Article published In:
Language and DialogueVol. 14:1 (2024) ► pp.122–151
Negotiating leader identities through indirect mockery in talk about decision-making in a distributed leadership context
In this article, we scrutinise how humour, and in particular, indirect mockery contributes to the construction of leader identities in talk about decision-making in an organisation characterized by a distributed leadership context. So rather than focusing on decision-making episodes themselves, we tease out an aspect of the goal achievement side of the leadership influence process. Through multimodal discourse analysis, we focus on episodes in which the implementation side of decisions is discussed and in which the head of the team initiates a humorous sequence, as this turned out to be an integral part of talk about decision-making. We found that the humour was always oriented towards upper management and that it could serve various functions. Overall, we argue that indirect mockery was a crucial means to navigate the tension that emerges from the team head’s position within the complex leadership constellation, thus offering a critical perspective on distributed leadership.
Keywords: discursive leadership, distributed leadership, meetings, humour, laughter, indirect mockery, multimodal discourse analysis
Article outline
- 1.Introduction
- 2.Research aim and method
- 3.Data
- 4.Analysis
- 4.1Head of the team as a follower
- 4.2Head of the team as a co-leader
- 5.Discussion and conclusions
- Notes
-
References
References
Acuña Ferreira, Virginia A.
2014 “Gossip as indirect mockery in
friendly conversation: The social functions of ‘sharing a laugh’ at third parties.” Discourse
studies 16 (5): 607–628. 
Boden, Deirdre
1994 The
Business of Talk: Organizations in Action. Cambridge, England: Polity Press.
Bolden, Richard
2011 “Distributed
Leadership in Organizations: A Review of Theory and Research.” International Journal of
Management
Reviews 13(3): 251–269.
Choi, Seongsook, and Stephanie Schnurr
2014 “Exploring
distributed leadership: Solving disagreements and negotiating consensus in a ‘leaderless’
team.” Discourse
Studies 16(1): 3–24.
Clifton, Jonathan
2006 “A
Conversation Analytical Approach to Business Communication: The Case of Leadership.” Journal of
Business
Communication 43(3): 202–219.
2009 “Beyond
taxonimies of influence: ‘Doing’ influence and making decisions in management team
meeting.” Journal of Business
Communication 46(1): 57–79.
2012 “A
discursive approach to leadership. Doing assessments and managing organizational
meanings.” Journal of Business
Communication 49(2): 148–168.
2017 “Taking
the (heroic) leader out of leadership. The in situ practice of distributed leadership in decision-making
talk.” In Challenging leadership stereotypes through
discourse, ed. by Cornelia Ilie and Stephanie Schnurr. New York: Springer.
Clifton, Jonathan, Magnus Larsson, and Stephanie Schnurr
2020 “Leadership
in interaction. An introduction to the Special Issue.” Leadership (London,
England) 16(5): 511–521.
Clifton, Jonathan, Dorien Van De Mieroop, Prachee Sehgal, and Aneet
2018 “The
multimodal enactment of deontic and epistemic authority in Indian
meetings.” Pragmatics 28(3): 333–360.
Coates, Jennifer
2007 “Talk
in a play frame: More on laughter and intimacy.” Journal of
Pragmatics 39(1): 29–49.
Collinson, David
2006 “Rethinking
followership: A post-structuralist analysis of follower identities.” The Leadership
Quarterly 17(2): 179–189.
Denis, Jean-Louis, Ann Langley, and Viviane Sergi
2012 “Leadership
in the Plural.” The Academy of Management
Annals 6(1): 211–283.
DeRue, D. Scott and Susan J. Ashford
2010 “Who
will lead and who will follow? A social process of leadership identity construction in
organizations.” Academy of Management
Review 35(4): 627–647.
Eggins, Suzanne and Diana Slade
1997 Analysing
Casual
Conversation. London: Cassell.
Fairhurst, Gail T.
2007 Discursive Leadership. In Conversation
with Leadership Psychology. London, England: Sage.
Fairhurst, Gail T., Brad Jackson, Erica Gabrielle Foldy, and Sonia M. Ospina
2020 “Studying
collective leadership: The road ahead.” Human
Relations 73(4): 598–614.
Ford, Cecilia A. and Barbara E. Fox
2010 “Multiple
practices for constructing laughables.” In Prosody in
Interaction, ed. by Dagmar Barth-Weingarten, Elisabeth Reder and Margret Selting, 339–368. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Gee, James Paul, Glynda Hull, and Colin Lankshear
1996 The
New Work Order. London: Saint Leonards Allen and Unwin.
Glenn, Philip
2003 Laughter
in Interaction. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Gumperz, John J.
1992 “Contextualization and
understanding.” In Rethinking Context. Language as an interactive
phenomenon, ed. by Alessandro Duranti and Charles Goodwin, 230–252. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Haakana, Markku and Marja-Leena Sorjonen
2011 “Invoking
another context: Playfulness in buying lottery tickets at convenience stores.” Journal of
Pragmatics 43(5): 1288–1302.
Holmes, Janet
2006 “Sharing
a laugh: Pragmatic aspects of humor and gender in the workplace.” Journal of
Pragmatics 38(1): 26–50.
Holmes, Janet and Meredith Marra
2006 “Humor
and leadership style.” Humor – International Journal of Humor
Research 19(2): 119–138.
