Managing criticisms in US-based and Taiwan-based reality talent contests: A cross-linguistic comparison

Chihsia Tang


This research studied how English and Chinese speakers encode their criticisms in the media discourse, aiming to explore the correlation between the speakers’ applications of pragmalinguistic strategies and their sociocultural orientations. Criticisms analyzed in the present study were collected from evaluative communications elicited from the US-based talent competition Project Runway and the Taiwan-based talent competition Super Designer. The current analysis of the face attack act referred to Brown and Levinson’s politeness framework and face notion. The results showed different frequencies of criticizing strategies and redressive devices in the English and Chinese sub-corpora. In addition, the findings also manifested some cross-language variations in pragmalinguistic representation of the same criticizing strategy. The discrepancies were discussed from the perspective of context orientation of the American and Taiwanese societies, evidencing the strong linkage between the speakers’ communication patterns and the cultural norms of their social networks.

Quick links
A browser-friendly version of this article is not yet available. View PDF
Austin, J.L
(1962) How to Do Thingswith Words. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Bardovi-Harlig, K., and R. Griffin
(2005) L2 pragmatic awareness: Evidence from the ESL classroom. System 33: 401-415. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Blum-Kulka, S
(1990) You don’t touch lettuce with your fingers: Parental politeness in family discourse. Journal of Pragmatics 14: 259-288. Crossref  BoPGoogle Scholar
Blum-Kulka, S., J. House, and G. Kasper
(1989) Cross-Cultural Pragmatics: Requests and apologies. Norwood: Ablex.  BoPGoogle Scholar
Bond, M.H., and K.-K. Hwang
(1986) The social psychology of Chinese people. In M.H. Bond (ed.), Psychology of the Chinese People. Hong Kong: Oxford University Press, pp.213-266.Google Scholar
Brown, P., and S.C. Levinson
(1987) Politeness: Some universals in language use. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Chen, Y.-S., C.-Y.D. Chen, and M.-H. Chang
(2011) American and Chinese Complaints: Strategy use from a cross-cultural perspective. Intercultural Pragmatics 8: 253-275. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Cheng, S.-W
(2005) An exploratory cross-cultural sutdy of interlanguage pragmatic developement of expressions of gratitude by Chinese learners of English. Ph.D. dissertation, University of Iowa, Iowa.Google Scholar
de Mooij, M
(2010) Global Marketing and Advertising: Understanding Cultural Paradoxes. Los Angeles: Sage.Google Scholar
Dickson, H.W., D.N. Hartog, and J.K. Mitchelson
(2003) Research on leadership in a cross-cultural context: Making progress and raising new questions. Leadership Quarterly 14: 729-768. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Dorfman, P.W., J.P. Howell, S. Hibino, J.K. Lee, U. Tate, and A. Bautista
(1997) Leadership in Western and Asian countries: Commonalities and differences in effective leadership processes across cultures. Leadership Quarterly 8: 233-274. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Ellis, R
(1994) The Study of Second Language Acquisition. Oxford: Oxford University Press.  BoPGoogle Scholar
Gibson, J.L., J.M. Ivancevich, and J.H. Donnelly
(1973) Organizational Structure, Processes, Behavior. Dallas: Business Publications.Google Scholar
Grice, P
(1975) Logic and conversation. In P.Cole,andJ.L. Morgan(eds.),Syntax and Semantics: Speech acts. New York: Academic Press, pp. 41-58.Google Scholar
Gudykunst, W.B., and S. Ting-Toomey
(1988) Culture and Interpersonal Communication. Newbury Park: Sage.Google Scholar
Gudykunst, W.B., Y.-C. Yoon, and T. Nishida
(1987) The influence of individualism-collectivism on perceptions of ingroup and outgroup relationships. Communication Monographs 54: 295-306. Crossref  BoPGoogle Scholar
Hall, E.T
(1976) Beyond Culture. New York: Anchor Books.Google Scholar
(1983) The Dance of Life. New York: Doubleday.Google Scholar
