Historical politics in newspaper reporting
Media representations of football supporters’ commemoration activism
Historical politics is usually an institutionalised top-down phenomenon, in which the government or the cultural elites selectively formulate a historical narrative to unify and homogenize the imagined nation-state. Yet, there are also grassroots movements in the public sphere, which participate in the uses and abuses of history for identity politics. We focus on one such case: the football supporters’ commemoration activism. While football supporters’ social activism and the role of football matches as lieux de mémoire have received significant scholarly interest, their commemoration activism is as yet poorly described. In this paper we investigate how two regional newspapers of differing political position report this issue. The DHA-inspired qualitative analysis shows that Gazeta Wyborcza writes about it relatively rarely and views it as an appropriation of collective memory. Głos Wielkopolski on the other hand constructs football supporters as a rejuvenating force in local identity and memory politics.
Article outline
- 1.Introduction
- 2.Social activism
- 3.Memory games
- 4.The socio-historical context of the study
- 5.Press representation of the commemoration activism of football supporters
- 5.1Representation of Lech Poznań supporters memory activism by Głos Wlkp
- 5.2Representation of Lech Poznań supporters memory activism by Gazeta Wyborcza
- 6.Discussion and conclusions
- Acknowledgements
-
Primary sources
-
References
References (54)
Primary sources
Bojarski, Piotr, Cykla, Tomasz, Kaźmierska, Marta, Kompowski, Adam, Lipoński, Seweryn, Łukaszewski, Jakub, Nawrot, Radosław, Mazur, Natalia, Wesołek, Marcin, Żytnicki, Piotr and Joanna Leśniewska
2013 “
Poznańskie Wydarzenia 2013 [Poznań events 2013].”
Gazeta Wyborcza, Strony Lokalne Poznań nr 3001, 27/12/2013.
Dąbrowski, Błażej
2016 “
Powstanie Wielkopolskie: Tysiące mogił powstańców czeka na tabliczki [Wielkopolska Uprising: Thousands of the insurgents’ graves waiting for the plaques].”
Głos Wielkopolski, 27/12/2016, Updated: 27/12/2016.
Dąbrowski, Błażej and Mikołaj Woźniak
2016 “
W Poznaniu świętowano, w Lesznie zagłuszano apel [Celebrations in Poznań, drowning the call in Leszno].”
Głos Wielkopolski, 28/12/2016.
Dobroń, Katarzyna
2014 “
Wielkopolska pamięta o swoich bohaterach [Wielkopolska remembers its heroes].”
Głos Wielkopolski, 27–28/12/2014.
Kowalski, Norbert
2016 “
Kibice Lecha Poznań znowu będą zbierali na groby Powstańców Wielkopolskich [Lech Poznań supporters will collect for the graves of the Wielkopolska Insurgents again].”
Głos Wielkopolski, 30/10/2016, Updated: 31/10/2016.
Kowalski, Norbert
2016 “
Wielka iluminacja fanów Lecha na rocznicę Powstania Wielkopolskiego [Great pyrotechnic display by Lech supporterson the anniversary of the Wielkopolska Uprising].”
Głos Wielkopolski, 23/12/2016, Updated: 27/12/2016.
Lehmann, Alicja
2016 “
Wyrok za antyislamskie okrzyki na Stadionie [Court sentence for the anti-Islamic jeers at the stadium].”
Gazeta Wyborcza, Strony Lokalne Poznań nr 1501, 29/06/2016.
Lipoński, Seweryn
2014 “
Sojusz prezydenta z kibicami [An Alliance between the Mayor and the football fans].”
Gazeta Wyborcza, Strony Lokalne Poznań nr 2701, 21/11/2014.
Osiadło, Katarzyna
2013 “
Snowman, Pyra i Dinozaur [Snowman, spud and dinosaur].”
Gazeta Wyborcza, Co jest Grane Poznań nr 1371, 14/06/2013.
Podemski, Krzysztof
2016 “Święta nas dzielą zamiast łączyć [Holidays divide instead of uniting us].”
Gazeta Wyborcza, Strony Lokalne Poznań nr 1581, 08/07/2016.
Świderska, Agnieszka
2014 “
Kibice Lecha Poznań przed powstańczą zbiórką: Pełna mobilizacja [Lech Poznań supporters before the uprising call: Red alert].”
Głos Wielkopolski, 21/10/2014.
Świderska, Agnieszka
2014 “
Szykuj paczkę dla Kresów. Dodaj pamięć [Prepare a present for the Borderlands. Add memory].”
Głos Wielkopolski, 12/12/2014.
Świderska, Agnieszka
2014 “
Wielkie racowisko dla powstańców [Great ppyrotechnic display for the insurgents].”
Głos Wielkopolski, 30/12/2014.
TR.
2014 “
Rowerami na powstanie [Cycling to the uprising].”
Głos Wielkopolski, 23/12/2014.
TR.
2014 “
Z racami pod pomnik, ze zniczami na powstańcze groby [With flares to the monuments, with candles to the insurgents’ graves].”
