Cover not available
Article In:
International Journal of Chinese Linguistics
Vol. 11:2 (2024) ► pp.282–320

崔世珍笔下的明代中期北京话

ORCID logo |
崔世珍（1468－1542）著述宏富，记录和讨论了大量明代中期的北京话词汇和语音现象。当时正处于南北官话融合的关键阶段，而反映北京话的本土资料却阙如，因此他所记录的北京口语资料是独一无二的，对于研究北京话形成史具有极高的价值。文章主要讨论四个问题：（1）崔世珍所记是不是北京话；（2）崔世珍所记资料的特点；（3）从崔世珍所记看明代中期南北官话词汇的融合；（4）明代中期的北京话词汇在现代北京话里的留存与消亡。
Keywords: 崔世珍, 明代中期, 北京话, 词汇, 语音
Article outline
  • 一、绪论
  • 二、崔世珍所记是不是北京话
    • 第一， “崔世珍们”学习汉语口语的目的。
    • 第二， 崔世珍是有机会到北京去“质正”的。
    • 第三， 不得已而去辽东质正，也是向精通汉语的硕学鸿儒质正，而不是一般的辽东人。
    • 第四， 除了面对面质正学习外，崔世珍还拥有丰富的书面资料可供参考。
  • 三、崔世珍所记资料的特点
  • 四、从崔世珍所记看明代中期南北官话词汇的融合
    • 1.沿用大都话
    • 2.大都话被淘汰
    • 3.融入南方话
      • 例1 立－站
      • 例2 赤根菜－菠䔖菜/菠菜
      • 例3 伴当－火伴/舍人
  • 五、明代中期的北京话词汇在现代北京话里的留存与消亡
  • 致谢
  • 笔记
  • Author queries
  • 参考文献
This content is being prepared for publication; it may be subject to changes.

Article language: Chinese

References (73)
参考文献
Chen, Li 陈莉 (2006). “Xunshipinghua” cihui yanjiu 训世评话词汇研究 [Vocabulary Study of ‘Xunshipinghua’]. Nanjingdaxue shuoshi xuewei lunwen 南京大学硕士学位论文 [Nanjing University Master’s Thesis].
Ding, Feng 丁锋 (1995). Liuhanduiyin yu Mingdai guanhuayin yanjiu 琉汉对音与明代官话音研究 [Study on the Phonetic Comparison between Ryukyuan and Mandarin of the Ming Dynasty]. Beijing: China Social Sciences Press.Google Scholar
(2008). Rihan liuhan duiyin yu Mingqing guanhuayin yanjiu 日汉琉汉对音与明清官话音研究 [Phonetic Comparison of Japanese, Ryukyuan, and Study of Ming-Qing Dynasty Mandarin]. Beijing: Zhonghua Book Company.Google Scholar
Dong, Jianjiao 董建交 (2007). “Sishengtongjie” ciyu zhaji 四声通解词语札记 [Notes on the Words in ‘Sishengtongjie’]. Zhongguoxue Yanjiu 中国学研究 [Sinology Studies] 101.Google Scholar
Dong, Shuren 董树人 (2010). Xinbian Beijing fangyan cidian 新编北京方言词典 [New Compilation of Beijing Dialect Dictionary]. Beijing: The Commercial Press.Google Scholar
(2023). Beijinghua cidian 北京话词典 [Beijing Dialect Dictionary]. Beijing: The Commercial Press.Google Scholar
Endo, Mitsuaki 远藤光晓 (1984). “Fanyilaoqida·piaotongshi” li de hanyu shengdiao 翻译老乞大·朴通事里的汉语声调 [The Chinese Tones in ‘Fanyilaoqida·piaotongshi’]. Yuyanxue luncong 语言学论丛 [Essays on Linguistics] 131.Google Scholar
Geng, Zhensheng 耿振生 (2007). Cong lishi shang de renkou bianqian kan jindai Beijinghua de dishan yanxu 从历史上的人口变迁看近代北京话的递嬗延续 [The Continuity of Modern Beijing Dialect from the Perspective of Historical Population Changes]. Jindai guanhua yuyin yanjiu 近代官话语音研究 [Research on Early Mandarin Phonology].Google Scholar
(2007). Jindai guanhua yuyin yanjiu 近代官话语音研究 [A Study on the Phonology of Early Mandarin]. Beijing: Language & Culture Press.Google Scholar
