Implicit homophobic argument structure
Equal-marriage discourse in The Moral Maze
This article analyses the linguistic and discursive elements which contribute to the production of implicit homophobia. Explicit homophobia has been well documented and strategies for countering discriminatory language have been developed (Baker 2014, Leap 2012). However, our interest here is in documenting implicit homophobia, where homophobic beliefs are only hinted at, are disassociated from the speaker, or are embedded within discursive and argument structures. We decided to analyse the debate in the media around the introduction of equal or same-sex marriage legislation in the UK. We focused our analysis on a series of radio programmes on BBC Radio 4, The Moral Maze (2011–2012), where the issue of same-sex marriage was debated with a team of panelists and invited guests from a range of different organisations. Different perspectives on same-sex marriage were discussed, in a seemingly objective and dispassionate way, where the interactants distanced themselves from homophobic beliefs and yet implicitly subscribed to homophobia. We used an analysis drawing on argumentation structure (Fairclough & Fairclough 2012) and through focusing on stance, recontextualisation, imaginaries, and metaphor, we developed an analysis which made the way that implicit homophobia works more visible. In this way, we hope to foreground implicit homophobia, and develop a linguistic and discursive ‘toolkit’ which will enable it to be challenged and countered.
References
Baker, Paul
2004 ‘Unnatural acts’: Discourses of homosexuality within the House of Lords debates on gay male law reform.
Journal of Sociolinguistics 8(1): 88–106.


Baker, Paul
2008 Sexed Texts: Language, Gender and Sexuality. London: Equinox.

Baker, Paul
2014 Using Corpora to Analyze Gender. London: Bloomsbury.

Baker, Paul & Ellece, Sibonile
2011 Key Terms in Discourse Analysis. London: Continuum.

Baunach, Dawn Michelle
2011 Decomposing trends in attitudes toward gay marriage, 1988–2006.
Social Science Quarterly 92(2): 346–363.


Brickell, Chris
2001 Whose ‘special treatment’? Heterosexism and the problems with liberalism.
Sexualities 4(2): 211–236.


Brown, Penelope & Levinson, Stephen
1987 Politeness: Some Universals in Language Usage. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.


Burr, Vivien
1995 An Introduction to Social Constructionism. London: Routledge.


Burridge, Joseph
2004 ‘I am not homophobic but…’: Disclaiming in discourse resisting repeal of Section 28.
Sexualities 7(3): 327–344.


Burton, Deirdre
1982 Through glass darkly, through dark glasses. In
Language and Literature, Ronald Carter (ed), 195–214. London: Allen and Unwin.

Butler, Judith
1997 Excitable Speech: A Politics of the Performative. London: Routledge.

Cameron, Deborah
1997 Performing gender identity: Young men’s talk and the construction of heterosexual masculinity. In
Language and Masculinity,
Sally Johnson &
Ulrike Hanna Meinhof (eds), 47–64. Oxford: Blackwell.

Carey, George
2012 Marriage will ONLY remain the bedrock of society if it is between a man and a woman.
Daily Mail 19 February 2012 <
[URL] (November 11, 2013).

Coulthard, Malcolm & Johnson, Alison
2007 An Introduction to Forensic Linguistics. London: Routledge.


Coupland, Justine & Coupland, Nikolas
2009 Attributing stance in discourses of body shape and weight loss. In
Stance: Sociolinguistic Perspectives, Alexandra Jaffe (ed), 227–249. Oxford: Oxford University Press.


Edwards, Jane
2007 ‘Marriage is sacred’: The religious right’s argument against ‘gay marriage’ in Australia.
Culture, Health and Sexuality 9(3): 247–261.


Fairclough, Norman
1989 Language and Power. London: Longman.

Fairclough, Isabelle & Fairclough, Norman
2012 Political Discourse Analysis. London: Routledge.

Fry, Stephen
2013 ‘Out there’,
BBC 21
14 October 2013 <
[URL] (March 1, 2014).

HM Government
2012 Equal marriage: The government’s response.
[URL] (November 11, 2013).
Holehouse, Matthew & Deacon, Michael
2013 Godfrey Bloom ‘should resign’ after sluts jibe, says Nigel Farage.
The Telegraph 20 September 2013 <
[URL] (January 21, 2014).

Jaffe, Alexandra
2009 Introduction: The sociolinguistics of stance. In
Stance: Sociolinguistic Perspectives,
Alexandra Jaffe (ed), 3–28. Oxford: Oxford University Press.


Jeffries, Lesley
2010 Critical Stylistics: The Power of English. London: Palgrave.


Lakoff, George & Johnson, Mark
1980 Metaphors We Live By. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.


Leap, William
2004 Language and homophobic discourse. Paper presented at the Eleventh Lavender Languages and Linguistics Conference, February 2004, American University, Washington, DC.
Leap, William
2010 Homophobia as moral geography.
Gender and Language 4(2): 187–220.