Głos Wielkopolski, 23/12/2014.
Żytnicki, Piotr, Nyczka, Tomasz and Tomasz Cykla
2016 “
Rocznica w cieniu Smoleńska [Anniversary in the shadow of Smoleńsk].”,
Gazeta Wyborcza, Strony Lokalne Poznań nr 1501, 29/06/2016.
Żytnicki, Piotr
2016 “
<<Wiadomości>> ogłosiły: KOD zbezcześcił obchody [The TVP News announced: The Committee for the Defence of Democracy desacrated the celebrations].”
Gazeta Wyborcza, Strony Lokalne Poznań́ nr 1521, 01/07/2016.
Allison, Lincoln
(ed.) 1986 The Politics of Sport. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
Antonowicz, Dominik, and Łukasz Wrzesiński
2009 “
Kibice jako wspólnota niewidzialnej religii [football fans as a community of invisible religion].”
Studia Socjologiczne 1921: 115–150.
Beck, Peter J.
2003 “
The relevance of the ‘irrelevant’: Football as the missing dimension in the study of British relations with Germany.”
International Affairs 79(2): 389–411.
Blecking, Diethelm
2012 „
Niezapomniane mecze [Unforgettable matches].” In
Polsko-niemieckie miejsca pamięci. [
Polish-German sites of memory], ed. by
Robert Traba, and
Hans Henning Hahn, 397–412. Warszawa: Wydawnictwo Naukowe Scholar.
Bishop, Hywel and Adam Jaworski
2003 “
‘We beat ’em’: Nationalism and the hegemony of homogeneity in the British press reportage of Germany versus England during Euro 2000.”
Discourse & Society 14(3): 243–271.
Borges, Fernando
2017 “
Benfica TV: Taking control of the communication process.” In
Football and Supporter activism in Europe. Whose Game Is It? [
Football Research in an Enlarged Europe series], ed. by
Garcia, Borja, and
Jinming Zheng, 187–210. Cham: Springer for Palgrave MacMillan.
Caudwell, Jayne
2017 “
<<I love going to watch Norwich>>: The experiences of a transgender football fan.” In
Football and Supporter Activism in Europe. Whose Game Is It? [
Football Research in an Enlarged Europe series], ed. by
Garcia, Borja, and
Jinming Zheng. 27–44. Cham: Springer for Palgrave MacMillan.
Croci, Osvaldo
2017 “
Football supporters’ trusts in Italy: A horizontal survey and the case of Sambenedettese.” In
Football and Supporter Activism in Europe. Whose Game Is It? [
Football Research in an Enlarged Europe series], ed. by
Garcia, Borja, and
Jinming Zheng, 65–88. Cham: Springer for Palgrave MacMillan.
Dmowski, Seweryn
2015 “
Football sites of memory in the Eastern Bloc 1945–1991.” In
European Football and Collective Memory, ed. by
Wolfram Pyta and
Nils Havemann, 171–184. Houndmills: Palgrave Macmillan.
Dudała, Jerzy
2004 Fani-chuligani. Rzecz o polskich kibolach. Studium socjologiczne [
Fans-hooligans. About Polish football supporters. A sociological study]. Warszawa: ŻAK Wydawnictwo Akademickie.
Fabiszak, Małgorzata, and Anna Weronika Brzezińska
2018 Cmentarz, park, podwórko. Poznańskie przestrzenie pamięci [
Cemetery, park, yard. Poznań spaces of memory]. Warsaw: Scholar.
García-García, Borja, Ramón Llopis-Goig, and Agustín Martín
2015 “
The contribution of Real Madrid’s first five European Cups to the emergence of a common football space.” In
European Football and Collective Memory, ed. by
Wolfram Pyta, and
Nils Havemann, 85–100. Houndmills: Palgrave Macmillan.
Groll, Michael
2015 “
UEFA football competitions as European sites of memory – cups of identity?” In
European Football and Collective Memory, ed. by
Wolfram Pyta, and
Nils Havemann, 64–84. Houndmills: Palgrave Macmillan.
Heberle, Rudolf
1951 Social Movements. An Introduction to Political Sociology. New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts.
Hobsbawm, Eric
1990 Nations and Nationalism Since 1780: Programme, Myth, Reality. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Kech, Clemens
2015 “
Heysel and its symbolic value in Europe’s collective memory.” In
European Football and Collective Memory, ed. by
Wolfram Pyta, and
Nils Havemann, 152–170. Houndmills: Palgrave Macmillan.
Korora, Aaron
2013 “
Political activism and student movement” In
Sociology Of Education: An A-To-Z Guide, ed. by
James Ainsworth, pages not numbered. Thousand Oaks, California: SAGE Publications. EBSCO Host.
Kossakowski, Radosław
2017 “
From the bottom to the Premiership: The significance of the supporters’ movement in the governance of football clubs in Poland.” In
Football and Supporter Activism in Europe. Whose Game Is It? [
Football Research in an Enlarged Europe series], ed. by
Garcia, Borja, and
Jinming Zheng, 233–255. Cham: Springer for Palgrave MacMillan.
