Optional agreement as successful/failed Agree
Evidence from Santiago Tz’utujil (Mayan)
We investigate optional predicate agreement in Santiago Tz’utujil (Mayan). Several generalizations emerge: (i) inanimate
arguments base-generated as complements control agreement optionally; (ii) some animate arguments base-generated as complements control
agreement optionally; (iii) all arguments base-generated as specifiers control full agreement obligatorily. We propose that two conditions
must be met for the operation Agree to succeed, resulting in the exponence of all the features of the agreement controller. First,
a goal must be visible (bear the right feature). Second, a goal must be accessible (be in the right structural position). If one or both
conditions are not met, Agree fails, but the derivation converges and 3sg agreement is exponed. While Agree is
deterministic, surface optionality arises when the operation fails. We use optional agreement to diagnose the syntactic structure of
understudied constructions in Mayan (nominalizations, Agent Focus). We discuss microvariation, highlighting methodological considerations
that arise when assuming an I-language approach.
Article outline
- 1.Introduction
- 2.Santiago Tz’utujil
- 2.1Previous work on optional agreement in Tz’utujil
- 2.2Properties of STz’
- 3.Optional agreement in STz’: Establishing a specifier vs. completement generalization
- 3.1Agreement controlled by base-generated specifier
- 3.1.1Subject of transitives
- 3.1.2Subject of antipassives
- 3.1.3Possessor
- 3.1.4Subject of nominal and adjectival predicates
- 3.1.5Interim summary
- 3.2Agreement controlled by base-generated complement
- 3.2.1Object of transitives
- 3.2.2Subject of passives
- 3.2.3Argument in an existential construction
- 3.3A generalization regarding inanimate controllers
- 4.Optional agreement as a diagnostic of underlying structure
- 4.1Intransitives
- 4.2Sole argument of stative predicates (revisited)
- 4.3Agent Focus (subjects and objects)
- 4.4The progressive construction
- 5.Animate controllers: Construction-specific pattern
- 6.Analysis
- 6.1Inanimate controllers: Visibility (structural size)
- 6.2Animate arguments: Construction-specific accessibility
- 6.2.1Accessibility and Set B agreement
- 6.2.2Accessibility and Set A agreement
- 6.2.3Pronouns revisited
- 6.3Summary of visibility and accessibility
- 7.Microvariation
- 7.1Microvariation across Mayan
- 7.2Microvariation in STz’ and a methodological note
- 8.Conclusions and future work
- Acknowledgements
- Notes
- List of abbreviations used in the paper
-
References
References (92)
Abney, S.
1987 The English noun phrase in its sentential aspect. Massachusetts Institute of Technology Doctoral dissertation.
Aissen, Judith
2011 On the syntax of agent focus in K’ichee’. (Ed.)
Kirill Shklovsky,
Pedro Mateo Pedro &
Jessica Coon.
Proceedings of FAMLi. MIT Working Papers in Linguistics.
Aissen, Judith
2017a Correlates of ergativity in Mayan. In
Jessica Coon,
Diane Massam &
Lisa Travis (eds.),
Oxford handbook of ergativity, 737–758. Oxford University Press.
Aissen, Judith
2017b Complement clauses. In
Judith Aissen,
Nora C. England &
Zavala Maldonado (eds.),
The Mayan Languages, 259–292. New York, NY: Routledge.
Aissen, Judith, Nora C. England & Roberto Zavala Maldonado
(eds.) 2017a The Mayan Languages. New York, NY: Routledge.
Aissen, Judith, Nora C. England & Roberto Zavala Maldonado
2017b Introduction. In
Judith Aissen,
Nora C. England &
Roberto Zavala Maldonado (eds.),
The Mayan Languages. New York, NY: Routledge.
Aissen, Judith L.
1992 Topic and focus in Mayan.
Language 68(1). 43–80.
Aldridge, Edith Catherine
2004 Ergativity and word order in Austronesian languages. Cornell University Doctoral dissertation.
Assmann, A., D. Georgi, F. Heck, G. Müller & P. Weisser
2015 Ergatives move too early: On an instance of opacity in syntax.
Syntax 18(4). 343–387.
