Article published in:
Constructing and Negotiating Identity in Dialogue
Edited by Răzvan Săftoiu
[Language and Dialogue 5:1] 2015
► pp. 152–175

Enunciative identity and individual representation of rape

| Interpsy, EA 4432. Lorraine University, France
| MSH Lorraine, France
| ATILF CNRS — UMR 7118, France
A total of 316 cases of forensic psychological assessment for sexual assaults were analyzed for plaintiffs over 15 years of age. The assessments were conducted between 2008 and 2014 in the presence of the same expert psychologist. The analyses clearly highlight the role of others in the act of filing a complaint. Therefore, the enunciations of the complaint were carefully examined in order to clarify the status of others. The Alterity can be observed in the speech of victims. The psychological assessment interview cannot be reduced to a dialogue in praesentia; in fact, another dialogue is brought to light. The latter falls within internal processes which, in turn, distinguish between two main types of plaintiffs: those who present themselves spontaneously to judicial authorities and the others.
Keywords: speech of sexual assault victims, forensic psychological assessment, Bakhtinian dialogism, dialogue in praesentia and in absentia, spontaneous complaint.
Published online: 23 June 2015
https://doi.org/10.1075/ld.5.1.08bat
References
Alaggia, Ramona, and Jennifer V. Turton
2005 “Against the Odds: The Impact of Woman Abuse on Maternal Response to Disclosure of Child Sexual Abuse.” Journal of Child Sexual Abuse 14 (4): 95–113. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Alaggia, Ramona, Tahany M. Gadalla, Aaron Shlonsky, Angelique Jenney, and Joanne Daciuk
2013 “Does Differential Response Make a Difference: Examining Domestic Violence Cases in Child Protection Services.” Child & Family Social Work 201: 83–95. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Amnesty International U.K
(2005) Sexual Assault Research Summary Report. Available at http://​www​.amnesty​.org​.uk​/news​_details​.asp​?NewsID​=16618
Anscombre, Jean-Claude, and Oswald Ducrot
1983 L’argumentation dans la langue. Bruxelles: Mardaga.Google Scholar
Authier-Revuz, Jacqueline
1984 “Hétérogénéités énonciatives.” Langages 731: 98–111. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Bakhtin, Mikhaïl
1981 The Dialogic Imagination: Four Essays by M. M. Bakhtin. Austin, TX: University of Texas Press.Google Scholar
Bakhtin, Mikhaïl Mikhaïlovitch
1984 Problems of Dostoevsky’s Poetics. Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Bakhtin, Mikhaïl
1986 Speech Genre and Other Late Essays. Austin, TX: University of Texas Press.Google Scholar
Barillon, Jacques, and Paul Bensussan
2004 Le désir criminel. Paris: Odile Jacob.Google Scholar
Bessoles, Philippe
2008 Viol et identité. Un génocide individuel. Paris: MJW édition.Google Scholar
Bouzidi, Houda
2008 Le viol et ses conséquences traumatiques sur la femme algérienne. Etude de trois cas clinique au centre d’accueil des femmes victimes de violence et qui sont en détresse. Unpublished Ph.D. thesis. Université de Constantine, Algérie.
