How “U” are “U” words?
Exploring variation in the usage and perception of class-based lexical shibboleths in British English
That U (upper-class) and non-U (non-upper class) speakers are identifiable through their vocabulary is an axiom in
England. These claims are repeated in books, in print media, on social media, and in conversations regarding social class.
However, such claims are seldom investigated empirically. To redress this, we consider the production and perception of allegedly
U and non-U lexis through two studies. In the first, we identify the sociolinguistic distribution of the usage of three variables
which are purported to be indicators of socioeconomic status, namely, loo, napkin, and sofa. The second study
employs the matched-guise technique to investigate the perception of variants of these three variables. The production results
reveal that all three variables exhibit change in apparent-time with limited evidence of class-based variation. In the perception
study, we find no systematic class-based indexicalities across the variables. Ultimately, our findings challenge the belief that
allegedly U words are shibboleths of upper-classness.
Article outline
- 1.Introduction
- 2.Social class in British sociolinguistics
- 3.Applying sociolinguistic theory to U and non-U vocabulary
- 4.Data collection and methods
- 4.1The variables and variants
- 4.2Production study
- 4.2.1Methods
- 4.2.2The participants
- 4.3Perception study
- 5.Results
- 6.Discussion
- 7.Conclusions
- Acknowledgements
- Notes
-
Sources
-
References
References (73)
Sources
Love, Robbie, Claire Dembry, Andrew Hardie, Vaclav Brezina, and Tony McEnery. 2017. The
Spoken BNC2014: Designing and Building a Spoken Corpus of Everyday Conversations. 〈[URL]〉.
References
Alderton, Roy. 2022. “T-Tapping
in Standard Southern British English: An ‘Elite’ Sociolinguistic Variant?” Journal of
Sociolinguistics 261: 287–298.
Ash, Sharon. 2002. “Social
Class”. In Jack K. Chambers, Peter Trudgill, and Natalie Schilling-Estes, eds. The
Handbook of Language Variation and
Change. Oxford: Blackwell, 402–422.
Badia Barrera, Berta. 2015. “A
Sociolinguistic Study of T-Glottaling in Young RP: Accent, Class, and Education”. Unpublished
Ph.D. thesis, University of Essex.
Baranowski, Maciej. 2017. “Class
Matters: The Sociolinguistics of goose and goat in Manchester
English”. Language Variation and
Change 291: 301–339.
Baranowski, Maciej, and Danielle Turton. 2015. “Manchester
English”. In Raymond Hickey, ed. Researching
Northern
Englishes. Amsterdam: Benjamins, 293–316.
Beal, Joan, and Lourdes Burbano-Elizondo. 2012. “‘All
the Lads and Lasses’: Lexical Variation in Tyne and Wear: A Discussion of How the Traditional Dialect Terms
Lad and Lass are Still Used in the Modern Urban Dialects of Newcastle upon Tyne and
Sunderland”. English
Today 281: 10–22.
Beeching, Kate. 2011. “Sociolinguistic
Aspects of Lexical Variation in French”. In Tim Pooley, and Dominique Largorgette, eds. On
Linguistic Change in French: Sociohistorical
Approaches. Chambéry: University of Savoy Press, 37–54.
Beltrama, Andrea, and Laura Staum Casasanto. 2017. “Totally
Tall Sounds Totally Younger: Intensification at the Socio-Semantics Interface”. Journal of
Sociolinguistics 211: 154–182.
Block, David. 2015. “Social
Class in Applied Linguistics”. Annual Review of
Linguistics 351: 1–19.
Boberg, Charles. 2004. “Real
and Apparent Time in Language Change: Late Adoption of Changes in Montreal English”. American
Speech 791: 250–269.
Bourdieu, Pierre. 1984. Distinction. London: Routledge.
Britain, David. 2012. “Countering
the Urbanist Agenda in Variationist Sociolinguistics: Dialect Contact, Demographic Change and the Rural-Urban
Dichotomy”. In Sandra Hansen, Christian Schwarz, Phillip Stoeckle, and Tobias Streck, eds. Dialectological
and Folk Dialectological Concepts of
Space. Berlin: Mouton, 12–30.
Britain, David. 2017. “Which
Way to Look? Perspectives on ‘Urban’ and ‘Rural’ in
Dialectology”. In Chris Montgomery, and Emma Moore, eds. Language
and a Sense of Place. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 171–188.
Brown, Roger. 1965. Social
Psychology. New York: Free Press.
Buckle, Richard. 1978. U
and Non-U Revisited. London: Debrett’s Peerage.
Campbell-Kibler, Kathryn. 2007. “Accent,
(ING), and the Social Logic of Listener Perceptions”. American
Speech 821: 32–64.
Crystal, David. 2019. The
Cambridge Encyclopedia of the English Language (3rd
ed.). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Cunningham, Niall. 2019. “Making
and Mapping Britain’s ‘New Ordinary’ Elite”. Urban
Geography 401: 604–626.