Guo, Rui 郭锐, Zhai, Yun 翟赟 and Xu, Jingjing 徐菁菁 (2017). Hanyu putonghua cong nali lai? — cong nanbei guanhua chayi kan putonghua cihui, yufa laiyuan 汉语普通话从哪里来？——从南北官话差异看普通话词汇、语法来源 [Where Does Mandarin Come From? — A Look at the Vocabulary and Grammar Origins from the Differences between Northern and Southern Mandarin]. Zhongguo yanyu wenhuaxue yanjiu 中国言语文化学研究 [Journal of Chinese Language and Culture] 61.Google Scholar
He, Liang 何亮 (2023). Hanyu fangyan “bangwan”, “yewan” yi shiwei yusu de gongshi fenbu yu lishi kaocha 汉语方言傍晚、夜晚义时位语素的共时分布与历时考察 [Synchronic and Diachronic Examination of the ‘evening and night’ in Chinese Dialects]. 待刊 [to be published].Google Scholar
(2017). Hanyu fangyan rinei shijian de biaoda geju jiqi chengyin tanxi 汉语方言日内时间的表达格局及其成因探析 [Analysis of the Patterns and Causes for Expressing Time of Day in Chinese Dialects]. Hanyushi xuebao 汉语史学报 [Journal of Chinese Language History] 171.Google Scholar
Hirata, Shouji 平田昌司 (2016). Wenhua zhidu he hanyushi 文化制度和汉语史 [Cultural Systems and Chinese Language History]. Beijing: Peking University Press.Google Scholar
Iwata, Ray 岩田礼 (2009). Hanyu fangyan jieshi ditu 汉语方言解释地图 [The Interpretative Maps of Chinese Dialects]. Tykyo: Hakuteisha.Google Scholar
(2012). Hanyu fangyan jieshi ditu (xuji) 汉语方言解释地图(续集) [The Interpretative Maps of Chinese Dialects Volume Two]. Tykyo: Kohbun Shuppan.Google Scholar
Jerry, Norman 罗杰瑞 (2004). Guanyu guanhua fangyan zaoqi fazhan de yixie xiangfa 关于官话方言早期发展的一些想法 [Some Thoughts on the Early Development of Mandarin]. Fangyan 方言 [Dialect] 41.Google Scholar
Ji, Yonghai 季永海 (1999). Hanyu “erhuayin” de fasheng yu fazhan — jian yu Li Sijing xiansheng shangque 汉语儿化音的发生与发展——兼与李思敬先生商榷 [The Emergence and Development of the ‘Erhua’ Sound in Chinese — A Discussion with Mr. Li Sijing]. Minzu yuwen 民族语文 [Minority Languages of China] 51.Google Scholar
Jin, Jishi 金基石 (2006). Cui Shizhen yu Hanguo Lichao shiqi de hanyuwen jiaoyu 崔世珍与韩国李朝时期的汉语文教育 [Cui Shizhen and Chinese Teaching in Korean Li Dynasty]. Hanyu xuexi 汉语学习 [Chinese Language Learning] 61.Google Scholar
Li, Dechun 李得春 (2003). Chaoxian wangchao de hanyu yanjiu jiqi zhuoyao chengguo 朝鲜王朝的汉语研究及其主要成果 [The Study of Chinese in Joseon Dynasty and Their Main Achievements]. Minzu yuwen 民族语文 [Minority Languages of China] 61.Google Scholar
Li, Rong 李荣 (2012). Wenzi wenti 文字问题 [Issues on Characters]. Beijing: The Commercial Press.Google Scholar
Li, Shunmei 李顺美 (2009). Shi “jiaotou” “kong” “jia” 释“角头”“控”“家” [An Explanation on “jiaotou” “kong” and “jia”]. Minzu yuwen 民族语文 [Minority Languages of China] 41.Google Scholar
(2011). “Laoqida”“Piaotongshi” changyong cihui yanjiu — yi “Laopiaojilan” wei zhongxin 老乞大朴通事常用词汇研究———以老朴集览为中心 [A Study on the Common Vocabulary of ‘Laoqida’ and ‘Piaotongshi’ — Centered on ‘Laopiaojilan’]. Fudandaxue boshi xuewei lunwen 复旦大学博士学位论文 [Fudan University Doctoral Dissertation].
