Article published in:
Journal of Language and Sexuality
Vol. 11:1 (2022) ► pp. 57–79

Enregistering “gender ideology”

The emergence and circulation of a transnational anti-gender language

| Federal University of Rio de Janeiro, Brazil
Mobilizations against gender equality and sexual diversity have gained political traction globally despite their hyperbolic modes of action and conspiracist rhetoric. These anti-gender campaigns rally around “gender ideology,” a trope used to anathemize feminist and LGBTQIA+ activism/scholarship. This paper argues that anti-genderism is a register – a conventionalized aggregate of expressive forms and enactable person-types – of which “gender ideology” is the most famous shibboleth. The paper shows how inchoate collections of words, modes of action, and images of people (i.e. signs) have been enregistered into the cohesive but heterogeneous whole of anti-genderism through semiotic processes of clasping, relaying, and grafting (Gal 2018; 2019). The paper offers a sociolinguistic analysis of anti-genderism to understand the challenges it poses to the enfranchisement of women, queer, trans, and nonbinary people.
Keywords: “gender ideology”, anti-genderism, enregisterment, register, metapragmatics
Article outline
  • 1.The challenges ahead
  • 2.Anti-genderism as a register
  • 3.Forging metapragmatic labels: The “totalitarian feminist”
  • 4.Expansion: Relaying discursive arenas of action
  • 5.Graftings: Turning rights vocabulary inside out
  • 6.Conclusion: Unexpected coalitions and queer refusal
  • Acknowledgements
  • Notes
  • References
Published online: 11 February 2022
https://doi.org/10.1075/jls.21003.bor
References
Agha, Asif
2003 The social life of a cultural value. Language and Communication 231: 231–273. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
2007 Language and Social Relations. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Anatrella, Tony
2007 Homosexuality and homophobia. In Lexicon: Ambiguous and Debatable Terms Regarding Family Life and Ethical Questions, Pontifical Council for the Family (ed), 425–444. Front Royal, VA: Human Life International.Google Scholar
Barát, Erzsébet
2021 Populist discourse and desire for social justice. In The Oxford Handbook of Language and Sexuality, Kira Hall & Rusty Barrett (eds). Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Barreiro, Ignacio
2007 Verbal engineering. In Lexicon: Ambiguous and Debatable Terms Regarding Family Life and Ethical Questions, Pontifical Council for the Family (ed), 927–946. Front Royal, VA: Human Life International.Google Scholar
Bernini, Lorenzo
2020 Queer Theories: An Introduction. New York: Routledge. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Borba, Rodrigo
2019 Gendered politics of enmity: Language ideologies and social polarisation in Brazil. Gender and Language 13(4): 423–448. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
2021 Disgusting politics: Circuits of affects and the making of Bolsonaro. Social Semiotics 31(5): 677–694. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Borba, Rodrigo, Hall, Kira & Hiramoto, Mie
2020 Feminist refusal meets enmity. Gender and Language 14(1): 1–7. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Borba, Rodrigo & Milani, Tommaso
2017 The banality of evil: Crystallised structures of cisnormativity and tactics of resistance in a Brazilian gender clinic. Journal of Language and Discrimination 1(1): 7–33. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Burgraff, Jutta
2007 Gender. In Lexicon: Ambiguous and Debatable Terms Regarding Family Life and Ethical Questions, Pontifical Council for the Family (ed), 399–408. Front Royal, VA: Human Life International.Google Scholar
Butler, Judith
2019 Anti-gender ideology and Mahmood’s critique of the secular age. Journal of the American Academy of Religion 87(4): 1–13. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Case, Mary Anne
2016 The role of the popes in the invention of complementarity and the Vatican’s anathemization of gender. Religion and Gender 6(2): 155–172. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
2019 Trans formations in the Vatican’s war on “gender ideology.” Signs 44(3): 639–664. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Cooper, Melinda
2017 Family Values: Between Neoliberalism and the New Social Conservatism. New York: Zone Books. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Corrêa, Sonia