Dailey-O’Cain, Jennifer. 2000. “The
Sociolinguistic Distribution of and Attitudes towards Focuser Like and Quotative
Like
”. Journal of
Sociolinguistics 41: 60–80.
Dann, Holly. 2019. “Productions
and Perceptions of bath and trap Vowels in Cornish English”. Unpublished
Ph.D. thesis, University of Sheffield.
Dodsworth, Robin. 2009. “Modelling
Socioeconomic Class in Variationist Sociolinguistics”. Language and Linguistics
Compass 31: 1314–1327.
Fletcher, Thomas, and Katherine Dashper. 2013. “‘Bring
on the Dancing Horses!’ Ambivalence and Class Obsession within British Media Reports of the Dressage at London
2012”. Sociological Research
Online 181: 118–125.
Foulkes, Paul, and Gerard J. Docherty. 2000. “Another
Chapter in the Story of /r/: ‘Labiodental’ Variants in British English”. Journal of
Sociolinguistics 41: 30–59.
Fox, Kate. 2004. Watching
the English: The Hidden Rules of English Behaviour. St. Ives: Clays.
Grieve, Jack, Chris Montgomery, Andrea Nini, Akira Murakami, and Diansheng Guo. 2019. “Mapping
Lexical Dialect Variation in British English Using Twitter”. Frontiers in Artificial
Intelligence 21 (accessed July 12, 2022).
Halfacre, Caitlin, and Ghada Khattab. 2019. “North-South
Dividers in Privately Educated Speakers: A Sociolinguistic Study of Received Pronunciation Using the foot-strut and
trap-bath Distinctions in the North East and South East of
England”. In Sasha Calhoun, Paola Escudero, Marija Tabain, and Paul Warren, eds. Proceedings
of the 19th International Congress of Phonetic
Sciences, 2665–2669.
Hecht, Katharina, Daniel McArthur, Mike Savage, and Sam Friedman. 2020. “Elites
in the UK: Pulling Away? Social Mobility, Geographic Mobility and Elite
Occupations”. January 2020 (accessed February 9, 2023. 〈[URL]〉
Himelfield, Dave. 2018. “Do
You Talk Posh? Take our Quiz to See if you Speak with Fancy Upper-Class Words – or those Used by the Rest of
us”. The Mirror. 〈[URL]〉 (accessed June 20, 2021)
Honey, John. 1985. “Acrolect
and Hyperlect: The Redefinition of English RP”. English
Studies 661: 241–257.
Ito, Rika, and Sali A. Tagliamonte. 2003. “Well
Weird, Right Dodgy, Very Strange, Really Cool: Layering and Recycling in English
Intensifiers”. Language in
Society 321: 257–279.
Jansen, Sandra. 2017. “Change
and Stability in goose, goat, and foot: Back Vowel Dynamics in Carlisle
English”. English Language and
Linguistics 231: 1–29.
Johnson, Ellen. 1993. “The
Relationship between Lexical Variation and Lexical Change”. Language Variation and
Change 51: 285–303.
Kerswill, Paul. 2009. “Language
and Social Class”. In Jonathan Culpeper, Francis Katamba, Paul Kerswill, Anthony McEnery, Ruth Wodak, and Tony McEnery, eds. English
Language. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, 358–372.
Labov, William. 1966. The
Social Stratification of English in New York. Washington D.C: Center for Applied Linguistics.
Labov, William. 1972. Sociolinguistic
Patterns. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
Labov, William. 1990. “The
Intersection of Sex and Social Class in the Course of Linguistic Change”. Language Variation
and Change 21: 205–254.
Labov, William. 2001. Principles
of Linguistic Change: Social
Factors. Oxford: Wiley.
Lambert, Wallace E., Richard C. Hodgson, Robert C. Gardner, and Samuel Fillenbaum. 1960. “Evaluational
Reactions to Spoken Languages”. The Journal of Abnormal and Social
Psychology 601: 44–51.
Lenth, Russell. V. 2021. Emmeans: Estimated Marginal Means, aka
Least-Squares Means. R package version 1.6.1. 〈[URL]〉 (accessed February 23, 2023)
Luhman, Reid. 1990. “Appalachian
English Stereotypes: Language Attitudes in Kentucky”. Language in
Society 191: 331–348.
Macaulay, Ronald K. S. 1977. Language, Social Class, and
Education. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
Macaulay, Ronald K. S. 2005. Talk That Counts: Age, Gender, and
Social Class Differences in Discourse. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
MacKenzie, Laurel, George Bailey, and Danielle Turton. 2016. “How
do People Refer to the Item of Furniture Pictured here?” 〈[URL]〉 (accessed May 17, 2022)
Malarski, Kamil. 2021. Loss
of Rhoticity in South-West England. Unpublished Ph.D
thesis. Poznań: Adam Mickiewicz University
Ng, Jia C. and Chloe Diskin-Holdaway. 2023. “Attitudes
towards English in Contemporary Malaysia”. World
Englishes 421: 562–578.
