Phylogenetic linguistic evidence and the Dene-Yeniseian homeland
Igor Yanovich | Universität Tübingen
Sicoli & Holton (2014) (PLoS ONE 9:3, e91722) use computational
phylogenetics to argue that linguistic data from the putative, but likely, Dene-Yeniseian macro-family are better compatible with
a homeland in Beringia (i.e., northeastern Siberia plus northwestern Alaska) than with one in central Siberia or deeper Asia. I
show that a more careful examination of the data invalidates this conclusion: in fact, linguistic data do not support Beringia as
the homeland. In the course of showing this, I discuss, without requiring a deep mathematical background, a number of
methodological issues concerning computational phylogenetic analyses of linguistic data and drawing inferences from them. The aim
is to contribute to making computational phylogenetics less of a black box for historical linguists. I conclude with a brief
overview of the current evidence bearing on the Dene-Yeniseian homeland from linguistics, archaeology, folklore studies and
genetics, and suggest current best practice for linguistic phylogenetics, the use of which would have helped to avoid some of the
problems in Sicoli and Holton’s Dene-Yeniseian study, and in turn the percolation of those problems into subsequent synthetic
interdisciplinary research.
Keywords: Dene-Yeniseian, Na-Dene, Yeniseian, Beringia, phylogenetics, tree prior, languages and genes, computational historical linguistics
Published online: 15 July 2020
https://doi.org/10.1075/dia.17038.yan
https://doi.org/10.1075/dia.17038.yan
References
References
Berezkin, Yuriy Evgenyevich
2010 Mifologičeskie obyasneniya smertnosti čeloveka i problema proiskhoždeniya na-dene [Mythological explanations for the mortality of man, and the problem of Na-Dene origins]. In Ot bytiya k inobytiyu. Folklor i pogrebal’nyj ritual v tradicionnykh kul’turakh Sibiri i Ameriki [From being to other-being. Folklore and mortuary rite in the traditional cultures of Siberia and the Americas], 7–50. Saint Petersburg: MAE RAN.
Bouckaert, Remco, Joseph Heled, Denise Kühnert, Tim Vaughan, Chieh-Hsi Wu, Dong Xie, Marc A. Suchard, Andrew Rambaut & Alexei J. Drummond
Bouckaert, Remco, Philippe Lemey, Michael Dunn, Simon J. Greenhill, Alexander V. Alekseyenko, Alexei J. Drummond, Russell D. Gray, Marc A. Suchard & Quentin D. Atkinson
Brooks, Stephen P. & Andrew Gelman
Campbell, Lyle
Clark, Peter U., Arthur S. Dyke, Jeremy D. Shakun, Anders E. Carlson, Jorie Clark, Barbara Wohlfarth, Jerry X. Mitrovica, Steven W. Hostetler & A. Marshall McCabe
Dos Reis, Mario & Ziheng Yang
Drummond, Alexei J. & Remco R. Bouckaert
Flegontov, Pavel, N. Ezgi Altinisik, Piya Changmai, Nadin Rohland, Swapan Mallick, Deborah A. Bolnick, Francesca Candilio, Olga Flegontova, Choongwon Jeong, Thomas K. Harper, Denise Keating, Douglas J. Kennett, Alexander M. Kim, Thiseas C. Lamnidis, Iñigo Olalde, Jennifer Raff, Robert A. Sattler, Pontus Skoglund, Edward J. Vajda, Sergey Vasilyev, Elizaveta Veselovskaya, M. Geoffrey Hayes, Dennis H. O’Rourke, Ron Pinhasi, Johannes Krause, David Reich & Stephan Schiffels
2017 Paleo-Eskimo genetic legacy across North America. Unpublished preprint, https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/203018v1. 
Flegontov, Pavel, Piya Changmai, Anastassiya Zidkova, Maria D. Logacheva, N. Ezgi Altınışik, Olga Flegontova, Mikhail S. Gelfand, Evgeny S. Gerasimov, Ekaterina E. Khrameeva, Olga P. Konovalova, Tatiana Neretina, Yuri V. Nikolsky, George Starostin, Vita V. Stepanova, Igor V. Travinsky, Martin Tříska, Petr Tříska & Tatiana V. Tatarinova
Gernhard, Tanja
Ho, Simon Y. W. & Sebastián Duchêne
Hoffecker, John F., Scott A. Elias, Dennis H. O’Rourke, G. Richard Scott & Nancy H. Bigelow
Kassian, Alexei
2016 Global lexicostatistical database. Na-Dene family: Athapaskan group. Available at starling.rinet.ru
Kibrik, Andrej A.
