Cover not available
Article published In:
Language, Context and Text
Vol. 4:2 (2022) ► pp.259–303

Semogenic variation in the construal of sayerhood in Arabic

ORCID logo | Macquarie University
This article studies projection and examines alternative modes of construing processes of saying/ speech events and the variation across three registers where projection is particularly important. It is one of many articles that describe and discuss projection as a semantic fractal manifested in a variety of lexicogrammatical environments. The first paper in this series, which was published in 2018 by Arús-Hita et al. in Word was an investigation of quoting and reporting strategies of speech and thought across six genetically unrelated languages (Arabic, Dagaare, English, Hindi, Japanese and Spanish). This paper, however, has a much narrower scope. It first looks at all participants in the verbal clause in Arabic, then it focuses on the main one – the Sayer. Since verbal projection is quite pervasive in different areas of the lexicogrammar, it only makes sense to look into these fractal motifs to have an idea about the different guises under which the Sayer appears. News reports, academic discourse and fictional narratives have been analysed to properly account for the registerial variety in construing the role of the Sayer in verbal clauses across metafunctions.
Keywords: projection, Sayer, interpersonal, experiential, logical, comments of presumption, fractal motif, semantic fractal, congruent manifestation, evidentiality, systemic functional linguistics
Article outline
  • 1.Introduction
  • 2.Background: Halliday’s notion of projection vs. traditional complement clauses
  • 3.Participants in the verbal clause
    • 3.1The Receiver
    • 3.2The Target
    • 3.3Verbiage and other verbal projections
    • 3.4The Sayer
      • 3.4.1Generic characteristics of the Sayer in Arabic
      • 3.4.2Sayerhood in Arabic across metafunctions
        • 3.4.2.1Experiential manifestation
          • 3.4.2.1.1Relational clauses construing verbal activities
          • 3.4.2.1.2Existential clauses construing verbal activities
          • 3.4.2.1.3Material processes construing verbal activities
          • 3.4.2.1.4Mental processes construing of verbal activities
          • 3.4.2.1.5Behavioral processes construing verbal activities
          • 3.4.2.1.6Circumstance of angle construing ‘sayerhood’
        • 3.4.2.2Interpersonal manifestation of sayerhood in Arabic
  • 4.Variations in the construal of Sayerhood across registers
  • 5.Conclusion
  • Notes
  • References
Published online: 29 September 2022
DOI logo
https://doi.org/10.1075/langct.21014.bar
References (59)
References
Abd Al-Ghani, Mansur. 2017. Al-ahali tanfarid: Rais al-jumhuriyya yatlub iadat ardh milaf matar Al-Nuzha, wa al-qarar khilal ayyam. (Al-Ahli’s exclusive: The president of the republic requests reinvestigating the file of Al-Nuzha airport and the decision will come out in a few days). Al-Ahali, 2nd May. Viewed 15 July, 2017. [URL]
Abd Al-Hameed, Ayda. 2017. Al-usratu mihwaru ihtimami raisi al-dawlati. (The families are at the centre of the president’s interest). Al-Khalij, 3 June. Viewed 15 July, 2017. [URL]
Akhbar Al-Yemen. 2015. Madha qala Hasan Nasr Allah fi khitabihi alyawm bishani Al-Yaman. (What has Hasan Nasr Allah said today in his speech about Yemen?). 4 December. Viewed 15 July, 2017. [URL]
Al-Amadi, Abd-Allah. 2018. Madha fi jaabati Ibn Salman lil-Kuwait. (What has Bin Salman got up his sleeve for Kuwait?). Al-Jazeera, 30 March. Viewed 15 April, 2018. [URL]