2018 A política do gênero: um comentário genealógico. Cadernos Pagu 531: e185301. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Corrêa, Sonia & Kalil, Isabela
2020 Políticas Antigénero en America Latina: Brasil. Rio de Janeiro: ABIA.Google Scholar
Corredor, Elizabeth
2019 Unpacking “gender ideology” and the Global Right’s antigender countermovement. Signs 44(3): 613–638. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Gal, Susan
2018 Registers in circulation: The social organization of interdiscursivity. Signs and Society 6(1): 1–24. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
2019 Making registers in politics: Circulation and ideologies of linguistic authority. Journal of Sociolinguistics 23(5): 450–466. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
2021 Gender and the discursive authority of far-right politics. Gender and Language 15(1): 96–103. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Gal, Susan & Irvine, Judith
2019 Signs of Difference: Language and Ideology in Social Life. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Garbagnoli, Sara
2016 Against the heresy of immanence: Vatican’s “gender” as a new rhetorical device against the denaturalization of the sexual order. Religion & Gender 6(2): 187–204. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Graff, Agnieszka & Korolczuk, Elzbieta
2017 “Worse than communism and Nazism put together”: War on gender in Poland. In Anti-gender Campaigns in Europe: Mobilizing against Equality, Roman Kuhar & David Paternotte (eds), 175–194. London: Rowman and Littlefield.Google Scholar
2021 Anti-Gender Politics in the Populist Moment. London: Routledge. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
John Paul II
1988 Mullieres dignatatem. Vatican City. https://​tinyurl​.com​/y3khuehb; accessed October 8, 2021.
1994 Lettera di Giovanni Paolo II alle famiglie Gratissimam Sane. Vatican City. https://​tinyurl​.com​/yyon775d; accessed October 8, 2021.
1995a Evangelium vitae. Vatican City. https://​tinyurl​.com​/yxt86wu7; accessed October 8, 2021.
1995b Lettera del papa Giovanni Paolo II alle donne. Vatican City. https://​tinyurl​.com​/y32ga9mz; accessed October 8, 2021.
Junqueira, Rogério
2019 A invenção da “ideologia de gênero”: A emergência de um cenário político-discursivo e a elaboração de uma retórica reacionária antigênero. Psicologia Política 18(43): 449–502.Google Scholar
Konnelly, Lex
2021 Nuance and normativity in trans linguistic research. Journal of Language and Sexuality 10(1): 71–82. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Korolczuk, Elzbieta & Graff, Agnieszka
2018 Gender as “Ebola from Brussels”: The anticolonial frame and the rise of illiberal populism. Signs 43(4): 797–821. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Kuhar, Roman & Paternotte, David
(eds) 2017 Anti-Gender Campaigns in Europe: Mobilizing Against Equality. London: Rowman and Littlefield.Google Scholar
Leap, William & Motschenbacher, Heiko
2012 Launching a new phase in language and sexuality studies. Language and Sexuality 1(1): 1–14. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Mad’arová, Zuzana
2015 Love and fear: Argumentative strategies against gender equality in Slovakia. In Anti-Gender Movements on the Rise? Strategising for Gender Equality in Central and Eastern Europe, Heinrich Böll Foundation (ed), 33–42. Berlin: Heinrich Böll Foundation.Google Scholar
Mayer, Stefanie & Sauer, Birgit
2017 “Gender ideology” in Austria: Coalitions around an empty signifier. In Anti-Gender Campaigns in Europe: Mobilizing Against Equality, Roman Kuhar & David Paternotte (eds), 23–40. London: Rowman and Littlefield.Google Scholar
Milani, Tommaso
2020 No-go zones in Sweden: The infectious communicability of evil. Language, Culture, and Society 2(2): 7–36. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Miskolci, Richard & Campana, Maximiliano
2017 “Ideologia de gênero”: Notas para a genealogia de um pânico moral contemporâneo. Sociedade e Estado 32(3): 725–747. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Moragas, Mirta
2020 Políticas Antigénero en America Latina: El Caso de la Organización de los Estados Americanos (OEA). Rio de Janeiro: ABIA.Google Scholar
O’Leary, Dale
1995 Gender – The Deconstruction of Women: Analysis of the Gender Perspective in Preparation for the Fourth World Conference on Women. https://​tinyurl​.com​/y55zokzm; accessed October 13, 2020.
