Chapter 6
Politics beyond death?
An analysis of the obituaries of Belgian
politicians
Obituaries constitute interesting research
material. Amongst other functions, they indicate how a society copes
with death and the fear of dying. Obituaries reflect which personal
and professional qualities the members of a particular culture or
group in society consider important or relevant enough to be
remembered in texts celebrating a deceased person. In this paper, we
present the results of a bottom-up discourse analysis of the
obituaries of one hundred Belgian politicians. The material
comprises both obituaries published in the media and obituaries
issued by the political party the deceased politician represented.
On a content level, we focus on two aspects: the qualities mentioned
and the presence of political orientation in the description of the
deceased. On a linguistic level, we determine whether the metaphors
used are politically inspired. The analysis carried out demonstrates
that the obituaries of political figures – in which the political
discourse and the discourse about the personal qualities of the
deceased coexist – often turn into political propaganda.
Article outline
- 1.Introduction
- 2.Theoretical considerations
- 3.Research material and method
- 4.Analysis and results
- 4.1Content analysis
- 4.2Linguistic analysis
- 4.2.1Lexical analysis
- 4.2.2Metaphor analysis
- 5.Discussion and concluding remarks
-
Notes
-
References
References
Anderson, Keith A., and Jina Han
2008 “
An Exploration of Ageism and Sexism in Obituary
Photographs: 1967–1997.”
Omega, Journal of Death and Dying 58 (4): 335–345.
Askildson, Lance
2007 “
Discoursal and Generic Features of U.S. Army
Obituaries: A Mini-Corpus Analysis of Contemporary Military
Death Announcements.”
Language, Meaning and Society 1: 77–106.
Barth, Susanne, Joris J. van Hoof, and Ardion D. Beldad
2014 “
Reading between the Lines: A Comparison of 480
German and Dutch Obituaries.”
Omega, Journal of Death and Dying 68 (2): 161–181.
Blair, Aaron, and Howard M. Hayes jr.
1982 “
Mortality Patterns among US Veterinarians,
1947–1977: An Expanded Study.”
International Journal of Epidemiology 11: 391–397.
Brown, Gillian, and George Yule
1983 Discourse Analysis. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Bull, Peter, and Anita Fetzer
2006 “
Who Are We and Who Are You? The Strategic Use of
Forms of Address in Political Interviews.”
Text and Talk 26 (1): 1–35.
Chilton, Paul
2004 Analysing Political Discourse. Theory and
Practice. London: Routledge.
Crespo-Fernández, Eliecer
2006 “
The Language of Death: Euphemisms and Conceptual
Metaphorization in Victorian Obituaries.”
SKY Journal of Linguistics 19: 101–130.
Crespo-Fernández, Eliecer
Curşeu, Petru L., and Smaranda Boroş
2011 “
Gender Stereotypes in Management: A Comparative
Study of Communist and Postcommunist Romania.”
International Journal of Psychology 46 (4): 299–309.
De Fina, Anna
1995 “
Pronominal Choice, Identity, and Solidarity in
Political Discourse.”
Text 15 (3): 379–410.
Dilevko, Juris, and Lisa Gottlieb
2004 “
The Portrayal of Librarians in Obituaries at the
End of the Twentieth Century.”
Library Quarterly 74 (2): 152–180.
[URL]
Eid, Mushira
1994 “
Hidden Women: Gender Inequality in 1938 Egyptian
Obituaries.” In
Investigating Arabic: Linguistic, Pedagogical and
Literary Studies in Honour of Ernest N. McCarus, ed. by
Raji M. Rammuny, and
Dilworth B. Parkinson, 111–136. Columbus: Greydan.
Eid, Mushira
2000 “
Women and Men in Egyptian Obituaries: Language,
Gender and Identity.” In
Hearing Many Voices, ed. by
M. J. Hardman, and
Anita Taylor, 18–34. New York: Hampton Press.
Eid, Mushira
2002 The World of Obituaries: Gender across Cultures and over
Time. Detroit: Wayne State University Press.
ElShiekh, Ahmed A.
