Article In: Journal of Immersion and Content-Based Language Education: Online-First Articles
Does CLIL make a difference?
Comparing out-of-class Willingness to Communicate in English as a foreign language among CLIL and non-CLIL secondary students in Andalusia
This content is being prepared for publication; it may be subject to changes.
Abstract
Despite extensive research on Willingness to Communicate (WTC), gaps remain regarding secondary EFL learners, comparisons
between CLIL and mainstream non-CLIL programmes, and context-specific predictors. This study addresses these gaps by examining out-of-class
WTC among 1,108 secondary students in Andalusia (southern Spain), comparing CLIL and non-CLIL groups and investigating its associations with
sociodemographic, personality, linguistic, affective, and intercultural factors. Participants were drawn from eleven schools across five
Andalusian provinces, representing both lower and upper secondary levels. CLIL students reported significantly higher WTC than their
non-CLIL peers, although the effect size was small. Given the cross-sectional design, this difference cannot be attributed to CLIL
instruction itself. The same principal predictors emerged in both groups, while their relative contributions showed different descriptive
patterns. The study offers pedagogical implications and directions for future research.
Article outline
- 1.Introduction
- 2.Literature review
- 2.1Willingness to Communicate: Concept and measurement
- 2.2Willingness to Communicate in bilingual vs. non-bilingual contexts
- 2.3Factors affecting WTC
- 3.Method
- 3.1Participants and context
- 3.2Instruments
- 3.3Data analysis
- 4.Results
- 4.1Descriptive statistics and group comparisons of Out-of-Class WTC (RQ1 and RQ2)
- 4.2Predictors of Out-of-Class WTC (RQ3)
- 5.Discussion
- 5.1Out-of-Class WTC: Levels and group differences (RQ1 and RQ2)
- 5.2Predictors of out-of-class WTC (RQ3)
- 5.2.1Intercultural sensitivity and perceived competence
- 5.2.2Affective variables: Anxiety and enjoyment
- 5.2.3Sociodemographic and personality factors
- 5.3Limitations and future directions
- 5.4Pedagogical implications
- 6.Conclusion
- Acknowledgements
- Note
References
References (103)
Amiryousefi, M. (2018). Willingness
to communicate, interest, motives to communicate with the instructor, and L2 speaking: a focus on the role of age and
gender. Innovation in Language Learning and
Teaching, 12(3), 221–234.
Anderson, R. W. (2022). Garfield,
SLA gold medalist: Examining the investments of an exceptional US language learner/hyperpolyglot. Foreign
Language
Annals, 55(4), 1043–1062.
Baker, S. C., & MacIntyre, P. D. (2003). The
role of gender and immersion in communication and second language orientations. Language
Learning, 50(2), 311–34.
Bandura, A. (1986). Social
foundations of thought and action: A social cognitive
theory. Prentice-Hall.
Bartlett, M. S. (1954). A
note on the multiplying factors for various χ² approximations. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society:
Series B
(Methodological), 16(2), 296–298.
Barrios, E., & Acosta-Manzano, I. (2025). Factors predicting classroom WTC in English and French as foreign languages among adult learners in Spain. Language Teaching Research, 29(1), 88–111.
Barrios, E., & Napiórkowska, M. (2026a). Affective factors, intercultural sensitivity, and willingness to communicate orally outside class: A study with EFL secondary school learners in Poland and Spain. Language Teaching Research, 30(7), 3928–3950.
(2026b). Secondary school EFL students’ in-class willingness to communicate in CLIL-based bilingual and non-bilingual programmes in Andalusia. International Journal of Multilingualism, 23(4), 2490–2507.
Bennett, M. J. (1993). Towards
a developmental model of intercultural sensitivity. In R. M. Paige (Ed.), Education
for the intercultural
experience (pp. 21–71). Intercultural Press.
Botes, E., Dewaele, J.-M., & Greiff, S. (2021). The
development and validation of the short form of the Foreign Language Enjoyment Scale. Modern Language
Journal, 105(4), 858–876.
(2022). Taking
stock: A meta-analysis of the effects of foreign language enjoyment. Studies in Second Language Learning
and
Teaching, 12(2), 205–232.
