Regular article
Null arguments in old Norwegian
Interaction between pronouns and the functional categories of the
clause
In this paper I propose a new analysis of null arguments in Old Norwegian. I
argue that the option of null realization in Old Norwegian correlates with a
distinction between φP and DP pronouns in the sense of
Déchaine & Wiltschko (2002), and that this
distribution can be captured by a version of pronoun deletion (
Roberts 2010b). On a more general,
theoretical level, I argue that both the structure of pronouns and that of the
functional domains C, T and v influence the null argument properties of a
language. Thus, null arguments, but also blocking of null
arguments in non-null-argument languages like Modern Norwegian and English, may
be derived in different ways.
Article outline
- 1.Introduction
- 2.Old Norwegian: definition and data
-
3.Principles of excerption
- 3.1Extracting null arguments
- 3.2One or more types of null arguments?
-
3.3The position of null arguments and rendering of linguistic examples
- 4.Null arguments in Old Norwegian: empirical observations
- 4.1Syntactic environments
- 4.2Clause type
- 4.3Person features
-
5.A syntactic analysis: only φPs can be deleted
- 5.1The framework of Déchaine & Wiltschko
(2002)
- 5.2Pronouns in Old Norwegian
- 5.2.11st and 2nd person pronouns as DPs
- 5.2.23rd person pronouns as φPs
-
5.3Derivation of null pronouns: the deletion analysis of Roberts (2010b)
-
5.4Deletion in Old Norwegian
- 6.Some cross-linguistic perspectives
-
6.1Old Norwegian vs. Modern Norwegian
- 6.2Old Norwegian vs. English
- 6.3Old Norwegian vs. other early Germanic languages
- 7.Conclusion
- Acknowledgements
- Notes
-
References
References (123)
References
Åfarli, Tor & Chet Creider. 1987. Nonsubject pro-drop in Norwegian.
Linguistic Inquiry
18(2). 339–345.
Alexiadou, Artemis & Elena Anagnostopoulou. 1998. Parametrizing AGR. Word order, V-movement and EPP
checking.
Natural Language and Linguistic Theory
16(3). 491–539.
Ariel, Mira. 1990.
Accessing noun-phrase antecedents
. London: Routledge.
Barbosa, Pilar. 1995.
Null subjects:
Massachusetts Institute of Technology PhD dissertation.
Barbosa, Pilar. 2009. Two kinds of subject pro.
Studia Linguistica
63(1). 2–58.
Barbosa, Pilar. 2013.
Pro as a minimal NP: towards a unified approach to
pro-drop. [URL], accessed 13 August 2014.
Barðdal, Jóhanna & Thórhallur Eythórsson. 2003. The change that never happened: the story of oblique
subjects.
Journal of Linguistics
39(3). 439–472.
Bayer, Josef. 1984.
comp in Bavarian syntax.
Linguistic Review
31. 209–274.
Biberauer, Theresa. 2008. Introduction. In Theresa Biberauer (ed.),
The limits of syntactic variation
, 1–74. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Borer, Hagit. 1986. I-subjects.
Linguistic Inquiry
17(3). 375–416.
Börjars, Kersti, Pauline Harries & Nigel Vincent. 2016. Growing syntax: the development of a DP in North Germanic. Language 92(1). e1–e37
Breitbarth, Anne & Melissa Farasyn. 2016. Nullsubjekte im Mittelniederdeutschen.
Beiträge zur Geschichte der deutschen Sprache und Literatur
138(4). 524–559.
Cardinaletti, Anna & Michal Starke. 1996. Deficient pronouns: a view from Germanic. A study in the unified
description of Germanic and Romance. In Höskuldur Thráinsson, Samuel David Epstein & Steve Peter (eds.),
Studies in comparative Germanic syntax
, vol. II1, 21–65. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers.
Cardinaletti, Anna & Michal Starke. 1999. The typology of structural deficiency: a case study on the three
classes of pronouns. In Henk van Riemsdijk (ed.),
Clitics in the languages of Europe
, 145–234. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
Chomsky, Noam. 2004. Beyond explanatory adequacy. In Adriana Belletti (ed.),
Structures and beyond: the cartography of syntactic
structures
, 104–131. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Chomsky, Noam. 2007. Approaching UG from Below. In Uli Säuerland & Hans-Martin Gärtner (eds.),
Interfaces + recursion = language? Chomsky’s minimalism and the view
from syntax-semantics
, 1–30. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
Chomsky, Noam. 2008. On phases. In Robert Freidin, Carlos Otero & Maria-Luisa Zubizarreta (eds.),
Foundational issues in linguistic theory
, 133–166. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Cole, Melvyn. 2010. Thematic null subjects and accessibility.