Al-Andalusi, Mohamed A. B. B. 2001. Al-muharraru al-wajiz fi tafsiri Al-Kitabi Al-Aziz. (The compendious record in the interpretation of The Mighty Book). Volume 51. Edited by Mohammed A. Al-Rayhani. Beirut: Dar Al-Kutub Al-Ilmiyya.Google Scholar
Al-Arabiyya. 2019. Sirrun bayna shakhsayni faqat… Ayna shathamin Saddam Husein wa awladuhu?. (A secret between only two… where are the corpses of Saddam Husein and his sons?) 16 July. Last updated: 20 May, 2020. Viewed 15 June, 2020. [URL]
Al-Bawwaba News. 2020. Masdar askari rusi yanfi saytarata almusallahin ala Saraqib fi rifi Idlib. (A Russian military source denies that armed rebels has taken control of Saraqib in Idlib’s countryside). 27 February. Viewed 15 March, 2020. [URL]
Al-Bayan. 2017. Haqaiqu muthira an hayati zaimi Kuriya Al-Shamaliyya. (Fascinating facts about the life of the leader of North Korea). 8 May, Viewed 15 March, 2020. [URL]
Al-Dallal, Mohamed. 2011. Nahj al-nahw. (Grammatical approach). Vol. 11. Sussa: Matbaat Al-Muallem.Google Scholar
Al-Dhaydi, Mashari. 2021. Himayatu al-bia… al-haqqu wa albatil. (The protection of the environment… truth and falsehood) Al-Sharq Al-Mutawassit, 30 June. Viewed 10 July, 2021. [URL]
Al-Duaaji, Ali. 1993. Sahirtu minhu al-layali. (I stayed up nights). Tunis: Al-Dar Al-Tunisiyya Linnashr.Google Scholar
Al-Jazeera. 2021. Aljinaiyya alduwaliyya tudhakkir biamr alqabdh alayh… Sayf Al-Islam Al-Qadhdhafi yuqaddim milaffa tarashshuhihi liriasati Libiya. (The international criminal court re-issue his arrest warrant… Saif Al-Islam Al-Qaddafi presents his presidential nomination). 14 November. Viewed 8 December, 2021. [URL]
Al-Masdar. 2017. Wizarat aldifaa: “dukhul almuwatinin limanatiq alamaliyat alaskaria almughlaqa mamnu wa yumkin an yuarridha hayatahum lilkhatar”. (The Ministry of Defence: “Entrance to closed military zones is prohibited and may endanger people’s lives”). 16 June. Viewed 15 July, 2017. [URL]
Al-Mutawakkil, Taha. 2003. Al-mutaqal, al-intifadha, al-kitaba. (The detention centre, the uprising, the writing). Beirut: Arab Institute for Research & Publishing.Google Scholar
. 2004. Hadaiqu Ibrahim: Awraqu Ibrahim Tuqan wa rasailuhu wa dirasatun fi shirihi. (Ibrahim’s Gardens: Ibrahim Tuqan’s papers, letters and a study of his poetry). Beirut: Arab Institute for Research & Publishing.Google Scholar
Al-Muwatin. 2017. Jawlat Al-Sisi al-khalijiyya alabraz fi assuhuf assadira alyawm. (Sisi’s visit to the Gulf region… The most important headlines in today’s papers). 7 May. Viewed 15 June, 2017. [URL]
Al-Rayhani, Mohammed A. 1997. Ittijahat attahlil azzamani fi addirasati allughawiyyati. (Trends in temporal analysis in linguistics studies). Cairo: Dar Qiba Littibaa wa Annashr wa Attawzii.Google Scholar
Al-Sabah News. 2015. ‘Itlaq rasas bimadkhal mathaf Bardu… wizarat addakhiliyya tuwadhdhih’. (Shots fired at the entrance of the Bardo Museum… The Home Office clarifies). 9 December. Viewed 15 June, 2017. [URL]
Al-Safwa News. 2013. ‘Hamad li-Sisi: Ghadan yanfadhu anka man aqnaaka anna alumura satantahi fi sabati ayyam’. (Hamed to Sisi: People, who have convinced you that the issues would be solved in seven days, will leave your side tomorrow) 30 November. Viewed 5 December 2013. [URL]
Al-Shuruq Online. 2021. ‘Iddau anna alwafat sababuha juraa zaida mina addawa: yaqtulu zawjatahu bi-Shshalaf wa abnauhu yatasattaruna ala al-jarima’. (They claimed that the cause of death was an extra dose of medicine: In [the province] of Chlef, he killed his wife and his kids covered it up). 22 March. Viewed 17 May, 2021. [URL]
