Visible movements of the orofacial area
Evidence for gestural or multimodal theories of language evolution?
Sławomir Wacewicz | Nicolaus Copernicus University
Przemysław Żywiczyński | Maria Curie-Sklodowska University
The age-old debate between the proponents of the gesture-first and speech-first positions has returned to occupy a central place in current language evolution theorizing. The gestural scenarios, suffering from the problem known as “modality transition” (why a gestural system would have changed into a predominantly spoken system), frequently appeal to the gestures of the orofacial area as a platform for this putative transition. Here, we review currently available evidence on the significance of the orofacial area in language evolution. While our review offers some support for orofacial movements as an evolutionary “bridge” between manual gesture and speech, we see the evidence as far more consistent with a multimodal approach. We also suggest that, more generally, the “gestural versus spoken” formulation is limiting and would be better expressed in terms of the relative input and interplay of the visual and vocal-auditory sensory modalities.
Keywords: multimodality, speech-first, gesture-first, hand-to-mouth links, visual-vocal redundancy, orofacial gestures, Gestural Primacy Hypothesis, evolution of language, mouth gestures, tongue gestures, orofacial movements
Published online: 19 July 2016
https://doi.org/10.1075/gest.15.2.05wac
https://doi.org/10.1075/gest.15.2.05wac
References
Ackermann, Hermann & Wolfram Ziegler
Arbib, Michael
Armstrong, David, William C. Stokoe, & Sherman E. Wilcox
Armstrong, David & Sherman Wilcox
August, Peter & John Anderson
Bard, Kim A
Bauer, Harold R
Bavelas, Janet B. & Nicole Chovil
Bergman, Thore J
Birdwhistell, Raymond L
Bolhuis, Johan J., Ian Tattersall, Noam Chomsky, & Robert C. Berwick
Bosman, Conrado, Vladimir Lopes, & Francisco Aboitz
Browman, Catherine P. & Louis Goldstein
Brunner, Lawrence J
Buccino, Giovanni, Ferdinand Binkofski, & Lucia Riggio
Call, Josep & Malinda Carpenter
Capek, Cheryl M., Dafydd Waters, Bencie Woll, Mairéad MacSweeney, Michael J. Brammer, Philip K. McGuire, Anthony S. David, & Ruth Campbell
Chevalier-Skolnikoff, Suzanne
Chibelushi, Claude C., Farzin Deravi, & John S.D. Mason
Chovil, Nicole
Clark, Nathaniel & Marcus Perlman
Clay, Zanna & Klaus Zuberbühler
Collins, Christopher
Corballis, Michael C
Coudé, Gino, Pier Francesco Ferrari, Francesco Rodà, Monica Maranesi, Eleonora Borelli, Vania Veroni, Fabio Monti, Stefano Rozzi, & Leonardo Fogassi
Cowley, Stephen J
Donald, Merlin
Dor, Daniel, Chris Knight, & Jerome Lewis
Eberl, Eva
Eccardt, Thomas
Ekman, Paul
Ekman, Paul & Wallace V. Friesen
Ekman, Paul, Wallace V. Friesen, & Joseph C. Hager
Enard, Wolfgang, Molly Przeworski, Simon E. Fisher, Cecilia S.L. Lai, Victor Wiebe, Takashi Kitano, Anthony P. Monaco, & Svante Pääbo
Fedurek, Pawel, Katie E. Slocombe, Jessica A. Hartel, & Klaus Zuberbühler
Ferrari, Pier F., Vittorio Gallese, Giacomo Rizzolatti, & Leonardo Fogassi
Fitch, W. Tecumseh, Mark D. Hauser, & Noam Chomsky
Forrester, Gillian & Alina Rodriguez
Fridlund, Alan J
Galantucci, Bruno, Carol A. Fowler, & M.T. Turvey
Gardner, R. Allen & Beatrice T. Gardner
Gazzola, Valeria, Lisa Aziz-Zadeh, & Christian Keysers
Gentilucci, Maurizio & Michael C. Corballis