OED
Online. Oxford: Oxford University Press [URL] (accessed 29 November
2022).
Rampton, Ben. 2010. “Social
Class and Sociolinguistics”. Applied Linguistics
Review 11: 1–22.
Robinson, Justina. A. 2010. “Semantic Variation and Change
in Present-Day English”. Unpublished Ph.D. thesis, University of Sheffield.
Romaine, Suzanne. 2008. “Corpus
Linguistics and Sociolinguistics”. In Anke Lüdeling, and Merja Kytö, eds. Corpus
Linguistics: An International
Handbook. Berlin: Mouton, 96–111.
Ross, Alan S. C. 1954. “Linguistic Class-Indicators
in Present-Day English”. Neuphilologische
Mitteilungen 551: 113–149.
Sandow, Rhys J. 2021. “Anglo-Cornish Dialect Lexis:
Variation, Change, and Social Meaning”. Unpublished Ph.D.
thesis, University of Sussex.
Sandow, Rhys J. 2022. “Attention, Identity and
Linguistic Capital. Inverted Style-Shifting in Anglo-Cornish Dialect Lexis”. English Language
and Linguistics 261: 677–695.
Sandow, Rhys J. 2023b. “An Emmet’s Tale: The Duality
of Lexical and Social Change”. Language and
Communication 931: 15–29.
Sandow, Rhys J. fc. “Interpreting Identity
Effects in Sociolinguistic Variation and Change: The Role of Identity in the Usage and Recognition of Anglo-Cornish Dialect
Lexis”. To appear in the Journal of English
Linguistics.
Sandow, Rhys J., George Bailey, and Natalie Braber. 2023. “Language
Change is Wicked: Semantic and Social Meaning of a Polysemous Adjective”. English Language and
Linguistics. (accessed January 30,
2024).
Savage, Mike. 2007. “Changing
Social Class Identities in Post-War Britain: Perspectives from Mass-Observation”. Sociological
Research Online 121: 14–26.
Savage, Mike, Fiona Devine, Niall Cunningham, Mark Taylor, Yaojun Li, Johs Hjellbrekke, Brigitte Le Roux, Sam Friedman, and Andrew Miles. 2013. “A
New Model of Social Class? Findings from the BBC’s Great British Class Survey
Experiment”. Sociology 471: 219–250.
Shi, Yaqian, and Lei Lei. 2021. “Lexical
Use and Social Class: A Study of Lexical Richness, Word Length, and Word Class in Spoken
English”. Lingua 2621, 103155.
Snell, Julia. 2018. “Solidarity,
Stance, and Class Identities”. Language in
Society 471: 665–691.
Stuart-Smith, Jane, Claire Timmins, and Fiona Tweedie. 2013. “‘Talkin’
Jockney’? Variation and Change in Glaswegian Accent”. Journal of
Sociolinguistics 111: 221–260.
Tagliamonte, Sali A., and Julian Brooke. 2014. “A
Weird (Language) Tale: Variation and Change in the Adjectives of Strangeness”. American
Speech 891: 4–41.
Tagliamonte, Sali A., and Katharina Pabst. 2020. “A
Cool Comparison: Adjectives of Positive Evaluation in Toronto, Canada and York,
England”. Journal of English
Linguistics 481: 3–30.
Trudgill, Peter. 1972. “Sex,
Covert Prestige and Linguistic Change in the Urban British English of Norwich”. Language in
Society 11: 179–195.
Trudgill, Peter. 1974. The
Social Differentiation of English in
Norwich. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Tyler, Imogen. 2008. “‘Chav
Mum Chav Scum’: Class Disgust in Contemporary Britain”. Feminist Media
Studies 81: 17–34.
Van Doesum, Niels J., Joshua M. Tybur, and Paul A. M. Van Lange. 2017. “Class
Impressions: Higher Social Class Elicits Lower Prosociality”. Journal of Experimental
Psychology 681: 11–20.
Victor, Tom. 2017. “If
you Use these 27 Words it Proves that you’re Definitely not
Posh”. ShortList. 〈[URL]〉 (accessed September 21, 2020).
Watt, Dominic. 2002. “‘I
don’t Speak with a Geordie Accent, I Speak, like, the Northern Accent’: Contact-Induced Levelling in the Tyneside Vowel
System”. Journal of
Sociolinguistics 61: 44–63.
Williams, Anne, and Paul Kerswill. 1999. “Dialect
Levelling: Change and Continuity in Milton Keynes, Reading, and
Hull”. In Paul Foulkes and Gerard Doherty, eds. Urban
Voices. London: Routledge, 141–162.