Al-Thnabat, Bayan H. 2013. Irab al-fiil al-mudharaa. (The desinential inflection of the present verb). Karak: Mutah University.Google Scholar
Al-Waad, Husein. 1991. Madkhal ila shir Al-Mutanabbi. (A gateway to the poetry of Al-Mutanabbi). Tunis: Dar Al-Janub Linnashr.Google Scholar
Al-Yahiyaui, Khadija. 2014. ‘Al-natiq bism al-mahkama al-ibtidaiyya bi-Tunis yakshifu an tafasil daqiqa hawla irhabiyyi Janduba’. (The spokesperson for the first instance court in Tunis sheds light on intimate details about the terrorist of Jenduba). Al-Shuruq, 17 March. Viewed 15 June, 2017. [URL]
Al-Zajjaji, Abi Al-Qacem A. I. 1984. Al-jumal fi al-nahw. (Sentences in grammar). Revised by Al-Hamad, Ali, Tawfik. Irbid (Jordan): Dar Al-Amal.Google Scholar
Al-Zamakhshari, Abi Al-Qacem M. I. 2004. Al-Mufassal fi ilm Al-Arabiyya. (A detailed [description] of the science of the Arabic language). Revised by Qadara Fakhr S. Oman: Dar Amar.Google Scholar
Arús-Hita, Jorge, Teruya, Kazu, Bardi, Mohamed Ali, Kumar Keshyap, A. & Mwinlaaru, Isaac N. 2018. ‘Quoting and reporting across languages: A system-based and text-based typology’ in Word. Vol 641, 69–102. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Ayet Hsayen, Mohamed. 2017. Tazarin tantadhiru juthman shahid alquwat almusallaha…wa alaskar yamnau alssahafa. (Tazzarin is waiting for the coffin of the armed forces’ martyr… and the military bans the press). Hespress, 17 May. Viewed 15 June, 2017. [URL]
Badawi, Elsaid, Michael Carter & Adrian Gully. 2004. Modern written Arabic: A comprehensive reference grammar. Revised by Maher Awad. London & New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
Bardi, Mohamed Ali. 2008. A systemic functional description of the grammar of Arabic. Sydney: Macquarie University.Google Scholar
BBC Arabic. 2011. Miat alqatla wa almafqudin fi zizlal wa tsunami Al-Yaban. (Hundreds of dead and missing in the Japanese earthquake and tsunami). Last update 11 March. Viewed 15 June, 2017. [URL]
. 2015. Haydar Al-Abadi yulinu “tahrir madinat Takrit” min aydi tandhim “addawla Al-Islamiyya”. (Haydar Al-Abadi declares “the city of Takreet free” from the control of “the Islamic State”). 31 March. Viewed 15 June, 2017. [URL]
. 2015. Al-Atrak yanshuruna tasjilan sawtiyyan yaqulun innahu “yuthbitu annahum hadhdharu attaira Al-Rusiyya”. (The Turkish army publishes a voice recording that “proves that it warned the Russian fighter jet”). 26 November. Viewed 15 June, 2017. [URL]
Cantarino, Vicente. 1974–1975. Syntax of modern Arabic prose. 31 Volumes. Bloomington & London: Indiana University Press.Google Scholar
Halliday, Michael A. K. 1977. Text as semantic choice in social contexts. In Teun van Dijk & Janos Petӧfi (eds.), Grammar and descriptions, 176–225. Berlin: Walter de Gruyter.Google Scholar
1985. An introduction to functional grammar. London: Edward Arnold.Google Scholar
Halliday, Michael A. K. & Christian M. I. M. Matthiessen. 2004. An introduction to functional grammar (3rd edition). London: Arnold.Google Scholar
Hasan, Abbas. 1973. Al-nahw al-waafi. (A comprehensive grammar [of Arabic]). Vol.21. Cairo: Daar Al-Maaref bimisr.Google Scholar
Holes, Clive. 2004. Modern Arabic. Washington D.C.: Georgetown University Press.Google Scholar
Husein, Imad Addine. 2015. La tuammimu albarlaman. (Do not nationalize the parliament). Al-Shuruq, 7 December. Viewed 10 July, 2021. [URL]
