Chapter 2
Online headline testing at a Belgian broadsheet
A postfoundational perspective on how news professionals ‘sell’
content
In this chapter, we investigate the impact of recent
audience-monitoring tools on the (online) newspaper sub-editors’ task of
crafting headlines. We zoom in on how metrics have become part of the
newsmaking process and are now intrinsic to a larger foundation of more
collaborative, participatory and engaging practices. Drawing on digital data
and fieldwork, we analyse the back and forth between the sub-editors’
journalistic gut feeling, their awareness of ‘selling’ their brand ‘in the
right way’, and the need to gain clicks. Relying on a linguistic
ethnographic perspective (NT&T
2011), we address how sub-editors reflect on their changing
professional routines. By investigating how the sub-editors’ aim to position
themselves in tandem with their algorithmic tools is foundational to news
media today, we shed new light on how the use of audience engagement metrics
intertwines with long-standing journalistic practices and contribute to
global debates on the politics of technology and online participation.
Article outline
- Introduction
- Research focus 1: Audience-monitoring tools and metrics
- Research focus 2: Headlines and (online) sub-editors
- Methodology and data
- Findings
- Online sub-editing and headline testing
- Cases
-
Case 1: For clickbait – “More of a trigger”
-
Case 2: For clickbait – “Missing the boat”
-
Case 3: Against clickbait - Staying true to the
brand
-
Case 4: Reframing the news story
- Newsworkers reflecting on the use of headline testing
- Conclusion
-
Notes
-
References
References (63)
References
Ahlers, Douglas. 2006. “News
Consumption and the New Electronic
Media.” Harvard International Journal
of
Press/Politics 11 (1): 29-52.
Anderson, Christopher W. 2011. “Deliberative,
Agonistic, and Algorithmic Audiences: Journalism's Vision of its
Public in an Age of Audience
Transparency.” International Journal
of
Communication 5: 19.
Barber, James P., and Kelley K. Walczak. 2009. “Conscience
and Critic: Peer Debriefing Strategies in Grounded Theory
Research.” American Educational
Research Association (AERA) Conference, 13–17
April.
Bednarek, Monika, and Hellen Caple. 2017. The
Discourse of News Values. New York: Oxford University Press.
Blom, Jonas Nygaard, and Kenneth Reinecke Hansen. 2015. “Click
Bait: Forward-Reference as Lure in Online News
Headlines.” Journal of
Pragmatics 76: 87–100.
Briggs, Charles L., and Daniel C. Hallin. 2016. Making
Health Public: How News Coverage is Remaking Media, Medicine, and
Contemporary Life. New York: Routledge.
Carlson, Matt. 2019. “News
Algorithms, Photojournalism and the Assumption of Mechanical
Objectivity in Journalism.” Digital
Journalism 7 (8): 1-17.
Chen, Yimin, Niall J. Conroy, and Victoria L. Rubin. 2015. “News
in an Online World: The Need for an Automatic Crap
Detector.” Proceedings of the
Association for Information Science and
Technology 52 (1): 1-4.
Christin, Angèle. 2017. Algorithms in practice: Comparing web journalism and criminal justice. Big Data & Society, 4(2), 2053951717718855.
Chyi, Hsiang Iris. 2005. “Willingness
to Pay for Online News: An Empirical Study on the Viability of the
Subscription Model.” Journal of Media
Economics 18 (2): 131-142.
Cohen, Nicole S. 2015. “From
Pink Slips to Pink Slime: Transforming Media Labor in a Digital
Age.” The Communication
Review 18 (2): 98-122.
Cotter, Colleen. 2010. News
Talk: Investigating the Language of
Journalism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Craft, Stephanie, Tim P. Vos, and J. David Wolfgang. 2016. “Reader
Comments as Press Criticism: Implications for the Journalistic
Field.” Journalism 17 (6): 677–693.
Creswell, John W., and J. David Creswell. 2017. Research
Design: Qualitative, Quantitative, and Mixed Methods
Approaches. Thousand Oaks: Sage.
D’heer, Evelien, and Steve Paulussen. 2013. “The
Use of Citizen Journalism for Hyperlocal News
Production.” Reserches En
Communication 39: 151–164.
Declercq, Jana. 2018. (De)Constructing
the Discourse of Health News: A Linguistic Ethnographic
Enquiry. Ghent: Ghent University.
Dutta-Bergman, Mohan J. 2004. “Complementarity
in Consumption of News Types Across Traditional and New
Media.” Journal of Broadcasting &
Electronic
Media 48 (1): 41-60.
Farhi, Paul. 2007. “Salvation?
The Embattled Newspaper Business is Betting Heavily on Web
Advertising Revenue to Secure its Survival. But That Wager is Hardly
a Sure Thing.” American Journalism
Review 29 (6): 18.
