Article published in:Dialogue in institutional settings
Edited by Franca Orletti and Letizia Caronia
[Language and Dialogue 9:1] 2019
► pp. 65–83
Decision announcements in small claims court
A recurring judge dilemma
This study analyzes judges’ decision announcements at the end of small claims hearings when the judge informs the parties who has won. Background on US small claims courts is provided, and the data and grounded practical theory, the analytic approach, are described. Then, we overview the small claims decision announcement genre, describe key areas of variation among judges, and identify and explicate a recurring problem built into the design of small claims proceedings. Cases that pit what is legally correct against what commonsense fairness dictates can be troublesome for judges and this trouble is marked discursively in judge announcements. The paper concludes by describing the challenge this raises for the development of grounded practical theory.
Keywords: small claims court, judge language, discourse analysis, grounded practical theory, genre, dilemma
- 2.Small claims court practices
- 3.The trial data and analytic approach
- 4.The small claims judicial announcement genre
- 5.How judges’ reason-giving varied
- 6.Disputes that pit legal correctness against common-sense fairness
Published online: 05 July 2019
Best, Arthur, Deborah Zalense, Kathleeen Bridges and Kathryn Chenoweth
Brown, Penelope and Stephen C. Levinson
Conley, John M. and William M. O’Barr
Craig, Robert T. and Karen Tracy
Ewick, Patrick and Susan S. Silbey
Garzone, Giuliana E.
Goerdt, John A.
Hafner, Christoph A.
Livermore, Michael A., Allen B. Riddell and Daniel N. Rockmore
Rohl, Klaus F.
Ruhnka, John C. and Steven Weller
Steele, Eric H.
1981 “The historical context of small claims courts.” Law and Social Inquiry 6 (2): 293–376. Retrieved from https://www.jstor.org/stable/828089
The Small Claims Study Group
Tracy, Karen and Mary Caron
Tracy, Karen and Danielle Hodge
Tyler, Tom R.
2007 “Procedural justice and the courts.” Court Review 44(1/2): 26–31. Retrieved from http://aja.ncsc.dni.us/publications/courtrv/cr44-1/CR44-1-2Tyler.pdf
Cited by 1 other publications
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 03 april 2022. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers. Any errors therein should be reported to them.