Baker, Mark C.
1996 The Polysynthesis Parameter. Oxford University Press.
Baker, Mark C.
2003 Lexical categories: Verbs, nouns and adjectives. Cambridge University Press.
Baker, Mark C.
2008 The syntax of agreement and concord. Cambridge University Press.
Bohnemeyer, Jürgen
2009 Temporal anaphora in a tenseless language. In
Wolfgang Klein &
Ping Li (eds.),
The expression of time in language, 83–128. Berlin: De Gruyter.
Burukina, Irine
2020 Structure of event nominals revealed. Manuscript. Budapest, ms.
Carstens, Vicki
2020 Concord and labeling. In
Peter W. Smith (ed.),
Agreement in the Minimalist Program (
Language Sciences Press Open Generative Syntax Series).
Chomsky, Noam
1965 Aspects of the theory of syntax. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Chomsky, Noam
1970 Remarks on nominalization. In
R. A. Jacobs &
P. S. Rosenbaum (eds.),
Readings in English transformational grammar, 184–221. Waltham, MA.
Chomsky, Noam
1986 Knowledge of Language: Its Nature, Origin, and Use. New York, NY: Praeger.
Chomsky, Noam
1995 The Minimalist Program. Cambridge, MA: Massachusetts Institute of Technology.
Chomsky, Noam
2001 Derivation by phase. In
Michael Kenstowicz (ed.),
Ken Hale: A life in language, 1–52. MIT Press.
Citko, Barbara
2014 Phase Theory: An introduction. Cambridge University Press.
Clemens, Lauren & Jessica Coon
2018 Deriving verb-initial word order in Mayan.
Language 94(2). 237–280.
Coon, Jessica
2012 Split ergativity and transitivity in Chol.
Lingua 1221. 241–256.
Coon, Jessica
2013 Aspects of split ergativity. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Coon, Jessica
2016 Mayan morphosyntax.
Language and linguistics compass 10(10). 515–550.
Coon, Jessica
2019 Building verbs in Chuj: Consequences for the nature of roots.
Journal of Linguistics 551. 35–81.
Coon, Jessica, Nico Baier & Theodore Levin
2021 Mayan Agent Focus and the ergative extraction constraint: Facts and fictions revisited.
Language 97(2).
Coon, Jessica & E. Carolan
2017 Nominalizations and the structure of progressives in Chuj Mayan.
Glossa: A journal of general linguistics 2(1). 1–35.
Coon, Jessica, Pedro Mateo Pedro & Omer Preminger
Coon, Jessica & Omer Preminger
2009 Positional roots and case absorption.
New perspectives in Mayan linguistics 35–58.
Corbett, Greville G.
2006 Agreement. New Yotk, NY: Cambridge University Press.
Craig, C. G.
1977 The structure of Jacaltec. Austin, TX: University of Texas Press.
Dayley, Jon Philip
1978 Voice in Tzututjil.
Journal of Mayan Linguistics 1(1). 20–52.
Dayley, Jon Philip
1985 Tzutujil grammar. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
Deal, Amy Rose
2009 The origin and content of expletives: Evidence from “selection.”
Syntax 12(4). 285–323.
Déchaine, R. M. & Martina Wiltschko
2002 Decomposing pronouns.
Linguistic Inquiry 33(3). 409–442.
Douglas, J., Rodrigo Ranero & M. Sheehan
2017 Two kinds of syntactic ergativity in Mayan. In
Michael Yoshitaka Erlewine (ed.),
Proceedings of GLOW in Asia XI, vol. 21, 41–56. MIT Working Papers in Linguistics.
Eberhard, D. M., G. F. Simons & C. D. Fenning
(eds.) 2019 Ethnologue: Languages of the World. 22nd edn. Dallas, TX: SIL International.
Elbourne, Paul
2001 E-type anaphora as NP-deletion.
Natural Language Semantics 9(3). 241–288.
England, Nora C.