Li, Wuwei 李无未 and Zhang, Hui 张辉 (2014). Chaoxianchao hanyu guanhua “zhizheng” zhidu kaolun — yi “Chaoxianwangchaoshilu” wei yiju 朝鲜朝汉语官话质正制度考论——以朝鲜王朝实录为依据 [A Study on Joseon Dynasty Chinese Mandarin “zhizheng” System-On the basis of the ‘Annals of the Joseon Dynasty’]. Guhanyu yanjiu 古汉语研究 [Research In Ancient Chinese Language] 11.Google Scholar
Li, Xinkui 李新魁 (1980). Lun jindai hanyu gongtongyu de biaozhunyin 论近代汉语共同语的标准音 [On the Standard Pronunciation of Modern Chinese Common Language]. Yuwen yanjiu 语文研究 [Linguistic Research] 11.Google Scholar
Lin, Tao 林焘 (1987). Beijing guanhua suyuan 北京官话溯源 [Tracing the Origins of Beijing Mandarin]. Zhongguo yuwen 中国语文 [Studies of the Chinese Language] 31.Google Scholar
Lin, Yimeng 林祎萌 (2023). Shuo fuci “hai” duyin de yanbian 说副词“还”读音的演变 [The Evolution of the Adverb “hai” Pronunciation]. 待刊 [to be published].Google Scholar
Liu, Chunlan 刘春兰 (2010). “Xunshipinghua” yufa yanjiu 训世评话语法研究 [Grammar Study of ‘Xunshipinghua’]. Nankaidaxue boshi xuewei lunwen 南开大学博士学位论文 [Nankai University Doctoral Dissertation].
Liu, Jian 刘坚 (1992). “Xunshipinghua” zhong suojian Mingdai qianqi hanyu de yixie tedian 训世评话中所见明代前期汉语的一些特点 [Some Characteristics of Early Ming Dynasty Chinese Observed in ‘Xunshipinghua’]. Zhongguo yuwen 中国语文 [Studies of the Chinese Language] 41.Google Scholar
Lu, Guoyao 鲁国尧 (1985). Mingdai guanhua jiqi jichu fangyan wenti — du “Limadouzhongguozhaji” 明代官话及其基础方言问题——读利玛窦中国札记 [Mandarin of the Ming Dynasty and Its Basic Dialect Issues — Reading ‘Matteo Ricci’s China Notes’]. Nanjingdaxue xuebao (zhexue renwenkexue shehuikexue） 南京大学学报（哲学·人文科学·社会科学） [Journal of Nanjing University(Philosophy, Humanities and Social Sciences)] 41.Google Scholar
(2007). Yanjiu Mingmo Qingchu guanhua jichu fangyan de nianer nian licheng — “cong zifeng li kan” dao “cong zimian shang kan” 研究明末清初官话基础方言的廿二年历程——“从字缝里看”到“从字面上看” [A Twenty-Two-Year Journey of Studying the Basic Dialects of Mandarin Chinese from the Late Ming to Early Qing Dynasties: From ‘Reading between the Lines’ to ‘Taking Things Literally’]. Jindai guanhua yuyin yanjiu 近代官话语音研究 [Research on Early Mandarin Phonology].Google Scholar
Lü, Shuxiang 吕叔湘 (1987). “Piaotongshi” li de zhidaici 朴通事里的指代词 [Pronouns in ‘Piaotongshi’]. Zhongguo yuwen 中国语文 [Studies of the Chinese Language] 61.Google Scholar
(1992). Jindai hanyu zhidaici 近代汉语指代词 [Early Chinese Pronouns]. Shanghai: Xuelin Publishing House.Google Scholar
