Article published in:
Journal of Argumentation in Context
Vol. 8:3 (2019) ► pp. 354–382

Rhetorical imaginings and multimodal arguments at the European Green Belt

Juxtaposing nonhuman nature and technology in our collective memory of the Cold War

| University of Southern California
| University of Nevada, Las Vegas
We analyze the visual, verbal, and material arguments present at the European Green Belt (EGB), a contemporary conservation project built from the former Iron Curtain. The EGB presents itself as a “living memorial” that fuses together former warring countries and thus makes an argument for the unity of Europe. To analyze this incredibly diverse and rhetorically significant project, we put the digital representations of the site and the discourse around the EGB into conversation with situated, rhetorical criticism performed along the EGB site itself. We analyze the EGB’s different argumentative juxtapositions regarding history and memory, nonhuman nature and technology, peace and war, memorial and tourism, and preservation and restoration. Overall, we find that the transformation of the Iron Curtain from divisive border into a European-wide, transboundary biodiversity conservation project uses transcendence as a key argumentative structure, which has implications for how we understand the human relationship with the environment, history, and memory
Keywords: Cold War, environmental memory, European Green Belt, juxtaposition, material rhetoric, transcendence
Article outline
  • Introduction
  • Material argument and the environment
  • Nonhuman nature and technology
  • Conservation and intervention
  • Conclusion
  • Note
  • References
Published online: 24 January 2020
https://doi.org/10.1075/jaic.18005.all
References
Blair, Carole, Dickinson, Greg, and Brian L. Ott
2010 “Introduction: Rhetoric/memory/place.” In Places of Public Memory: The Rhetoric of Museums and Memorials, ed. by Greg Dickinson, Carole Blair, and Brian Ott, 1–56. Tuscaloosa, AL: University of Alabama Press.Google Scholar
Bloomfield, Emma Frances, and Angeline Sangalang
2014 “Juxtaposition as Visual Argument: Health Rhetoric in Super Size Me and Fat Head .” Argumentation and Advocacy 501: 141–156. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Brummett, Barry
1981 “Burkean Scapegoating, Mortification, and Transcendence in Presidential Campaign Rhetoric.” Central States Speech Journal 32(4): 254–264. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Burke, Kenneth
1966 Language as Symbolic Action. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
1968 Counter-Statement. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.Google Scholar
1969a A Grammar of Motives. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.Google Scholar
1969b A Rhetoric of Motives. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.Google Scholar
1970 The Rhetoric of Religion: Studies in Logology. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.Google Scholar
1984 Attitudes Toward History. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.Google Scholar
Cagle, Lauren E., and Denise Tillery
2017 “Tweeting the Anthropocene: #400ppm as Networked Event.” In Scientific Communication: Practices, Theories, and Pedagogies, ed. by Han Yu and Kathryn M. Northcut, 131–148. New York, NY: Routledge. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Carson, Rachel
[1962] 2002 Silent Spring (40th anniversary ed.). Boston, MA: Houghton Mifflin.Google Scholar
Cronon, William
1996 “The Trouble with Wilderness: Or, Getting Back to the Wrong nature.” Environmental History 1(1): 7–28. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Conley, Donovan S., and Lawrence J. Mullen
2008 “Righting the Commons in Red Rock Canyon.” Communication and Critical/Cultural Studies 5(2): 180–199. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Davies Boren, Zachary
2015, June 19. “Germany is turning 62 military bases into wildlife sanctuaries.” Independent. Retrieved from http://​www​.independent​.co​.uk​/news​/world​/europe​/germany​-is​-turning​-62​-military​-bases​-into​-wildlife​-sanctuaries​-10332109​.html
DeLuca, Kevin Michael
1999 “Unruly Arguments: The Body Rhetoric of Earth First!, Act Up and Queer Nation.” Argumentation and Advocacy 361: 9–21. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Dunlap, Riley E., and Kent D. Van Liere
1978 “The ‘New Environmental Paradigm.’” The Journal of Environmental Education 9(4): 10–19. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
EUROPARC Federation (ed)
2010 “Following Nature's Design. Promoting Cross-Border Cooperation in Nature Conservation.” Stuttgart, Germany: Heidehof Stiftung. Retrieved from https://​www​.europarc​.org​/wp​-content​/uploads​/2009​/01​/brochure​_TransParcNet​_final​_low​_resolution​.pdf
European Commission
2013, May 5. “Green Infrastructure (GI) – Enhancing Europe’s Natural Capital.” European Commission. Retrieved from http://​eur​-lex​.europa​.eu​/resource​.html​?uri​=cellar:d41348f2​-01d5​-4abe​-b817​-4c73e6f1b2df​.0014​.03​/DOC​_1​&format​=PDF
European Green Belt
2017a “Borders Separate. Nature Unites!” European Green Belt. Retrieved from http://​www​.europeangreenbelt​.org​/initiative​.html
2017b “European Green Belt.” European Green Belt. Retrieved from http://​www​.europeangreenbelt​.org/
