Article published In:
Journal of Language and Politics: Online-First Articles

“We pursue justice”

Legitimation strategies in the public-facing communications of philanthropic foundations in global sustainability governance

ORCID logo | Erasmus University Rotterdam | Utrecht University
ORCID logo | Erasmus University Rotterdam
ORCID logo | Utrecht University
Philanthropic foundations are key players in global sustainability governance. This paper explores the legitimation strategies these foundations use to justify their actions and positions in the sustainable development community. By combining Theo van Leeuwen’s legitimation framework with our novel analytical justice framework, we offer a new tool to analyse hard-to-research actors. Analysing data from 41 foundation websites, we find that foundations emphasize Global Egalitarian Cosmopolitanism in their values and objectives to align with global sustainability discourses. However, Libertarian ideas dominate when discussing programs and founders. This indicates there may be internal conflicts within foundations over the relationship between extreme wealth accumulation required for global philanthropy and sustainability objectives. In turn, this has implications for how foundations position themselves as agents of justice in sustainable development. While discourse analysis provides valuable insights into philanthropic legitimation strategies, further research is needed to fully understand how justice intersects with organizational decision-making.
Keywords: justice, philanthropy, sustainable development, legitimation, critical discourse studies
Article outline
  • 1.Introduction
  • 2.Philanthropy and sustainable development
  • 3.Legitimation and justice
    • 3.1Van Leeuwen’s legitimation framework
    • 3.2Analytical justice framework
      • 3.2.1Theories of justice
      • 3.2.2Aspects of justice
  • 4.Methodology
    • 4.1Corpus selection
    • 4.2Analytical method
    • 4.3Audience
  • 5.Results
    • 5.1Authorisation
    • 5.2Moral evaluation
    • 5.3Rationalisation
    • 5.4Mythopoesis
  • 6.Discussion
  • 7.Conclusion
  • Acknowledgements
  • Note
  • References
Available under the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) 4.0 license.

For any use beyond this license, please contact the publisher at [email protected].

