Disagreements in a feminist digital safe space
The relationship between impoliteness, identity and power
Research on impoliteness has underlined the need for multidisciplinary approaches to impoliteness (Sifianou 2019a). In this article, I adopt the concept of “safe space”, as discussed in
works on feminist digital media (Clark-Parsons 2018; Rentschler 2014), to explore how impoliteness relates to identity construction and the negotiation of
power dynamics in the context of a Greek feminist website, constructed as a safe space. Both the concept of “safe space” and
discursive and relational approaches to impoliteness (Angouri and Locher 2012; Graham 2007; Locher and Watts 2005, 2008) relate to
norms of appropriate behaviour in particular contexts and relational issues, such as power and identity.
The data for this article comprise comments posted in discussions taking place in the Greek website of A,
mpa, in which participants became involved in disagreements. Culpeper’s
(2010) framework for conventionalised impoliteness formulae is the starting point of the analysis, which takes a
discourse analytical approach to investigate the intersection of identity and power in the site. Results show that criticisms and
challenging questions are linked to the identification of participants with particular feminist positions, and to the negotiation
of the power distribution between the administrator and themselves. Furthermore, the paradoxical nature of safe spaces plays an
important role in these processes, as the use of impoliteness points to the negotiation of the norms for interaction among
participants and reveals the struggle between individual expression and maintenance of safety.
Article outline
- 1.Introduction
- 2.Background
- 2.1(Im)politeness, conflict, and disagreement: An overview
- 2.2Impoliteness and identity in on-line contexts
- 2.3Feminist safe spaces online
- 3.Methodology
- 4.Discussion of findings
- 5.Conclusions
- Notes
-
References
References
Angouri, Jo, and Miriam A. Locher
2012 “
Theorising
Disagreement.”
Journal of
Pragmatics 44(12):1549–1553.
Angouri, Jo, and Theodora Tseliga
2010 “
‘you
HAVE NO IDEA WHAT YOU ARE TALKING ABOUT!’ From e-disagreement to e-impoliteness in Two Online
Fora.”
Journal of Politeness
Research 6(1):57–82.
Bou-Franch, Patricia, and Pilar Garcés-Conejos Blitvich
2014 “
Conflict
Management in Massive Polylogues: A Case Study from YouTube.”
Journal of
Pragmatics 731:19–36.
Bousfield, Derek, and Miriam A. Locher
2008 “
Introduction:
Impoliteness and Power in Language.” In
Impoliteness in Language:
Studies on its Interplay with Power in Theory and Practice, edited by
Derek Bousfield and
Miriam A. Locher, 1–13. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
Bridges, Judith
2017 “
Gendering
Metapragmatics in Online Discourse: ‘Mansplaining man gonna mansplain…’.”
Discourse, Context
& Media 201: 94–102.
Brownlie, Julie
2018 “
Looking
out for each other Online: Digital Outreach, Emotional Surveillance and Safe(r)
Spaces.”
Emotion, Space and
Society 271: 60–67.
Bucholtz, Mary, and Kira Hall
2005 “
Identity
and Interaction: A Sociocultural Linguistic Approach.”
Discourse
Studies 7(4–5): 585–614.
Carstensen, Gunilla
2016 “
Sexual
Harassment Reconsidered: The Forgotten Grey Zone.”
NORA-Nordic Journal of Feminist and Gender
Research 24(4):267–280.
Clark-Parsons, Rosemary
2018 “
Building
a Digital Girl Army: The Cultivation of Feminist Safe Spaces Online.”
New Media &
Society 20(6): 2125–2144.
Cohen, Claire
2018 A
Decade after Lynndie: Non-ideal Victims of Non-ideal Offenders–Doubly Anomalised, Doubly
Invisibilised. Bristol: Policy Press.
Connelly, Sarah M.
2015 “
‘Welcome to the FEMINIST CULT’:
Building a Feminist Community of Practice on Tumblr.” Undergraduate Senior
Thesis, Gettysburg College.
Culpeper, Jonathan
2005 “
Impoliteness
and Entertainment in the Television Quiz Show: The Weakest Link
.”
Journal of
Politeness
Research 1(1):35–72.
Culpeper, Jonathan
2010 “
Conventionalised
Impoliteness Formulae.”
Journal of
Pragmatics 42(12):3232–3245.
Culpeper, Jonathan
2011 Impoliteness:
Using Language to Cause Offence. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Culpeper, Jonathan, and Claire Hardaker
2017 “
Impoliteness.” In
The
Palgrave Handbook of Linguistic (Im)politeness, edited by
Jonathan Culpeper,
Michael Haugh, and
Dániel Z. Kádár, 199–225. London: Palgrave Macmillan.
de Fina, Anna, Deborah Schiffrin, and Michael Bamberg
2006 Discourse
and Identity. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Eelen, Gino
2001 A
Critique of Politeness Theories. Manchester: St. Jerome.