Flaxman, Setz, Sharad Goel, and Rao, Justin M. 2016. “Filter
Bubbles, Echo Chambers, and Online News
Consumption.” Public Opinion
Quarterly 80 (1): 298-320.
Franiuk, Renae, Seefelt, Jennifer L., and Joseph A. Vandello. 2008. “Prevalence
of Rape Myths in Headlines and their Effects on Attitudes Toward
Rape.” Sex
Roles 58 (11–12): 790-801.
Gabielkov, Maksym, Arthi Ramachandran, Augustin Chaintreau, and Arnaud Legout. 2016. “Social
Clicks: What and Who Gets Read on
Twitter?” ACM SIGMETRICS Performance
Evaluation
Review 44 (1): 179–192.
Galtung, Johan, and Mari Holmboe Ruge. 1965. “The
Structure of Foreign News: The Presentation of the Congo, Cuba and
Cyprus Crises in Four Norwegian
Newspapers.” Journal of Peace
Research 2 (1): 64–90.
Hamari, Juho, Jonna Koivisto, and Harri Sarsa. 2014. “Does
Gamification Work? A Literature Review of Empirical Studies on
Gamification.” 47th Hawaii
International Conference on System Sciences,
3025-3034.
Harcup, Tony. 2014. A
Dictionary of
Journalism. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Harcup, Tony, and Deidre O’Neill. 2001. “What
is News? Galtung and Ruge
Revisited.” Journalism
Studies 2 (2): 261–280.
Harcup, Tony and Deidre O’Neill. 2017. “What
is News? News Values Revisited
(Again).” Journalism
Studies 18: 1470-1488.
Hermida, Alfred, and Neil Thurman. 2008. “A
Clash of Cultures: The Integration of User-Generated Content within
Professional Journalistic Frameworks at British Newspaper
Websites.” Journalism
Practice 2 (3): 343–356.
Ikonen, Pasi, Vilma Luoma-aho, and Shannon Bowen. 2017. “Transparency
for Sponsored Content: Analysing Codes of Ethics in Public
Relations, Marketing, Advertising and
Journalism” International Journal of
Strategic
Communication 11 (2): 165–178.
Kohavi, Ron, and Roger Longbotham. 2017. “Online
Controlled Experiments and A/B
Testing.” In Encyclopedia
of Machine Learning and Data Mining, ed.
by Claude Sammut, and Geoffrey I. Webb, 922–929.
Kuiken, Jeffrey, Anne Schuth, Martijn Spitters, and Maarten Marx. 2017. “Effective
Headlines of Newspaper Articles in a Digital
Environment.” Digital
Journalism 5 (10): 1300-1314. Boston: Springer. .
Lai, Linda, and Audun Farbrot. 2014. “What
Makes You Click? The Effect of Question Headlines on Readership in
Computer-Mediated
Communication.” Social
Influence 9 (4): 289–299.
Larrondo Ainara, David Domingo, Ivar John Erdal, Pere Masip, and Hilde Van Den Bulck. 2016. “Opportunities
and Limitations of Newsroom Convergence: A Comparative Study on
European Public Service Broadcasting
Organisations.” Journalism
Studies 17 (3): 277-300.
Lee, Eun-Ju, and Edson C. Tandoc Jr. 2017. “When
News Meets the Audience: How Audience Feedback Online Affects News
Production and Consumption.” Human
Communication
Research 43 (4): 436–449.
Maras, Steven. 2013. Objectivity
in Journalism. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons.
European Social
Survey. 2014. “Media
Landscape Media
Claims.” Accessed May 6,
2020. [URL].
Metrics
Glossary. (n.d.). Accessed
May 6, 2020. [URL].
Myllylahti, Merja. 2017. “What
Content is Worth Locking behind a Paywall? Digital News
Commodification in Leading Australasian Financial
Newspapers.” Digital
Journalism 5 (4): 460-471.
NT&T. 2011. “Towards
a Linguistics of News
Production.” Journal of
Pragmatics 43 (7): 1843–1852.
Ohlsson, Jonas, Johan Lindell, and Sophia Arkhede. 2017. “A
Matter of Cultural Distinction: News Consumption in the Online Media
Landscape.” European Journal of
Communication 32 (2): 116–130.
O’Neil, Cathy. 2016. Weapons
of Math Destruction: How Big Data Increases Inequality and Threatens
Democracy. New York: Broadway Books.
Petre, Caitlin. 2015. “The
Traffic Factories: Metrics at Chartbeat, Gawker Media, and The New
York Times.” Columbia University, Tow
Center for Digital Journalism. .