Botes, E., van der Westhuizen, L., Dewaele, J.-M., MacIntyre, P., & Greiff, S. (2022). Validating
the short-form of the Foreign Language Classroom Anxiety Scale (S-FLCAS). Applied
Linguistics, 43(5), 1006–1033.
Cao, Y. (2011). Investigating
situational willingness to communicate within second language classrooms from an ecological
perspective. System, 39(4), 468–479.
Chen, G. M., & Starosta, W. J. (2000). The
development and validation of the intercultural communication sensitivity scale. Human
Communication, 3(1), 3–14.
Cheng, L., & Xu, J. (2022). Chinese
English as a foreign language learners’ individual differences and their willingness to
communicate. Frontiers in
Psychology, 13. Article 883664.
Chou, M.-H. (2022). Investigating
the mediating role of foreign language anxiety in students’ task goal orientations, perceived communication competence, English ability,
and willingness to communicate in EMI classrooms. English Teaching and
Learning, 46(3), 235–254.
Coyle, D., Hood, P., & Marsh, D. (2010). CLIL:
Content and language integrated learning. Cambridge University Press.
Dalton-Puffer, C. (2011). Content-and-language
integrated learning: From practice to principles? Annual Review of Applied
Linguistics, 31, 182–204.
Denman, J., van Schooten, E., & de Graaff, R. (2023). Inclusive
CLIL: Pre-vocational pupils’ target language oral proficiency, fluency, and Willingness to
Communicate. AILA
Review, 35(2), 325–350.
De Smet, A., Mettewie, L., Galand, B., Hiligsmann, P., & Van Mensel, L. (2018). Classroom
anxiety and enjoyment in CLIL and non-CLIL: Does the target language matter? Studies in Second Language
Learning and
Teaching, 8(1), 47–71.
Dewaele, J.-M. (2019). The
effect of classroom emotions, attitudes toward English, and teacher behavior on willingness to communicate among English foreign language
learners. Journal of Language and Social
Psychology, 38(4), 523–535.
Dewaele, J.-M., & Dewaele, L. (2018). Learner-internal
and learner-external predictors of willingness to communicate in the FL classroom. Journal of the European
Second Language
Association, 2, 24–37.
Dewaele, J.-M., & MacIntyre, P. D. (2014). The
two faces of Janus? Anxiety and enjoyment in the foreign language classroom. Studies in Second Language
Learning and
Teaching, 4(2), 237–274.
Dewaele, J.-M., & Pavelescu, L. M. (2021). The
relationship between incommensurable emotions and willingness to communicate in English as a foreign language: A multiple case
study. Innovation in Language Learning and
Teaching, 15(1), 66–80.
Elahi Shirvan, M., Khajavy, G. H., MacIntyre, P. D., & Taherian, T. (2019). A
meta-analysis of L2 willingness to communicate and its three high-evidence correlates. Journal of
Psycholinguistic Research, 48, 1241–1267.
Eysenck, S. B. G., Eysenck, H. J., & Barrett, P. (1985). A
revised version of the psychoticism scale. Personality and Individual
Differences, 6, 21–29.
Fallah, N., Gaskaree, B. L., & Moghaddam, S. Z. (2025). Teacher
enthusiasm and EFL learners’ willingness to communicate: The role of enjoyment and boredom. English
Teaching &
Learning, 49, 495–516.
Fathi, J., Pawlak, M., Mehraein, S., Hosseini, H. M., & Derakhshesh, A. (2023). Foreign
language enjoyment, ideal L2 self, and intercultural communicative competence as predictors of willingness to communicate among EFL
learners. System, 115, 103067.
Fatima, I., Ismail, S. A. M. M., Pathan, Z. H., & Memon, U. (2020). The
power of openness to experience, extraversion, L2 self-confidence, classroom environment in predicting L2 willingness to
communicate. International Journal of
Instruction, 13(3), 909–924.
Fernández-Barrionuevo, E., Baena-Extremera, A., & Villoria-Prieto, J. (2021). Bilingual
physical education as a way to motivate learning in a foreign language. Preliminary study based on the Trans-Contextual
Model. Retos, 42, 244–255.
Fernández-Barrionuevo, E., Villoria Prieto, J., Tomás Gonzalez-Fernandez, F., & Baena-Extremera, A. (2020). Willingness
to communicate in a foreign language in the four skills. Sex and age differences. Espiral-Cuadernos del
Profesorado, 13(27), 192–203.
