Article published In:
Australian Review of Applied LinguisticsVol. 14:1 (1991) ► pp.17–34
Miscommunication in the medical encounter
A function of language or social roles?
The paper draws upon a study of interaction between staff and non-native speakers of English in the Outpatients Department carried out at the request of a large public hospital. It discusses the nature of communication in the medical setting and the effects of institutionalized models of interaction on patients of both non-English speaking and English-speaking background. An attempt is made to characterize typical language exchanges at various points in patients’ passage through the system and to offer explanations for communication problems arising from selected interactions between patients and hospital staff. Outcomes of these interactions as evidenced by patients’ ability to demonstrate understanding of their medication regimes are also considered.
While according cross-cultural factors an important role in communication with non-English speakers, and accepting that NESB patients on account of their limited English may be disadvantaged in the medical encounter, it was concluded that communication difficulties can arise intraculturally as well as cross-culturally and that the differentiated roles of staff and patients constitute the overriding constraint on effective communication. Implications are drawn for the ways in which social interaction between unequal parties is mediated through language.
References (36)
Bliesener, T. and Siegrist, J. (1981) Greasing the wheels: conflicts on the round and how they are managed. Journal of Pragmatics 51:181–204. 
Buller, M. and Buller, D. (1987) Physicians’ communication style and Patient Satisfaction. Journal of Health and Social Behaviour 281:375–388.
Candlin, C., H. Coleman and J. Burton (1983) Dentist-patient communication: communicating complaint. In N Wolfson and E. Judd (eds) Sociolinguistics and Language Acquisition Rowley, Mass.: Newbury House, 56–81.
Candlin, C. and J. Lucas (1984) Modes of counselling in family planning. Honolulu, Hawaii. University of Hawaii at Manoa.
Cassell, E.J., L. Skopek, and B. Fraser (1976) A preliminary model for the examination of doctor-patient communication Language Sciences, December.
Cicourel, A. V. (1987) The interpenetration of communicative contexts: examples from medical encounters. Social Psychology Quarterly 50, 2:217–226.
Clyne, M. and J. Piatt (1991) The role of language in cross-cultural communication. In A. Pauwels (ed).
Eisenbruch, M. (1989) Medical education for a multicultural society. The Medical Journal of Australia 1511:574–80.
Fisher, S. (1984) In the patient’s best interest: women and the politics of medical decisions. Rutgers University Press.
Fisher, S. and A.D. Todd (eds) (1983) The social organization of doctor-patient communication. Washington, D.C., Center for Applied Linguistics.
Garner, M. C. Elder and L. Worley (1990) ‘Getting the message across’: communication with patients from a non-English speaking background in the Outpatients Department of the Royal Women’s Hospital. A report to the Outpatient Committee. University of Melbourne, Linguistics and Language Studies.
Gourley, P., R. Moore, B. Clayton and W. Young (1983) Pharmacist’s role in patient education’ Australian Journal of Hospital Pharmacy 13(2):49–53
Haynes, R., D. Taylor, and D. Sackett eds (1979) Compliance in health care. Baltimore: John Hopkins University Press.
Hein, N. & R. Wodak (1987) Medical interviews in internal medicine. Some results of an empirical investigation. Text 7,1: 37–65.
Huddleston, J. & L. Stirling (1982) Directives in doctor-patient discourse: an account of speech exchanges. Unpublished ms. University of Queensland, Department of English.
Inui, T., W. Carter, W. Kukull and V. Haigh (1982) Outcome-based doctor-patient interaction analysis. Medical Care 201:535–549.
Isaac, D.R. (1989) A transcultural support group for Turkish women in poor health. In A. Pauwels (ed).
Labov, W. & D. Fanshel, D. (1977) Therapeutic discourse: psychotherapy as conversation. New York, Academic Press.
Levinson, S.C. (1983) Pragmatics. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
Ley, P (1982) Satisfaction, compliance and communication: a review. British Journal of Clinical Psychology 211:241–54.
Madden, E. Jr. (1973) Evaluation of outpatient pharmacy counselling. Journal of the American Pharmaceutical Association 131,81:437–43.
Pauwels, A. (1991) Language in cross-cultural medical settings. In A. Pauwels (ed.).
(ed) (1991) Cross-cultural communication in medical encounters. Community Languages in the Profession Unit, Language and Society Centre, National Languages Institute of Australia (Working paper 4) Monash University.
Rose, A. (1991) Forms of communication in the medical profession. In A, Pauwels (ed.).
Shapiro, M. and Najman, J. (1987) Socio-economic status differences in patients’ desire for and capacity to obtain information in the clinical encounter. Australian Journal of Social Issues 221: 465–71
Shaw J., M. Hemming, P. Hobson, P. Niemann and N. Naismith (1977a) Comprehension of therapy by non-English speaking hospital patients. Medical Journal of Australia 21:423–7.
Shaw, J., M. Hemming, P Hobson and J. Marty (1977b) Comparison of English and non-English speaking outpatients’ comprehension of medications. Australian Journal of Hospital Pharmacy 7(3): 116–19
Schegloff, E.A. (1977) On some questions and ambiguities in conversation. In W. Dressier (ed.) Current trends intext linguistics Berlin, de Gruyter:81–102.
Shuy, R. (1983) Three Types of Interference to an Effective Exchange of information in the Medical Interview. In S. Fisher and A. Todd (eds) The social organization of doctor- patient communication. Washington, D.C. Center for Applied Linguistics: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich.
Singh, B. (1989) Cross-cultural communicaion issues in the medical curriculum. Proceedings of the conference on cross-cultural communication in the health professions. National Centre for Community Languages in the Professions (Working Paper 2), Monash University.
Tannen, D. (1979) ‘What’s in a Frame? Surface evidence for underlying expectations. In R.O. Freedle (ed) New Directions in Discourse Processing (Vol 11, Advances in Discourse Processes). Norwood, New Jersey: Ablex Publishing Corporation.
Tannen, D. and C. Wallat (1987) Interactive frames and knowledge schemas in interaction: examples from a medical examination/ interview. Social Psychology Quarterly. 50, 22: 205–216.
Tuckett, D. M. Boulton and C. Olson. (1985) A New Approach to the measurement of patients’ understanding of what they are told in medical consultations. Journal of Health and Social Behaviour 261:27–38.
Waitzkin, H. (1989) A critical theory of medical discourse: ideology, social control, and the processing of social context in medical encounters. Journal of Health and Social Behaviour 301:220–239
West, C. (1984) Routine complications. Troubles with talk between doctors and patients Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
Wodak, R. (1981) Women relate, men report: sex differences in language behaviour in a therapeutic group. Journal of Pragmatics 51, 261–285.