Published online: 6 January 2025
DOI logo
https://doi.org/10.1075/jlp.24040.deh
References (48)
References
Bennett, Samuel. 2022. “Mythopoetic Legitimation and the Recontextualisation of Europe’s Foundational Myth.” Journal of Language and Politics 21 (2): 370–89. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Berkey, Brian. 2021. “The Philosophical Core of Effective Altruism.” Journal of Social Philosophy 52 (1): 93–115. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Betsill, Michele, Ashley Enrici, Elodie Le Cornu, and Rebecca Gruby. 2021. “Philanthropic Foundations as Agents of Environmental Governance: A Research Agenda.” Environmental Politics 31 (4): 684–705. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Biermann, Frank, Thomas Hickmann, Carole-Anne Sénit, Marianne Beisheim, Steven Bernstein, Pamela Chasek, Leonie Grob, et al. 2022. “Scientific Evidence on the Political Impact of the Sustainable Development Goals.” Nature Sustainability 51:795–800. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Biermann, Frank, Thomas Hickmann, Carole-Anne Sénit, and Leonie Grob. 2022. “The Sustainable Development Goals as a Transformative Force?” In The Political Impact of the Sustainable Development Goals: Transforming Governance Through Global Goals?, ed. by Frank Biermann, Thomas Hickmann, and Carole-Anne Sénit, 204–26. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Biermann, Frank, and Agni Kalfagianni. 2020. “Planetary Justice: A Research Framework.” Earth System Governance 61. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Bishop, Matthew, and Michael Green. 2008. Philanthrocapitalism: How the Rich Can Save the World and Why We Should Let Them. London: A & C Black.Google Scholar
Blackwatters, Jeffrey, Michele Betsill, Ashley Enrici, Elodie Le Cornu, Xavier Basurto, and Rebecca Gruby. 2023. “More than Funders: The Roles of Philanthropic Foundations in Marine Conservation Governance.” Conservation Science and Practice 5 (5): 1–13. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Bogers, Maya, Frank Biermann, Agni Kalfagianni, and Rakhyun Kim. 2022. “Sustainable Development Goals Fail to Advance Policy Integration: A Large-n Text Analysis of 159 International Organizations.” Environmental Science and Policy 1381:134–45. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Bogers, Maya, Frank Biermann, Agni Kalfagianni, Rakhyun Kim, Jelle Treep, and Martine de Vos. 2022. “The Impact of the Sustainable Development Goals on a Network of 276 International Organizations.” Global Environmental Change 761. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Breeze, Beth. 2021. “Interviewing Elite Donors: Gaining Access, Developing Rapport and Dealing with the Dazzle.” Voluntas: International Journal of Voluntary and Nonprofit Organizations 341:154–61. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Budabin, Alexandra, Louise Rasmussen, and Lisa Richey. 2017. “Celebrity-Led Development Organisations: The Legitimating Function of Elite Engagement.” Third World Quarterly 38 (9): 1952–72. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Correa-Cabrera, Guadalupe, Lucas Núñez, and Hayden Ludwig. 2021. “Assessing the International Influence of Private Philanthropy: The Case of Open Society Foundations.” Global Studies Quarterly 1 (4): 1–14. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Dijk, Teun van. 2006. “Discourse, Context and Cognition.” Discourse Studies 8 (1): 159–77. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Eikenberry, Angela, and Roseanne Mirabella. 2018. “Extreme Philanthropy: Philanthrocapitalism, Effective Altruism, and the Discourse of Neoliberalism.” PS: Political Science & Politics 51 (1): 43–47.Google Scholar
Gabriel, Iason. 2017. “Effective Altruism and Its Critics.” Journal of Applied Philosophy 34 (4): 457–73. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Gavriely-Nuri, Dalia. 2017. “Cultural Approach to CDA: From Theory to Practice.” In The Routledge Handbook of Critical Discourse Studies, ed. by John Flowerdew and John Richardson, 120–32. Abingdon: Routledge. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Gruby, Rebecca, Ashley Enrici, Michele Betsill, Elodie Le Cornu, and Xavier Basurto. 2021. “Opening the Black Box of Conservation Philanthropy: A Co-Produced Research Agenda on Private Foundations in Marine Conservation.” Marine Policy 1321. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Harrow, Jenny, and Tobias Jung. 2015. “Debate: Thou Shalt Have Impact, Total Impact — Government Involvement in Philanthropic Foundations’ Decision-Making.” Public Money & Management 35 (3): 176–78. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Kagan, Jennifer, and Jennifer Dodge. 2023. “The Third Sector and Climate Change: A Literature Review and Agenda for Future Research and Action.” Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly 52 (4): 871–91. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Kalfagianni, Agni. 2022. “Philanthropic Foundations as Agents of Justice in Global Sustainability Governance.” Global Studies Quarterly 21:1–7. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Krzyżanowski, Michał. 2014. “Values, Imaginaries and Templates of Journalistic Practice: A Critical Discourse Analysis.” Social Semiotics 24 (3): 345–65. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Leeuwen, Theo van. 2007. “Legitimation in Discourse and Communication.” Discourse & Communication 1 (1): 91–112. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