Kubicek, Paul
2015 European Politics. New York: Pearson Education.
Kurczewska, Joanna
2016 “
Wspólnoty pamięci lokalnej i narodowej. Kilka uwag o ich zbiorowym wytwarzaniu à la polonaise [Communities of local and national memory. Some notes on their collective production à la polonaise].”
Teksty Drugie 61: 30–51.
Martin, Brian
2007 “
Activism, social and political”. In
Encyclopaedia of Activism and Social Justice, ed. by
Kathryn Herr, and
Gary L. Anderson. 19–27. Thousand Oaks: SAGE.
McKerrell, Simon
2012 “
Hearing sectarianism: Understanding Scottish sectarianism as a song.”
Critical Discourse Studies 9(4): 363–374.
Meyer, David S., and Kelsy Kretschmer
2007 “
Social movements”. In
21St Century Sociology: A Reference Handbook, ed. by
Clifton D. Bryant,
Gale Thomson, and
Dennis L. Peck, 540–548. Thousand Oaks: SAGE.
Meyer, Jean Christophe
2015 “
Erecting a European ‘Lieu de mémoire’? Media coverage of the 1966 World Cup and French discussions about the ‘Wembley goal.’” In
European Football and Collective Memory, ed. by
Wolfram Pyta, and
Nils Havemann, 119–138. Houndmills: Palgrave Macmillan.
Millward, Peter
2011 The Global Football League. Transnational Networks, Social Movements and Sport in the New Media Age. Houndmills: Palgrave Macmillan.
Mittag, Jürgen
2015 “
Negotiating the Cold War? Perspectives in memory research on UEFA, the early European football competitions and the European nations cups”. In
European Football and Collective Memory, ed. by
Wolfram Pyta, and
Nils Havemann, 40–63. Houndmills: Palgrave Macmillan.
Nora, Pierre
1989 “
Between memory and history: Les lieux des memories”.
Representations 261: 7–26.
Nowak, Marek
2015 Teoria nieracjonalnego działania. Socjologiczne studium na temat wolontariatu i społecznego aktywizmu. [
Theory of non-rational action. A sociological study of volunteer action and social activism]. Poznań: Wydawnictwo Naukowe UAM.
O’Brien, Jim
2017 “
C.A. Osasuna: Identity, ownership and governance in Spanish club football.” In
Football and Supporter Activism in Europe. Whose Game Is It? [
Football Research in an Enlarged Europe series], ed. by
Garcia, Borja, and
Jinming Zheng, 121–139. Cham: Springer for Palgrave MacMillan.
Piotrowski, Grzegorz
2105 “
Ruch społeczny czy subkultura? Alterglobaliści w Europie Środkowej i Wschodniej [Social movement or subculture? Alterglobalists in Central and Eastern Europe].”
Przegląd Socjologii Jakościowej 11(4): 168–191.
Sokołowski, Marek
2012 W lustrze mediów. Wizerunki wybranych subkultur, grup społecznych i zawodowych [
In the media mirror. The image of selected subcultures, social and professional groups]. Toruń: Wydawnictwo Adam Marszałek.
Tindall, David B., and Tracy Groenewegen
2014 “
Activists and Activists, Digital”. In
Encyclopedia Of Social Media and Politics, ed. by
Harvey Kerric, 2–11. Thousand Oaks: SAGE.
Totten, Mick
2015 “
Sport activism and political praxis within the FC Sankt Pauli fan subculture”,
Soccer & Society 16(4): 453–468.
Trenz, Hans-Jörg
2005 Europa in den Medien. Die europäische Integration im Spiegel nationalen Öffentlichkeit. Frankfurt: Campus.
Wilson, John
1973 Introduction to Social Movements. New York: Basic Books.
Zheng, Jinming and Borja Garcia
2017 “
Conclusions: The rising importance of supporter activism in European football.” In
Football and Supporter Activism in Europe. Whose Game Is It? [
Football Research in an Enlarged Europe series], ed. by
Garcia, Borja, and
Jinming Zheng, 277–285. Cham: Springer for Palgrave MacMillan.
Ziesche, Daniel
2017 “
Well governed? Fan representation in German professional football clubs.” In
Football and Supporter Activism in Europe. Whose Game Is It? [
Football Research in an Enlarged Europe series], ed. by
Garcia, Borja, and
Jinming Zheng, 89–120. Cham: Springer for Palgrave MacMillan.
Cited by (1)
Cited by 1 other publications
Fabiszak, Małgorzata & Anna Weronika Brzezińska
2020.
Konflikt pamięci czy konflikt władzy? Strategie językowe w dyskusji nad zmianą nazwy ulicy w Poznaniu.
tekst i dyskurs - text und diskurs :13 (2020)
► pp. 81 ff.
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 5 july 2024. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers.
Any errors therein should be reported to them.