Gentilucci, Maurizio & Riccardo Dalla Volta
Ghazanfar, Asif A. & Nikos K. Logothetis
Ghazanfar, Asif & David Lewkowicz
Ghazanfar, Asif A., Daniel Y. Takahashi, Neil Mathur, & Tecumseh Fitch
Gillespie-Lynch, Kristen, Patricia M. Greenfield, Heidi Lyn, & Sue Savage-Rumbaugh
Goffman, Erving
Gogate, Lakshmi J. & Lorraine E. Bahrick
Goldin-Meadow, Susan
Goldin-Meadow, Susan & Melissa A. Singer
Goldin-Meadow, Susan, Wing Chee So, Aslı Özyürek, & Carolyn Mylander
Grice, H. Paul
Harpham, Geoffrey G
Hauser, Marc D
Hauser, Mark D., Noam Chomsky, & W. Tecumseh Fitch
Hawhee, Debra
Hewes, Gordon W
Higginbotham, David R., Matthew I. Isaak, & James N. Domingue
Hinde, Robert & Thelma Rowell
Hobaiter, Catherine & W. Byrne Richard
Hockett, Charles. F
Hockett, Charles F. & Stuart A. Altmann
Hooff, Jan van
Imai, Mitsumi & Sotaro Kita
Jiang, Jintao, Abeer Alwan, Patricia A. Keating, Edward T. Auer Jr., & Lynne E. Bernstein
Johansson, Sverker
Kegl, Judy, Ann Senghas, & Marie Coppola
Kendon, Adam
Kendon
Kohler, Evelyne, Christian Keysers, M. Alessandra Umilta, Leonrado Fogassi, Vittorio Gallese, & Giacomo Rizzolatti
Langacker, Ronald
Leavens, David A., Jamie L. Russell, & William D. Hopkins
Leavens, David, Jared Taglialatela, & William Hopkins
(2014) From grasping to grooming to gossip: innovative use of chimpanzee signals in novel environments supports both vocal and gestural theories of language origins. In Marco Pina & Nathalie Gontier (Eds.), The evolution of social communication in primates: A multidisciplinary approach (pp. 179–194). New York: Springer. 

Le Cabec, Adeline, Philipp Gunz, Kornelius Kupczik, José Braga, & Jean-Jacques Hublin
Levinson, Steven C. & Judith Holler
Lewis, Jerome
Liberman, Alvin, Franklin Cooper, Donald Shankweiler, & Michael Studdert-Kennedy
Liberman, Alvin M. & Ignatius G. Mattingly
Liberman, Alvin M. & Doug H. Whalen
Liebal, Katja, Bridget M. Waller, Anne M. Burrows, & Katie E. Slocombe
Linell, Per
Liszkowski, Ulf
Little, Anthony C., Benedict C. Jones, Corri Waitt, Bernard P. Tiddeman, David R. Feinberg, David I. Perrett, Coren L. Apicella, & Frank W. Marlowe
Little, Anthony C., Benedict C. Jones, & Lisa M. DeBruine
MacNeilage, Peter F. & Barbara L. Davies
Matsumoto-Oda, Akiko & Masaki Tomonaga
in press). Why we gesture: The surprising role of the hands in communication. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
McNeill, David, Susan D. Duncan, Jonathan Cole, Shaun Gallagher, & Bennett Bertenthal
Marcus, Garry F. & Simon E. Fisher
Meguerditchian, Adrien, Hélène Cochet, & Jacques Vauclair
(2011) From gesture to language: ontogenetic and phylogenetic perspectives on gestural communication and its cerebral lateralization. In Anne Vilain, Jean-Luc Schwartz, Christian Abry, & Jacques Vauclair (Eds.), Primate communication and human language: vocalization, gestures, imitation and deixis in humans and non-humans (pp. 89–118). Amsterdam: John Benjamins. 

Meguerditchian, Adrien, Marie Plouvier, Jill Pruetz, & William Hopkins
(2014) From hand to mouth: fine precision grip during mutual grooming elicited wide lip movements in wild fongoli chimpanzees. In Erica Cartmill, Sean Roberts, Heidi Lyn, & Hannah Cornish (Eds.), The evolution of language. Proceedings of the 10th International Conference (EVOLANG 10) (pp. 487–488). Singapore: World Scientific.