Fernández Fontecha, A., & Canga Alonso, A. (2014). A
preliminary study on motivation and gender in CLIL and non-CLIL types of instruction. International Journal
of English
Studies, 14(1), 21–36.
Fu, R. (2025). Enjoyment
and Grit as mediators between informal digital learning English, basic psychology needs, and willingness to communicate among English as a
foreign language university students. Current
Psychology, 1–15.
Gardner, R. C., & Lambert, W. E. (1972). Attitudes
and motivation in second-language learning. Newbury House.
Ghasemi, A., & Zahediasl, S. (2012). Normality
tests for statistical analysis. International Journal of Endocrinology and
Metabolism, 10(2), 486–489.
Halupka-Resetar, S., Knezevic, L., & Topalov, J. (2018). Revisiting
willingness to communicate in English as a foreign language: The Serbian perspective. Journal of
Multilingual and Multicultural
Development, 39(10), 912–924.
Heras, A., & Lasagabaster, D. (2015). The
impact of CLIL on affective factors and vocabulary learning. Language Teaching
Research, 19(1), 70–88.
Horwitz, E. K., Horwitz, M. B., & Cope, J. (1986). Foreign
language classroom anxiety. The Modern Language
Journal, 70, 125–132.
International Test Commission. (2017). The ITC
guidelines for translating and adapting tests (Second edition). [URL]
Jin, S., & Lee, H. (2022). Willingness
to communicate and its high-evidence factors: A meta-analytic structural equation modeling
approach. Journal of Language and Social
Psychology, 41(6), 716–745.
Kang, S.-J. (2005). Dynamic
emergence of situational willingness to communicate in a second
language. System, 33(2), 277–292.
Khajavy, G. H., MacIntyre, P. D., & Barabadi, E. (2018). Role
of the emotions and classroom environment in willingness to communicate: Applying doubly latent multilevel analysis in second language
acquisition research. Studies in Second Language
Acquisition, 40, 605–624.
Khany, R., & Nejad, A. M. (2017). L2
willingness to communicate, openness to experience, extraversion, and L2 unwillingness to communicate: The Iranian EFL
context. RELC
Journal, 48(2), 241–255.
Lambert, W. E., & Tucker, G. R. (1972). Bilingual
education of children: The St. Lambert experiment. Newbury House.
Lasagabaster, D., & Doiz, A. (2017). A
longitudinal study on the impact of CLIL on affective factors. Applied
Linguistics, 38(5), 688–712.
Lee, J. S., & Drajati, N. A. (2019). Affective
variables and informal digital learning of English: Keys to willingness to communicate in a second
language. Australasian Journal of Educational
Technology, 35(5), 168–182.
Lee, J. S., & Hsieh, J. C. (2019). Affective
variables and willingness to communicate of EFL learners in in-class, out-of-class, and digital
contexts. System, 82, 63–73.
Lee, J. S., & Lee, K. (2020). Affective
factors, virtual intercultural experiences, and L2 willingness to communicate in in-class, out-of-class, and digital
settings. Language Teaching
Research, 24(6), 813–833.
Lee, J. S., & Taylor, T. (2024). Positive
psychology constructs and extramural English as predictors of primary school students’ willingness to
communicate. Journal of Multilingual and Multicultural
Development, 45(7), 2898–2916.
Lee, J. S., Yeung, N. M., & Osburn, M. B. (2024). Foreign
Language Enjoyment as a mediator between Informal Digital Learning of English and willingness to communicate: A sample of Hong Kong EFL
secondary students. Journal of Multilingual and Multicultural
Development, 45(9), 3613–3631.
Li, C., Dewaele, J.-M., Pawlak, M., & Kruk, M. (2025). Classroom
environment and willingness to communicate in English: The mediating role of emotions experienced by university students in
China. Language Teaching
Research, 29(5), 2140–2160.
Lialikhova, D. (2018). Triggers
and constraints of lower secondary students’ willingness to communicate orally in English in a CLIL setting in the Norwegian
context. Journal of Immersion and Content-Based Language
Education, 6(1), 27–56.