Ota, Tatsuo 太田辰夫 (1994). “Yanshanconglu” ni miru mingdai Beijingyu 燕山丛录に见る明代北京语 [Ming Dynasty Beijing Dialect as Seen in the ‘Yanshanconglu’]. Zhongguoyu yanjiu 中国语研究 [Studies in the Chinese Language] 361.Google Scholar
(1991a). “Laoqidayanjie” “Piaotongshiyanjie” 老乞大谚解朴通事谚解 [‘Laoqidayanjie’ and ‘Piaotognshiyanjie’]. Hanyushi tongkao 汉语史通考 [Comprehensive Examination of Chinese Language History].Google Scholar
(1991b). “Xunshipinghua” de yuyan 训世评话的语言 [The Language of ‘Xunshipinghua’]. Zhongguoyu yanjiu 中国语研究 [Studies in the Chinese Language] 331.Google Scholar
(1991c). “Laopida” de yuyan 老乞大的语言 [The Language of ‘Laoqida’]. Hanyushi tongkao 汉语史通考 [Comprehensive Examination of Chinese Language History].Google Scholar
(1991d). Guanyu “haneryanyu” — shilun baihua fazhanshi 关于汉儿言语——试论白话发展史 [About “haneryanyu” — An Attempt to Discuss the History of Verbal Chinese Development]. Hanyushi tongkao 汉语史通考 [Comprehensive Examination of Chinese Language History].Google Scholar
(2003). Zhongguoyu lishi wenfa 中国语历史文法 [Historical Grammar of Chinese Language]. Beijing: Peking University Press.Google Scholar
Wang, Hongjun 王洪君, Guo, Rui 郭锐 and Liu, Yunzong 刘云总 (2018). Zaoqi Beijinghua zhenben dianji jiaoshi yu yanjiu 早期北京话珍本典籍校释与研究 [Annotated Research on Early Beijing Dialect Classics]. Beijing: Peking University Press.Google Scholar
Wang, Weihui 汪维辉 (2003). Guanyu “Xunshipinghua” wenben de ruogan wenti 关于训世评话文本的若干问题 [Some Problems on the Text of ‘Xunshipinghua’]. Yuyan yanjiu 语言研究 [Studies in Language and Linguistics] 41.Google Scholar
(2005a). Chaoxian shidai hanyu jiaokeshu congkan 朝鲜时代汉语教科书丛刊 [A Series of Chinese Language Textbooks in Joseon Dynasty]. Beijing: Zhonghua Book Company.Google Scholar
(2005b). “Laoqidayanjie” zhu banben suo fanying de jibenci lishi gengti 老乞大诸版本所反映的基本词历时更替 [The Diachronic Substitution of Basic Words in the Four Editions of ‘Laoqida’]. Zhongguo yuwen 中国语文 [Studies of the Chinese Language] 61.Google Scholar
(2006). Lun ci de shidaixing he diyuxing 论词的时代性和地域性 [On the Temporality and Regionality of Words]. Yuyan yanjiu 语言研究 [Studies in Language and Linguistics] 21.Google Scholar
(2011). “Laoqidayanjie”“Piaotongshiyanjie” yu “Xunshipinghua” de cihui chayi 老乞大谚解朴通事谚解与训世评话的词汇差异 [Word-use Difference between ‘Laoqidayanjie’‘Piaotongshiyanjie’ and ‘Xunshipinghua’]. Yuyan yanjiu 语言研究 [Studies in Language and Linguistics] 21.Google Scholar
