Cover not available
Article published In:
Argumentation in European Politics
Edited by Corina Andone and Bart Garssen
[Journal of Argumentation in Context 11:1] 2022
► pp. 27–46

Antifascist argumentation in Giacomo Matteotti’s 1924 speech to the Italian Parliament

| University of Trieste

Decades after the Second World War, fascism is still rife in Europe. After acknowledging a certain difficulty on the part of contemporary antifascist arguers to affirm their tenets and discredit those of their opponents, this investigation looks back at the past to examine an inspiring antifascist speech. The speech that socialist leader Giacomo Matteotti delivered to the Italian Parliament in 1924 is analysed though the methodological lens of Pragma-dialectics, focusing on the notions of strategic manoeuvring, argumentative structure and argumentative style. The results show that Matteotti’s argumentation against the fascists hinged on facts and rules as premises of argumentation. The speaker supported his arguments with factual evidence and organised them in a multiple argumentation structure. In addition, he “dressed up” his speech, apparently characterised by a detached argumentative style, with traits of a more engaged style, whose combination has turned Matteotti’s invective against the fascist regime into an argumentative masterpiece.

Keywords: antifascist argumentation, argumentative style, argumentative structure, facts, strategic manoeuvring
Article outline
  • 1.Fascism and antifascism in contemporary Italy: A brief overview
  • 2.Matteotti’s speech: Contextualisation and analytical methodology
  • 3.Argumentation in Matteotti’s speech
  • 4.Discussion
  • 5.Conclusions
  • Notes
  • References
Published online: 8 March 2022
DOI logo
https://doi.org/10.1075/jaic.21022.bra
References
ANPI
2021 Appello del Presidente nazionale ANPI al Presidente del Consiglio dei Ministri [Appeal of the ANPI National President to the Prime Minister of Italy]. Available at: [URL] (last accessed on 28th September 2021).
Bray, Mark
2017 Antifa. The Anti-fascist Handbook. Brooklyn/London: Melville House.Google Scholar
Canali, Mauro
2014 “The Matteotti Murder, 1924–2014.” Printed Matter. Centro Primo Levi Online Monthly. Available at: [URL] (last accessed on 29th September 2021).
Carta di Stazzema
[Stazzema Charter] 2017 Available at: [URL] (last accessed on 28th September 2021).
Crystal, David
2017 Making Sense. The Glamorous Story of English Grammar. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
de Búrca, Gráinne
2018 “Is EU Supranational Governance a Challenge to Liberal Constitutionalism?” The University of Chicago Law Review 85 (2): 337–368.Google Scholar
Duggan, Christopher
2013 Fascist Voices. An Intimate History of Mussolini’s Italy. Oxford/New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Encyclopedia Britannica, Giacomo Matteotti
Italian Political leader. Available at: [URL] (last accessed on 28th September 2021).
Feinstein, Stephen C.
2000 “Art after Auschwitz. Jozef Szajna’s ‘Theatre of Panic’.” In The Holocaust’s Ghost, ed. by F. C. Decoste, and Bernard Schwartz, 109–123. Alberta: The University of Alberta Press.Google Scholar
Finaldi, Giuseppe
2013 Mussolini and Italian Fascism. Abingdon/New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
F.Q.
2021 “Durigon finalmente fuori dal governo. Il sottosegretario si dimette 22 giorni dopo le parole sul ‘parco Mussolini’ [Durigon Finally Out of Government. The Undersecretary Resigns 22 Days After His Words on the ‘Mussolini Park’].” Il Fatto Quotidiano 26th August 2021 Available at: [URL] (last accessed on 2nd October 2021).
Garssen, Bart
2017 “The Role of Pragmatic Problem-solving Argumentation in Plenary Debate in the European Parliament.” In Prototypical Argumentative Patterns, ed. by Frans H. van Eemeren, 31–51. Amsterdam/Philadelphia: John Benjamins. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Garssen, Bart, and Manfred Kienpointner
2011 “Figurative Analogy in Political Argumentation.” In Keeping in Touch with Pragma-dialectics, ed. by Eveline T. Feteris, Bart Garssen, and Francisca Snoeck Henkemans, 39–58. Amsterdam/Philadelphia: John Benjamins. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Grasso, Giorgio
2010 Per una biografia politica di Giuseppe Lupis [For a Political Biography of Giuseppe Lupis]. Liber Iter edizioni elettroniche (e-book).Google Scholar
Hughes-Hallett, Lucy
2013 “My Hero: Giacomo Matteotti.” The Guardian 8th November 2013 Available at: [URL] (last accessed on 28th September 2021).
Lanfranco, Monica
2018 “Antifascisti, non esiste violenza giusta. Il fascismo si nutre anche della rabbia di chi lo combatte [Antifascists, There Is No Just Violence. Fascism also Feeds on the Anger of Those Who Struggle against It].” Il Fatto Quotidiano 23rd February 2018 Available at: [URL] (last accessed on 20th September 2021).
Milsark, Gary L.
2015 Existential Sentences in English. Abingdon/New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
Oxford Reference, Matteotti Crisis
Available at: [URL] (last accessed on 28th September 2021).
Raimo, Christian
2019 “La lezione antifascista di Matteotti oggi è più utile che mai [Matteotti’s Antifascist Lesson Today is More Useful than Ever].” Internazionale 15th July 2019 Available at: [URL] (last accessed on 4th October 2021).
van Eemeren, Frans H.
2010 Strategic Maneuvering in Argumentative Discourse. Extending the Pragma-dialectical Theory of Argumentation. Amsterdam/Philadelphia: John Benjamins. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
2016 “Identifying Argumentative Patterns: a Vital Step in the Development of Pragma-dialectics.” Argumentation 301: 1–23. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
2019 “Argumentative Style: a Complex Notion.” Argumentation 331: 153–171. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
2021 “Examining Argumentative Style. A New Theoretical Perspective.” Journal of Argumentation in Context 10 (1): 8–25. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
van Eemeren, Frans H., and Francisca Snoeck Henkemans
2017 Argumentation. Analysis and Evaluation. London/New York: Routledge (2nd edition).Google Scholar
Walton, Douglas
2002 Legal Argumentation and Evidence. University Park (PA): The Pennsylvania State University Press.Google Scholar