Studia Linguistica
64(3). 271–320.
Dahl, Östen. 2015.
Grammaticalization in the North: noun phrase morphosyntax in
Scandinavian vernaculars
. Berlin: Language Science Press.
De Bastiani, Chiara. 2014.
Die Entwicklung des definiten Artikels im Althochdeutschen unter
einer semantischen Perspektive
. Ca’ Foscari University of Venice MA thesis.
Déchaine, Rose-Marie & Martina Wiltschko. 2002. Decomposing pronouns.
Linguistic Inquiry
33(3). 409–442.
Déchaine, Rose-Marie & Martina Wiltschko. 2015. When and why can 1st and 2nd person pronouns be bound
variables? In Patrick Grosz, Pritty Patel-Grosz & Igor Yanovich (eds.),
The semantics of pronouns. Proceedings of the special session of the
40th North East Linguistics Society
. 1–50. Amherst, MA: GLSA.
Delsing, Lars-Olof. 2003. Syntaktisk variation i nordiska nominalfraser. In Øystein Alexander Vangsnes, Anders Holmberg & Lars-Olof Delsing (eds.),
Dialektsyntaktiska studier av den nordiska nominalfrasen
, 11–64. Oslo: Novus forlag.
Demske, Ulrike. 2001.
Merkmale und relationen. Diachrone Studien zur Nominalphrase des Deutschen
. Berlin: De Gruyter.
Duguine, Maia. 2013.
Null arguments and linguistic variation: a minimalist analysis of
pro-drop:
University of the Basque country/Université de Nantes PhD dissertation.
Dyvik, Helge. 1979. Omkring fremveksten av artiklene i norsk. Språklig markering av
referensielle forutsetninger.
Maal og Minne
1(2). 40–78.
Elbourne, Paul. 2005.
Situations and individuals
. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Eythórsson, Thórhallur & J. Barðdal. 2005. Oblique subjects: A common Germanic inheritance.
Language
84(4). 824–881.
Faarlund, Jan Terje. 1990.
Syntactic change. Toward a theory of historical syntax
. Mouton de Gruyter.
Faarlund, Jan Terje. 2004.
The syntax of Old Norse: with a survey of the inflectional
morphology and a complete bibliography
. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Faarlund, Jan Terje. 2013. The pro cycle. In Elly van Gelderen, Jóhanna Barðdal & Michela Cennamo (eds.),
Argument structure in flux. The Naples-Capri papers
, 257–284. John Benjamins.
Faarlund, Jan Terje, Svein Lie & Kjell Ivar Vannebo. 1997.
Norsk referansegrammatikk
. Oslo: Universitetsforlaget.
Falk, Hjalmar & Alf Torp. 1900.
Dansk-norskens syntax i historisk fremstilling
. Kristiania: H. Aschehoug & Co.
Farrell, Patrick. 1990. Null objects in Brazilian Portuguese.
Natural Language and Linguistic Theory
81. 325–346.
Frascarelli, M. & R. Hinterhölzl. 2007. Types of topics in German and Italian. In K. Schwabe & S. Winkler (eds.),
On information structure, meaning and form
, 87–116. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Frascarelli, Mara. 2007. Subjects, topics and the interpretation of referential
pro.
Natural Language & Linguistic Theory
25(4). 691–743.
van Gelderen, Elly. 2013. Null subjects in Old English.
Linguistic Inquiry
441. 271–285.
Giorgi, Alessandra & Fabio Pianesi. 1997.
Tense and aspect. From semantics to morphosyntax
. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Greenberg, Joseph H. 1978. How does a language acquire gender markers? In Joseph H. Greenberg (ed.),
Universals of human language
, vol. 31. Word structure, 47–82. Stanford Calif: Stanford University Press.
Håberg, Live. 2010.
Den preproprielle artikkelen i norsk: ei undersøking av
namneartiklar i Kvæfjord, Gausdal og Voss
. Universitetet i Oslo MA thesis.
Haegeman, Liliane. 1990. Understood subjects in English diaries.
Mulitilingua
9(2). 157–199.
Haegeman, Liliane. 2000. Adult null subjects in non pro-drop languages. In Marc-Ariel Friedemann & Luigi Rizzi (eds.),
The acquisition of syntax
, 129–169. Harlow: Longman.