(2016). Yuanming yidai yu xiandai hanyu minzugongtongyu de xingcheng 元明易代与现代汉语民族共同语的形成 [The Transition from Yuan to Ming Dynasty and the Formation of the Modern Chinese Common Language]. Yuyan zhanlve yanjiu 语言战略研究 [Chinese Journal of Language Policy and Planning] 41.Google Scholar
(2018). Jindai guanhua cihui xitong de xingcheng — yi “Xunshipinghua” yu “Laoqidayanjie” “Piaotongshiyanjie” de bijiao wei chufadian 近代官话词汇系统的形成——以训世评话与老乞大朴通事的比较为出发点 [The Formation of the Modern Mandarin Vocabulary System — Starting from a Comparison between ‘Xunshipinghua’ and ‘Laoqida’‘Piaotongshi’]. Nankai yuyan xuekan 南开语言学刊 [Nankai Linguistics] 11.Google Scholar
(2022a). Chaoxian shidai hanyu jiaokeshu shizhong huiji 朝鲜时代汉语教科书十种汇辑 [A Compilation of Ten Types of Chinese Language Textbooks in Joseon Dynasty]. Shanghai: Shanghai Educational Publishing House.Google Scholar
(2022b). Zai tan “gei” de laiyuan — yu Zhao Kuixin xiansheng shangque jian lun zici guanxi de fuzaxing 再谈“给(gěi)”的来源——与赵葵欣先生商榷兼论字词关系的复杂性 [The Origin of “gei” Revisited: A Discussion with Mrs. Zhao Kuixin and Some lssuesof the Complexity of the Character-word Relation]. Fangyan 方言 [Dialect] 31.Google Scholar
Wang, Weihui 汪维辉 and Akidani Hiroyuki 秋谷裕幸 (2010). Hanyu “zhanli” yi ci de xianzhuang yu lishi 汉语“站立”义词的现状与历史 [Synchronic Distribution and Diachronic Development of the Words with the Meaning “to stand” in Chinese]. Zhongguo yuwen 中国语文 [Studies of the Chinese Language] 41.Google Scholar
Wang, Weihui 汪维辉 and Ju, Minhui 具民惠 (2022). “赤根菜”与“시금치”——韩语中的汉语借词研究之一 [“chigencai” and “시금치” — A Study on Chinese Loanwords in Korean]. Yuyan yanjiu 语言研究 [Studies in Language and Linguistics] 11.Google Scholar
Wang, Weihui 汪维辉 and Xu, Junwei 许峻玮 (2018). “Yanshanconglu·changanliyu” zhong de wanming Beijinghua 燕山丛录·长安里语中的晚明北京话 [Late Ming Beijing Dialect in ‘Yanshanconglu·Changanliyu’]. Yuyanxue luncong 语言学论丛 [Essays on Linguistics] 581.Google Scholar
Yang, Jianqiao 杨剑桥 (2003). Chaoxian “Sishengtongjie” zai hanyushi yanjiu shang de jiazhi 朝鲜四声通解在汉语史研究上的价值 [The Value of Korean ‘Sishengtongjie’ in the Study of the History of the Chinese Language]. Fudan xuebao（shehuikexue ban） 复旦学报(社会科学版) [Fudan Journal(Social Sciences Edition)] 61.Google Scholar
Yao, Weijia 姚伟嘉 (2011). Mingkan “Baituji” cihui yufa zhuanti yanjiu 明刊白兔记词汇语法专题研究 [The Lexical and Grammatical Research on ‘Baituji’ published in Ming Dynasty]. Nanjingdaxue boshi xuewei lunwen 南京大学博士学位论文 [Nanjing University Doctoral Dissertation].