Ermida, Isabel
2013 “
‘A
Beached Whale Posing in Lingerie’: Conflict Talk, Disagreement and Impoliteness in Online Newspaper
Commentary.”
Revista
Diacrítica 27(1):95–130.
Garcés-Conejos Blitvich, Pilar
2009 “
Impoliteness
and Identity in the American News Media: The ‘Culture Wars’.”
Journal of Politeness
Research 5(2):273–303.
Garcés-Conejos Blitvich, Pilar
2010 “
The
YouTubification of Politics, Impoliteness and Polarization.” In
the
Handbook of Research on Discourse Behavior and Digital Communication: Language Structures and
Social Interaction, edited by
Rotimi Taiwo, 540–563. Hershey, PA: IGI Global.
Garcés-Conejos Blitvich, Pilar
2013 “
Introduction:
Face, Identity and Im/politeness. Looking Backward, Moving Forward: From Goffman to Practice
Theory.”
Journal of Politeness
Research 9(1):1–33.
Garcés-Conejos Blitvich, Pilar
2018 “
Globalization,
Transnational Identities, and Conflict Talk: The Superdiversity and Complexity of the Latino
Identity.”
Journal of
Pragmatics 1341:120–133.
Garcés-Conejos Blitvich, Pilar, and Patricia Bou-Franch
2019 “
Introduction
to Analyzing Digital Discourse: New Insights and Future
Directions.” In
Analyzing Digital Discourse: New Insights and Future
Directions, edited by
Patricia Bou-Franch and
Pilar Garcés-Conejos Blitvich, 3–22. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan.
Garcés-Conejos Blitvich, Pilar, and Maria Sifianou
2017 “
(Im)politeness
and Identity.” In
The Palgrave Handbook of Linguistic
(Im)politeness, edited by
Jonathan Culpeper,
Michael Haugh, and
Dániel Z. Kádár, 227–256. London: Palgrave Macmillan.
Garcés-Conejos Blitvich, Pilar, and Maria Sifianou
2019 “
Im/politeness
and Discursive Pragmatics.”
Journal of
Pragmatics 1451:91–101.
Georgakopoulou, Alexandra
2001 “
Arguing
about the Future: On Indirect Disagreements in Conversations.”
Journal of
Pragmatics 33(12):1881–1900.
Gill, Rosalind
2017 “
The
Affective, Cultural and Psychic Life of Postfeminism: A Postfeminist Sensibility 10 Years
on.”
European Journal of Cultural
Studies 20(6):606–626.
Gill, Rosalind, and Shani Orgad
2018 “
The
Shifting Terrain of Sex and Power: From the ‘Sexualization of Culture’ to
#MeToo.”
Sexualities 21(8):1313–1324.
Graham, Sage Lambert
2007 “
Disagreeing to Agree:
Conflict, (Im)politeness and Identity in a Computer-Mediated Community.”
Journal of
Pragmatics 39(4):742–759.
Graham, Sage Lambert, and Claire Hardaker
2017 “
(Im)politeness
in Digital Communication.” In
The Palgrave Handbook of Linguistic
(Im)politeness, edited by
Jonathan Culpeper,
Michael Haugh, and
Dániel Z. Kádár, 785–814. London: Palgrave Macmillan.
Hall, Kira, and Mary Bucholtz
2013 “
Epilogue:
Facing Identity.”
Journal of Politeness
Research 9(1):123–132.
Harris, Anita
2008 “
Young
Women, Late Modern Politics, and the Participatory Possibilities of Online Cultures.”
Journal
of Youth
Studies 11(5):481–495.
Haugh, Michael
2007 “
The
Discursive Challenge to Politeness Research: An Interactional Alternative.”
Journal of
Politeness
Research 31:295–317.
Haugh, Michael
2019 “
The
Metapragmatics of Consideration in (Australian and New Zealand)
English.” In
From Speech Acts to Lay Understandings of
Politeness, edited by
Eva Ogiermann and
Pilar Garcés-Conejos Blitvich, 201–225. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Jackson, Sue
2018 “
Young
Feminists, Feminism and Digital Media.”
Feminism &
Psychology 28(1):32–49.
Jeffreys, Sheila
2009 “
Prostitution,
Trafficking and Feminism: An Update on the Debate.” In
Women’s
Studies International
Forum 32(4):316–320.
Kádár, Dániel Z., and Michael Haugh
2013 Understanding
Politeness. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Kakavá, Christina
1993 Negotiation
of Disagreement by Greeks in Conversations and Classroom Discourse. Ph.D.
diss., Georgetown University.
