Cover not available
Article published In:
Popular News Discourse: American and British newspapers 1833-1988
[Journal of Historical Pragmatics 15:2] 2014
► pp. 255–291

Ideological closure in newspaper political language during the U.S. 1872 election campaign

| Hadassah Academic College
This paper studies political language in late nineteenth century partisan newspapers by (a) evaluating the degree of pragmatic force, or ideological closure in political editorial content published during the 1872 election year in three leading Iowa newspapers; and (b) linking variations in the degree of ideological closure of these texts to the institutional and social-political contexts of their production, i.e. the political role of editors and the web of relationships within which they performed their work. The degree of ideological closure is evaluated by analysing a range of rhetorical and discursive practices. The study identified variations in degree of closure both between newspapers affiliated with the same party and within a single newspaper over time. Such variations are interpreted as reflecting editors’ need to mitigate an intricate set of political interests and obligations. The analysis also brings to light the richness of partisan editorial language of this time. These finds demonstrate the complexity of the political language and discourse of Gilded Age newspapers.
Keywords: political language, discursive practices, rhetorical practices, ideological closure, 1872 elections, Iowa, Gilded Age
Published online: 21 July 2014
DOI logo
https://doi.org/10.1075/jhp.15.2.06str
References (106)
Alonso Belmonte, Isabel. 2007. “Newspaper Editorials and Comment Articles: A ‘Cinderella’ Genre?” RAEL: Revista Electrónica de Lingüistica Aplicada 11: 1–9.Google Scholar
Baehr, Harry W., Jr. 1972 [1936]. The New York Tribune Since the Civil War. New York: Octagon Books.Google Scholar
Baker, Paula. 1991. The Moral Frameworks of Public Life: Gender, Politics, and the State in Rural New York, 1870–1930. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Baldasty, Gerald J. 1992. The Commercialization of the News in the Nineteenth Century. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.Google Scholar
Barnhurst, Kevin G., and John Nerone. 2001. The Form of News. (The Guilfrd Communication Series.) New York: Guilford Press.Google Scholar
Barthes, Roland. 1970. S/Z. Paris: Seuil.Google Scholar
Bazzanella, Carla. 2011. “Redundancy, Repetition, and Intensity in Discourse.” Language Sciences 33 (2): 243–254. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Bederman, Gail. 1995. Manliness & Civilization: A Cultural History of Gender and Race in the United States, 1880–1917. (Women in Culture and Society.) Chicago and London: The University of Chicago Press. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Berry, Stephen J. 2005. “Why Objectivity Still Matters.” Nieman Reports 59 (2): 15–16.Google Scholar
Bormann, Ernest G. 1972. “Fantasy and Rhetorical Vision: The Rhetorical Criticism of Social Reality.” Quarterly Journal of Speech 581: 396–407. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
. 1982. “Colloquy: I. Fantasy and Rhetorical Vision: Ten Years Later.” Quarterly Journal of Speech 681: 288–305. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Bowes, Andrea, and Albert Katz. 2011. “When Sarcasm Stings.” Discourse Processes 481: 215–236. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Brown, Penelope, and Stephen Levinson. 1987. Politeness: Some Universals in Language Use. (Studies in Interactional Sociolinguistics 4.) Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Burke, Martin J. 1995. The Conundrum of Class: Public Discourse on the Social Order in America. Chicago and London: The University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Caffi, Claudia, and Richard W. Janney. 1994. “Toward a Pragmatics of Emotive Communication.” Journal of Pragmatics 221: 325–373. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Calhoun, Charles W. 1996. “The Political Culture: Public Life and the Conduct of Politics.” In The Gilded Age: Essays on the Origins of Modern America, ed. by Charles W. Calhoun, 185–213. Wilmington, DE: SR Books.Google Scholar
. 2010. From Bloody Shirt to Full Dinner Pail: The Transformation of Politics and Governance in the Gilded Age. New York: Hill and Wang.Google Scholar
Carter, Ronald, and Walter Nash. 1990. Seeing Through Language: A Guide to Styles of English Writing. Oxford: Blackwell.Google Scholar
Carvalho, Anabela. 2008. “Media (ted) Discourse and Society: Rethinking the Framework of Critical Discourse Analysis.” Journalism Studies 9 (2): 161–177. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Carver, Terrel. 1997. “Identity and Narrative in Prime-Time politics: The Hill-Thomas Hearings.” In Interpreting the Political: New Methodologies, ed. by Terrel Carver, and Matti Hyvärinen, 7–17. London and New York: Routledge. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Cherny, Robert W. 1997. American Politics in the Gilded Age, 1868–1900. Wheeling, IL: Harlan Davidson.Google Scholar