Khal, Abduh. 2012. Fusuq. (Immorality). Beirut: Dar Al-Saaqi.Google Scholar
Mahfudh, Najib. 1993. Al-Qahira al-jadida. (New Cairo). Cairo: Maktabat Masr.Google Scholar
Masrawi. 2017. Tasrihat Al-Sisi tatasaddaru anawin suhuf Al-Jumua… wa attalim: “jahizun liththanawiyya alamma”. (Sisi’s declarations dominate Friday’s papers and the education sector: “Is ready for the baccalaureate exam”). 2 June. Viewed 15 June, 2017. [URL]
Matthiessen, Christian M. I. M. 2004. Descriptive motifs and generalizations. In Alice Caffarel, James R. Martin & Christian M. I. M. Matthiessen (eds.), Language typology: A functional perspective, 537–673. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Matthiessen, Christian M. I. M. & Kazuhiro Teruya. 2014a. Projection as a fractal motif: semantic and lexicogrammatical manifestations. MS. The Hong Kong Polytechnic University, Hong Kong.Google Scholar
. 2014b. Projection in English: The environment of quoting. MS. The Hong Kong Polytechnic University, Hong Kong.Google Scholar
Munif, Abd Al-Rahman. 2001. Al-Sharq al-mutawassit. (East of the Mediterranean). Tunis: Dar Al-Janub Linnashr.Google Scholar
. 2007. Urwat Al-zaman Al-Bahi. (Al-Bahi the hoodlum of time). Beirut: Arab Institute for Research & Publishing.Google Scholar
Munif, Abd Al-Rahman & Ibrahim J. Jabra. 2004. Alam bila kharait. (A world without maps). Beirut: Arab Institute for Research & Publishing.Google Scholar
Nuaima, Mikhail. 1998. Kan ma kan. (Once upon a time). Sussa: Dar Al-Maarif Li-Attibaa Wa Annashr.Google Scholar
Pickthall, Shakir, & Yusuf Ali. (n.d.). Quran Comparison. [URL]
Ryding, Karin C. 2005. A reference grammar of Modern Standard Arabic. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Saad, George N. 1982. Transitivity, causation and passivization: A semantic-syntactic study of the verb in Classical Arabic. Kegan Paul International: London.Google Scholar
Saati, Al-Tahir. 2016. ‘Taharriyat’. (Investigations) Mawqa Al-Nilayn, 13 April. Viewed 10 July, 2021. [URL]
Salah, Ali. 2017. Al-suhuf Al-Saudiyya: “Al-Sisi” yuakkid hirsa Masr ala amn Al-Khalij… wa “Salman” yadu zuama al-alam Al-Islami min ajli tawhid alhadaf fi qimmati Al-Riyadh… tafaul alami biriasati “Macron”. (Saudi Newspapers: “Al-Sisi” confirms Egypt’s commitment to the security of the Gulf region… King Salman calls upon the leaders of the Islamic world to present a unified front at the summit in Riyadh… International optimism about Macron’s presidency). Sada Al-Balad. 10 May. Viewed 15 June, 2017. [URL]
Salah, Al-Tayyeb. n. d. Mawsimu alhijrati ila ashshamal. (Season of migration to the north). Beirut: Dar Al-Awda.
Shannuf, Ridha. 2021. Hasaba taqrir ilami… Ammar Al-Sidani rais albarlaman Al-Jazairi alsabaq yalja ila Al-Maghreb. (According to a news report… Ammar Al-Sidani the previous president of the Algerian parliament seeks asylum in Morocco). Al-Quds Al-Arabi, 4 April. Viewed 10 July, 2021. [URL]
Sibawayh, Ibn Qanbar A. A. I. 1988. Al-kitab. (The book). Revised by Harun Abd Al-Salam Mohamed. Cairo: Maktabat Al-Ghanji.Google Scholar
Yunus, Sharif. 2012. Nida Al-Shab: Tarikh naqdi lilidiyulujia Al-Nasiriyya. (The call of the people: A historical assessment of the Nasserist ideology). Cairo: Dar El- Shorouk.Google Scholar
Yusri, Raheem. 2018. Ahl Al-Sudani almaqtul fi Qatar yakshifun unsuriyyat nidham Al-Hamadieen. (The family of the Sudanese murder victim in Qatar reveals the racism of the Hamadian regime). Sada Al-Balad, 9 July. Viewed 19 April, 2019. [URL]