Kiparsky, Paul
Kolipakam, Vishnupriya, Fiona M. Jordan, Michael Dunn, Simon J. Greenhill, Remco Bouckaert, Russell D. Gray & Annemarie Verkerk
Krauss, Michael E.
Leer, Jeff
2008 Recent advances in AET comparison. Available at http://www.uaf.edu/anla/collections/search/resultDetail.xml?id=CA965L2008b
Lewis, Paul O.
Maurits, Luke, Robert Forkel, Gereon A. Kaiping & Quentin D. Atkinson
Moreno-Mayar, J. Víctor, Lasse Vinner, Peter de Barros Damgaard, Constanza de la Fuente, Jeffrey Chan, Jeffrey P. Spence, Morten E. Allentoft, Tharsika Vimala, Fernando Racimo, Thomaz Pinotti, Simon Rasmussen, Ashot Margaryan, Miren Iraeta Orbegozo, Dorothea Mylopotamitaki, Matthew Wooller, Clement Bataille, Lorena Becerra-Valdivia, David Chivall, Daniel Comeskey, Thibaut Devièse, Donald K. Grayson, Len George, Harold Harry, Verner Alexandersen, Charlotte Primeau, Jon Erlandson, Claudia Rodrigues-Carvalho, Silvia Reis, Murilo Q. R. Bastos, Jerome Cybulski, Carlos Vullo, Flavia Morello, Miguel Vilar, Spencer Wells, Kristian Gregersen, Kasper Lykke Hansen, Niels Lynnerup, Marta Mirazón Lahr, Kurt Kjær, André Strauss, Marta Alfonso-Durruty, Antonio Salas, Hannes Schroeder, Thomas Higham, Ripan S. Malhi, Jeffrey T. Rasic, Luiz Souza, Fabricio R. Santos, Anna-Sapfo Malaspinas, Martin Sikora, Rasmus Nielsen, Yun S. Song, David J. Meltzer & Eske Willerslev
Neal, Radford
2008 The harmonic mean of the likelihood: Worst Monte Carlo Method Ever. UToronto. https://radfordneal.wordpress.com/2008/08/17/-the-harmonic-mean-of-the-likelihood-worst-monte-carlo-method-ever/
Nikolaev, Sergei
Potter, Ben A.
Raftery, Adrian E., Michael A. Newton, Jaya M. Satagopan & Pavel N. Krivitsky
Rice, Keren
Ritchie, Andrew M., Nathan Lo & Simon Y. W. Ho
Ronquist, Fredrik, John Huelsenbeck & Maxim Teslenko
Ronquist, Fredrik, Seraina Klopfstein, Lars Vilhelmsen, Susanne Schulmeister, Bebra L. Murray & Alexandr P. Rasnitsyn
Ronquist, Fredrik, Paul van der Mark & John P. Huelsenbeck
Ronquist, Fredrik, Maxim Teslenko, Paul van der Mark, Daniel L. Ayres, Aaron Darling, Sebastian Höhna, Bret Larget, Liang Liu, Marc A. Suchard & John P. Huelsenbeck
Sicoli, Mark A. & Gary Holton
Skoglund, Pontus & David Reich
Starostin, George
Tamm, Erika, Toomas Kivisild, Maere Reidla, Mait Metspalu, David Glenn Smith, Connie J. Mulligan, Claudio M. Bravi, Olga Rickards, Cristina Martinez-Labarga, Elsa K. Khusnutdinova, Sardana A. Fedorova, Maria V. Golubenko, Vadim A. Stepanov, Marina A. Gubina, Sergey I. Zhadanov, Ludmila P. Ossipova, Larisa Damba, Mikhail I. Voevoda, Jose E. Dipierri, Richard Villems & Ripan S. Malhi
Thorne, Jeffrey L. & Hirohisa Kishino
Vajda, Edward J.
Watson, Traci
Wilson, Joseph A. P.
Xie, Wangang, Paul O. Lewis, Yu Fan, Lynn Kuo & Ming-Hui Chen
Yang, Ziheng