. 2008. Discourse and Practice: New Tools for Critical Analysis. Oxford: Oxford University Press. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
. 2018. “Moral Evaluation in Critical Discourse Analysis.” Critical Discourse Studies 15 (2): 140–53. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Leeuwen, Theo van, and Ruth Wodak. 1999. “Legitimizing Immigration Control: A Discourse-Historical Analysis.” Discourse Studies 1 (1): 83–118. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Lenz, Tobias, and Fredrik Söderbaum. 2023. “The Origins of Legitimation Strategies in International Organizations: Agents, Audiences and Environments.” International Affairs 99 (3): 899–920. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Luyckx, Joost, and Maddy Janssens. 2020. “Ideology and (de)Legitimation: The Belgian Public Debate on Corporate Restructuring during the Great Recession.” Organization 27 (1): 110–39. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Ma, Ji, and René Bekkers. 2024. “Consensus Formation in Nonprofit and Philanthropic Studies: Networks, Reputation, and Gender.” Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly 53 (1): 127–58. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Machin, David, and Yueyue Liu. 2023. “How Tick List Sustainability Distracts from Actual Sustainable Action: The UN 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development.” Critical Discourse Studies 21 (2): 164–81. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Maclean, Mairi, Charles Harvey, Roy Suddaby, and Kevin O’Gorman. 2018. “Political Ideology and the Discursive Construction of the Multinational Hotel Industry.” Human Relations 71 (6): 766–95. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
McGoey, Linsey. 2015. No Such Thing as a Free Gift. London: Verso.Google Scholar
Monier, Anne. 2023. “The Mobilization of the Philanthropic Sector for the Climate: A New Engagement?” In The Palgrave Handbook of Environmental Politics and Theory, ed. by Joel Kassiola and Timothy Luke, 367–82. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Moran, Michael. 2023. “Global Philanthropy.” In International Organization and Global Governance, ed. by Thomas Weiss, 3rd ed., 440–56. Milton: Routledge. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Morena, Edouard. 2016. The Price of Climate Action: Philanthropic Foundations in the International Climate Debate. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Papin, Marielle, and Philippe Beauregard. 2023. “Can’t Buy Me Love: Billionaire Entrepreneurs’ Legitimation Strategies in Transnational Climate Governance.” Environmental Politics 33 (1): 70–91. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Reich, Rob. 2018. Just Giving: Why Philanthropy Is Failing Democracy and How It Can Do Better. Princeton: Princeton University Press. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Reisigl, Martin. 2018. “The Discourse-Historical Approach.” In The Routledge Handbook of Critical Discourse Studies, 75–94. Abingdon: Routledge.Google Scholar
Reisigl, Martin, and Ruth Wodak. 2016. “The Discourse-Historical Approach (DHA).” In Methods of Critical Discourse Studies, ed. by Ruth Wodak and Michael Meyer, 3rd ed., 23–61. London: SAGE Publications.Google Scholar
Schmitz, Hans, and Elena McCollim. 2021. “Billionaires in Global Philanthropy: A Decade of the Giving Pledge.” Society 581:120–30. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Schnurbein, Georg von, Marta Rey-Garcia, and Michaela Neumayr. 2021. “Contemporary Philanthropy in the Spotlight: Pushing the Boundaries of Research on a Global and Contested Social Practice.” Voluntas: International Journal of Voluntary and Nonprofit Organizations 321:185–93. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Suchman, Mark. 1995. “Managing Legitimacy: Strategic and Institutional Approaches.” The Academy of Management Review 20 (3): 571–610. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Vaara, Eero. 2014. “Struggles over Legitimacy in the Eurozone Crisis: Discursive Legitimation Strategies and Their Ideological Underpinnings.” Discourse & Society 25 (4): 500–518. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Vaara, Eero, Ana Aranda, and Helen Etchanchu. 2024. “Discursive Legitimation: An Integrative Theoretical Framework and Agenda for Future Research.” Journal of Management 50 (6): 2343–73. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Wiener, Antje. 2007. “The Dual Quality of Norms and Governance Beyond the State: Sociological and Normative Approaches to ‘Interaction.’” Critical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy 10 (1): 47–69. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Wierzbicka, Anna. 1998. “German ‘Cultural Scripts’: Public Signs as a Key to Social Attitudes and Cultural Values.” Discourse & Society 9 (2): 241–82. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Wodak, Ruth, and Michael Meyer. 2009. “Critical Discourse Analysis: History, Agenda, Theory, and Methodology.” In Methods for Critical Discourse Analysis, ed. by Ruth Wodak and Michael Meyer, 1–33. London: SAGE Publications.Google Scholar
Youde, Jeremy. 2019. “The Role of Philanthropy in International Relations.” Review of International Studies 45 (1): 39–56. DOI logoGoogle Scholar