(2017). Chenghuaben “Baituji” zhong beifang suyuci zhaji 成化本白兔记中北方俗语词札记 [Notes on Northern Vernacular Words in the Chenghua Edition ‘Baituji’]. Zhongguoyuxue kaipian 中国语学·开篇 [Chinese Language Studies: Beginning] 351.Google Scholar
Yao, Xiaoping 姚小平 (2020). Jindai Beijinghua yu Nanjinghua: 17–19 shiji xishi bixia de beinan guanhua zhi zheng 近代北京话与南京话：17―19世纪西士笔下的北南官话之争 [Premodern Dialects of Beijing and Nanjing: Rivalry between the Two Major Branches of Mandarin as Described by Westerners during the 17–19th Centuries]. Zhongguo yuwen 中国语文 [Studies of the Chinese Language] 41.Google Scholar
Yin, Xiaojie 殷晓杰, Chen, Chunxue 陈春雪 and Chen, Ji a陈佳 (2017). Zai lun “zhu” yu “kuai(zi)” de lishi tihuan ji xiangguan wenti 再论“箸”与“筷(子)”的历时替换及相关问题 [Again on the Diachronic Replacement of “zhu” and “kuai(zi)” and Related Issues]. Hanyushi xuebao 汉语史学报 [Journal of Chinese Language History] 171.Google Scholar
Yu Chi, Zhiping 尉迟治平 (1990). “Laoqida Piaotongshi yanjie” hanziyin de yuyin jichu 老乞大、朴通事谚解汉字音的语音基础 [The Phonological Basis of Sino-Korean in ‘Laoqidayanjie’ and ‘Piaotongshiyanjie’]. Yuyan yanjiu 语言研究 [Studies in Language and Linguistics] 11.Google Scholar
Yu, Min 俞敏 (1984). Beijing yinxi de chengzhang he ta shou de zhouwei yingxiang 北京音系的成长和它受的周围影响 [The Growth of the Beijing Phonological System and Its External Influences]. Fangyan 方言 [Dialect] 41.Google Scholar
Yu, Xiaorong 遇笑容 and Cao, Guangshun 曹广顺 (2013). “Xunshipinghua” zhong de teshu yuyan xianxiang jiqi yuyan xingzhi 训世评话中的特殊语言现象及其语言性质 [Special Linguistic Phenomena in ‘Xunshipinghua’ and their Linguistic Nature]. Lishiyuyanxue Yanjiu 历史语言学研究 [Research in Historical Linguistics] 61.Google Scholar
Zhang, Hui 张辉 (2015). Chaoxianchao hanyu guanhua yuyin “zhizheng” zhidu yanjiu 朝鲜朝汉语官话语音“质正”制度研究 [A Study on the “zhizheng” System of Mandarin Phonology in Joseon Dynasty]. Xiamen: Xiamen University Press.Google Scholar
Zhang, Meilan 张美兰 (2013). Cong “Xunshipinghua” kan Mingchu ji zu changyong dongci de xingtai 从训世评话看明初几组常用动词的兴替 [Observing the Rise and Replacement of Several Common Verbs in Early Ming Dynasty through ‘Xunshipinghua’]. Lishiyuyanxue Yanjiu 历史语言学研究 [Research in Historical Linguistics] 61.Google Scholar
Zhang, Weidong 张卫东 (1998a). Shilun jindai nanfang guanhua de xingcheng jiqi diwei 试论近代南方官话的形成及其地位 [Modern Southern Mandarin: Its Formation and Social Status]. Shenzhendaxue xuebao （renwen shehuikexue ban） 深圳大学学报(人文社会科学版) [Journal of Shenzhen University(Humanities & Social Sciences)] 31.Google Scholar
(1998b). Beijingyin heshi chengwei hanyu guanhua biaozhunyin 北京音何时成为汉语官话标准音 [When Beijing Sounds Became the Standard Sound Systemof Chinese Mandarin?]. Shenzhendaxue xuebao (renwen shehuikexue ban) 深圳大学学报(人文社会科学版) [Journal of Shenzhen University(Humanities & Social Sciences)] 41.Google Scholar