Chilton, Paul, and Christina Schäffner. 1997. “Discourse and Politics.” In Discourse as Social Interaction. (Discourse Studies: A Multidisciplinary Introduction 2), ed. by Teun A. van Dijk, 206–230. London: Sage.Google Scholar
Chouliaraki, Lilie. 2000. “Political Discourse in the News: Democratizing Responsibility or Aestheticizing Politics?” Discourse and Society 11 (3): 293–314. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Cmiel, Kenneth. 1990. Democratic Eloquence: The Fight over Popular Speech in Nineteenth-Century America. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
Cohen, Ted. 1978. “Metaphor and the Cultivation of Intimacy.” Critical Inquiry 5 (1): 3–12. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Conboy, Martin. 2007. The Language of the News. London and New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
Cook, Robert J. 1994. Baptism by Fire: The Republican Party in Iowa, 1838–1878. Ames: Iowa State University Press.Google Scholar
Corbett, Edward P.J. 1965. Classical Rhetoric for the Modern Student. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
David, James Corbett. 2007. “The Politics of Emasculation: The Caning of Charles Sumner and Elite Ideologies of Manhood in the Mid-Nineteenth-Century United States.” Gender and History 19 (2): 324–345. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Davis, Howard, and Paul Walton. 1983. “Death of a Premier: Consensus and Closure in International News.” In Language, Image, Media, ed. by Howard Davis, and Paul Walton, 8–49. London: Blackwell.Google Scholar
Downey, Mathew T. 1967. “Horace Greeley and the Politicians: The Liberal Republican Convention of 1872.” The Journal of American History 531: 727–750. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Eco, Umberto. 1979. The Role of the Reader: Explorations in the Semiotics of Texts. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.Google Scholar
Eisenhart, Christopher, and Barbara Johnstone. 2008. “Discourse Analysis and Rhetorical Studies.” In Rhetoric in Detail: Discourse Analysis of Rhetorical Talk and Text. (Discourse Approaches to Politics, Society and Culture), ed. by Barbara Johnstone, and Christopher Eisenhart, 3–21. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Fairclough, Norman. 1992a. “Discourse and Text: Linguistic and Intertextual Analysis within Discourse Analyis.” Discourse and Society 3 (2): 193–217. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
. 1992b. “Intertextuality in Critical Discourse Analysis.” Linguistics and Education 41: 269–293. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
. 1995. Critical Discourse Analysis: The Critical Study of Language. (Language in Social Life Series.) London: Longman.Google Scholar
Flood, Christopher G. 1996. Political Myth: A Theoretical Introduction. (Theories of Myth.) New York: Garland Publishing.Google Scholar
Flowerdew, John 1999. “Description and Interpretation in Critical Discourse Analysis.” Journal of Pragmatics 311: 1089–1099. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Foner, Eric. 1988. Reconstruction: America’s Unfinished Revolution, 1863–1877. Cambridge: Harper and Row.Google Scholar
Gamson, William A. 1992. Talking Politics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Gerrig, Richard J., and Raymond W. Gibbs. 1988. “Beyond the Lexicon: Creativity in Language Production.” Metaphor and Symbolic Activity 31: 1–19. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Green, David E. 1987. Shaping Political Consciousness: The Language of Politics in America from McKinley to Reagan. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.Google Scholar
Gue, Benjamin F. 1903. History of Iowa from the Earliest Times to the Beginning of the Twentieth Century, IV: Iowa Biography. New York: Century History.Google Scholar
Hall, Stuart. 1980. “Encoding/Decoding.” In Culture, Media, Language: Working Papers in Cultural Studies, 1972–79, ed. by Stuart Hall, Dorothy Hobson, Andrew Lowe, and Paul Willis, 128–138. London: Hutchinson & Co.Google Scholar
Hartley, John. 1982. Understanding News. London: Methuen.Google Scholar
Hilkey, Judy. 1997. Character is Capital: Success Manuals and Manhood in Gilded Age America. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.Google Scholar
Hirshson, Stanley P. 1962. Farewell to the Bloody Shirt: Northern Republicans and the Southern Negro, 1847–1893. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.Google Scholar
Hofstadter, Richard. 1962. Anti-Intellectualism in American Life. New York: Alfred Knopf.Google Scholar