2017c “From Deathzone to Lifeline.” European Green Belt. Retrieved from http://​www​.europeangreenbelt​.org​/initiative​/origin​.html
2017d “Iron Curtain.” European Green Belt. Retrieved from http://​www​.europeangreenbelt​.org​/iron​-curtain​.html
2017e “Route of the Green Belt.” European Green Belt. Retrieved from http://​www​.europeangreenbelt​.org​/route​.html
2017f “Backbone of Diversity.” European Green Belt. Retrieved from http://​www​.europeangreenbelt​.org​/ecological​-network​.html
Foss, Sonja K.
1984 “Women Priests in the Episcopal Church: A Cluster Analysis of Establishment Rhetoric.” Religious Communication Today 71: 1–11.Google Scholar
Geidezes, L. & Kreutz, M.
2004 Green Belt Europe – Nature knows no boundaries. From Iron Curtain to Europe’s lifeline Urbani izziv, 15(2), 135–138. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Gilbert, Michael A.
1994 “Multi-Modal Argumentation.” Philosophy of the Social Sciences 24(2): 159–177. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Groarke, Leo
2015 “Going Multimodal: What is a Mode of Arguing and Why Does it Matter?” Argumentation 29(2): 133–155. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Groarke, Leo, Palczewski, Catherine H., and David Godden
Navigating the Visual Turn in Argument.” Argumentation and Advocacy 521: 217–235. Crossref
Iron Curtain Trail
2014, August 27. “Iron Curtain Becomes 7,000-Kilometer Bike Trail.” Iron Curtain Trail. Retrieved from http://​www​.ironcurtaintrail​.eu​/en​/ict​_realisieren​/realisierte​_abschnitte​/6663040​.html
Jamieson, Kathleen H.
1980 “The Metaphoric Cluster in the Rhetoric of Pope Paul VI and Edmund G. Brown, Jr.” Quarterly Journal of Speech 66(1): 51–72. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Kentigern Siewers, Alfred
(eds.) 2014 Re-Imagining Nature: Environmental Humanities and Ecosemiotics. Lanham, MD: Bucknell University Press.Google Scholar
Kjeldsen, Jens E.
2015a “The Rhetoric of Thick Representation: How Pictures Render the Importance and Strength of an Argument Salient.” Argumentation 29(2): 197–215. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
2015b “The Study of Visual and Multimodal Argumentation.” Argumentation 29(2): 115–132. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
McGeough, Ryan E., Catherine H. Palczewski, and Randall A. Lake
2015 “Oppositional Memory Practices: U.S. Memorial Spaces as Arguments over Public Memory.” Argumentation and Advocacy 511: 231–254. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Milstein, Tema
2011 “Nature Identification: The Power of Pointing and Naming.” Environmental Communication 51: 3–24. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Olson, Kathryn M. and G. Thomas Goodnight
1994 Entanglements of Consumption; Cruelty, Privacy, and Fashion: The Social Controversy over Fur. The Quarterly Journal of Speech 80(3): 249–276. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Pasvik Inari Trilateral Park
2007 Pasvik-Inari: Nature and History Shared [PDF file]. Oulu, Finland: Kalevaprint. Retrieved from https://​prosjekt​.fylkesmannen​.no​/Documents​/Pasvik%20​-%20Inari​/Dokument​/InariPasvik​_EN​_web​.pdf
Perelman, Chaim, and Lucie Olbrechts-Tyteca
[1969] 1971 The New Rhetoric: A Treatise on Argumentation. Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press.Google Scholar
Pinto, Robert C.
2001 Argument, inference and dialectic: Collected Papers on Informal Logic. Dordrecht: Kluwer. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Plumwood, Val
1993 Feminism and the Mastery of Nature. New York, NY: Routledge.Google Scholar
Point Alpha Foundation
n.d.a.. “The Point Alpha Memorial.” Point Alpha Foundation. Retrieved from http://​pointalpha​.com​/en​/point​-alpha​-memorial
n.d.b.. “Path of Hope (‘Weg der Hoffnug’).” Point Alpha Foundation. Retrieved from http://​pointalpha​.com​/en​/path​-hope​-weg​-der​-hoffnung
Protection and Preservation of Natural Environment in Albania
n.d.. “Balkan Green Belt.” PPNEA. Retrieved from http://​ppnea​.org​/news​/balkan​_green​_belt​_.html
Rickards, Lauren A.
2015 “Metaphor and the Anthropocene: Presenting Humans as a Geological Force.” Geographical Research 53(3): 280–287. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Senda-Cook, Samantha
2013 “Materializing Tensions: How Maps and Trails Mediate Nature.” Environmental Communication 7(3): 355–371. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Sepp, Kalev
2011 The Estonian Green Belt. Tallinn: The Estonian University of Life Sciences.Google Scholar
Sharer, Wendy
1999 “Disintegrating Bodies of Knowledge: Historical Material and Revisionary Histories of Rhetoric.” In Rhetorical Bodies, ed. by Jack Selzer and Sharon Crowley, 120–142. Madison, WI: The University of Wisconsin Press.Google Scholar
Wells, Justine, McGreavy, Bridie, Senda-Cook, Samantha, & McHendry, George F.
(2018) Introduction: Rhetoric’s ecologies. In Bridie McGreavy, Justine Wells, George F. McHendry, & Samantha Senda-Cook (Eds.), Tracing Rhetoric and Material Life (pp. 1–36). Cham: Springer International Publishing. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Willis, Emma
2014 Theatricality, Dark Tourism, and Ethical Spectatorship: Absent Others. New York, NY: Palgrave Macmillan. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Zappen, James P.
2009 “Kenneth Burke on Dialectical-Rhetorical Transcendence.” Philosophy & Rhetoric 42(3): 279–301. CrossrefGoogle Scholar