Liu, M. (2017). Adult
Chinese as a second language learners’ willingness to communicate in Chinese: Effects of cultural, affective, and linguistic variables,
Psychological
Reports, 120(3), 423–442.
Lorenzo, F., Granados, A., & Rico, N. (2021). Equity
in bilingual education: Socioeconomic status and content and language integrated learning in monolingual Southern
Europe. Applied
Linguistics, 42(3), 393–413.
Lumley, T., Diehr, P., Emerson, S., & Chen, L. (2002). The
importance of the normality assumption in large public health data sets. Annual Review of Public
Health, 23(1), 151–169.
Lynn, M. R. (1986). Determination
and quantification of content validity. Nursing
Research, 35, 382–385.
MacIntyre, P. D. (1992). Anxiety
and language learning from a stages of processing perspective. Unpublished Doctoral
Dissertation, University of Western Ontario, Canada. Available at: [URL] (accessed May 11, 2025)
(2007). Willingness
to communicate in the second language: Understanding the decision to speak as a volitional process. The
Modern Language
Journal, 91(4), 564–576.
(2020). Expanding
the theoretical base for the dynamics of willingness to communicate. Studies in Second Language Learning
and
Teaching, 10(1), 111–131.
MacIntyre, P. D., Baker, S. C., Clément, R., & Conrod, S. (2001). Willingness
to communicate, social support, and language-learning orientations of immersion students. Studies in Second
Language
Acquisition, 23(3), 369–388.
MacIntyre, P. D., Baker, S. C., Clément, R., & Donovan, L. A. (2002). Sex
and age effects on willingness to communicate, anxiety, perceived competence, and L2 motivation among junior high school French immersion
students. Language
Learning, 52(3), 537–564.
MacIntyre, P. D., Dörnyei, Z., Clément, R., & Noels, K. A. (1998). Conceptualizing
willingness to communicate in a L2: A situational model of L2 confidence and affiliation. Modern Language
Journal, 82, 545–562.
MacIntyre, P. D., & Legatto, J. J. (2011). A
dynamic system approach to willingness to communicate: Developing an idiodynamic method to capture rapidly changing
affect. Applied
Linguistics, 32(2), 149–171.
Mady, C. (2015). Immigrants
outperform Canadian-born groups in French immersion: examining factors that influence their
achievement. International Journal of
Multilingualism, 12(3), 298–311.
Menezes, E., & Juan-Garau, M. (2015). English
learners’ willingness to communicate and achievement in CLIL and formal instruction
contexts. In M. Juan-Garau & J. Salazar-Noguera (Eds.), Content-based
language learning in multilingual educational
environments (pp. 221–236). Springer.
Mizumoto, A. (2015). Langtest (Version
1.0) [Web application]. [URL]
(2023). Calculating
the relative importance of multiple regression predictor variables using dominance analysis and random
forests. Language
Learning, 73, 161–196.
Mulyono, H., & Saskia, R. (2021). Affective
variables contributing to Indonesian EFL students’ willingness to communicate within face-to-face and digital
environments. Cogent
Education, 8(1), 1911282.
Napiórkowska, M., & Barrios, E. (2024). Classroom willingness to communicate among EFL secondary school students in Poland and Spain. Porta Linguarum, 42, 179–196.
Normann, A. (2021). Secondary
school students’ perceptions of language-learning experiences from participation in short Erasmus+ mobilities with non-native speakers of
English. Language Learning
Journal, 49(6), 753–764.
Osborne, J. W., & Waters, E. (2002). Four
assumptions of multiple regression. Practical Assessment, Research &
Evaluation, 8(2), Article
2.
Oz, H. (2014). Big
Five personality traits and willingness to communicate among foreign language learners in Turkey. Social
Behavior and
Personality, 42(9), 1473–1482.
Pawlak, M., & Mystkowska-Wiertelak, A. (2015). Investigating
the dynamic nature of L2 willingness to
communicate. System, 50, 1–9.
Peng, J. E. (2019). The
roles of multimodal pedagogic effects and classroom environment in willingness to communicate in
English. System, 82, 161–173.
Peng, J. E., & MacIntyre, P. D. (2025). Directional
or reciprocal? A random intercept cross-lagged panel analysis of the relationships between emotions, motivation, willingness to
communicate, and L2 achievement. Learning and Individual
Differences, 118, 102638.