Leap, William
2012 Queer linguistics, sexuality and discourse analysis. In
The Routledge Handbook of Discourse Analysis,
James Paul Gee &
Michael Handford (eds), 558–571. London: Routledge.

Mills, Sara
2008 Language and Sexism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.


Morrish, Elizabeth
1997 ‘Falling short of God’s ideal’: Public discourse about lesbians and gays. In
Queerly Phrased: Language, Gender and Sexuality,
Anna Livia &
Kira Hall (eds), 335–345. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Morrish, Elizabeth
2010 Situating and resisting homophobic discourse: Response to Leap, Junge, Peterson, and Provencher.
Gender and Language 4(2): 323–335.

Moscowitz, Leigh M
2010 Gay marriage in television news: Voice and visual representation in the same-sex marriage debate.
Journal of Broadcasting and Electronic Media 54(1): 24–39.


Motschenbacher, Heiko
2011 Taking queer linguistics further: Sociolinguistics and critical heteronormativity research.
International Journal of the Sociology of Language 2121: 149–179.

O’Brien, Keith
2012 We cannot afford to indulge this madness.
The Telegraph 3 March 2012 <
[URL] (November 11, 2013).

Pascoe, Cheri Jo
2005 ‘Dude, you’re a fag’: Adolescent masculinity and the fag discourse.
Sexualities 8(3): 329–346.


Peterson, David
2010 ‘The basis for a free, just and stable society’: Institutional homophobia and governance at the Family Research Council.
Gender and Language 4(2): 257–286.

Peterson, David
2011 Neoliberal homophobic discourse: Heteronormative human capital and the exclusion of queer citizens.
Journal of Homosexuality 581: 742–757.


Provencher, Denis
2010 ‘I dislike politicians and homosexuals’: Language and homophobia in France.
Gender and Language 4(2): 287–321.

The Moral Maze: Gay Marriage
2012 BBC Radio 4. 14 March, 20:00. Broadcast available from:
[URL] (February 1, 2014).
The Moral Maze: The Moral Virtue of Marriage
2013 BBC Radio 4. 6 February, 20:00. Broadcast available from:
[URL] (February 1, 2014).
The Moral Maze: The Moral Worth of Marriage
2011 BBC Radio 4. 16 February, 20:00. Broadcast available from:
[URL] (February 1, 2014).
Tiersma, Peter M
1999 Legal Language. Chicago: Chicago University Press.

van Gend, David
2004 Re-entering the circle of life, gays, ex-gays, and marriage (Address to the National Marriage Forum, August 4th 2004, Parliament House, Canberra).
[URL] (December 13, 2013).
Watts, Richard J
2003 Politeness. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.


Yep, Gust A
2002 From homophobia and heterosexism to heteronormativity.
Journal of Lesbian Studies 6(3–4): 163–176.


Cited by
Cited by 13 other publications
Chiang, Anita Yen & Hsi-Yao Su
2022.
Stop family destruction!: ideologies concerning family destruction metaphors in same-sex marriage debates.
Critical Discourse Studies ► pp. 1 ff.

Findlay, Jamie Y.
Jones, Lucy
2016.
“If a Muslim says ‘homo’, nothing gets done”: Racist discourse and in-group identity construction in an LGBT youth group.
Language in Society 45:1
► pp. 113 ff.

Jones, Lucy & Luke Collins
Kania, Ursula
2020.
Marriage for all (‘Ehe fuer alle’)?! A corpus-assisted discourse analysis of the marriage equality debate in Germany.
Critical Discourse Studies 17:2
► pp. 138 ff.

Liu, Xuekun
2021.
‘But if Taiwan legalizes same-sex marriage … ’: discourses of homophobia and nationalism in a Chinese antigay community online.
Critical Discourse Studies 18:4
► pp. 429 ff.

Motschenbacher, Heiko
2016.
The Language–Identity–Normativity Interface and Critical Discourse Studies. In
Language, Normativity and Europeanisation,
► pp. 51 ff.

Paterson, Laura L. & Laura Coffey-Glover
Paterson, Laura L. & Georgina Turner
2020.
Approaches to discourses of marriage.
Critical Discourse Studies 17:2
► pp. 133 ff.

Turner, Georgina, Sara Mills, Isabelle van der Bom, Laura Coffey-Glover, Laura L Paterson & Lucy Jones
2018.
Opposition as victimhood in newspaper debates about same-sex marriage.
Discourse & Society 29:2
► pp. 180 ff.

Vilanova, Anna, Susanna Soler & Eric Anderson
2020.
Examining the experiences of the first openly gay male team sport athlete in Spain.
International Review for the Sociology of Sport 55:1
► pp. 22 ff.

ÇEÇEN, Ahmet Faruk
2022.
İslamofobi Bağlamında Kodlanmış ve Açık Ayrımcı Dile Bakmak: İslamofobik Nefret Söylemi Açısından Bir Kategorizasyon Çabası.
TRT Akademi 
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 23 march 2023. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers.
Any errors therein should be reported to them.