Haegeman, Liliane & Marjo van Koppen. 2012. Complementizer agreement and the relation between C and
T.
Linguistic Inquiry
43(3). 441–454.
Hægstad, Marius. 1922. Um maalet i Óláfs saga hins helga. Delag. samling i Uppsala, no.
8 fol. In Oscar Albert Johnsen (ed.),
Olafs saga hins helga. Efter pergamenthaandskrift i Uppsala
Universitetsbibliotek, Delagardieske samling nr. 8II
, XXVIII–LVII. Kristiania: Dybwad.
Hagland, Jan Ragnar. 2013. Gammalislandsk og gammalnorsk språk. In Odd Einar Haugen (ed.),
Handbok i norrøn filologi
, 600–639. Bergen: Fagbokforlaget 2nd edn.
Håkansson, David. 2008.
Syntaktisk variation och förändring. En studie av subjektslösa
satser i fornsvenska:
Lunds universitet dissertation.
Haugan, Jens. 1998. Passiv av norrøne dobbelt objekt-konstruksjonar og
subjektspørsmålet.
Norsk lingvistisk tidsskrift
161. 157–184.
Haugen, Odd Einar & Åslaug Ommundsen. 2010. Nye blikk på homilieboka. In Odd Einar Haugen & Åslaug Ommundsen (eds.),
Vår eldste bok. skrift, miljø og biletbruk i den norske
homilieboka
, Oslo: Novus forlag.
Heltoft, Lars. 2012. Zero expression of arguments in Old Danish.
Acta Linguistica Hafniensia
44(2). 169–191.
Höhn, Georg. 2015. Demonstratives and personal pronouns.
Cambridge Occasional Papers in Linguistics
81. 84–105.
Holmberg, Anders. 2005. Is there a little pro? Evidence from Finnish.
Linguistic Inquiry
36(4). 533–564.
Holmberg, Anders. 2010. Null subject parameters. In Theresa Biberauer, Anders Holmberg, Ian Roberts & Michelle Sheehan (eds.),
Parametric variation. Null subjects in minimalist theory
, 88–124. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Holmberg, Anders. 2016. Null subjects in Finnish and the typology of
pro-drop. [URL], accessed 23 Sept 2016.
Hooper, Joan B. & Sandra Thompson. 1973. On the applicability of root transformations.
Linguistic Inquiry
4(4). 465–497.
Huang, Yan. 2000.
Anaphora: a cross-linguistic approach
. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Indrebø, G. 1931. Innleiding. In G. Indrebø (ed.),
Gamal norsk homiliebok
, *5–*64. Oslo: Jacob Dybwad.
Iversen, Ragnvald. 1972.
Norrøn grammatikk
. Oslo: Tano.
Johannessen, Janne Bondi. 2006. Just any pronoun anywhere? Pronouns and “new” demonstratives in
Norwegian. In Torgrim Solstad, Atle Grønn & Dag Haug (eds.),
A festschrift for Kjell Johan Sæbø – in partial fulfilment of
the requirements for the celebration of his 50th birthday
, 91–106. Oslo: Novus Press.
Johannessen, Janne Bondi. 2008a. Psykologiske demonstrativer. In Janne Bondi Johannessen & Kristin Hagen (eds.),
Språk i Oslo. Ny forskning omkring talespråk
, 63–77. Oslo: Novus forlag.
Johannessen, Janne Bondi. 2008b. The pronominal psychological demonstrative in Scandinavian: its
syntax, semantics and pragmatics.
Nordic Journal of Linguistics
31(2). 161–192.
Johnsen, Oscar Albert. 1992. Indledning. In Oscar Albert Johnsen (ed.),
Olafs saga hins helga. Efter pergamenthaandskrift i Uppsala
Universitetsbibliotek, Delagardieske samling nr. 8II
, I–XXVII. Oslo: Dybwad
Julien, Marit. 2015. The force of V2 revisited.
Journal of Comparative Germanic Linguistics
181. 139–181.
Kayne, Richard S. 2000.
Parameters and universals
. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Kinn, Kari. 2011. Overt non-referential subjects and subject-verb agreement in
Middle Norwegian.
Working Papers in Scandinavian Syntax
881. 21–50.
Kinn, Kari. 2016. Null subjects in the history of Norwegian, University of Oslo PhD thesis.
Kinn, Kari, Kristian A. Rusten & George Walkden. 2016. Null subjects in early Icelandic.
Journal of Germanic Linguistics
28(1). 31–78. .
de Korte, Siebe. 2008.