Peng, J. E., & Woodrow, L. (2010). Willingness
to communicate in English: A model in the Chinese EFL classroom context. Language
Learning, 60(4), 834–876.
Pihko, M. K. (2007). Foreign
language anxiety in content and language integrated learning (CLIL) and in traditional foreign language
classes. In S. Tella (Ed.), From
brawn to brain: Strong signals in foreign language
education (pp. 129–142). University of Helsinki.
Plichta, P., Muszyńska, K., & Otwinowska, A. (2023). Are
Polish CLIL learners more willing to communicate in English than non-CLIL learners? Psychology of Language
and
Communication, 27(1), 405–435.
Polit, D. F., & Beck, C. T. (2006). The
content validity index: Are you sure you know what’s being reported? Critique and recommendations. Research
in Nursing &
Health, 29(5), 489–497.
Quinto, E. J. M., Ofalia, B. C., Bae, J., & Salonga, L. S. B. (2019). (Un)willingness
to communicate in English among Korean study abroad students in the Philippines. Journal Komunikasi:
Malaysian Journal of
Communication, 35(4), 17–31.
Raykov, T., & Hancock, G. R. (2005). Examining
change in scale reliability using covariance structure analysis. Educational and Psychological
Measurement, 65(2), 227–246.
Rezai, A. (2023). Investigating
the association of informal digital learning of English with EFL learners’ intercultural competence and willingness to communicate: A SEM
study. BMC
Psychology, 11, 314.
Schermelleh-Engel, K., Moosbrugger, H., & Müller, H. (2003). Evaluating
the fit of structural equation models: Tests of significance and descriptive goodness-of-fit
measures. Methods of Psychological Research
Online, 8(2), 23–74.
Somers, T., & Llinares, A. (2021). Students’
motivation for content and language integrated learning and the role of programme intensity. International
Journal of Bilingual Education and
Bilingualism, 24(6), 839–854.
Swain, M., & Johnson, R. K. (1997). Immersion
education: A category within bilingual education. In R. K. Johnson & M. Swain (Eds.), Immersion
education: International
perspectives (pp. 1–16). Cambridge University Press.
Sylvén, L. K., & Thompson, A. S. (2015). Language
learning motivation and CLIL: Is there a connection? Journal of Immersion and Content-Based Language
Education, 3(1), 28–50.
Taherian, T., Elahi Shirvan, M., Yazdanmehr, E., Kruk, M., & Pawlak, M. (2024). A
longitudinal analysis of informal digital learning of English, willingness to communicate and foreign language boredom: A latent change
score mediation model. The Asia-Pacific Education
Researcher, 33(4), 997–1010.
Tarp, G. (2020). Intercultural
encounters and their influence on willingness to communicate in a second language other than
English. Language and Intercultural
Communication, 20(3), 270–283.
Tavakoli, E., & Davoudi, M. (2017). Willingness
to communicate orally: The case of Iranian EFL learners. Journal of Psycholinguistic
Research, 46, 1509–1527.
Thompson, A. S., & Sylvén, L. K. (2015). Does
English make you nervous? Anxiety profiles of CLIL and non-CLIL students in Sweden. Apples: Journal of
Applied Language
Studies, 9(2), 1–23.
Villabona, N., & Cenoz, J. (2021). The
integration of content and language in CLIL: a challenge for content-driven and language-driven
teachers. Language, Culture and
Curriculum, 35(1), 36–50.
Wu, C.-P., & Lin, H.-J. (2014). Anxiety
about speaking a foreign language as a mediator of the relation between motivation and willingness to
communicate. Perceptual and Motor
Skills, 119(3), 785–798.
Yashima, T. (2002). Willingness
to communicate in a second language: The Japanese EFL context. Modern Language
Journal, 86(1), 54–66.
Zabihi, R., Ghominejad, S., & Ahmadian, M. J. (2024). Can
willingness to communicate, communication in English anxiety, behavioural inhibition, and behavioural action predict perceived L2
fluency? Language Teaching
Research, 28(6), 1625–1647.
Zhang, C., Meng, Y., & Ma, X. (2024). Artificial
intelligence in EFL speaking: Impact on enjoyment, anxiety, and willingness to
communicate. System, 121, Article
103259.