Article published In:
Historiographia Linguistica: Online-First Articles

Misquoting the ancients

Editorial practices in the Kangxi zidian

 | Zhejiang University
The Kangxi zidian 康熙字典 [Kangxi Dictionary] was without doubt the most influential and widely used dictionary in China during the past three centuries, and its impact on education, scholarship, and intellectual life in general, cannot be overstated. The dictionary’s compilation was a major step in the development of Chinese lexicography, and it has been at the foundation of all large dictionary projects ever since. This paper addresses the editors’ tendency to misquote and misattribute quotations, which has been among the most commonly criticized issues. My aim here is not to identify further mistakes but to document the patterns of misquotations, as these can help understand the process of the dictionary’s compilation. One noteworthy find is that in many cases members of the editorial team quoted their sources indirectly, relying on more recent encyclopedias and miscellanea.
Article outline
  • 1.Introduction
  • 2.The dictionary
  • 3.Mistakes of attribution
  • 4.Inaccurate quoting
  • 5.Conclusions
  • Notes
  • References
  • Primary sources
  • Secondary sources
Published online: 25 October 2024
DOI logo
https://doi.org/10.1075/hl.00154.gal
References (38)
References
A. Primary sources
Fang, Yizhi 方以智. 1990 [1636]. Tongya 通雅 [Comprehensive Eloquence]. Beijing: Zhongguo shudian.Google Scholar
Ge, Hong 葛洪. 1993 [d. u.]. Xijing zaji 西京雜記 [Miscellaneous Notes of the Western Capital]. Cheng Lin 成林 and Cheng Zhangcan 程章燦, tr. Xijing zaji quanyi 西京雜記全譯. Guiyang: Guizhou renmin chubanshe.Google Scholar
He, Kai 何楷. 1987 [d. u.]. Shijing shiben guyi 詩經世本古義 [Ancient Meanings of the Extant Editions of the Classic of Songs]. Siku quanshu 四庫全書, Shanghai: Shanghai guji chubanshe, v. 811.Google Scholar
Kong, Chuan 孔傳. 2015 [1134]. Dongjia zaji 東家雜記 [Miscellaneous Records of the Eastern Family]. 21 juan. Zhang Aifang 張愛芳, ed., Quzhou wenxian jicheng 衢州文献集成 [Collected Texts from Quzhou]. Beijing: Guojia tushuguan chubanshe, v. 221.Google Scholar
Pan, Zimu 潘自牧. 1987 [1209]. Jizuan yuanhai 記纂淵海 [The Deep Ocean of Records and Compilations]. Siku quanshu, Shanghai: Shanghai guji chubanshe, vols. 930–9321.Google Scholar
Peng, Dayi 彭大翼. 1595. Shantang sikao 山堂肆考. Supplemented and edited by Zhang Youxue 張幼學. Jinling: Jinling shulin.Google Scholar
Tao, Zongyi 陶宗儀. 1935–1936 [ca. 1400]. Chuogeng lu 輟耕錄 [Records of Resting from Ploughing]. Zhang Yuanji 張元濟 ed., Sibu congkan sanbian 四部叢刊三編, v. 372–3791. Shanghai: Shanghai shangwu yinshuguan.Google Scholar
Wang, Shizhen 王世貞. 1976 [1577]. Yanzhou shanren sibu gao 弇州山人四部稿 [Four-section Drafts of the Mountain Man of Yanzhou]. Taibei: Chuanwen tushu chubanshe.Google Scholar
Wang, Yinzhi 王引之. 1831. 字典考證 [Evidentiary Research on the Zidian]. Gaoyou: Airitang.Google Scholar
Wu, Chuhou 吳處厚. 1985 [1087]. Qingxiang zaji 青箱雜記 [Miscellaneous Notes from the Blue Box]. Beijing: Zhonghua shuju.Google Scholar
Xiong, Zhong 熊忠. 2000 [1297]. Gujin yunhui juyao 古今韻會舉要 [Essential Selection of Rhymes from Ancient and Modern Times]. Beijing: Zhonghua shuju.Google Scholar
Zhang, Ying 張英 and Wang Shizhen 王士禎. 1985 [1710]. Yuanjian leihan 淵鑑類函 [Categorized Boxes of the Yuanjian Studio]. Beijing: Zhongguo shudian.Google Scholar
Zhang, Yushu 張玉書 and Chen Tingjing 陳廷敬 , eds. 1716. Kangxi zidian 康熙字典 [Kangxi Dictionary]. Beijing: Wuyingdian.Google Scholar
B. Secondary sources
Andrews, Bridie. 2019. “Dictionaries and science in Republican China”. Twentieth-Century China 44:2. 206–222. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
App, Urs. 2010. The Birth of Orientalism. Philadelphia/Oxford: University of Pennsylvania Press. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Bottéro, Françoise. 1996. Sémantisme et classification dans l’écriture chinoise: les systèmes de classement des caractères par clés du Shuowen jiezi au Kangxi zidian. Paris: Institut des hautes études chinoises, Collège de France.Google Scholar