Zhang, Yulai 张玉来 (2000). Jindai hanyugongtongyu de goucheng tedian jiqi fazhan 近代汉语共同语的构成特点及其发展 [The Constitutional Features and Developmentof Modern Chinese Common Language]. Guhanyu yanjiu 古汉语研究 [Research in Ancient Chinese Language] 21.Google Scholar
(2005). Chaoxian shiqi suo chuanxi de Mingdai hanyu guanhua de yuyin xingzhi 朝鲜时期所传习的明代汉语官话的语音性质 [The Phonetic Nature of the Transliteration Data in Korea Times in Ming Dynasty]. Yuyan yanjiu 语言研究 [Studies in Language and Linguistics] 21.Google Scholar
(2010). Mingqing shidai hanyu guanhua de shehui shiyong zhuangkuang 明清时代汉语官话的社会使用状况 [The Social Use Status of Chinese Mandarin in Ming-Qing Period]. Yuyan jiaoxue yu yanjiu 语言教学与研究 [Language Teaching and Linguistic Studies] 11.Google Scholar
(2017a). Chaoxian yanwen hanzi zhengyin yu duiyin tixi de zhuanxie wenti 朝鲜谚文汉字正音对音体系的转写问题 [The Transcription Issues of the Korean Hangul Hanja Correct Pronunciation System]. Minzu yuwen 民族语文 [Minority Languages of China] 11.Google Scholar
(2017b). Mingdai guanhua shengdiao xitong jiqi yinbian tedian 明代官话声调系统及其音变特点 [The Tone System of Ming Dynasty Mandarin and Its Phonetic Changes]. Hanyushi yu hanzangyu yanjiu 汉语史与汉藏语研究 [Chinese History and the Study of Sino-Tibetan Language] 21.Google Scholar
Zhang, Yulai 张玉来 and Yin, Yu 尹瑀 (2021). Mingdai laihua ouzhou chuanjiaoshi suo ji hanyu — fei Mingdai hanyu guanhua “Nanjing biaozhunyin shuo” 明代来华欧洲传教士所记汉语——非明代汉语官话“南京标准音说” [A Study on the Nature of Mandarin Recorded by European Missionaries in the MingDynasty: Nanjing Dialect Was Not the Standard Pronunciation of Mandarin in the Ming Dynasty]. Dongfang luntan — Qingdaodaxue xuebao （shehui kexue ban） 东方论坛——青岛大学学报(社会科学版) [Eastern Forum-Journal of Qingdao University(Social Science Edition)] 51.Google Scholar
Zhang, Zhumei 张竹梅 (2007). Shilun Mingdai qianqi Nanjinghua de yuyan diwei 试论明代前期南京话的语言地位 [Modern Southern Mandarin: Its Formation and Social Status]. Jindai guanhua yuyin yanjiu 近代官话语音研究 [Research on Early Mandarin Phonology].Google Scholar
Zhao, Kuixin 赵葵欣 (2021). Mingqing Beijing guanhua wenxian zhong biao jiyuyi de “gei” de duyin 明清北京官话文献中表给予义的“给［kei］”的读音 [The Pronunciations of the GlVE Verb “gei” in Mandarin Literatures in Ming and Qing Dynasties]. Fangyan 方言 [Dialect] 31.Google Scholar
Zhou, Jianshe 周建设 (2014–2015). Ming, Qing, Minguo shiqi zhenxi lao Beijinghua lishi wenxian zhengli yu yanjiu 明、清、民国时期珍稀老北京话历史文献整理与研究 [Compilation and Research on Rare Historical Documents of Old Beijing Dialect from the Ming, Qing, and Republic of China Periods]. Beijing: Beijing Capital Normal University Press.Google Scholar
Zhu, Dexi 朱德熙 (1958). “Laoqidayanjie”“Piaotongshiyanjie” shuhou 老乞大谚解朴通事谚解书后 [Postscript to ‘Laoqidayanjie’ and ‘Piaotongshiyanjie’]. Beijingdaxue xuebao （zhexue shehuikexue ban） 北京大学学报(哲学社会科学版) [Journal of Peking University(Philosophy and Social Sciences)] 21.Google Scholar