Hoganson, Kristin L. 1998. Fighting for American Manhood: How Gender Politics Provoked the Spanish-American and Philippine-American Wars. New Haven: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Jensen, Richard. 1971. The Winning of the Midwest: Social and Political Conflict, 1888–1896. Chicago and London: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Kaplan, Richard. 2002. Politics and the American Press: The Rise of Objectivity, 1865–1920. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
. 2010. “The Origins of Objectivity in American Journalism.” In The Routledge Companion to News and Journalism, ed. by Stuart Allan, 25–37. London and New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
King, Elliot. 2005. “Objectivity During a Clash of Titans, 1883–1915.” In Fair & Balanced: A History of Journalistic Objectivity, ed. by Steven R. Knowlton, and Karen L. Freeman, 117–130. Northport, AL: Vision Press.Google Scholar
Kleppner, Paul. 1970. The Cross of Culture: A Social Analysis of Midwestern Politics, 1850–1900. New York: Free Press.Google Scholar
Leech, Geoffrey N. 1969. A Linguistic Guide to English Poetry. (English Language Series 4.) London: Longman.Google Scholar
Levine, Lawrence W. 1993. The Unpredictable Past: Explorations in American Cultural History. Oxford: Oxford University Press. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Mayer, Gordon. 2006. “Party Rags? Politics and the News Business in Chicago’s Party Press, 1831–71.” Journalism History 32 (3): 138–146.Google Scholar
McGerr, Michael E. 1986. The Decline of Popular Politics: The American North, 1865–1928. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
McGerr, Michael. 1990. “Political Style and Women’s Power, 1830–1930.” The Journal of American History 77 (3): 864–885. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
McPherson, James M. 1965. “Grant or Greeley? The Abolitionist Dilemma in the Election of 1872.” The American Historical Review 711: 43–61. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
McQuarrie, Edward F., and David G. Mick. 1996. “Figures of Rhetoric in Advertising Language.” Journal of Consumer Research 22 (4): 424–438. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Mindich, David T.Z. 1998. Just the Facts: How “Objectivity” Came to Define American Journalism. New York: New York University Press.Google Scholar
Mothersbaugh, David L., Bruce A. Huhmann, and George R. Franke. 2002. “Combinatory and Separative Effects of Rhetorical Figures on Consumers’ Effort and Focus in Ad Processing.” Journal of Consumer Research 28 (4): 589–602. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Mott, Frank L. 1952. The News in America. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Murphy, Kevin P. 2008. Political Manhood: Red Bloods, Mollycoddles, and the Politics of Progressive Era Reform. New York: Columbia University Press.Google Scholar
n.a. 1897. “Editorial Department: Notable Deaths.” Annals of Iowa 3 (1): 75.Google Scholar
Nelson, Dana D. 1998. National Manhood: Capitalist Citzenship and the Imagined Fraternity of White Men. Durham: Duke University Press. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Ostler, Jeffrey. 1993. Prairie Populism: The Fate of Agrarian Radicalism in Kansas, Nebraska, and Iowa, 1880–1892. (Rural America.) Lawrence: University Press of Kansas.Google Scholar
Patnode, Randall, Donald L. Shaw, and Steven R. Knowlton. 2005. “The 19th Century: The Evolution of Objectivity.” In Fair & Balanced: A History of Journalistic Objectivity, ed. by Steven R. Knowlton, and Karen L. Freeman, 65–75. Northport, AL: Vision Press.Google Scholar
Payne, Charles E. 1938. Josiah Bushnell Grinnell. Iowa City: State Historical Society of Iowa.Google Scholar
Pendergast, Tom. 2000. Creating the Modern Man: American Magazines and Consumer Culture, 1900–1950. Columbia, MO: University of Missouri Press.Google Scholar
Pilkington, Adrian. 1992. “Poetic Effects.” Lingua 871: 29–51. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Plett, Heinrich F. 1999. “Rhetoric and Intertextuality.” Rhetorica 17 (3): 313–329. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Rasmussen, Claire, and Michael Brown. 2005. “The Body Politic as Spatial Metaphor.” Citizenship Studies 9 (5): 469–484. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Reitano, Joanne. 1994. The Tariff Question in the Gilded Age: The Great Debate of 1888. University Park: Pennsylvania State University Press.Google Scholar
Riffaterre, Michael. 1990. “Compulsory Reader Response: The Intertextual Drive.” In Intertextuality: Theories and Practices, ed. by Michael Worton, and Judith Still, 56–78. Manchester: Manchester University Press.Google Scholar
Robertson, Andrew W. 1995. The Language of Democracy: Political Rhetoric in the United States and Britain, 1790–1900. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.Google Scholar
Rodgers, Daniel T. 1987. Contested Truths: Keywords in American Politics Since Independence. New York: Basic Books Publishers.Google Scholar