Kanai, Akane
2015 “
WhatShouldWeCallMe?
Self-branding, Individuality and Belonging in Youthful Femininities on Tumblr.”
M/C
Journal 18(1) (2015) Retrieved February 1, 2019, from
[URL].
Keller, Jessalynn
2016 Girls’
Feminist Blogging in a Postfeminist Age. New York: Routledge.
Kent, Antonia
2018 “
Power
and Agency: Characterisations of the Female Victim of Family Violence.”
Australian & New
Zealand Journal of Criminology, 0004865818794804.
Kienpointner, Manfred, and Maria Stopfner
2017 “
Ideology
and (Im)politeness.” In
The Palgrave Handbook of Linguistic
(Im)politeness, edited by
Jonathan Culpeper,
Michael Haugh, and
Dániel Z. Kádár, 61–87. London: Palgrave Macmillan.
Kissil, Karni, and Maureen Davey
2010 “
The
Prostitution Debate in Feminism: Current Trends, Policy and Clinical Issues Facing an Invisible
Population.”
Journal of Feminist Family
Therapy 22(1):1–21.
Koller, Veronika
2014 “
Applying
Social Cognition Research to Critical Discourse Studies: The Case of Collective
Identities.” In
Contemporary Critical Discourse
Studies, edited by
Christopher Hart and
Piotr Cap, 147–165. London: Bloomsbury.
Krikela, Sofia
2019 “
‘This
is a website for humans, who are women’: Counter-discourses and Alternative Identities in a Greek
Website.” Master’s Thesis, National and Kapodistrian University of Athens.
Langlotz, Andreas, and Miriam A. Locher
2012 “
Ways
of Communicating Emotional Stance in Online Disagreements.”
Journal of
Pragmatics 44(12):1591–1606.
Locher, Miriam A.
2004 Power and Politeness in Action:
Disagreements in Oral Communication. New York: Mouton de Gruyter.
Locher, Miriam A., and Richard J. Watts
2005 "
Politeness Theory and Relational Work".
Journal of Politeness Research 1(1):9-33.
Locher, Miriam A., and Richard J. Watts
2008 “
Relational
Work and Impoliteness: Negotiating Norms of Linguistic
Behaviour.” In
Impoliteness in Language: Studies on its Interplay
with Power in Theory and Practice, edited by
Derek Bousfield and
Miriam A. Locher, 77–99. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
Lorenzo-Dus, Nuria, Pilar Garcés-Conejos Blitvich, and Patricia Bou-Franch
2011 “
On-line
Polylogues and Impoliteness: The Case of Postings Sent in Response to the Obama Reggaeton YouTube
Video.”
Journal of
Pragmatics 43(10):2578–2593.
Luzón, María José
2013 “
‘This is an Erroneous
Argument’: Conflict in Academic Blog Discussions.”
Discourse, Context &
Media 2(2):111–119.
Matos, Carolina
2017 “
New
Brazilian Feminisms and Online Networks: Cyberfeminism, Protest and the Female ‘Arab
Spring’.”
International
Sociology 32(3):417–434.
Mills, Sara
2003 Gender
and Politeness. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Mullany, Louise
2008 “
‘Stop
Hassling Me!’ Impoliteness, Power and Gender Identity in the Professional
Workplace.” In
Impoliteness in Language: Studies on its Interplay
with Power in Theory and Practice, edited by
Derek Bousfield and
Miriam A. Locher, 231–251. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
Negra, Diane
2009 What
a Girl Wants?: Fantasizing the Reclamation of Self in
Postfeminism. London: Routledge.
Ogiermann, Eva, and Pilar Garcés-Conejos Blitvich
2019 “
Im/politeness
between the Analyst and Participant Perspectives: An Overview of the
Field.” In
From Speech Acts to Lay Understandings of Politeness:
Multilingual and Multicultural Perspectives, edited by
Eva Ogiermann and
Pilar Garcés-Conejos Blitvich, 1–24. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Reicher, Stephen D., Russell Spears, and Tom Postmes
1995 “
A
Social Identity Model of Deindividuation Phenomena.”
European Review of Social
Psychology 6(1):161–198.
Rentschler, Carrie A.
2014 “
Rape Culture and the Feminist
Politics of Social Media.”
Girlhood
Studies 7(1):65–82.
Roberts, Nicola, Catherine Donovan, Kate Tudor, and Matthew Durey
2018 “
Agency,
Resistance and the Non ‘Ideal Victim’: How Women Deal with Everyday Sexual Violence.” Paper
presented at British Society of Criminology Annual Conference, Birmingham City
University, 3–6 July, 2018.