Reis, Julio, Fabricio Benevenuto, Pedro Olmo,Raquel Prates, Haewoon Kwak, and Jisun An. 2015. “Breaking
the News: First Impressions Matter on Online
News.” Proceedings of the Ninth
International AAAI Conference on Web and Social
Media.
Romano, Frank. 2004. “An
Investigation into Printing Industry
Trends.” Accessed May 6,
2020. [URL].
Rowe, David. 2011. “Obituary
for the Newspaper? Tracking the
Tabloid.” Journalism 12 (4): 449–466.
Ryan, Michael. 2001. “Journalistic
Ethics, Objectivity, Existential Journalism, Standpoint
Epistemology, and Public
Journalism.” Journal of Mass Media
Ethics 16 (1): 3-22.
Safran, Nathan. 2013. “5
Data Insights into the Headlines Readers
Click.” [URL].
Smith, Weny K., Andy Binns, and Michael L. Tushman. 2010. “Complex
Business Models: Managing Strategic Paradoxes
Simultaneously.” Long Range
Planning 43(2–3): 448-461.
Smolkin, Rachel. 2006. “Adapt
or die?” American Journalism
Review 28(3): 16-23.
Spillett, Marydee A. 2003. “Peer
Debriefing: Who, What, When, Why,
How.” Academic Exchange
Quarterly 7 (3): 36.
Streckfuss, Richard. 1990. “Objectivity
in Journalism: A Search and a
Reassessment.” Journalism
Quarterly 67 (4): 973-983.
Tenenboim, Ori, and Akiba A. Cohen. 2015. “What
Prompts Users to Click and Comment: A Longitudinal Study of Online
News.” Journalism 16 (2): 198–217.
Vandendaele, Astrid, and Geert Jacobs. 2014. “The
Lowlands Newsroom Model: Fieldwork Notes on the Position of the
Newspaper Sub-Editor.” Journalism
Studies 15(6): 879–897.
Vandendaele A, Ludovic De Cuypere, and Ellen Van Praet. 2015. “Beyond
“Trimming the Fat: The Sub-Editing Stage of
Newswriting.” Written
Communication 32 (4): 368–395.
Vandendaele, Astrid. 2017a. “Inside
Out/Outside In: (Auto-)Ethnographic Work on the Position of the
Newspaper
Sub-Editor.” In Towards
a Praxis-Based Media and Journalism
Research, ed. by Leon Barkho, 131–148. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Vandendaele, Astrid. 2017b. “The
Newsroom’s Last Line of Defence: A Linguistic Ethnographic
Investigation into Newspaper
Sub-Editing.” Ghent University, Faculty of Arts and Philosophy.
Vandendaele, Astrid. 2018. “‘Trust
me, I’m a sub-editor’: Production Values at Work in Newspaper
Sub-Editing.” Journalism
Practice 12 (3): 268–89.
Vandendaele, Astrid. 2020. “Designing
the News : A Practitioner Perspective on the Production Values in
Newspaper
Sub-Editing.” Journalism 21 (11): 1655–75. .
Van Dijk, Teun A. 1988. News
as
Discourse. Hillsdale: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
Van Leuven, Sarah, and Annelore Deprez. 2017. “’To
Follow or Not to Follow?’: How Belgian Health Journalists use
Twitter to Monitor Potential
Sources.” Journal of Applied
Journalism and Media
Studies 6 (3): 545–566.
Waisbord, Silvio. 2019. “The
5Ws and 1H of Digital
Journalism.” Digital
Journalism 7 (3): 351-358.
Wahl-Jorgensen, Karin, Andrew Williams, Richard Sambrook, Janet Harris, Iñaki Garcia-Blanco, Lina Dencik, Stephen Cushion, Cynthia Carter, and Stuart Allan. 2016. “The
Future of Journalism” Digital
Journalism 4 (7): 809-815.
Wall, Melissa. 2015. “Citizen
Journalism: A Retrospective on What We Know, an Agenda for What We
Don’t.” Digital
Journalism 3 (6): 797–813.
Yoon, Seunghyun, Kunwoo Park, Joongbo Shin, Hongun Lim, Seungpil Won, Meeyoung Cha, and Kyomin Jung. 2019. “Detecting
Incongruity between News Headline and Body Text via a Deep
Hierarchical Encoder.” Proceedings of
the AAAI Conference on Artificial
Intelligence 33: 791-800.
Cited by (1)
Cited by one other publication
Vandendaele, Astrid, Olivier Standaert & Catherine Bouko
2022.
Language perceptions and use among (TV) journalists in multilingual Belgium: how pragmatic realities affect the idealized benchmark of bilingualism.
Journalism 23:7
► pp. 1469 ff.
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 4 july 2024. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers.
Any errors therein should be reported to them.