Breitenbecher, Kelly H
2001 “Sexual Revictimization among Women. A Review of the Literature Focusing on Empirical Investigations.” Agression and Violent Behavior 61: 415–432. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Breslau, Naomi, Glenn C. Davis, Patricia Andreski, and Edward Peterson
1991 “Traumatic Events and Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder in an Urban Population of Young Adults.” Archives of General Psychiatry 481: 216–222. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Briere, John, and Marsha Runtz
1993 “Childhood Sexual Abuse: Long-term Sequelae and Implications for Psychological Assessment.” Journal of Interpersonnal Violence 8 (3): 312–330. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Carel, Marion, and Oswald Ducrot
2009 “Mise au point sur la polyphonie.” Langue française 4 (164): 33–43. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Coutanceau, Roland
2010 Les blessures de l’intimité. Paris: Odile Jacob.Google Scholar
Cormon, Véronique
2002 “Viols et métamorphoses.” Journal international de victimologie. Available at http://​www​.jidv​.com​/njidv​/index​.php​/jidv01​/58​-jidv01​/183​-viols​-et​-metamorphosesGoogle Scholar
Darmanin, Janine
1995 “Victime de viol/ victime d’inceste.” Forensic: Revue de psychiatrie légale 91: 45–48.Google Scholar
Darves-Bonoz, Jean-Michel
1996 Syndromes traumatiques du viol et de l’inceste. Congrès de psychiatrie et de neurologie de langue française. Toulon: Masson.Google Scholar
Darves-Bonoz, Jean-Michel, Jean-Pierre Lépine, F. Pierre, Andrée Degiovanni, and Philippe Gaillard
1998 “Screening for Psychologically Traumatized Rape Victims.” European Journal of Obstetrics & Gynecology and Reproductive Biology 771: 71–75. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Ducrot, Oswald
1984 Le dire et le dit. Paris: Editions de minuit.Google Scholar
Dupont, Mélanie, Paul Messerschmitt, Gilbert Vila, Dominique Bohu, and Caroline Rey-Salmon
2014 “Le processus de révélation dans les agressions sexuelles intrafamiliales et extrafamiliales sur mineurs.” Annales Médico-psychologiques 1721: 426–431. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Eyssel, Friederike, and Gerd Bohner
2001 “Schema Effects of Rape Myth Acceptance on Judgments of Guilt and Blame in Rape Cases: The Role of Perceived Entitlement to Judge.” Journal of Interpersonal Violence 261: 1579–1605. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Ferrão, Maria-Clara, Gabriela Goncalves, Tiago Parreira, and Jean-Christophe Giger
2013 “Rape-Victim Empathy Scale (REMV): An Exploratory Study in a Portuguese Sample.” Psychological Thought 6 (2): 283–295. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Ficher, Donald G., L. Wendy, and W. McDonald
1998 “Characteristics of Intrafamilial and Extrafamilial Child Sexual Abuse.” Child Abuse Neglect 221: 915–929. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Fua, Dominique
1997 “Agressions sexuelles: connaître la victime et ses attentes.” Le Journal des Psychologues 1441: 30–31.Google Scholar
Geninet, Isabelle, and André Marchand
2007 “La recherche de sens à la suite d’un évènement traumatique.” Santé mentale au Québec 32 (2): 11–35. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Gilmore, Kate, and Lise Pittman
1993 To Report or not to Report: A Study of Victims/Survivors of Sexual Assault and Their Experience of Making an Initial Report to the Police. Melbourne: Centre Against Sexual Assault (CASA House) and Royal Women’s Hospital.Google Scholar
Goffman, Erving
1981 Façons de parler. Traduit de l’anglais par Alain Kihm. Paris: Editions de Minuit.Google Scholar
Gold, Steven N., Dawn M. Hughes, and Janine M. Swingle
1999 “Degrees of Memory of Childhood Sexual Abuse among Women Survivors in Therapy.” Journal of Family Violence 14 (1): 35–46. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Gregory, Jeanne, and Sue Lees
1999 Policing Sexual Assault. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Gregory-Bills, Therese, and Melanie Rhodeback
1995 “Comparative Psychopathology of Women who Experienced Intra-familial versus Extra-familial Sexual Abuse.” Child Abuse and Neglect 191: 177–189. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Grice, Paul H
1975 “Logic and Conversation.” In Syntax and Semantics, 3, ed. by Peter Cole, and Jerry Morgan, 41–58. New York: Academic Press.Google Scholar
Grossen, Michèle, and Anne Salazar Orvig
2011 “Third Parties’ voices in a Therapeutic Interview.” Text & Talk 31 (1): 53–76. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Jacques, Francis
1985 L’espace logique de l’interlocution. Paris: PUF.Google Scholar
Jeanneret, Thérèse
1999 La coénonciation en français. Approches discursive, conversationnelle et syntaxique. Berne: Peter Lang.Google Scholar
Kellogg, Nancy D., and Shirley W. Menard
2003 “Violence Among Family Members of Children and Adolescents Evaluates for Sexual Abuse.” Child Abuse & Neglect 27 (12): 1367–1376. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Kelly, Liz