Hall, E.T., and M.R. Hall
(1990) Understanding Cultural Differences: Germans, French and Americans. Yarmouth: Intercultural Press.Google Scholar
Hana, H.E.F
(2012) Hedges in movie dialogues in English:Theoretical and practical aspects. The Journal for Languages and Literatures of the Faculty of Philosophy in Novi Sad 2: 177-192.Google Scholar
Hiraga, M.K., and J.M. Turner
(1996) Differing perceptions of face in British and Japanese academic settings. Language Sciences 18: 605-627. Crossref  BoPGoogle Scholar
Hofstede, G.H
(1980) Culture’s Consequences: International differences in work-related values. Beverly Hills: Sage.Google Scholar
(1983) Dimensions of national cultures in fifty countries and three regions. In J.B. Deregowski, S. Dziurawiec, andR.C. Annis (eds.), Expectations in Cross-cultural Psychology. Lisse: Swets and Zeitlinger, pp. 335-355.Google Scholar
(1997) Cultures and Organizations: Software of the mind. New York: McGraw-Hill.Google Scholar
(2001) Culture’s Consequences:Comparing values, behaviors, institutions, and organizations across nations. Thousand Oaks: Sage.Google Scholar
Holmes, J
(1995) Women, Men, and Politeness. London: Longman.  BoPGoogle Scholar
House, R.J., P.J. Hanges, M. Javidan, P.W. Dorfman, and V. Gupta
(2004) Culture,Leadership,and Organizations: The GLOBE study of 62 societies.Thousand Oaks: Sage.Google Scholar
House, R.J., and T.R. Mitchell
(1974) Path-goal theory of leadership. Journal of Contemporary Business 3: 81-97.Google Scholar
Hsu, F.L.K
(1981) American and Chinese: Passage to differences. Honolulu: University Press of Hawaii.Google Scholar
Itakura, H., and A.B.M. Tsui
(2011) Evaluation in academic discourse: Managing criticism in Japanese and English book reviews. Journal of Pragmatics 43: 1366-1379. Crossref  BoPGoogle Scholar
Johnston, M.W., A. Parasuraman, C.M. Futrell, and W.C. Black
(1990) A longitudinal assessment of the impact of selected organizational influences on salespeople’s organizational commitment during early employment. Journal of Marketing Research 27: 333-344. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Kim, M.-S., and S.R. Wilson
(1994) A cross-cultural comparisons of implicit theories of requesting. Communication Monograph 61: 210-235. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Leech, G.N
(1983) Principles of Pragmatics. London: Longman.Google Scholar
Lewin, B., J. Fine, and L. Young
(2001) Expository Discourse: A genre-based approach to social research text. New York: Continuum.  BoPGoogle Scholar
Li, L
(2008)Requests and refusals in English and Chinese. Ph.D. dissertation, Leeds, University of Leeds.Google Scholar
Liang, G.-D., and J. Han
(2005) A contrastive study on disagreement strategies for politeness between American English andMandarin Chinese. Asian EFL Journal 7: 1-12.Google Scholar
Mallen, M.J., S.X. Day, and M.A. Green
(2003) Online versus face-to-face conversation: An examination of relational and discourse variables. Psychotherapy: Theory, research, practice, training 40: 155-163. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Man, L
(2006) Indirect speech act-an effecitve pragmatic strategy. Journal of Taizhou 28: 57-60.Google Scholar
Nguyen, T.T.M
(2005) Criticizing and responding to criticism in a foreign language: A study of Vietnamese learners of English. Ph.D. dissertation, Auskland, University of Auckland.Google Scholar
(2008) Modifying L2 criticisms: How learners do it? Journal of Pragmatics 40: 768-791. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Okabe, R
(1983) Cultural assumptions of East and West: Japanese and the United States. In W.B. Gudykunst (ed.), International Communication Theory. Beverly Hill: Sage, pp.21-41.Google Scholar
Onkvisit, S., and J.J. Shaw
(1993) International Marketing: Analysis and strategy. New York: Macmillian.Google Scholar
Park, H.-S., and X.-W. Guan
(2009) Cross-cultural comparison of verbal and nonverbal strategies of apologizing. Journal of International and Intercultural Communication 2: 66-87. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Pye, L.W