Brewer, Charlotte. 2007. Treasure-House of the Language: The Living OED. New Haven: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Chalmers, John. 1873–1874. “Kanghi’s dictionaries”. China Review 21. 335–341.Google Scholar
. 1878. Concise Dictionary of Chinese on the Basis of K’anghi. Canton: Guangdong Lundun jiaohui.Google Scholar
De Caro, Antonio. 2022. Angelo Zottoli, a Jesuit Missionary in China (1848 to 1902): His Life and Ideas. Singapore: Palgrave Macmillan. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Edkins, J. 1876. Introduction to the Study of the Chinese Characters. London: Trübner & Co.Google Scholar
Fourmont, Etienne. 1729. “Dissertation sur la littérature chinoise”. Histoire de l’Académie royale des inscriptions et belles lettres 51. 312–319.
Knechtges, David R. 2014. “ Xijing zaji 西京雜記 (Diverse Notes of the Western Capital)”. Ancient and Early Medieval Chinese Literature: A Reference Guide. Part Three ed. by David R. Knechtges & Taiping Chang, 1648–1655. Leiden & Boston: Brill. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Li, Man-kuei. 2010 [1943]. “Wang Yin-zhih 王引之.” Eminent Chinese of the Ch’ing Period, 1644–1912 ed. by Arthur H. Hummel, 841–842. Kent: Global Oriental.Google Scholar
Li, Rui & Annette Skovsted Hansen. 2018. “A Remarkable compilation shift: A genealogical study of Medhurst’s Chinese and English dictionary (1842–1843)”. Historiographia Linguistica 45:3. 263–288. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Leung, Cécile. 2002. Etienne Fourmont, 1683–1745: Oriental and Chinese Languages in Eighteenth-century France (= Leuven Chinese Studies, XIII). Leuven: Leuven University Press.Google Scholar
Medhurst, Walter Henry. 1842. Chinese and English Dictionary, Containing all the Words in the Chinese Imperial Dictionary, Arranged according to the Radicals. Batavia: Parapattan.Google Scholar
Morrison, Robert. 1815–1823. A Dictionary of the Chinese Language, in Three Parts. Macau: East India Company.Google Scholar
Nienhauser, William H., Jr. 1978. “Once again, the authorship of the Hsi-ching Tsa-chi (Miscellanies of the Western Capital)”. Journal of American Oriental Society 981. 219–236. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Pei, Mengsu 裴夢蘇 and Li, Wuwei 李無未. 2015. “Riben xuezhe dui Kangxi zidian de jiaokan yu zhushi” 日本學者對《康熙字典》的校勘與注釋. [Corrections and Annotations of Japanese Scholars to the Kangxi zidian ]. Cishu yanjiu 辭書研究 [The study of Dictionaries] 21. 69–75.Google Scholar
Sun, Yuanyuan 孫園園. 2010. “ Kangxi zidian zhengyin Liji shiwu” 《康熙字典》征引《禮記》拾誤. [Collected Errors in the Kangxi zidian’s Quotations from the Liji ]. Wenjiao ziliao 文教資料 [Cultural and Educational Material] 361. 23–26.Google Scholar
. 2019. “China, c. 600–1700.” The Cambridge World History of Lexicography ed. by John Considine, 109–129. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Wang, Li 王力. 1989. Wang Li wenji 王力文集. [Collected Writings of Wang Li]. Jinan: Shandong jiaoyu chubanshe.Google Scholar
Watanabe, On 渡部温. 1872. Tsūzoku Isoppu monogatari 通俗伊蘇普物語. [Popular Version of Aesop’s Fables]. Tokyo.Google Scholar
Xu, Hui 徐慧. 2009. “ Kangxi zidian yinshu yiwu julie” 《康熙字典》引書疑誤舉例. [Examples of Incorrect Quotations in the Kangxi zidian ]. Caizhi 才智 [Talent and Wisdom] 221. 198–199.Google Scholar
Yang, Ruifang 楊瑞芳. 2021. “ Kangxi zidian dongchuan Chaoxian bandao tujing kaoshu” 《康熙字典》東傳朝鮮半島途徑考述 [The Channels along which the Kangxi zidian Spread to Korea]. Hanji yu hanxue 漢籍與漢學 [Chinese Texts and Sinology] 11. 22–34.Google Scholar
Zurndorfer, Harriet T. 2012. “Women in Chinese encyclopedias”. Overt and Covert Treasures: Essays on the Sources for Chinese Women’s History ed. by Clara Wing-chung Ho, 279–306. Hong Kong: Chinese University of Hong Kong Press. DOI logoGoogle Scholar