2012 “
The Deontic and the Epistemic in Egyptian and
Jordanian Obituaries: A Comparative/Contrastive Study of
Religious Minorities Linguistic Expression.”
Asian Social Science 8 (2): 135–146.
Fairclough, Norman
2010 Critical Discourse Analysis. The Critical Study of
Language (2nd ed). Harlow: Longman.
Fowler, Bridget
2004 “
Mapping the Obituary: Notes towards a
Bourdieusian Interpretation.”
The Sociological Review 52: 148–171.
Galal, Mohamed M.
2014 “
Death Euphemism in English and Arabic. A
Conceptual Metaphorization Approach.”
International Journal of Linguistics 6 (1): 153–170.
Gee, James P.
1990 Social Linguistics and Literacies. Ideologies in Discourse. New York: Routledge.
Hartl, Barbara, Erich Kirchler, and Stephan Muehlbacher
2013 “
Geschlechterstereotype auf
Führungsebene zwischen 1974 und 2010. Eine Analyse von
Todesanzeigen versterbener weiblicher und männlicher
Führungskräfte” [“Gender stereotypes about managers
between 1974 and 2010. An analysis of obituaries of deceased
female and male managers].”
Zeitschrift für Arbeits- und
Organisationspsychologie 57: 121–131.
Hermann, Richard C.
1989 “
Physician Deaths under the Age of 50 Years:
Information from the Obituaries.”
JAMA. The Journal of the American Medical
Association 260 (23): 3433.
Heynderickx, Priscilla, and Sylvain Dieltjens
2016 “
An Analysis of Obituaries in Staff
Magazines.”
Death Studies 40 (1): 11–21.
Heynderickx, Priscilla, Sylvain Dieltjens, and Albert Oosterhof
2017 “
The Final Fight. An Analysis of Metaphors in
Online Obituaries of Professional Athletes.”
Omega, Journal of Death and Dying.
Heynderickx, Priscilla, and Sylvain Dieltjens
2019 “
If Cemeteries could Talk & A Discourse-Analytical
Analysis of Epitaphs.”
Omega, Journal of Death and Dying.
Issa, Sadam, and Ghazi Abuhakema
2011 “
Rhetorical Properties and Generic Structure
Analysis of Christian and Muslim Obituaries: The Case of the
Egyptian Daily Newspaper Al-Ahram.”
Al-Arabiyya 44 (5): 65–86.
Jones, Ben
(ed) 1994 Politics UK. New York: Harvester Wheatsheaf.
Josephi, Beate, Christine Müller, and Hans-Jürgen Friske
2006 “
How Private a Death? Obituaries in Australia and
Germany.”
Hungarian Journal of English and American Studies
(HJEAS) 12 (1–2): 31–45.
Kastenbaum, Robert, Sara Peyton, and Beatrice Kastenbaum
1976 “
Sex Discrimination after Death.”
Omega, Journal of Death and Dying 7 (4): 351–359.
Katz, Jonathan D., and Martin D. Slade
2006 “
Anesthesiologists are Living Longer: Mortality
Experience 1992 to 2001.”
Journal of Clinical Anesthesia 18 (6): 405–408.
Kinnier, Richard T., Arlene T. Metha, Lydia P. Buki, and Patrick M. Rawa
1994 “
Manifest Values of Eminent Psychologists: A
Content Analysis of their Obituaries.”
Current Psychology 13: 88–94.
Kirchler, Erich
1992 “
Adorable Woman, Expert Man: Changing Gender
Images of Women and Men in Management.”
European Journal of Social Psychology 22: 363–373.
Lakoff, George
1993 “
The Contemporary Theory of
Metaphor.” In
Metaphor and Thought, ed. by
Andrew Ortony, 202–251. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Lakoff, George, and Mark Johnson
1980 Metaphors We Live By. London: The University of Chicago Press.
Miller, Barry A., Aaron Blair, and Michael McCann
1985 “
Mortality Patterns among Professional Artists: A
Preliminary Report.”