Holmes, Janet, Meredith Marra, and Bernadette Vine
2011 Leadership,
Discourse and Ethnicity. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Holt, Elizabeth
2011 “On
the nature of “laughables”: Laughter as a response to overdone figurative phrases.” Pragmatics:
Quarterly publication of the International Pragmatics
Association 21(3): 393–410.
Honkanen, Suvi and Riikka Nissi
2014 “Managing
organizational change through joint vision building: an analysis of practices of
recontextualization” In Analysing Text AND Talk: Att analysera texter
OCH samtal, ed. by Anna-Malin Karlsson and Henna Makkonen-Craig, 28–43. Uppsala: Uppsala universitet.
Hosking, Dian Marie
1988 “Organizing, leadership and
skilful process.” Journal of Management
Studies 25 (2): 147–166.
Huisman, Marjan
2001 “Decision-Making
in Meetings as Talk-in-Interaction.” International Studies of Management &
Organization 31(3): 69–90.
Kangasharju, Helena and Tuija Nikko
2009 “Emotions
in Organizations: Joint Laughter in Workplace Meetings.” The Journal of Business Communication
(1973) 46(1): 100–119.
Kelly, Simon
2008 “Leadership:
A categorical mistake?” Human
Relations 61(6): 763–782.
2014 “Towards
a negative ontology of leadership.” Human
Relations 67(8): 905–922.
Larsson, Magnus
2017 “Leadership
in Interaction.” In Routledge Companion to
Leadership, ed. by John Storey, Jean Hartley, Jean-Louis Denis, Paul ‘t Hart and Dave Ulrich, 173–193. London: Routledge.
Larsson, Magnus, Jonathan Clifton, and Stephanie Schnurr
2021 “The
fallacy of discrete authentic leader behaviours: Locating authentic leadership in
interaction.” Leadership 17(4): 421–440.
Lehtinen, Marjukka
2012 Episteemisen auktoriteetin ja yhteisen ymmärryksen konstruointi kokouskeskustelussa. Fokuksessa
-hAn-lausumat. [Constructing Epistemic Authority and Shared Understanding in
Meeting Talk: A Focus on Utterances Containing the Finnish Clitic Particle
-hAn.] Helsinki: Aalto University publication series.
Mondada, Lorenza
2016 “Challenges
of multimodality: Language and the body in social interaction.” Journal of
Sociolinguistics 20(3): 336–366.
Northouse, Peter
2016 Leadership:
theory and practice, 7th edition. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Sarangi, Srikant and Celia Roberts
1999 “Introduction.” In Talk,
work and institutional order; discourse in medical, mediation and management settings, ed.
by Srikant Sarangi and Celia Roberts, 61–74. Berlin/New York: Mouton de Gruyter.
Schnurr, Stephanie
2009a “Constructing
leader identities through teasing at work.” Journal of
Pragmatics 41(6): 1125–1138.
2009b Leadership
Discourse at Work: Interactions of humour, gender and workplace
culture. Houndmills: Palgrave Macmillan.
Schnurr, Stephanie, and Angela Chan
2011 “Exploring
another side of co-leadership: Negotiating professional identities through face-work in
disagreements.” Language in
Society 40 (2):187–209.
Sorjonen, Marja-Leena
2018 “Reformulating
prior speaker’s turn in Finnish: Turn-initial “siis”, “eli(kkä)”, and “nii(n)
et(tä)”.” In Between turn and sequence: Turn-initial particles across
languages, ed. by John Heritage and Marja-Leena Sorjonen, 251–286. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Stogdill, Ralph M.
1950 “Leadership, membership and
organisation.” Psychological
Bulletin 471: 1–14.
Thornborrow, Joanna and Deborah Morris
2004 “Gossip
as strategy: The management of talk about others on reality TV show ‘Big Brother’.” Journal of
Sociolinguistics 8(2): 246–271.
Van De Mieroop, Dorien
2020 “A
deontic perspective on the collaborative, multimodal accomplishment of
leadership.” Leadership 16 (5): 592–619.
Van De Mieroop, Dorien and Jonathan Clifton
2017 “Corporate
settings.” In The Routledge Handbook of Language in the
Workplace, ed. by Bernadette Vine, 127–137. New York: Routledge.
Van De Mieroop, Dorien, Jonathan Clifton, and Avril Verhelst
2020 “Investigating
the interplay between formal and informal leaders in a shared leadership configuration: A multimodal conversation analytical
study.” Human
Relations 73(4): 490–515.
Van De Mieroop, Dorien and Jolien Wouters
2020 “Co-leiderschap
in vergaderingen.” Tijdschrift voor
Taalbeheersing 42(3): 249–277.
Vine, Bernadette, Janet Holmes, Meredith Marra, Dale Pfeifer, and Brad Jackson
2008 “Exploring
Co-leadership Talk Through Interactional
Sociolinguistics.” Leadership 4(3): 339–360.
Vöge, Monika
2010 “Local
identity processes in business meetings displayed through laughter in complaint
sequences.” Journal of
Pragmatics 42(6): 1556–1576.
Watson, Cate and Valerie Drew
2017 “Humour
and laughter in meetings: Influence, decision-making and the emergence of
leadership.” Discourse &
Communication 11(3): 314–329.
Yukl, Gary
1989 “Managerial
Leadership: A Review of Theory and Research.” Journal of
management 15 (2): 251–289.