Dutch topic drop as a PF phenomenon
. University of Amsterdam MA thesis.
Leijström, Gunnar. 1934.
Om obestämda artikeln. Et bidrag til nordisk språkhistorie
. Stockholm: Hugo Geber.
Löbner, Sebastian. 1985. Definites.
Journal of Semantics
41. 279–326.
Longobardi, Giuseppe. 1994. Reference and proper names: a theory of N-movement in syntax and
logical form.
Linguistic Inquiry
25(4). 609–665.
Magnusson, Erik. 2007.
Gränsöverskridande koordination. Syntaktisk förändring i äldre
svenska:
Göteborgs Universitet PhD dissertation.
Miyagawa, Shigeru. 2010.
Why agree? Why move? Unifying agreement-based and
discourse-configurational languages
. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Mørck, Endre. 1994. The distribution of subject properties and the acquisition of
subjecthood in the West Scandinavian languages. In Toril Swan, Endre Mørck & Olaf Jansen Westwik (eds.),
Language change and language structure. Older Germanic languages in
a comparative perspective
, 159–194. Berlin: Walter de Gruyter.
Mörnsjö, Maria. 2002.
V1 declaratives in spoken Swedish. Syntax, information structure and
prosodic pattern:
Lund University PhD dissertation.
Mundal, Else. 2004. Sagalitteraturen. In Odd Einar Haugen (ed.),
Handbok i norrøn filologi
, 267–302.
Neeleman, Ad & Kriszta Szendrői. 2007. Radical pro drop and the morphology of pronouns.
Linguistic Inquiry
38(4). 671–214.
Nygaard, Marius. 1894. Udeladelse af subjekt; “subjektløse” sætninger i det norrøne
sprog (den klassiske sagastil).
Arkiv för nordisk filologi
10, ny följd 6(1). 1–25.
Nygaard, Marius. 1905.
Norrøn syntax
. Oslo: Aschehoug.
Nygård, Mari. 2013.
Discourse ellipsis in spontaneously spoken Norwegian:
Norwegian University of Science and Technology dissertation.
Ottosson, Kjartan. 2002. Old Nordic: a definition and delimitation of the
period. In Oscar Bandle, Kurt Braunmüller, Ernst Håkon Jahr, Allan Karker, Hans-Peter Naumann & Ulf Telemann (eds.),
The Nordic languages. An international handbook of the history of the
North Germanic languages
, vol. 11, 787–793. Walter de Gruyter.
Ouali, Hamid. 2008. On C-to-T ϕ-feature transfer: the nature of Agreement and
Anti-Agreement in Berber. In Roberta D’Allesandro, Susann Fischer & Gunnar Hrafn Hrafn-bjargarson (eds.),
Agreement restrictions
, 159–180. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
Platzack, Christer. 1986.
COMP, INFL and Germanic word order. In Lars Hellan & Kirsti Koch Christensen (eds.),
Topics in Scandinavian syntax
, 185–234. Dordrecht: D. Reidel.
Platzack, Christer. 1998.
Svenskans inre grammatik – det minimalistiska programmet. En
introduktion till modern generativ grammatik
. Lund: Studentlitteratur.
Poletto, Cecilia. 2006. Parallel phases: a study on the high and low perihery of Old
Italian. In Mara Frascarelli (ed.),
Phases of interpretation
, 261–294. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
Postal, Paul. 1969. On so-called “pronouns” in English. In David A. Reibel & Sanford A. Schane (eds.),
Modern studies in English: readings in transformational
grammar
, 201–226. Englewood Cliffs, N.J: Prentice Hall.
Radford, Andrew. 2004.
Minimalist syntax. Exploring the structure of English
. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Rizzi, Luigi. 1997. The fine structure of the left periphery. In Liliane Haegeman (ed.),
Elements of grammar
, 281–337. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers.
Roberts, Ian. 2010a.
Agreement and head movement. Clitics, incorporation, and defective
goals
. Cambridge, Mass: MIT Press.
Roberts, Ian. 2010b. A deletion analysis of null subjects. In Theresa Biberauer, Anders Holmberg, Ian Roberts & Michelle Sheehan (eds.),
Parametric variation. Null subjects in minimalist theory
, 58–87. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Roberts, Ian & Anders Holmberg. 2010. Introduction: parameters in minimalist theory. In Theresa Biberauer, Anders Holmberg, Ian Roberts & Michelle Sheehan (eds.),
Parametric variation. Null subjects in minimalist theory
, 1–57. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Rögnvaldsson, Eiríkur. 1995. Quirky subjects in Old Icelandic. In H.Á. Sigurðsson (ed.),
Papers from the twelfth Scandinavian conference on
linguistics
, University of Iceland.