Journal of Environmental Pathology Toxicology and
Oncology 6 (2): 303–313.
Miller, David
1991 “
Politics.” In
The Blackwell Encyclopaedia of Political
Thought, ed. by
David Miller, 390–391. Oxford and Malden, MS: Blackwell.
Moremen, Robin D., and Cathy Cradduck
1998 “
‘How will you Be Remembered after you Die?’
Gender Discrimination after Death Twenty Years
Later.”
Omega, Journal of Death and Dying 38 (4): 241–255.
Moses, Rae A., and Giana D. Marelli
2004 “
Obituaries and the Discursive Construction of
Dying and Living.”
Texas Linguistic Forum 47: 263–279.
Murray, Heathe
1998 “
The Development of Professional Discourse and
Language Awareness in EFL Teacher Training.”
IATEFL Teacher Trainers SIG Newsletter 21: 3–7.
Ogletree, Shirley M., Patricia Figueroa, and Daniella Pena
2005 “
A Double Standard in Death? Gender Differences in
Obituaries.”
Omega, Journal of Death and Dying 51 (4): 337–342.
Samalweh, Murad
2019 “
Rhetorical Structure and Sociocultural Analysis
of Muslim and Christian Obituaries in Jordanian
Newspapers.”
International Journal of Arabic-English Studies 19 (2): 317–334.
Spilka, Bernard, Gerald Lacey, and Barbara Gelb
1979 “
Sex Discrimination after Death: A Replication,
Extension and a Difference.”
Omega, Journal of Death and Dying 10 (3): 227–233.
Swales, John M.
1990 Genre Analysis: English in Academic and Research
Settings. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Tenzek, Kelly E., and Bonnie M. Nickels
2017 “
End-of-Life in Disney and Pixar Films: An
Opportunity for Engaging in Difficult
Conversation.”
Omega, Journal of Death and Dying.
Tight, Malcolm
2008 “
Dead Academics: What Can we Learn about Academic
Work and Life from Obituaries?”
London Review of Education 6 (2): 125–135.
Vieweg, Walter V. R., Linda M. Dougherty, and Kimberley Barfield
2003 “
Lifespan of Male Attorneys: Preliminary
Findings.”
Southern Medical Journal 96 (3): 264–265.
Walenta, Christa, Erich Kirchler, and Erik Hölzl
2001 “
Gender Stereotypes of Leaders: An Analysis of the
Contents of Obituaries from 1974 to 1998.”
Sex Roles 45 (11–12): 827–843.
Walrath, Judy, Pierre Decouflé, and Terry L. Thomas
1987 “
Mortality among Workers in a Shoe Manufacturing
Company.”
American Journal of Industrial Medicine 12 (5): 615–623.
Waugh, Linda R., Theresa Catalano, Khaled Al Masaeed, Tom Hong Do, and Paul G. Renigar
2016 “
Critical Discourse Analysis: Definition,
Approaches, Relation to Pragmatics, Critique and
Trends”. In
Interdisciplinary Studies in Pragmatics, Culture and
Society. Perspectives in Pragmatics, Philosophy &
Psychology. Vol. 4, ed. by
Alessandro Capone, and
Jacob L. Mey, 71–135.
Wright, David J. M., and A. P. Roberts
1996 “
Which Doctors Die First? Analysis of BMJ Obituary
Columns.”
British Medical Journal 313 (7072): 1581–1582.
Zehnter, Miriam K., Jerome Olsen, and Erich Kirchler
2018 “
Obituaries of Female and Male Leaders from 1974
to 2016 Suggest Change in Descriptive but Stability of
Prescriptive Gender.”
Frontiers in Psychology 9.
.
[URL]
Cited by
Cited by 1 other publications
Heynderickx, Priscilla C., Silke Creten & Sylvain M. Dieltjens
2024.
Rumor Has it: “Dementia” A Discourse-Analytical Analysis of Obituaries of People With Dementia.
OMEGA - Journal of Death and Dying 88:4
► pp. 1430 ff.
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 20 march 2024. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers.
Any errors therein should be reported to them.