1991 Changes in basic word order in Mayan languages.
International Journal of American Linguistics 57(4). 466–486.
England, Nora C.
2001 Introducción a la gramática de los idiomas mayas. Guatemala City: Editorial Cholsamaj.
England, Nora C.
2011 Plurality Agreement in Some Eastern Mayan Languages.
International Journal of American Linguistics 77(3). 397–412.
Erlewine, Michael Yoshitaka
2016 Anti-locality and optimality in Kaqchikel Agent Focus.
Natural Language & Linguistic Theory 34(2). 429–479.
Freeze, Ray
1992 Existentials and other locatives.
Language 681. 553–595.
Fried, Marisa, Paulina Lyskawa & Rodrigo Ranero
2020 Agreement in K’iche’ (Mayan): Reflections on microvariation and acquisition. In
To appear in Proceedings of the 44th Penn Linguistics Conference.
García Ixmatá, Pablo (Ajpub’)
1997 Gramática Tz’utujiil. Guatemala: Editorial Cholsamaj.
García Ixmatá, Pablo (Ajpub’)
1998 Jotaytziij Tz’utujiil: Derivación de Palabras Tz’utujiil. Guatemala: Editorial Cholsamaj.
Hale, Kenneth
2002 Eccentric agreement. In
B. Fernández &
Pablo Albizu (eds.),
Kasu eta Komunztaduraren gainean [
On Case and Agreement], 15–48. Vitoria-Gasteiz: Euskal Herriko Unibetsitatea.
Harley, Heidi
2017 The “bundling” hypothesis and the disparate functions of little v. In
Roberta D’Alessandro,
Irene Franco &
Ángel J. Gallego (eds.),
The verbal domain, 3–28. Oxford University Press.
Harley, Heidi & Elizabeth Ritter
2002 Person and number in pronouns: A feature-geometric analysis.
Language 78(3). 482–526.
Haviland, John B.
1994 “Te xa setel xulem” [The buzzards were circling] – Categories of verbal roots in (Zinacantec) Tzotzil.
Linguistics 321. 691–741.
Heaton, R.
2017 A typology of antipassives, with special reference to Mayan. Manoa: University of Hawai’i Doctoral dissertation.
Henderson, Robert
2009 A Case-Agreement Split in Kaqchikel. Manuscript. UC Santa Cruz, ms.
Henderson, Robert
2012 Morphological alternations at the intonational phrase edge.
Natural Language & Linguistic Theory 30(3). 741–787.
Henderson, Robert
2019 The roots of measurement.
Glossa: A journal of general linguistics 4(1). 1–31.
Hornstein, Norbert
1999 Movement and control.
Linguistic Inquiry. MIT Press 30(1). 69–96.
Imanishi
2014 Default ergative. Massachusetts Institute of Technology Doctoral dissertation.
Ionin, T.
2003 Article semantics in second language acquisition. Massachusetts Institute of Technology Doctoral dissertation.
Ionin, T.
2006 This is definitely specific: specificity and definiteness in article systems.
Natural Language Semantics 14(2). 175.
Kenstowicz, Michael
2013 Realize morpheme in Kaqchikel.
Studies in Kaqchikel grammar 81.
Legate, Julie Anne
2003 Some interface properties of the phase.
Linguistic Inquiry 34(3). 506–515.
Legate, Julie Anne
2008 Morphological and abstract case.
Linguistic inquiry. MIT Press 39(1). 55–101.
Legate, Julie Anne
2014 Split ergativity based on nominal type.
Lingua 1481. 183–212.
Levin, Theodore
2015 Licensing without Case. Massachusetts Institute of Technology Doctoral dissertation.
Levin, Theodore, Paulina Lyskawa & Rodrigo Ranero
2020 Optional agreement in Santiago Tz’utujil (Mayan) is syntactic.
Zeitschrift für Sprachwissenschaft. De Gruyter Mouton 39(3). 329–355.
Little, Carol Rose
2020a Left branch extraction, object shift, and freezing effects in Tumbalá Ch’ol.
Glossa: A journal of general linguistics 5(1).
