelle Espagne, & de la grande ville de Mexique, autrement nommee, Tenuctilan. Paris: Michel Sonnius.Google Scholar
Gerbault, Matthieu
2003López de Gómara dans les controverses sur le Nouveau Monde: les traductions françaises de la Historia general de las Indias y conquista de Mexico. Édition critique et commentaire comparé. PhD diss., École Nationale de Chartres (Paris).Google Scholar
Gruzinski, Serge
2010America and Islam at the Dawn of Modern Times [orig. Quelle Heure est-il là-bas? ]. Translated by Jean Birrell. Cambridge: Polity Press.Google Scholar
Gurría Lacroix, Jorge
2007 “Prólogo.” In Historia de la conquista de México, Francisco López de Gómara, edited by Jorge Gurría Lacroix and Mirla Alcibíades, ix–xxxii. Caracas: Ayacucho.Google Scholar
Hart, Jonathan
2001Representing the New World. New York: Palgrave Macmillan. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Iglesia, Ramón
1942Cronistas e historiadores de la conquista de México. México: El Colegio de México.Google Scholar
Knutson, Roslyn L., and David McInnis
2011 “The Lost Plays Database: A Wiki for Lost Plays.” In Medieval and Renaissance Drama in England, volume 24, edited by S. P. Cerasano, 46–57. Madison, NJ: Fairleigh Dickinson University Press.Google Scholar
Le Breton, Guillaume
1588Voyages et conquestes du capitaine Ferdinand Courtois, és Indes occidentales, histoire traduite de langue espagnole. Paris: Abel L’Angelier.Google Scholar
López de Gómara, Francisco
2007Historia de la conquista de México, edited by Jorge Gurría Lacroix and Mirla Alcibíades. Caracas: Biblioteca Ayacucho.Google Scholar
Maczelka, Csaba
2017 “Exile, Translation and Authorial Self-Representation in Elizabethan Travel Literature: The Case of Thomas Nicholls.” In Displacing the Anxieties of Our World: Spaces of the Imagination, edited by Ildikó Limpár, 44–62. Newcastle: Cambridge Scholars Publishing.Google Scholar
Markey, Lia
2016Imagining the Americas in Medici Florence. University Park, PA: Pennsylvania State University Press. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Mauro, Lucio
1566La terza parte delle Historie dell‘Indie. Nella quale particolarmente si tratta dello scoprimento della provincia di Incatan detta Nuoua Spagna, & delle cose degne di memoria, fatte da Spagnuoli nella conquista della grande, & marauigliosa città di Messico, & delle altre Prouincie ad essa sottoposte. Nuovamente tradotta di lingua spagnuola, da Lucio Mauro. Venetia: Giordano Ziletti.Google Scholar
Nicholls, Thomas
1596The Pleasant Historie of the Conquest of the West India, now called new Spaine. Atchieued by the most woorthie Prince Hernando Cortes, Marques of the Valley of Huaxacac, most delectable to reade. London: Thomas Creede.Google Scholar
O’Gorman, Edmundo
1971 “Estudio analítico de los escritos históricos de Motolinía.” In Memoriales o Libro de las cosas de la Nueva España y de los naturales de ella, Fray Toribio de Motolinía, edited by Edmundo O’Gorman, xv-cxxxi. México: UNAM, Instituto de Investigaciones Históricas.Google Scholar
Roa-de-la-Carrera, Cristián
2005Histories of Infamy: Francisco López de Gómara and the Ethics of Spanish Imperialism. Boulder, CO: University Press of Colorado.Google Scholar
2010 “Francisco López de Gómara and La conquista de México .” In Chimalpahin’s Conquest: A Nahua Historian’s Rewriting of Francisco López de Gómara’s La conquista de México, edited and translated by Susan Schroeder, Anne J. Cruz, Cristián Roa-de-la-Carrera, and David E. Tavárez, 35–49. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Roa-de-la-Carrera, Cristián, Susan Schroeder, and David E. Tavárez
eds. 2011Chimalpahin y La conquista de México de Francisco López de Gómara. México: UNAM.Google Scholar
Valdeón, Roberto A.
2014Translation and the Spanish Empire in the Americas. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. CrossrefGoogle Scholar