Roestone Collective
2014 “
Safe
Space: Towards a
Reconceptualization.”
Antipode 46(5): 1346–1365.
Segal, Lynne
[1999]
2015 Why Feminism?: Gender, Psychology, Politics. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons.
Shaw, Frances
2013a “
Blogging
and the Women’s Movement: New Feminist Networks.” In
The Women’s
Movement in Protest, Institutions and the Internet: Australia in Transnational Perspective, edited
by
Sarah Maddison and
Marian Sawer, 118–131. London: Routledge.
Shaw, Frances
2013b “
FCJ-157
Still ‘Searching for Safety Online’: Collective Strategies and Discursive Resistance to Trolling and Harassment in a Feminist
Network.”
The Fibreculture Journal 22 2013, Trolls and the Negative Space of the
Internet 221: 93–108.
Shorey, Samantha
2015 “
Fragmentary
Girls: Selective Expression on the Tumblr Platform.” Master’s
thesis, University of Massachusetts Amherst.
Sifianou, Maria
2012 “
Disagreements,
Face and Politeness.”
Journal of
Pragmatics 44(12): 1554–1564.
Sifianou, Maria
2019a “
Conflict,
Disagreement and (Im)politeness.” In
The Routledge Handbook of
Language in Conflict, edited by
Matthew Evans,
Lesley Jeffries, and
Jim O’Driscoll, 176–195. London: Routledge.
Sifianou, Maria
2019b “
Im/politeness
and In/civility: A Neglected Relationship?.”
Journal of
Pragmatics 1471:49–64.
Sileo, Amanda
2018 “
On
Consent and the ‘Gray
Zone’.”
Bust,
March 8.
Spencer-Oatey, Helen
2002 “
Managing
Rapport in Talk: Using Rapport Sensitive Incidents to Explore the Motivational Concerns Underlying the Management of
Relations.”
Journal of
Pragmatics 34(5):529–545.
Spencer-Oatey, Helen
2008 Culturally
Speaking: Culture, Communication and Politeness Theory. 2nd
ed. London/New York: Continuum.
Spencer-Oatey, Helen
2011 “
Conceptualising
‘the Relational’ in Pragmatics: Insights from Metapragmatic Emotion and (Im)politeness
Comments.”
Journal of
Pragmatics 43(14):3565–3578.
Spencer-Oatey, Helen, and Vladimir Žegarac
2017 “
Power,
Solidarity and (Im)politeness.” In
The Palgrave Handbook of
Linguistic (Im) politeness, edited by
Jonathan Culpeper,
Michael Haugh, and
Dániel Z. Kádár, 119–141. London: Palgrave Macmillan.
Stengel, Barbara S.
2010 “
The Complex Case of Fear and
Safe Space.”
Studies in Philosophy and
Education 29(6):523–540.
Sweeney, Brian N.
2017 “
Slut
shaming.” In
The SAGE Encyclopedia of Psychology and
Gender, edited by
Kevin L. Nadal, 1579–1580. Newbury Park: Sage.
Tannen, Deborah
2002 “
Agonism
in Academic Discourse.”
Journal of
Pragmatics 34(10–11):1651–1669.
Terkourafi, Marina
2001 Politeness
in Cypriot Greek: A Frame-based Approach. Ph.D.
diss., University of Cambridge.
Terkourafi, Marina
2008 “
Toward
a Unified Theory of Politeness, Impoliteness, and
Rudeness.” In
Impoliteness in Language: Studies on its Interplay with
Power in Theory and Practice, edited by
Derek Bousfield and
Miriam A. Locher, 45–74. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
Upadhyay, Shiv R.
2010 “
Identity and Impoliteness in
Computer-mediated Reader Responses.”
Journal of Politeness
Research 6(1):105–127.
van der Bom, Isabelle, and Sara Mills
2015 “
A
Discursive Approach to the Analysis of Politeness Data.”
Journal of Politeness
Research 11(2):179–206.
Vásquez, Camilla, and Addie Sayers China
2019 “
From
‘My Manly Husband…’ to ‘… Sitting Down to Take a Pee’: The Construction and Deconstruction of Gender in Amazon
Reviews”. In
Analyzing Digital Discourse: New Insights and Future
Directions, edited by
Patricia Bou-Franch and
Pilar Garcés-Conejos Blitvich, 193–218. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan.
Watts, Richard J.
2003 Politeness. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Cited by
Cited by 2 other publications
Saz-Rubio, Ma Milagros del
2023.
Assessing impoliteness-related language in response to a season's greeting posted by the Spanish and English Prime Ministers on Twitter.
Journal of Pragmatics 206
► pp. 31 ff.
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 20 march 2024. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers.
Any errors therein should be reported to them.