Rosenkvist, H. 2009. Referential null subjects in Germanic languages – an
overview.
Working Papers in Scandinavian Syntax
841. 151–180.
Rusten, Kristian A. 2010.
A study of empty referential pronominal subjects in Old
English
. University of Bergen MA thesis.
Rusten, Kristian A. 2013. Empty Referential Subjects in Old English Prose: a quantitative
analysis.
English Studies
94(8). 970–992.
Rusten, Kristian A. & George Walkden. 2016. Null subjects in Middle English.
English Language and Linguistics
1–35.
Seip, Didrik Arup. 1929.
Den legendariske olavssaga og fagrskinna
. Oslo: Dybwad.
Sigurðsson, Halldór Ármann. 1993. Argument-drop in Old Icelandic.
Lingua
891. 247–280.
Sigurðsson, Halldór Ármann. 2004. The syntax of person, tense, and speech features.
Italian Journal of Linguistics
16(1). 219–251.
Sigurðsson, Halldór Ármann. 2006. The Icelandic noun phrase. Central traits.
Arkiv for nordisk filologi
1211(193–236).
Sigurðsson, Halldór Ármann. 2011. Conditions on argument drop.
Linguistic Inquiry
42(2). 267–304.
Sigurðsson, Halldór Ármann. 2014. About pronouns.
Working Papers in Scandinavian Syntax
921. 65–98.
Sigurðsson, Halldór Ármann & Verner Egerland. 2009. Impersonal null-subjects in Icelandic and
elsewhere.
Studia Linguistica
63(1). 158–185.
Sigurðsson, Halldór Ármann. 1989.
Verbal syntax and case in Icelandic
. Department of Scandinavian Languages, Lund University.
Stausland Johnsen, Sverre. 2016. Null subjects, preproprial articles, and the syntactic structure
of Old Norwegian pronouns.
Norsk lingvistisk tidsskrift
341. 183–217.
Stjernholm, Karine. 2008.
Subjektsellipser: fins pro i norsk talespråk?
University of Oslo MA thesis.
Taraldsen, Knut Tarald. 1980.
On the nominative island condition, vacuous application and the
that-trace filter
. Indiana University Linguistics Club.
Thráinsson, Höskuldur. 2007.
The Syntax of Icelandic
. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Thráinsson, Höskuldur & Thóra Björk Hjartardóttir. 1986. Pro-drop, topic-drop. Where do Old and Modern Icelandic fit
in? In Östen Dahl & Anders Holmberg (eds.),
Scandinavian syntax
, 150–161. University of Stockholm.
Trutkowski, Ewa. 2011. Referential null subjects in German. In Chris Cummins, Chi-Hé Elder, Thomas Godard, Morgan Macleod, Elaine Schmidt & George Walkden (eds.),
Proceedings of the sixth Cambridge postgraduate conference in
linguistics (CamLing)
, 206–217. Cambridge: Cambridge Institute for Language Research.
Vainikka, Anne & Yonata Levy. 1999. Empty subjects in Finnish and Hebrew.
Natural Language & Linguistic Theory
17(3). 613–671.
Walkden, George. 2013. Null subjects in Old English.
Language Variation and Change
251. 155–178.
Walkden, George. 2014.
Syntactic reconstruction and Proto-Germanic
. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Weir, Andrew. 2012. Left-edge deletion in English and subject omission in
diaries.
English Language and Linguistics
16(1). 105–129.
Weiß, Helmut. 2005. Inflected complementizers in Continental West Germanic
dialects.
Zeitschrift für Dialektologie und Linguistik
721. 148–166.
Wendt, Bo-A. 2006. Vykortsstil i verkligheten. Elliptiskt och icke satsformat
språkbruk i vykort. In Sofia Ask, Gunilla Byrman, Solveig Hammarbäck, Maria Lindgren & Per Stille (eds.),
Lekt och lärt. Vänskrift till Jan Einarsson
, 244–295. Växjö: University Press.
Wiggen, Geir. 1975. Utelatelse av setningsledd.
Norskrift
31. 1–47.
Cited by (1)
Cited by one other publication
Kinn, Kari
2016.
Referential vs. non-referential null subjects in Middle Norwegian.
Nordic Journal of Linguistics 39:3
► pp. 277 ff.
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 8 july 2024. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers.
Any errors therein should be reported to them.