2002 A Research Review on the Reporting, Investigation and Prosecution of Rape Cases. London: Her Majesty’s Crown Prosecution Service Inspectorate.Google Scholar
Konradi, Amanda, and Tina Burger
2000 “Having the Last Word: An Examination of Rape Survivors’ Participation in Sentencing.” Violence Against Women 6 (49): 353–397. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Lacan, Jacques
1981 Le séminaire, livre III, Les psychoses, 1955–1956. Paris: Le Seuil.Google Scholar
Lee, Jenny S
2007 “Comfort Women and the Stockholm Syndrome: The Psychological Trauma of Sexual Victimization in Warfare.” The Undergraduate Journal of Psychology 201: 12–15.Google Scholar
Levinson, Stephen C
1979 “Activity Types and Language.” Linguistics 171: 365–399. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
McArthur, Margaret J
1990 “Reality Therapy With Rape Victims.” Archives of Psychiatric Nursing 4 (6): 360–365. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Mack, Kathy
1998 ““You Should Scrutinise her Evidence with Great Care”: Corroboration of Women’s Testimony About Sexual Assault.” In Balancing the Scales: Rape, Law Reform and Australian Culture, ed. by Patricia Easteal , 59–75. Sydney: The Federation Press.Google Scholar
MacKinnon, Catharine
2008 “Rape as “Torture”? Catharine MacKinnon and Questions of Feminist Strategy.” Feminist Legal Studies 16 (1): 71–85. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Magalhães, Teresa, Francisco Taveira, Patricia Jardim, Liliana Santos, Eduarda Matos, and Agostinho Santos
2009 “Sexual Abuse of Children. A Comparative Study of Intra and Extra-Familial Cases.” Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine 161: 455–459. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Mason, Fiona, and Zoe Lodrick
2012 “Psychological Consequences of Sexual Assault.” Best Practice & Research Clinical Obstetrics and Gynaecology 271: 27–37. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Monnet, F-P., A. Soussy, P-B. Monnet, and O. Diamant-Berger
1989 “Approche psychopathologique de victimes de violences sexuelles à partir de l’expérience vécue du service médico-judiciaire de l’Hôtel-Dieu à Paris.” Déviance et Société 13 (4): 339–351. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Ponterottop, Diane
2014 “The Risks of Uncertainty: Hedging Strategies in Rape Trial Discourse.” Language and Dialogue 4 (1): 93–111. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Richard-Zappella, Jeanine
2007 “Lorsque de l’indicible nait le désir de dire.” In Confidence / Dévoilement de soi dans l’interaction, ed. by Catherine Kerbrat-Orechioni, and Véronique Traverso, 313–318. Tubingen: Niemeyer. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Russell, Diana E-H
1986 The Secret Trauma: Incest in the Lives of Girls and Women. New York: Basic Book.Google Scholar
Salmona, Muriel
2009 Conséquences des troubles psychotraumatiques et de leurs mécanismes neurobiologiques sur la prise en charge médicale et judiciaire des victimes de viols. Available at http://​www​.memoiretraumatique​.org​/assets​/files​/doc​_violences​_sex​/cons​_troubles​_psychotrauma​_sur​_prise​_en​_charge​_victimes​_de​_viols​.pdf
Steketee, Gail, and Edna B. Foa
1987 “Rape Victims: Post-Traumatic Stress Responses and Their Treatment. A Review of the Literature.” Journal of Anxiety Disorders 11: 69–86. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Suarez, Eliana, and Gadalla Tahany M
2010 “Stop Blaming the Victim: A Meta-Analysis on Rape Myths.” Journal of Interpersonal Violence 25 (11): 2010–2035. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Summit, Roland C
1983 “The Child Abuse Accommodation Syndrome.” Child Abuse & Neglect 71: 177–193. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Todorov, Tzvetan
1981 Mikhaïl Bakhtine: le principe dialogique. Paris: Le Seuil.Google Scholar
Trognon, Alain, and Martine Batt
2002 “Logique interlocutoire d’un incipit.” In Les modèles du discours au défi d’un ‘dialogue romanesque’, ed. by Eddy Roulet, and Marcel Burger, 403–459. Nancy: PUN.Google Scholar
Vanderveken, Daniel
1988 Les actes de discours. Essai de philosophie du langage et de l’esprit sur la signification des énonciations, Philosophie et langage. Liège: Pierre Mardaga.Google Scholar
Van Gijseghem, Hubert
1999 Us et abus de la mise en mots en matière d’abus sexuel. Montréal: Méridien.Google Scholar
Weigand, Edda
2007 “Vivre la vie et raconter la vie. La confidence dans la vie quotidienne et la confidence en confidence en literature.” In Confidence/ dévoilement de soi dans l’interaction, ed. by Catherine Kerbrat-Orecchioni, and Véronique Traverso, 393–406. Tubingen: Niemeyer. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Woodhams, Jessica, Clive R Hollin, Ray Bull, and Claire Cooke
2011 “Behavior Displayed by Female Victims During Rapes Committed by Lone and Multiple Perpetrators.” Psychology, Public Policy, and Law 18 (3): 415–452. CrossrefGoogle Scholar