Little, Carol Rose
2020b Interdependencies of nominal and clausal syntax: A view from Ch’ol. Cornell University Doctoral dissertation.
Lyskawa, Paulina & Rodrigo Ranero
2021a Vowel Harmony in Santiago Tz’utujil (Mayan). Handout presented at the Meeting of the Society for the Study of the Indigenous Languages of the Americas.
Lyskawa, Paulina & Rodrigo Ranero
2021b Sibilant harmony in Santiago Tz’utujil (Mayan). In
Proceedings of the Linguistic Society of America
61
1, vol. 61, 265–279.
Martin, L.
1998 Irrealis constructions in Mocho (Mayan).
Anthropological linguistics 198–213.
Massam, Diane
2001 Pseudo noun incorporation in Niuean.
Natural Language & Linguistic Theory (19). 153–197.
Mateo-Toledo, B’alam Eladio
2008 The family of complex predicates in Q’anjob’al (Maya): Their syntax and meaning. Austin, TX: University of Texas Doctoral dissertation.
Mithun, M.
1984 The Evolution of Noun Incorporation.
Language 60(4). 847–894.
Norris, Mark
2014 A theory of nominal concord. ProQuest Dissertations and Theses. University of California, Santa Cruz Doctoral dissertation.
Norris, Mark
2017 Description and analyses of nominal concord (Parts I-II).
Language and Linguistics Compass 11(11).
O-Brien Rothe, L.
2015 Songs that Make the Road Dance: Courtship and Fertility Music of the Tz’utujil Maya. University of Texas Press.
Ordóñez, F.
1995 The antipassive in Jacaltec: A last resort strategy.
Catalan Working Papers in Linguistics (CatWPL) 4(2). 329–343.
Paster, Mary
2019 Analyzing interspeaker variation in Maay.
Loquens 6(2).
Polinsky, Maria
2016 Deconstructing ergativity: Two types of ergative languages and their features. Oxford University Press.
Polinsky, Maria
2017 Antipassive. In
Jessica Coon,
Diane Massam &
Lisa Travis (eds.),
The Oxford Handbook of Ergativty. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Postal, Paul
1966 On so-called ‘pronouns’ in English. In
F. Dinneen (ed.),
19th Monograph on Languages and Linguistics, 201–224. Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press.
Preminger, Omer
2014 Agreement and its failures (
Linguistic Inquiry Monographs). Cambridge, Massachusetts ; London, England: The MIT Press.
Ranero, Rodrigo
2021 Identity Conditions on Ellipsis. University of Maryland, College Park Doctoral Dissertation.
Ritter, Elizabeth
2014 Featuring animacy.
Nordlyd 411. 103–134.
Royer, Justin
2021 Prosody as syntactic evidence: The view from Mayan.
Natural Language & Linguistic Theory.
Sauerland, Uli
2003 A new semantics for number. In
Proceedings of SALT
13
1, 258–275. Cornell University, Ithaca, NY: CLC Publications.
Stiebels, B.
2006 Agent focus in Mayan languages.
Natural Language & Linguistic Theory 24(2). 501–570.
Tada, H.
1993 A/A-bar partition in derivation. Massachusetts Institute of Technology Doctoral dissertation.
Thráinsson, H.
2001 Object Shift and Scrambling. In
Mark Baltin &
Chris Collins (eds.),
The Handbook of Contemporary Syntactic Theory, 149–202. Wiley-Blackwell.
Tummons, E. J.
2010 Positional Roots in Kaqchikel Maya. University of Kansas Masters thesis.
Woolford, E.
1997 Four-way case systems: Ergative, nominative, objective and accusative.
Natural Language & Linguistic Theory 15(1). 181–227.
Cited by (2)
Cited by 2 other publications
Levin, Theodore, Paulina Lyskawa & Rodrigo Ranero
2021.
Optional agreement in Santiago Tz’utujil (Mayan) is syntactic.
Zeitschrift für Sprachwissenschaft 39:3
► pp. 329 ff.
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 5 july 2024. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers.
Any errors therein should be reported to them.