Cover not available
Article published In:
Language and Linguistics
Vol. 23:3 (2022) ► pp.371–410

香港粵語「咗」的語法特點

與北京話「了1」的比較

| Peking University
| The Chinese University of Hong Kong
本文詳細分析香港粵語的體助詞「咗」的語法特點。較之北京話的「了1」，「咗」在現實句裡使用範圍更大，在非現實句裡使用範圍更小，在複雜短語裡須緊附於首個謂詞上，更容易用來表達持續性事件。我們推測，「咗」異於「了1」的這些特點主要有三個動因。第一，粵語是語序最偏VO型的漢語方言，「動後限制」較弱，它不懼動詞後帶複雜成分，相對地抗拒句末時體詞。第二，「咗」很可能源自附著義動詞「著」，這導致它排斥作表示客體損失義的動相補語，更容易用於表述持續性事件的謂語中。第三，「咗」的時體義略異於「了1」，這也會造成二者的使用差異。這項比較研究在漢語方言的整體格局方面亦有兩項發現。一方面，漢語的完整體標記分為「著」系和「了」系兩大組，它們有成系統的語法差異；另一方面，南北漢語在語序類型和時體範疇上的差異導致不同方言的完句條件有區別，漢語的完句研究不該集中於普通話，應該回歸到方言口語中。
Keywords: 咗, 完整體, 香港粵語, 了1 , 語序類型, 完句
Article outline
  • 1.引言
  • 2.語法表現
    • 2.1現實句：使用範圍更大
      • 2.1.1強制性更高
      • 2.1.2分佈範圍廣
    • 2.2非現實句：使用範圍更小
    • 2.3句法位置：緊附於首個謂詞
    • 2.4語義範圍：更易用於持續性事件的表達
  • 3.動因推測
    • 3.1語序類型：強VO型
      • 3.1.1謂中時體詞和謂語複雜度
      • 3.1.2句末時體詞和完句效應
    • 3.2詞源語義：動詞「著」
      • 3.2.1「著」系完整體標記的語法表現
      • 3.2.2「了」系完整體標記的語法表現
      • 3.2.3小結：詞源意義和語法表現
    • 3.3其他動因：時體特徵
  • 4.結語
  • 謝辭
  • 笔记
  • 參考文獻
Available under the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) 4.0 license.

For any use beyond this license, please contact the publisher at [email protected].

Published online: 13 July 2022
DOI logo
https://doi.org/10.1075/lali.00110.fan
References (66)
參考文獻
Cao, Zhiyun (曹志耘). 2008. Hanyu fangyan dituji • Yufa juan 漢語方言地圖集•語法卷 [Linguistic atlas of Chinese dialects: Grammar]. Beijing: The Commercial Press.Google Scholar
Chan, Kin Wing Kevin. 2010. Coordinative conjunctions in Chinese dialects: A typological study. Hong Kong: Hong Kong University of Science and Technology. (Master’s thesis.)
Chan, Pak Fai (陳伯輝). 1998. Lun Yue fangyan benzi kaoyi 論粵方言詞本字考釋 [On the etymology of Cantonese lexicons]. Hong Kong: Chung Hwa Book Company.Google Scholar
Chao, Yuen Ren. 1968. A grammar of spoken Chinese. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
Chappell, Hillary. 1998. The perfective aspect marker jó in Cantonese Yue spoken narratives. In T’sou, Benjamin K. (ed.), Studia linguistica serica, 145–173. Hong Kong: Language Information Sciences Research Centre, City University of Hong Kong.Google Scholar
Chen, Limin (陳立民). 2005. Ye shuo “jiu” he “cai” 也說「就」和「才」 [On “jiu” and “cai”]. Dangdai Yuyanxue 當代語言學 [Contemporary Linguistics] (7) 11. 16–34.Google Scholar
Cheung, Hung-nin Samuel. 1992. The pretransitive in Cantonese. In Editorial Committee of Institute of History and Philology, Academia Sinica (ed.), Zhongguo Jingnei Yuyan Ji Yuyanxue diyiji: Hanyu fangyan 中國境內語言暨語言學第一輯：漢語方言 [Chinese languages and linguistics. I: Chinese dialects], 241–303. Taipei: Institute of History and Philology, Academia Sinica.Google Scholar
. 1997. Completing the completive: (Re)constructing early Cantonese grammar. In Sun, Chaofen (ed.), Studies on the history of Chinese syntax (Journal of Chinese Linguistics Monograph Series 10), 133–165. Berkeley: Project on Linguistic Analysis, University of California.Google Scholar
Cheung, Hung-nin Samuel (張洪年). 2007[1972]. Xianggang Yueyu yufa de yanjiu 香港粵語語法的硏究 [A grammar of Cantonese as spoken in Hong Kong]. Revised edn. Hong Kong: The Chinese University of Hong Kong. (Originally published in 1972 by The Chinese University of Hong Kong.)Google Scholar
Ding, Jian (丁健). 2020. Wuyu Luqiao fangyan de wanjieti biaoji “yao” “wan” “qi” 吳語路橋方言的完結體標記「爻」「完」「起」 [The completive markers [ɦɔ31], [ɦue31], and [ʨʻiəʔ5] in Luqiao Wu dialect]. Yuyan Yanjiu 語言研究 [Studies in Language and Linguistics] 40(2). 106–113.Google Scholar
Fan, Xiao (范曉). 1988. Wuyu “V+tuo” zhong de “tuo” 吳語「V脫」中的「脫」 [The tuo in the Wu dialect V + tuo ]. In Wu Language Laboratory, Institute of Chinese Language and Literature, Fudan University (復旦大學中國語言文學研究所吳語研究室) (ed.), Wuyu luncong 吳語論叢 [Essays on Wu], 214–222. Shanghai: Shanghai Education Publishing House.Google Scholar
Fan, Xiaolei. 2014. Tense, aspect and modality in Chinese: A typology study. Hong Kong: Hong Kong University of Science and Technology. (Doctoral dissertation.)
Fan, Xiaolei (范曉蕾). 2017. Jiyu Hanyu fangyan de guanchang fanchou yanjiu 基於漢語方言的慣常範疇研究 [A study of the habitual-generic category with the evidence from Chinese dialects]. Dangdai Yuyanxue 當代語言學 [Contemporary Linguistics] 19(4). 561–590.Google Scholar
. 2018. Xingtai hua “LE1” de liangge bianti 邢台話1的兩個變體 [The verbal-LE variants in Xingtai dialect]. Language and Linguistics 19(3). 410–438.Google Scholar
. 2019. “Chayidian” de yuyi tezheng ji qi jufa houguo: Jiantan fouding, fan yuqi, shiti de guanlian 「差一點」的語義特徵及其句法後果——兼談否定、反預期、時體的關聯 [The semantic features of “chayidian” and their syntactic effects: On the relationships of negation, counter-expectation, and tense-aspect]. Dangdai Yuyanxue 當代語言學 [Contemporary Linguistics] 21(2). 207–237.Google Scholar
. 2020. Binyu he dongci dui “le1” de zhiyue xiaoguo 賓語和動詞對1的制約效果 [How the obejct and the verb condition the use of verbal -le ]. In Editorial Committee of Yuyanxue luncong, Center for Chinese Linguistics, Peking University (北京大學中國語言學硏究中心《語言學論叢》編委會) (ed.), Yuyanxue luncong 語言學論叢 [Essays on linguistics], vol. 611, 222–279. Beijing: The Commercial Press.Google Scholar
. 2021. Putonghua le1 le2 de yufa yizhixing 普通話1 2的語法異質性 [The grammatical heterogeneity of le1 and le2 in Mandarin]. Beijing: Peking University Press.Google Scholar
Feng, Shengli (馮勝利). 2015. Shengdiao, yudiao yu Hanyu de jumo yuqi 聲調、語調與漢語的句末語氣 [Tone, intonation and sentence final particles in Chinese]. In Editorial Committee of Yuyanxue luncong, Center for Chinese Linguistics, Peking University (北京大學中國語言學硏究中心《語言學論叢》編委會) (ed.), Yuyanxue Luncong 語言學論叢 [Essays on Linguistics], vol. 511, 52–79. Beijing: The Commercial Press.Google Scholar
Francis, Elaine J. & Matthews, Stephen. 2006. Categoriality and object extraction in Cantonese serial verb constructions. Natural Language & Linguistic Theory 24(3). 751–801. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Gan, Yu’en (甘于恩). 2011. Guangdong Yue fangyan wanchengti biaoji de zonghe kaocha 廣東粵方言完成體標記的綜合考察 [A comprehensive study on the completive aspect markers in Guangdong Yue]. (Paper presented at the 16th International Conference on Yue Dialects, Hong Kong, 15–16 December 2011.)
Hashimoto, Mantaro (橋本萬太郎). 2008[1978]. Yuyan dili leixingxue 語言地理類型學 [Linguistic geographical typology]. Beijing: Beijing World Publishing Corporation. (Originally published in 1978 by Koubundou.) (Translated by Zhihong, Yu.)Google Scholar
Hou, Jingyi (侯精一) & Wen, Duanzheng (溫端政). 1993. Shanxi fangyan diaocha yanjiu baogao 山西方言調查研究報告 [Report on Shanxi dialect investigation and study]. Taiyuan: Shanxi United University Press.Google Scholar
Hu, Xuhui. 2019. When telicity, perfect aspect, and verbal quantification come together: A study on the verbal le in Yixing Chinese. (Paper presented at the Seventh Symposium for the Syntax and Semantics of Modern Chinese, Guangzhou, 8–10 November 2019.)
Huang, Yang. 2014. Synchronic variation, grammaticalization and language contact: The development of the FINISH morphemes in the Yue-Chinese and the Zhuang languages in the Guangxi region. Hong Kong: City University of Hong Kong. (Doctoral dissertation.)
Jin, Lixin (金立鑫). 2005. “mei” he “le” gongxian de jufa tiaojian 「沒」和「了」共現的句法條件 [The co-occurrence of mei and le ]. Hanyu Xuexi 漢語學習 [Chinese Language Learning]. 2005(1). 25–27.Google Scholar
Kimura, Hideki (木村英樹). 1983. Guanyu buyuxing ciwei “zhe” he “le” 關於補語性詞尾 「著/zhe/」和「了/le/」 [The zhe and le with the phase-complement nature]. Yuwen Yanjiu 語文研究 [Linguistic Research] 1983(2). 22–30.Google Scholar
Kwok, Bit-chee (郭必之) & Kataoka, Shin (片岡新). 2006. Zaoqi Guangzhouhua wanchengti biaoji “HIU” de laiyuan he yanbian 早期廣州話完成體標記「嘵」的來源和演變 [The origin and development of the perfective aspect marker hiu in early Cantonese]. Zhongguo Wenhua Yanjiusuo Xuebao 中國文化研究所學報 [Journal of Chinese Studies] 461. 91–116.Google Scholar
Lai, Huei-ling. 1995. Rejected expectations: The scalar particles CAI and JIU in Mandarin Chinese. Austin: The University of Texas at Austin. (Doctoral dissertation.)
Li, Charles N. & Thompson, Sandra A. 1981. Mandarin Chinese: A functional reference grammar. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
Li, Charles N. & Thompson, Sandra A. & Thompson, R. McMillan. 1982. The discourse motivation for the perfect aspect: The Mandarin particle le . In Hopper, Paul J. (ed.), Tense-aspect: Between semantics and pragmatics, 19–44. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Li, Xingya (李興亞). 1989. Shi shuo dongtai zhuci “le” de ziyou yinxian 試說動態助詞「了」的自由隱現 [On the free appearance and disappearance of the dynamic auxiliary le ]. Zhongguo Yuwen 中國語文 [Studies of the Chinese Language] 1989(5). 334–340.Google Scholar
Lin, Huayong (林華勇) & Li, Huachen (李華琛) & Zhong, Ziwei (鍾子維). forthcoming. Lianjiang Yueyu de guanchangti: Miaoxie yu bijiao 廉江粵語的慣常體：描寫與比較 [The habitual aspect of Lianjiang Cantonese: A description from the comparative perspective]. (Accpeted by Journal of Chinese Linguisitics.)
Lin, Huayong (林華勇) & Li, Minying (李敏盈). 2019. Cong Lianjiang fangyan kan Yueyu “KEOI” zi chuzhiju 從廉江方言看粵語「佢」字處置句 [The Cantonese disposal construction with keoi: Evidence from the Lianjiang dialect]. Zhongguo Yuwen 中國語文 [Studies of the Chinese Language] 2019(1). 89–101.Google Scholar
Lin, Jo-wang. 2008. Event decompostion and the syntax and semantics of durative phrases in Chinese. In Dölling, Johannes & Heyde-Zybatow, Tatjana & Schäfer, Martin (eds.), Event structures in linguistic form and interpretation (Language, Context and Cognition 5), 31–54. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Lin, Jo-wang (林若望). 2017. Zai lun ciwei LE de shiti yiyi 再論詞尾「了」的時體意義 [The temporal meaning of the verbal -le revisited]. Zhongguo Yuwen 中國語文 [Studies of the Chinese Language] 2017(1). 3–23.Google Scholar
Liu, Danqing (劉丹青). 2001. Hanyu fangyan de yuxu leixing bijiao 漢語方言的語序類型比較 [The comparison of word-order types across Chinese dialects]. Xiandai Zhongguoyu Yanjiu 現代中國語研究 [Contemporary Research in Modern Chinese] 21. 24–38.Google Scholar
Lu, Man (魯曼). 2010. Changsha fangyan zhong de “ka” he “da” 長沙方言中的「咖」和「噠」 [“ka41” and “ta21” in the Changsha dialect]. Zhongguo Yuwen 中國語文 [Studies of the Chinese Language] 2010(6). 526–535.Google Scholar
Ma, Xiwen (馬希文). 1983. Guanyu dongci “le” de ruohua xingshi /lou/ 關於動詞「了」的弱化形式 /lou/ [On the weakened form lou of the verb le ]. Zhongguo Yuyan Xuebao 中國語言學報 [Chinese Linguistics: The Journal of Linguistic Society of China] 11. 1–14.Google Scholar
Mai, Yun (麥耘). 2003. Guangzhouhua yi “KEOI” fuzhi shoushizhe de jushi 廣州話以「佢」復指受事者的句式 [The Cantonese sentence pattern with KEOI to coreference patients]. In Zhan, Bohui (詹伯慧) (ed.), Di Ba Jie Guoji Yuefangyan Yantaohui lunwenji 第八屆國際粵方言研討會論文集 [Proceedings of the 8th International Conference on Yue Dialects], 515–524. Beijing: China Social Sciences Press.Google Scholar
Mei, Tsu-Lin (梅祖麟). 1980[1979]. Wuyu qingmaoci “tsi” de yuyuan 吳語情貌詞「仔」的語源 [The etymology of the aspect marker tsi in the Wu dialect]. Guowai Yuyanxue 國外語言學 [Contemporary Linguistics] 1980(3). 22–28. (Originally published in 1979 by Journal of Chinese Linguistics.) (Translated by Lu, Jianming.)Google Scholar
. 1981. Xiandai Hanyu wanchengmao jushi he ciwei de laiyuan 現代漢語完成貌句式和詞尾的來源 [The origin of the sentence-type of perfective aspect and the perfective suffix in Modern Chinese]. Yuyan Yanjiu 語言研究 [Studies in Language and Linguistics] 1981(1). 65–77.Google Scholar
. 1989. Hanyu fangyan li xuci “zhe” zi sanzhong yongfa de laiyuan 漢語方言裡虛詞「著」字三種用法的來源 [The origin of the three uses of the Mandarin function-word zhe in Chinese dialects]. Zhongguo Yuyan Xuebao 中國語言學報 [Chinese Linguistics: The Journal of Linguistic Society of China] 31. 193–216. Beijing: The Commercial Press.Google Scholar
Mithun, Marianne. 1984. The evolution of noun incorporation. Language 60(4). 847–894. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Ota, Tatsuo (太田辰夫). 1958. Chūgokugo rekishi bunpō 中国語歴史文法 [A historical grammar of Modern Chinese]. Kyoto: Hoyu Book.Google Scholar
Pan, Wuyun (潘悟雲). 1996. Wenzhou fangyan de ti he mao 溫州方言的體和貌 [Aspects in the Wenzhou dialect]. In Chang, Song Hing (張雙慶) (ed.), Dongci de ti 動詞的體 [Aspects of verbs], 254–284. Hong Kong: T.T. Ng Chinese Language Language Research Centre, Institute of Chinese Studies, The Chinese University of Hong Kong.Google Scholar
Payne, Thomas Edward. 1997. Describing morphosyntax: A guide for field linguistics. Cambridge University Press. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Peng, Xiaochuan (彭小川). 2010. Guangzhouhua zhuci yanjiu 廣州話助詞研究 [Studies in Cantonese particles]. Guangzhou: Jinan University Press.Google Scholar
Sheng, Yimin (盛益民). 2014. Wuyu Shaoxing Keqiaohua cankao yufa 吳語紹興話柯橋參考語法 [A reference grammar of Shaoxing Keqiao Wu dialect]. Tianjin: Nankai University. (Doctoral dissertation.)
Shi, Qisheng (施其生). 1996. Shantou fangyan de ti 汕頭方言的體 [Aspects in the Shantou dialect]. In Chang, Song Hing (張雙慶) (ed.), Dongci de ti 動詞的體 [Aspects of verbs], 161–194. Hong Kong: T.T. Ng Chinese Language Language Research Centre, Institute of Chinese Studies, The Chinese University of Hong Kong.Google Scholar
Smith, Carlota S. 1997. The parameter of aspect. 2nd edn. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Tang, Sze-Wing (鄧思穎). 2015. Yueyu yufa jiangyi 粵語語法講義 [A lecture on Cantonese grammar]. Hong Kong: The Commercial Press.Google Scholar
Tao, Huan (陶寰). 1996a. Lun Wuyu de shijian biaoji 論吳語的時間標記 [On tense markers in the Wu dialect]. Shanghai: Fudan University. (Doctoral dissertation.)
. 1996b. Shaoxing fangyan de ti 紹興方言的體 [Aspects in the Shaoxing dialect]。 In Chang, Song Hing (張雙慶) (ed.), Dongci de ti 動詞的體 [Aspects of verbs], 302–330. Hong Kong: T.T. Ng Chinese Language Language Research Centre, Institute of Chinese Studies, The Chinese University of Hong Kong.Google Scholar
Teng, Shou-Hsin. 1975. Predicate movements in Chinese. Journal of Chinese Linguistics 3(1). 60–75.Google Scholar
Wang, Jian (王健). 2010. Su Wan fangyan zhong “diao” leici de gongshi biaoxian yu yufahua dengji 蘇皖方言中「掉」類詞的共時表現與語法化等級 [The synchronic behaviors and the degrees of grammaticalization of diao type words in the dialects of Jiangsu and Anhui provinces]. Yuyan Kexue 語言科學 [Linguistics Sciences] 2010(2). 187–196.Google Scholar
Wang, Li (王力). 1980[1958]. Hanyu shigao 漢語史稿 [Manuscript of Chinese history]. Beijing: Zhonghua Book Company.Google Scholar
Wu, Fang (吳芳). 2007. Guangdong Yuefangyan wanchengti biaozhi de fenbu ji “zo” de yuyuan 廣東粵方言完成體標誌的分佈及「咗」的語源 [The distribution of the completive marker in Guangdong Yue and the etymology of zo ]. In Lin, Yi (林亦) & Yu, Jin (余瑾) (eds.), Di Shiyijie Guoji Yuefangyan Yantaohui lunwenji 第十一屆國際粵方言研討會論文集 [Proceedings of the 11th International Conference on Yue Dialects], 328–333. Nanning: Guangxi People’s Publishing House.Google Scholar
Wu, Fuxiang (吳福祥). 2002. Nanfang fangyan jige zhuangtai buyu biaoji de laiyuan (Er) 南方方言幾個狀態補語標記的來源（二） [Origin of some markers of stative complements in the southern Chinese dialects (Part II)]. Fangyan 方言 [Dialect] 2002(1). 24–34.Google Scholar
Wu, Guo (武果). 2007. Yuqici “le” de “zhuguanxing” yongfa 語氣詞「了」的「主觀性」用法 [The “subjective” usage of the mood particle le ]. In Editorial Committee of Yuyanxue luncong, Center for Chinese Linguistics, Peking University (北京大學漢語語言學研究中心《語言學論叢》編委會) (ed.), Yuyanxue luncong 語言學論叢 [Essays on linguistics], vol. 361, 341–362. Beijing: The Commercial Press.Google Scholar
Wu, Jizhang (吳繼章). 2007. Hebei Weixian fangyan de “le”—— Yu Hanyu Putonghua ji qita xiangguan fangyan, jindai Hanyu deng de bijiao yanjiu 河北魏縣方言的「了」——與漢語普通話及其他相關方言、近代漢語等的比較研究 [ Le in the Weixian dialect in Hebei: A comparative study with Hanyu Putonghua and other related dialects and Modern Chinese]. Yuwen Yanjiu 語文研究 [Linguistic Research] 2007(3). 35–47.Google Scholar
Wu, Yunji (伍雲姬). 2006. Xiangfangyan dongtai zhuci de xitong jiqi yanbian 湘方言動態助詞的系統及其演變 [The development of aspectual systems in the Chinese-Xiang dialects]. Changsha: Hunan Normal University Press.Google Scholar
Yakhontov, Sergei (雅洪托夫). 1958. Hanyu de dongci fanchou 漢語的動詞範疇 [The category of verb in Chinese]. Beijing: Zhonghua Book Company. (Translated by Chen, Konglun.)Google Scholar
Yue, Lijing (岳立靜). 2006. Xingshi Yinyuan Zhuan zhuci yanjiu 〈醒世姻緣傳〉助詞研究 [A study on the particles in Xingshi Yinyuan Zhuan ]. Beijing: Beijing Language and Culture University. (Doctoral dissertation.)
Zhang, Min (張敏). 2010. “Donghou xianzhi” de quyu tuiyi jiqi shizhi 「動後限制」的區域推移及其實質 [The postverbal constraint as a geographical continuum]. (Paper presented at the International Symposium for Comparative and Typological Research on Languages of China, Hong Kong, 8–9 May 2010.)
Zhao, Jinming (趙金銘). 1979. Dunhuang Bianwen zhong suojian de “le” he “zhe” 敦煌變文中所見的「了」和「著」 [The le and zhe in Dunhuang Bianwen]. Zhongguo Yuwen 中國語文 [Studies of the Chinese Language] 1979(1). 65–69.Google Scholar