Chapter published in:
Thetics and CategoricalsEdited by Werner Abraham, Elisabeth Leiss and Yasuhiro Fujinawa
[Linguistik Aktuell/Linguistics Today 262] 2020
► pp. 13–30
Categorical versus thetic sentences in the Universal Grammar of Realism
Elisabeth Leiss | Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München
The aim of this paper is to outline that the notions of thetic versus categorical sentences are
characteristic of a long tradition of philosophy, especially of the philosophy of Realism. Characteristic of Realism
is a highly developed theory of the copula. Sentences consist of a subject, a rather abstract copula, and a predicate.
Thus, the structure of any sentence and of any judgment is conceived as being triadic in nature. The copula appears –
overtly or covertly – in synthetic sentences as well as in analytic sentences, both of which are categorical sentences
(Roger Bacon 1240/2009: 70), whereby the analytic copula differs from the
synthetic copula with respect to the mode of signifying reality. It will be evidenced that the function of analytic
sentences is to build up a shared system of knowledge (mental lexicon), whereas synthetic sentences represent a
technique to socialize individual experiences. According to the philosophy of Realism, the copula appears even in
thetic sentences. Sentences without a copula are meant to be inconceivable. The working hypothesis is that in contrast
to categorical sentences, thetic sentences are not triadic, but dyadic in structure. According to the Realist
philosopher Lotze, thetic sentences consist of a copula and an amalgam of linguistically unstructured impressions,
compressed in the predicate. In line with the philosophy of Realism, thetic sentences are conceived as some premature
stage in the evolution of language. Thus, thetic sentences represent an embryonic stage of a categorical sentence as
well as of thought (Lotze 1874/1989: 70–74). Thetic sentences are able to
imitate the structure of categorical sentences (pseudo-subject – copula – pseudo-predicate). The conclusion is that
thetic sentences are pseudo-structured “intransitive” judgments. They consist of a copula and one single chunk of
“intransitive experience” only.
Keywords: Realism, Universal Grammar of Realism, categorical sentence, thetic sentence, analytic sentence, copula
Article outline
- 1.Universal Grammar (Philosophical Grammar) in the paradigm of Realism
- 2.The function of the copula in analytic categorical sentences
- 3.The function of the copula in synthetic categorical sentences
- 4.The function of the copula in thetic sentences
- 5.Outlook
-
Notes -
References
Published online: 22 July 2020
https://doi.org/10.1075/la.262.01lei
https://doi.org/10.1075/la.262.01lei
References
Abraham, Werner, Leiss, Elisabeth & Tanaka, Shin
von Aquin, Thomas. ca.
Bacon, Roger
Bertolacci, Amos
Bickerton, Derek
Brentano, Franz
Brito, Radulphus
Bühler, Karl
Casielles, Eugenia & Progovac, Ljiljana
Coseriu, Eugenio
Doitchinov, Serge
Frege, Gottlob
Goldberg, Adele E.
Kelly, Louis G.
Kuroda, Sige-Yuki
Leiss, Elisabeth
(2000): Artikel
und Aspekt. Die grammatischen Muster von Definitheit. (Studia Linguistica Germanica;
55). Berlin, New York: Walter de Gruyter. [Translation into Brazilian Portuguese by Ina Emmel. With
a preface by Werner Abraham. Florianopolis 2016: Artigo
e aspecto. Moldes gramaticais de definitude].
2017 Kodierung
von Wissen und Erfahrung anhand von zwei unterschiedlichen Kopula- und
Prädikatsqualitäten. In Grammatische Funktionen aus Sicht
der japanischen und deutschen Germanistik [Linguistische Berichte, Sonderheft
24], Shin Tanaka, Elisabeth Leiss, Werner Abraham & Yasuhiro Fujinawa (eds), 41–58. Hamburg: Buske.
2020 Thetik,
Kategorik und die Theorie der Koula in der Theorie der Universalgrammatik des
Realismus. In Zur Architektur von Thetik und Kategorik.
Deutsch, Japanisch, Chinesisch und Norwegisch [Studien zur deutschen Grammatik
97], Werner Abraham, Elisabeth Leiss & Shin Tanaka (eds), 15–40. Tübingen: Stauffenburg.
Lotze, Rudolf Hermann
Marty, Anton
Michaelis de Marbasio
Naumann, Bernd, Plank, Frans & Hofbauer, Gottfried
Okamoto, Junji
2020 Sind
thetische Aussagen inkompatibel mit deutschen Modal- und japanischen
Satzendpartikeln. In Zur Architektur von Thetik und
Kategorik. Deutsch, Japanisch, Chinesisch und Norwegisch [Studien zur deutschen Grammatik
97], Werner Abraham, Elisabeth Leiss & Shin Tanaka (eds), 267–319. Tübingen: Stauffenburg.
Peirce, Charles S.
Pinker, Steven
Rämä, Pia, Sirri, Louah & Serres, Josette
Schmitz, Kenneth L.
Smith, A. Mark
2001 Alhacen’s Theory of
Vision. A Critical Edition, with English Translations and Commentary, of the First Three books of Alhacen’s De
Aspectibus, the Medieval Latin Version of Ibn al-Hytham’s Kitāb
al-Manāẓir, Vol. 1: Introduction and
Latin Text [Transactions of the American Philosophical Society 91, parts 4 &
5]. Philadelphia PA: American Philosophical Society.
Tanaka, Shin
2018 V2-Puzzle
aus japanischer Perspektive: Zur Affinität von V2 und -wa im
Konditionalsatz. In Die Zukunft von Grammatik – Die
Grammatik der Zukunft. Festschrift für Werner Abraham anlässlich seines 80.
Geburtstags [Studien zur deutschen Grammatik 92], Elisabeth Leiss & Sonja Zeman (eds), 407–428. Tübingen: Stauffenburg.
Tulving, Endel
Vater, Johann Severin
Cited by
Cited by 1 other publications
Abraham, Werner
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 03 april 2022. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers. Any errors therein should be reported to them.