1997 The Gender Agenda: Redefining Equality. Lafayette, LA: Vital Issues.Google Scholar
Paternotte, David
2015 Habemus gender! Autopsie d’une obsession vaticane. In Habemus Gender! Déconstruction d’une Risposte Religieuse, David Paternotte & Sofie van der Dussen (eds), 7–22. Brussels: EUB.Google Scholar
2019 Backlash: A misleading narrative. Engenderings https://​blogs​.lse​.ac​.uk​/gender​/2020​/03​/30​/backlash​-a​-misleading​-narrative/; accessed October 8, 2021.
Paternotte, David & Kuhar, Roman
2017 “Gender ideology” in movement: Introduction. In Anti-Gender Campaigns in Europe: Mobilizing Against Equality, Roman Kuhar & David Paternotte (eds), 1–22. London: Rowman and Littlefield.Google Scholar
Paul VI
1965 Messaggio del Santo Padre Paolo VI alle donne. Vatican City. https://​tinyurl​.com​/y3mjeuf9 ; accessed August 28, 2020.
Pearce, Ruth, Erikainen, Sonja & Vincent, Ben
2020 TERF wars: An introduction. The Sociological Review Monographs 68(4): 677–698. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Pius XII
1950 Humani generis. Vatican City. https://​tinyurl​.com​/y4rnlf9d; accessed August 28, 2020.
Quinlan, Casey
2016 Pope calls teaching about gender identity “ideological colonization.” ThinkProgress. https://​tinyurl​.com​/yy2pd7p7; accessed August 2, 2020.
Ramirez, Gabriela Arguedas
2020 “Ideología de Género,” lo “Post-Secular,” el Fundamentalismo Neopentecostal y el Neointegrismo Católico. Rio de Janeiro: ABIA.Google Scholar
Ratzinger, Joseph
1985 Rapporto sulla Fede. Alba: San Paolo.Google Scholar
1997a Préface. In L’Évangile face au Désordre Mondial, Michel Schooyans, i–iv. Paris: Fayard.Google Scholar
1997b La Sal de la Tierra. Madrid: Libros Palabra.Google Scholar
Revoredo, Óscar
1998 La Ideología de Género: Sus Peligros y Alcances. Lima: Conferencia Episcopal Peruana. https://​tinyurl​.com​/y3zj8pv8; accessed August 29, 2020.
Russell, Eric
2019  Les Hommen: The language of reactionary masculinity. Gender and Language 13(1): 94–121. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Sauntson, Helen
2020 Conflicting discourses of “democracy” and “equality”: A discourse analysis of the language of pro- and anti-LGBTIQ+ inclusion in the relationships and sex education guidance for schools in England. Trabalhos em Linguística Aplicada 59(3): 1995–2016. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Sauntson, Helen & Borba, Rodrigo
2021 Silence and sexuality in school settings: A transnational perspective. In The Handbook of Solitude, Silence and Loneliness, Julien Stern, Malgorzata Walejko, Christopher Sink & Wong Ho (eds), 174–188. London: Bloomsbury.Google Scholar
Schooyans, Michel
1997 L’Évangile face au Désordre Mondial. Paris: Fayard.Google Scholar
Sommers, Christina
1994 Who Stole Feminism? How Women Have Betrayed Women. New York: Simon & Schuster.Google Scholar
Trujillo, Afonso López
2007 Preface. In Lexicon: Ambiguous and Debatable Terms Regarding Family Life and Ethical Questions, Pontifical Council for the Family (ed), xiii–xxii. Front Royal, VA: Human Life International.Google Scholar
Vatican
2000 Famiglia, Matrominio e “Unioni de Fatto” https://​tinyurl​.com​/ohgrees; accessed September 28, 2020.
Wodak, Ruth
2021 Politics of Fear: The Shameless Normalization of Far-Right Discourse. London: Sage.Google Scholar
Zimman, Lal
2020 Transgender language, transgender moment: Towards a trans linguistics. In The Oxford Handbook of Language and Sexuality, Kira Hall & Rusty Barrett (eds). New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
2021 Beyond the cis gays’ cis gaze: The need for a trans linguistics. Gender and Language 15(3): 423–429. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Zottola, Angela & Borba, Rodrigo
forthcoming. “Gender ideology” and the discursive infrastructure of a transnational conspiracy narrative. In Discourses Of and About Conspiracy Theories, Massimiliano Demata, Ruth Breeze, Virginia Zorzi & Angela Zottola eds London John Benjamins