Sifting the Evidence

| University of Wisconsin
| The Ohio State University
ISBN 9789027236463 (Eur) | EUR 110.00
ISBN 9781556195976 (USA) | USD 165.00
ISBN 9789027275714 | EUR 110.00 | USD 165.00
The “Nostratic” hypothesis — positing a common linguistic ancestor for a wide range of language families including Indo-European, Uralic, and Afro-Asiatic — has produced one of the most enduring and often intense controversies in linguistics. Overwhelmingly, though, both supporters of the hypothesis and those who reject it have not dealt directly with one another’s arguments. This volume brings together selected representatives of both sides, as well as a number of agnostic historical linguists, with the aim of examining the evidence for this particular hypothesis in the context of distant genetic relationships generally.
The volume contains discussion of variants of the Nostratic hypothesis (A. Bomhard; J. Greenberg; A. Manaster-Ramer, K. Baertsch, K. Adams, & P. Michalove), the mathematics of chance in determining the relationships posited for Nostratic (R. Oswalt; D. Ringe), and the evidence from particular branches posited in Nostratic (L. Campbell; C. Hodge; A. Vovin), with responses and additional discussion by E. Hamp, B. Vine, W. Baxter and B. Comrie.
[Current Issues in Linguistic Theory, 142]  1998.  vi, 293 pp.
Publishing status: Available
Table of Contents
Joseph C. Salmons and Brian D. Joseph
I. The Nature and Status of Nostratic
Some Draft Principles for Classification
Eric P. Hamp
Nostratic, Eurasiatic, and Indo-European
Allan R. Bomhard
The Convergence of Eurasiatic and Nostratic
Joseph H. Greenberg
Exploring the Nostratic Hypothesis
Alexis Manaster-Ramer, Peter A. Michalove, Karen S. Baertsch and Karen L. Adams
Indo-European and Nostratic: Some further comments
Brent Vine
Nostratic: A personal assessment
Lyle Campbell
II. The Mathematics of Nostratic
A Probabilistic Evaluation of Indo-Uralic
Don Ringe
A Probabilistic Evaluation of North Eurasiatic Nostratic
Robert L. Oswalt
Response to Oswalt and Ringe
William H. Baxter
III. Relationships within Nostratic
The Implications of Lislakh for Nostratic
Carleton T. Hodge
Nostratic and Altaic
Alexander Vovin
Regular Sound Correspondences and Long-Distance Genetic Comparison
Bernard Comrie
Index of Subjects
Index of Languages
Index of Names
“Greenberg's paper is a welcome programmatic introduction to this thinking on Nostratic and Eurasiatic [...] The papers, by Manaster-Ramer et al. Vine and Campbell, represent [...] the best of what current historical linguistics has to offer: philological depth, methodological and theoretical aophistication, and historical sensitivity. Each could be required reading for advanced courses in historical linguistics. [...] Campbell shows a depth and sophistication in his assessment of the Nostratic issue that is a model of scholarly research.”
“[I]t seemed high time to bring prominent proponents of the theory together with some of their most prominent critics, and to see whether some kind of consensus could be reached, if not on the Nostratic theory itself, then at least on criteria for a proper evaluation of its methods and claims. In doing this, this collection of papers is an innovative and welcome endeavor. [...] For any linguist wishing to find an introduction to the nature and problems of the Nostratic debate, this book, more than any single work, should serve as the point of entry.”
“[A] good state of the art report of Nostratic Studies. [...] It helps the clarification of concepts. It proves that it is worthwhile to deal with.”
“[A]n excellent snap-shot of the state of the art, and a very instructive one.”
Cited by

Cited by 11 other publications

No author info given
2020. Erreseina. Advances in Proto-Basque Reconstruction with Evidence for the Proto-Indo- uropean-Euskarian Hypothesis. Fontes Linguae Vasconum :130 Crossref logo
Ceolin, Andrea
2019. Significance testing of the Altaic family. Diachronica 36:3  pp. 299 ff. Crossref logo
Ceolin, Andrea, Cristina Guardiano, Giuseppe Longobardi, Monica Alexandrina Irimia, Luca Bortolussi & Andrea Sgarro
2021. At the boundaries of syntactic prehistory. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 376:1824 Crossref logo
Dediu, Dan, Scott R. Moisik, W. A. Baetsen, Abel Marinus Bosman & Andrea L. Waters-Rist
2021. The vocal tract as a time machine: inferences about past speech and language from the anatomy of the speech organs. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 376:1824 Crossref logo
Emlen, Nicholas Q. & Johannes Dellert
2020. On the polymorphemic genesis of some Proto-Quechuan roots. Diachronica 37:3  pp. 318 ff. Crossref logo
Epps, Patience & Katherine Bolaños
2017. Reconsidering the “Makú” Language Family of Northwest Amazonia. International Journal of American Linguistics 83:3  pp. 467 ff. Crossref logo
Greller, Wolfgang, Michael P. Barnes, Peter Schrijver & Stephen J. Walton
2017.  In Encyclopedia of the Languages of Europe,  pp. 339 ff. Crossref logo
Hickey, Raymond
2020.  In The Handbook of Language Contact,  pp. 1 ff. Crossref logo
Jäger, Gerhard
2015. Support for linguistic macrofamilies from weighted sequence alignment. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 112:41  pp. 12752 ff. Crossref logo
Kaplan, Judith R.H.
2018. The global lexicostatistical database: A total archive of linguistic prehistory. History of the Human Sciences 31:5  pp. 106 ff. Crossref logo
Pereltsvaig, Asya
2020.  In Languages of the World, Crossref logo

This list is based on CrossRef data as of 16 september 2021. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers. Any errors therein should be reported to them.

Subjects & Metadata
BIC Subject: CF – Linguistics
BISAC Subject: LAN009000 – LANGUAGE ARTS & DISCIPLINES / Linguistics / General
ONIX Metadata
ONIX 2.1
ONIX 3.0
U.S. Library of Congress Control Number:  98017514 | Marc record