(1985) Asian Power and Politics: The cultural dimensions of authority. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Salager-Meyer, F., and M.Á. Alcaraz Ariza
(2004) Negative appraisals in academic book reviews: A cross-linguistic approach. In C. Candlin, and M. Gotti (eds.), Intercultural Aspects of Specialized Communication. Bern: Peter Lang, pp.149-172.Google Scholar
Sanchez-Burks, J., F. Lee, I.-C. Choi, R. Nisbett, S.-M. Zhao, and J.-S. Koo
(2003) Conversing across cultures: East-West communication styles in work and nonwork contexts. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 85: 363-372. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Searle, J
(1975) Indirect speech acts. In P. Cole, andJ.L. Morgan (eds.), Syntax and Semantics: Speech acts. New York: Academic Press, pp.59-82.  BoP. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
(1979) A taxonomy of illocutionary acts. In Z.-X. He (ed.), SelectedReadings for Pragmatics. Shanghai: Shanghai Foreign Language Education Press, pp.260-281.Google Scholar
Shih, Y.-H
(1988) Conversational Politeness and Foreign Language Teaching. Taipei: Crane Publishing.Google Scholar
Shim, T.Y.-J., M.-S. Kim, and J.N. Martin
(2008) Changing Korea: Understanding Culture and Communication. New York: Peter Lang.Google Scholar
Singh, N.K
(2012) Eastern andCross Cultural Management. India: Springer. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Smith, P.B., and M.H. Bond
(1993) Social Psychology across Cultures: Analysis and perspectives. New York: Harvester Wheatsheaf.Google Scholar
Spencer-Oatey, H
(1997) Unequal relationships in high and low power distance societies: A comparative study of tutor-student role relations in Britain and China. Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology 28: 284-302. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Triandis, H.C
(1995) Individualism andCollectivism. Boulder: Westview Press.Google Scholar
Teas, K.R
(1981) An empirical test of models of salespersons’ job expectancy and instrumentality perceptions. Journal of Marketing Research 18: 209-226. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
(1983) Supervisory behavior, role stress, and the job satisfaction of industrial salespeople. Journal of Marketing Research 20: 84-91. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Wang, Y
(2010) An analysis of similarities and differences of criticism and compliments between Chinese and English in the perspective of Face-saving Theory. Journal of Chongqing College of Education 23: 109-112.Google Scholar
Wetzel, P.J
(1993) The language of vertical relationships and linguistic analysis. Multilingua 12: 387-406. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Wu, S.-Q
(2003) Cross-cultural comparison of vocative in Chinese and English criticism speech act. Journal of Hubei Three Gorges University 6: 82-84.Google Scholar
Wu, S.-Q., and W.-W. Fan
(2004) A comparison of the strategies of English and Chinese criticism speech act. Foreign Language Education 25: 22-25.Google Scholar
Yu, M.-C
(2003) On the universality of face: Evidence from Chinese compliment response behavior. Journal of Pragmatics 35: 1679-1710. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
(2005) Sociolinguistic competence in the complimenting act of native Chinese and American English speaker. Language and Speech 48: 91-119. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Yuan, Y
(2001) An inquiry into empirical pragmatics data-gathering methods: Written DCTs, oral DCTs, field notes, and naturalconversations. Journal of Pragmatics 33: 271-292. Crossref  BoPGoogle Scholar
Yum, J.-O
(1988) The impact of Confucianism on interpersonal relationship and communication patterns in East Asia. Communication Monographs 55: 374-388. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Zhu, X.-Y
(2007) Social factors that affect options of pragmatic strategies in Chinese criticism. Journal of Guangzhou University 6: 62-65.Google Scholar
Zhu, X.-Y., and J. Zhou
(2004) A comparative study of the speech act of criticism by Chinese and foreigners. Journal of South China Normal University 3: 80-84.Google Scholar