Roeh, Izhak, and Akiba Cohen. 1992. “One of the Bloodiest Days: A Comparative Analysis of Open and Closed Television News.” Journal of Communication 42 (2): 42–55. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Rubin, Joan Shelley. 1998. “Listen, My Children: Modes and Functions of Poetry Reading in American Schools, 1880–1950.” In Moral Problems in American Life: New Perspectives on Cultural History, ed. by Karen Halttunen, and Lewis Perry, 261–281. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.Google Scholar
Ryfe, David M. 2006. “News, Culture and Public Life: A Study of 19th-Century American Journalism.” Journalism Studies 7 (1): 60–77. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Ryfe, David M., and Markus Kemmelmeier. 2010. “Quoting Practices, Path Dependency and the Birth of Modern Journalism.” Journalism Studies 121: 1–17.Google Scholar
Sage, Leland L. 1956. William Boyd Allison: A Study in Practical Politics. Iowa City: State Historical Society of Iowa.Google Scholar
Seidel, Gill. 1985. “Political Discourse Analysis.” In Handbook of Discourse Analysis, 4: Discourse Analysis in Society, ed. by Teun A. van Dijk, 43–60. New York: Academic Press.Google Scholar
Simpson, Brooks D. 1998. The Reconstruction Presidents. Lawrence: University of Kansas Press.Google Scholar
Slotkin, Richard. 1985. The Fatal Environment: The Myth of the Frontier in the Age of Industrialization, 1800–1890. Norman: University of Oklahoma Press.Google Scholar
Smythe, Ted Curtis. 2003. The Gilded Age Press, 1865–1900. (The History of American Journalism 4.) Westport, Conn. and London: Praeger Publishers.Google Scholar
Strauss, Dafnah. 2006. “Between Partisanship and Independence: American Editor-Politicians and Independent-Partisan Newspapers, 1870–1910.” Ph.D. Dissertation. Haifa: Haifa University.Google Scholar
Suleiman, Susan R. 1980. “Redundancy and the ‘Readable’ Text.” Poetics Today 1 (3): 119–142. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Summers, Mark W. 1994. The Press Gang: Newspapers and Politics, 1865–1878. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.Google Scholar
Tannen, Deborah. 1989. Talking Voices: Repetition, Dialogue and Imagery in Conversational Discourse. (Studies in Interactional Sociolonguistics 6.) Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Testi, Arnalso. 1995. “The Gender of Reform Politics: Theodore Roosevelt and the Culture of Masculinity.” The Journal of American History 81 (4): 1509–1533. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Throne, Mildred. 1955. “The Liberal Republican Party in Iowa, 1872.” Iowa Journal of History 531: 121–152.Google Scholar
Titscher, Stefan, Michael Meyer, Ruth Wodak, and Eva Vetter. 2000. Methods of Text and Discourse Analysis. Translated by Bryan Jenner. London: Sage.Google Scholar
Tonear, Mark, and James Munch. 2001. “Consumer Responses to Tropes in Print Advertising.” Journal of Advertising 30 (1): 55–65. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Toolan, Michael J. 2001. Narrative: A Critical Linguistic Introduction, 2nd edition. London and New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
Tucher, Andie. 2001. “In Search of Jenkins: Taste, Style, and Credibility in Gilded-Age Journalism.” Journalism History 271: 50–55.Google Scholar
Ungerer, Friedrich. 1997. “Emotions and Emotional Language in English and German News Stories.” In The Language of Emotions: Conceptualization, Expression, and Theoretical Foundation, ed. by Susanne Niemeier, and René Dirven, 307–328. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.Google Scholar
van Dijk, Teun A. 1992. “Racism and Argumentation: Race Riot Rhetoric in Tabloid Editorials.” In Argumentation Illuminated, ed. by Frans H. van Eemeren, Rob Grootendorst, J. Anthony Blair, and Charles A. Willard, 243–257. Amsterdam: SICSAT.Google Scholar
. 1996. “Opinions and Ideologies in Editorials.” Unpublished Paper for the 4th International Symposium of Critical Discourse Analysis, Language, Social Life and Critical Thought, Athens, 14–16 December, 1995 (second draft available at: [URL] accessed 4 December 2013).
. 1998. “Opinions and Ideologies in the Press.” In Approaches to Media Discourse ed. by Allan Bell, and Peter Garrett, 21–63. Oxford: Blackwell.Google Scholar
Walsh, Justin E. 1968. To Print the News and Raise Hell! A Biography of Wilbur F. Storey. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.Google Scholar
Weizman, Elda. 1984. “Some Register Characteristics of Journalistic Language: Are They Universals?” Applied Linguistics 5 (1): 39–50. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Wilson, John. 1990. Politically Speaking: The Pragmatic Analysis of Political Language. Oxford: Blackwell.Google Scholar
Wolfsfeld, Gadi. 1997. Media and Political Conflict: News from the Middle East. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar