The pitfalls of negative evidence
‘Nuclear Austronesian’, ‘Ergative Austronesian’, and their progeny
Beginning with publications in the early 1980s there have been attempts to use syntactic data to determine the highest-order subgroups of Austronesian. These efforts fall into two categories: those which claim that the voice affixes of Philippine-type languages originally had exclusively nominalizing functions, and those which claim that the affixes themselves were innovated after the separation of Rukai from the ancestor of all other Austronesian languages. Although these ideas lay dormant for some years, recently both have been revived in renewed efforts to show that the Austronesian family tree is not ‘rake-like’ in its highest nodes, but shows extensive embedding of subgroups that can be justified by successive layers of syntactic innovations. This paper questions the methodological soundness of both types of arguments on the grounds that they appeal to negative evidence, and logically any such appeal can do no better than reach an inference of indeterminate status rather than the positive conclusions that have been proposed.
Keywords: subgrouping, negative evidence, Nuclear Austronesian hypothesis, Ergative Austronesian hypothesis
Published online: 10 October 2017
[ p. 617 ]References
Adelaar, K. Alexander
2014 Ergativity from subjunctive in Austronesian languages. Online Proceedings of The 14th International Symposium on Chinese Languages and Linguistics (IsCLL-14), 289–318. Available at http://iscll-14.ling.sinica.edu.tw/files-pdf/Papers/Session6/Aldridge.pdf (accessed 15 September 2016).
Anceaux, J. C.
1999 Subgrouping, circularity and extinction: some issues in Austronesian comparative linguistics. Selected Papers from the Eighth International Conference on Austronesian Linguistics, ed. by Elizabeth Zeitoun & Paul Jen-kuei Li, 31–94. (Symposium Series of the Institute of Linguistics (Preparatory Office), Academia Sinica, No. 1.) Taipei: Academia Sinica.
Blust, Robert, & Stephen Trussel
Ongoing. The Austronesian Comparative Dictionary. Web edition. Available at www.trussel2.com/ACD (accessed 15 September 2016).
Chang, Henry Y.
2006 Rethinking the Tsouic subgroup hypothesis: a morphosyntactic perspective. Streams Converging into an Ocean: Festschrift in Honor of Professor Paul Jen-kuei Li on His 70th Birthday. (Language and Linguistics Monograph Series W-5), ed. by Henry Y. Chang, Lillian M. Huang & Dah-an Ho, 565–584. Taipei: Institute of Linguistics, Academia Sinica.
Chen, Victoria[ p. 618 ]
n.d. Fieldnotes on Nanwang Puyuma and Tgdaya Seediq.
Codrington, R. H., & J. Palmer
English, Leo James
English-Tagalog Online Translator
Available at http://www.tagalogtranslate.com/ (accessed 15 September 2016).
Huang, Lillian M.
Jensen, John Thayer
Lewis, M. Paul, Gary F. Simons, & Charles D. Fennig
(eds.) 2016 Ethnologue: Languages of the World. 19th edition. Dallas: SIL International. Available at http://www.ethnologue.com (accessed 15 September 2016).
Li, Paul Jen-kuei
Li, Paul Jen-kuei, & Shigeru Tsuchida
2011 A syntactic account of interrogative verbs in Kavalan. Paper Presented at the 47th Annual Meeting of the Chicago Linguistic Society, April 7–9, 2011. Illinois: University of Chicago.
Ogawa, Naoyoshi, & Erin Asai
Online Dictionary of Formosan languages (ODFL)[ p. 619 ]
Available at http://e-dictionary.apc.gov.tw (accessed 15 September 2016).
Pawley, Andrew, & Lawrence A. Reid
2006 Reconstructing the case-marking and personal pronoun systems of Proto Austronesian. Streams Converging into an Ocean: Festschrift in Honor of Professor Paul Jen-kuei Li on His 70th Birthday, ed. by Henry Y. Chang, Lillian M. Huang & Dah-an Ho, 521–564. (Language and Linguistics Monograph Series W-5.) Taipei: Institute of Linguistics, Academia Sinica.
2014 Major morphosyntactic changes in early Austronesian. Lecture at the Advanced Linguistics Workshop on Language Change, July 14–24. Taipei: Institute of Linguistics, Academia Sinica.
Sagart, Laurent, Roger Blench, & Alicia Sanchez-Mazas
Schachter, Paul, & Fe T. Otanes
1995 A grammatical subgrouping of Formosan languages. Austronesian Studies Relating to Taiwan, ed. by Paul Jen-kuei Li, Cheng-hwa Tsang, Ying-kuei Huang, Dah-an Ho & Chiu-yu Tseng, 683–726. (Symposium Series of the Institute of History and Philology, Academia Sinica, No. 3.) Taipei: Academia Sinica.
Starosta, Stanley, Andrew Pawley, & Lawrence A. Reid[ p. 620 ]
Teng, Stacy Fang-ching
Teng, Stacy Fang-ching, & Malcolm Ross
Teng, Stacy Fang-ching, & Elizabeth Zeitoun
Topping, Donald M. (with the assistance of Bernadita C. Dungca)
Tryon, D. T. & B. D. Hackman
2005 Recent discoveries at a Tapenkeng culture site in Taiwan: implications for the problem of Austronesian origins. The Peopling of East Asia: Putting Together Archaeology, Linguistics and Genetics, ed. by Laurent Sagart, Roger Blench & Alicia Sanchez-Mazas, 63–73. London & New York: Routledge Curzon.
Tuuk, H. N. van der
Verheijen, Jilis A. J.
Wolff, John U.
Yeh, Marie M.
2016 A comparative study of nominalization in Rukai. Paper Read at the 11th International Symposium on Taiwanese Languages and Teaching, July 12–13, 2016. Taipei: Academia Sinica.
Zeitoun, Elizabeth, Tai-hwa Chu, & Lalo a Tahesh Kaybaybaw
Zeitoun, Elizabeth, & Stacy Fang-ching Teng
Cited by 1 other publications
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 19 august 2021. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers. Any errors therein should be reported to them.