Meguerditchian, Adrien & Jacques Vauclair
Morton, Eugene S
Mühlenbernd, Roland, Dankmar Enke, Matthias Villing, Natalja Gavrilov, & Jonas David Nick
Orzechowski, Sylwester, Sławomir Wacewicz, & Przemysław Żywiczyński
Özyürek, Aslı
Paget, Richard A.S
Parr, Lisa A
Parr, Lisa A. & Frans B.M. de Waal
Parr, Lisa A. & Bridget M. Waller
Parr, Lisa A., Matthew Heintz, Elizabeth Lonsdorf, & Emily Wroblewski
Petrides, Michael, Geneviève Cadoret, & Scott Mackey
Petrides, Michael & Deepak N. Pandya
Pyers, Jennie E. & Karen Emmorey
Ravizza, Susan
Ricci Bitti, Pio & Isabella Poggi
Roll, Patrice, Gabrielle Rudolf, Sandrine Pereira, Barbara Royer, Ingrid E. Scheffer, Annick Massacrier, Maria-Paola Valenti, Nathalie Roeckel-Trevisiol, Sarah Jamali, Christophe Beclin, Caroline Seegmuller, Marie-Noëlle Metz-Lutz, Arnaud Lemainque, Marc Delepine, Christophe Caloustian, Anne de Saint Martin, Nadine Bruneau, Danièle Depétris, Marie-Geneviève Mattéi, Elisabeth Flori, Andrée Robaglia-Schlupp, Nicolas Lévy, Bernd A. Neubauer, Rivka Ravid, Christian Marescaux, Samuel F. Berkovic, Edouard Hirsch, Mark Lathrop, Pierre Cau, & Pierre Szepetowski
Sandler, Wendy
Sereno, Martin
Sia, Gek-Ming, Roger Clem, & Richard Huganir
Skipper, Jeremy
Slocombe, Katie E., Bridget M. Waller, & Katja Liebal
Sperber, Dan & Deirdre Wilson
Stam, James H
Steklis, Horst & Stevan R. Harnad
Studdert-Kennedy, Michael
Sueyoshi, Ayano & Debra M. Hardison
Summerfield, Quentin
Sutton, Dwight
Sweet, Henry
(1888) A history of English sounds from the earliest period, with full word-lists. Oxford: Clarendon (retrieved from https://archive.org/details/ahistoryenglish05sweegoog).
Taglialatela, Jared P., Jamie L. Russell, Jennifer A. Schaeffer, & William D. Hopkins
Taglialatela, Jared P., Jamie L. Russell, Sarah M. Pope, Tamara Morton, Stephanie Bogart, Lisa A. Reamer, Steven J. Schapiro, & William D. Hopkins
Tallerman, Maggie
Tallerman, Maggie, & Kathleen Gibson
Vainio, Lari, Mikko Tiainen, Kaisa Tiippana, & Martti Vainio
Vargha-Khadem, Faraneh, Kate E. Watkins, C.J. Price, John Ashburner, Katie J. Alcock, Alan Connelly, Richard S.J. Frackowiak, Karl J. Friston, M.E. Pembrey, Mortimer Mishkin, David G. Gadian, & Richard E. Passingham
Vigliocco, Gabriella, Pamela Perniss, & David Vinson
Vygotsky, Lev S
Wacewicz, Sławomir & Przemysław Żywiczyński
Waters, Gabriel S. & Roger S. Fouts
Watkins, Kate & Tomáš Paus
Watson, Stuart K., Simon W. Townsend, Anne M. Schel, Claudia Wilke, Emma K. Wallace, Leveda Cheng, Victoria West, & Katie Slocombe
Woll, Bencie
Yehia, Hani, Philip Rubin, & Eric Vatikiotis-Bateson
Yehia, Hani C., Takaaki Kuratate, & Eric Vatikiotis-Bateson
Zimmermann, Elke, Lisette Leliveld, & Simone Schehka
(2013) Toward the evolutionary roots of affective prosody in human acoustic communication: A comparative approach to mammalian voices. In Eckart Altenmüller, Sabine Schmidt, & Elke Zimmermann (Eds.), Evolution of emotional communication: From sounds in nonhuman mammals to speech and music in man (pp. 116–132). Oxford: Oxford University Press. 

Cited by
Cited by 10 other publications
Dediu, Dan, Rick Janssen & Scott R. Moisik
Mortazavi, Mohsen & Afshin Davarpanah
Vainio, Lari
Wacewicz, Sławomir & Przemyslaw Zywiczynski
Wacewicz, Sławomir, Przemysław Żywiczyński & Alessandra Chiera
Zlatev, Jordan, Sławomir Wacewicz, Przemyslaw Zywiczynski & Joost van de Weijer
Zywiczynski, Przemyslaw, Nathalie Gontier & Slawomir Wacewicz
Żywiczyński, Przemysław & Sławomir Wacewicz
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 09 april 2022. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers. Any errors therein should be reported to them.